5 ms·
Europe still burns witches – if they’re named Monsanto
- reacweb 9y agoWhatever the brainwash of lobbies, I am sure an herbicide can not be effective and healthy at the same time.
- j7ake 9y agoAny herbicide whether natural or artificial that prevents other organisms from eating your crop cannot be effective and healthy at the same time. This applies also for vegetables that are naturally resistant to pests (e.g. Vegetable strains that are Much more bitter than the wild type ). The solution is to not to have an expectation that vegetables should be free of any insect or animal contact. But not everybody likes caterpillar bite marks on their vegetables.
- kuang_eleven 9y agoHerbicides aren't intended to keep animals from eating crops. That would be an insecticide, in the case of insects. Herbicides are designed to kill plants, and Glyphosate in particular really only does that.
- j7ake 9y agoThanks for the clarification i was not clear with my words
- christopheml 9y agoSure. But the two mandatory questions of banning any pesticide are tough to answer: - Can we have similar output (quality/quantity/cost) without any pesticide at all? - If not, are the alternative molecules better or worse?
- zaarn 9y agoDepends on the dosage. Like any chemist will tell you. Herbicide can certainly be effective and at the same time not be dangerous to the human body simply because our body mass is higher and thus the effective dosage per kg of body mass is lower. Or alternatively, herbicides can be made less effective against mammals but more effective against other animals/insects by disrupting cell chemistry not present in mammals (or humans if you want to be more specific on the chemical). Of course, herbicide is not healthy if consumed in any large amounts, it's after all a poison, small dosages can be made safe for humans while still being dangerous to not-humans.
- stonewhite 9y agoCaffeine is an effective pesticide, yet it is considered to be healthy too. Despite claiming your views are not effected by all the propaganda, you are biased against herbicides in a very propaganda smelling 2 dimensional manner.
- matt4077 9y agoI hate Monsanto more than the vermin and weeds they poison. But your statement just isn't true. There are differences in organisms' metabolisms, and it's perfectly possible for one substance to be deadly to one (class of) species, yet harmless or even nourishing to others. Take antibiotics, which kill bacteria but have mild-to-none effects on humans (and most of the negative side effects on humans stem from their killing of even beneficial bacteria).
- JohnGB 9y agoThis article reads like a political agenda providing few verifiable facts, and many broad, unsubstantiated claims. If one is going to make bold claims, they should be substantiated by fact, not by other bold claims. I am no expert on glyphosates, but that article has left me less than convinced that they are "safe".
- dotdi 9y agoI came here to write a very similar thing. While activists exaggerate to persuade people it's not safe because it might be carcinogenic, the author is on the other extreme: it's safe until proven otherwise. It also sports a fair share of whataboutism: "what about bacon, that's also considered carcinogenic!?".
- zaarn 9y agoI recall my chemist teacher repeating the age old phrase "the dosage makes the poison" so often that I'm basically immune to anyone crying "X is poison". It's all about "how much?" and "over which time period?" and "where did you put it into your body?" to determine if something will kill you or cause cancer.
- orwin 9y agoTrue. Glyphosate opponent target the fact that everybody ingest glyphosate (and that's supposed to be bad). But the dose we ingest (at least in western europe) is too small to be really dangerous, and i think this arguent is a bad one. However, i am concerned about farmer and gardener using the product, as well as kids living near them. Most natural pesticide and herbicide show bad affect on young people brain developpement. I would be really surprised if a chemical, more potent one was harmless.
- zaarn 9y agoIt really depends, mostly on whether or not Glyphosate can cross the Blood-Brain barrier and how easily it does. If it barely or not at all goes through then there should be less of an impact.
- Yaa101 9y agoGuess who is paid by Monsanto...
- cholantesh 9y agoGood ol' shill gambit.
- fredley 9y agoThe article mentions that Glyphosates are cancerous, but so is bacon, which people eat in large amounts. But this is only a qualitative measure. How much exposure are we getting? How much exposure gives an equivalent risk factor to eating one portion of bacon a week? Lazy comparisons like this raise a red flag for me. A scientific look at the harm caused by Glyphosates this is not.
- stonewhite 9y agoIt doesn't say Glyphosates are cancerous, it says the same international group (IARC) considers them to be cancerous, even at a higher risk level. Also the authority and integrity of IARC is at question in this article.
- pjmlp 9y agoWe will gladly burn them in multiple fires, I like to eat healthy food, without influence of greedy multinationals that even impose patent suits into farmers.
- eesmith 9y ago"I don't want to over-hype it, but it felt a little like mob rule. You can still burn the witch in Europe — if the witch is called Monsanto." The author may not want to over-hype it, but successfully did so. Using the same argument, the FDA ban is a witch-burning mob because of its ban on sodium cyclamate, despite its approval in the vast majority of other countries and despite the continued lack of evidence that it's a carcinogen.
- natskyge 9y agoI expected better from you HN. I personally know people who work for the EU in determining whether or not pesticides are safe or not. And not a single one of the has any doubt that glyphosate is safe. FFS people, don't say you know things you don't...
- singularity2001 9y agoWhat a sad piece of propaganda. If they want to white-wash poison, they should try harder.
- yodsanklai 9y agoThis article raises some valid points. If anything, it makes me want to learn more on glyphosates and have an informed opinion. I'd like to hate Monsanto, but for valid reasons! Many commenters here criticise the article without providing any argument other than "you are brainwashed/paid by the lobbies". Not the standard of argumentation one expect on HN!
- friedButter 9y agoWell, the real problem with burning witches was that they were actually Human! I dont see whats the problem with a market illogically choosing to boycott a product, if the market wants a less efficient solution, so be it!
- matt4077 9y agoEven if the author is right, and Monsanto is treated unfairly: It borders on immoral to compare the plight of women who were burned alive to environmental concerns hurting a multinational's ability to earn a profit. I know it's used metaphorically, but it's just the wrong metaphor.
- matt4077 9y agoThe author is really not doing himself any favours with the comparisons. Would anyone dispute that bacon and sun exposure are risk factors in cancer? Contrary to his assertion, Australia also ran a pretty well-funded campaign against sun exposure in the 80s and 90s. The reasons why bacon and the sun aren't banned are simply that the former is that eating bacon is a decision people can take individually, and banning it would intrude on peoples' lives and culture much more strongly than banning a pesticide. As for the sun, it is really hard to ban, and has been shown to have benefits that counterweight the cancer risk. Mocking the risk designation of "working as a hairdresser" is similarly hair-raising: Hair-dressers handle all sorts of chemicals, such as colouring agents. I wonder how easily the author could be convinced to expose himself to the lifetime exposure of a typical hairdresser.
- eviltandem 9y agoLiterally everything you said could go both ways: The reason glyphosate isn't banned is simply that the decision to use is it is one people take individually, and banning it would intrude on people's lives and culture - for argument sake I assume farmers also count as people. As for glyphosate, it is really hard to ban, and has been shown to have benefits the counterweight the cancer risk.
- mcphage 9y ago> You can still burn the witch in Europe — if the witch is called Monsanto. Wait, so Monsanto is a person, not a company? And they've been murdered by a mob? Oh, wait, no, just their product was licensed for 5 years instead of 15. Yeah, I guess how that's similar to a mob grabbing women and murdering them by fire.