35 ms·
For anyone coming straight to the comments looking for an answer to the question: it turns into CO2 (and a bit of water) and you breathe it out. When you reali
by mikeash 9y ago
For anyone coming straight to the comments looking for an answer to the question: it turns into CO2 (and a bit of water) and you breathe it out.
When you realize that you have to breathe out all the weight you lose, I think it gives you a bigger appreciation for how difficult weight loss can be.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoExercise makes more sense! Breathing hard == losing weight!
- Zanta 9y agoFrom the paper "Replacing one hour of rest with exercise that raises the metabolic rate to seven times that of resting by, for example, jogging, removes an additional 39 g of carbon from the body, raising the total by about 20% to 240 g. For comparison, a single 100 g muffin represents about 20% of an average person’s total daily energy requirement. Physical activity as a weight loss strategy is, therefore, easily foiled by relatively small quantities of excess food."
- misterdata 9y agoThe question is whether the body spends any energy outside of that hour after exercising (e.g. by growing muscle, etc.) than it would otherwise. That would make exercise more effective when considering longer periods of time.
- k__ 9y ago200g are what would be "breathed out" in one hour without exercise? So you can only increase your "burn rate" by 20%?
- finnh 9y agoIncreasing your basal rate of caloric consumption (and, thus, CO2 exhaled) is hard.
- Filligree 9y agoA remarkable fraction of your energy consumption is spent on basic maintenance, and of the rest, far more than you'd think is spent on the brain. Your body is extremely efficient, by engineering standards, but that includes locomotion. Exercise is still a good way to drop in weight, but not simply due to burning up the fat; that could happen anyway. What seems to be happening is that the exercise improves the body's budgeting logic, probably by putting you back in a regime evolution already dealt with. The way to drop in weight isn't to exercise (as such), and it isn't to eat less. All the logic that says those count, is valid, but you have to account for the body fighting back. The goal is to eat less because you don't feel hungry, not despite feeling hungry. Very few have the willpower to literally starve themselves.
- yetihehe 9y ago> Very few have the willpower to literally starve themselves. Yep, tried this recently with closed loop weight control. After about 8-10kg (from 116kg) lost it's almost impossible to keep on going, you can't control yourself enough to not eat.
- sparkzilla 9y agoI have lost the same amount from about the same weight in the past eight weeks or so, and will have no trouble continuing. The key (for me at least) is to eat a big lunch (around 1000 calories) of whatever you like (today I had burger and fries) and then have a couple of small snacks to a total of 200-300 calories in the evening (I'm eating a Muller corner yoghurt right now). The problem with most diets is that they starve you throughout the day, when the actual problem is habitual snacking. With this method, the most you have to wait is until the next day, when you can eat whatever you like again for lunch. Originally I intended to have a cheat day every 10 days, but I've barely needed them.
- StevePerkins 9y agoI can't help but groan at some of the "obvious" health and weight loss platitudes that get smugly thrown around. "Calories in, calories out!" "You can't outrun a bad diet!" "Weight is lost in the kitchen!" Sure, things ultimately boil down to intake-vs-expenditure. However, it IS more complicated than that in practice. As software developers, we complain when management makes decisions based on inadequate or poor metrics. But likewise there so many more benefits to physical exercise that aren't captured by a diet and exercise tracking app. During times when I've been 100% sedentary for long periods, I experience overwhelming cravings for sugar and crappy foods. When I force myself to take up any consistent exercise, even just a 30 min walk in the morning or lunchtime... then the cravings subside and regular meals are sufficient. This is fairly common. Exercise has so many physical and mental health benefits. But even just looking at weight management alone, exercise tends to ramp up your metabolism for hours after each exercise session. Something that doesn't get captured by your tracker app or wearable gadget. So often, when I hear somebody smugly minimizing the importance of exercise to health and weight management, it's a person who is too-clever-by-half. They're constantly dabbling with soylent shakes or paleo/keto fad diets... because the truth is they're just lazy and don't want to get off their ass, and look to rationalize that. EDIT: At least half of these replies are completely missing my point altogether. I'm not saying that there is a binary choice to be made between "good diet" OR "exercise", and that you should make the latter choice rather than the former. I'm saying that treating this as a binary choice in the first place is ridiculous. Exercise correlates with proper eating, it's not incidental or ancillary. It's ineffective to tell someone to "go the gym" without changing their eating habits? Well sure, but telling them to "go keto" without worrying about physical activity will be no more successful a year out. It's the pretense that most people can consistently stick with one of these things, and not both together, that is absurd.
- beardbandit 9y ago"I can't help but groan at some of the "obvious" health and weight loss platitudes that get smugly thrown around." On the flip side, the people that are told this are the ones that are annoyingly attempting to maintain their bad eating habits while just adding exercise, or adding fab foods, or anything really to delude themselves into thinking they can continue to eat the same way.
- srcmap 9y agoI wish there is a way to allow one to enjoy eating but control how much to absorb the food.
- colanderman 9y agoI'm not sure whether you're being serious, but as a serious answer, that unabsorbed food has to go somewhere. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olestra#Side_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olestra#Side_effects
- nradov 9y agoEnjoy eating by picking better quality food in small portions instead of focusing on quantity.
- bo1024 9y agoThat quote is deceptive. An hour's jogging will burn at least 500 calories even for quite small people going quite slow, perhaps 700-800 for larger or faster ones. That would be a massive muffin and significantly more than 20% of an average calorie consumption.
- ac29 9y agoMuffins can have quite a lot of calories. The (admittedly fairly large) ones at Costco are over 600 calories: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/food/calories/kirkland-costco-blueberry-muffin-205473697 http://www.myfitnesspal.com/food/calories/kirkland-costco-bl...
- bo1024 9y agoOkay, but not a small amount of food as they describe/imply.
- arkh 9y agoIt's easier to eat less calories than exercise.
- eeks 9y agoI don't know about easier, but it's certainly more efficient.
- bunderbunder 9y agoHow easy it is probably depends on your circumstances. There are infographics and whatnot out there detailing the caloric density of different kinds of food, that make it clear that, depending on the diet you already eat, you can reduce your calorie intake by vast amounts just by switching up what kinds of food you eat. But it's potentially a more expensive way to eat, and probably a more time-consuming one if you don't already enjoy cooking.
- pascalxus 9y agoI used to believe that too. Just eat low caloric density foods, right? It makes a lot of sense. So, I calculated the precise caloric density of Everything and ate nothing but <0.8 calories/gram foods with increased emphesis on 0.2 I had to eat truely vast amounts of food to get anywhere near full. We're talking many many pounds of spinach and 8 zero calorie jellos, pound after pound of vegetables and high fiber fruits: like berries. It does NOT work well at all. Don't get me wrong, it helps a little, but your stomach is extremely smart and it knows alot more about calorie counting than we do. Like it or not, it keeps it's own account of your calorie intake and adjusts your hunger and appetite accordingly. If you're like me and you're already eating a very healthy diet and you exercise regularly and your still gaining weight, you only have one option: go hungry. Very hungry. Right now, it's the only way. You could exercise a lot more, but either way, you're going to suffer.
- eeks 9y agoThat’s also my experience. I do a lot of Thai boxing and I need to control my weight to maintain my weight class. I switched from a balanced diet to a keto diet hoping for change but at the end both averaged the same. The only difference was that with the balanced diet I had to eat twice as much food to actually feel full and work out without being dizzy. Now I am walking down the path of strict calorie intake control, trying to better understand my metabolism tipping point. Working out more has no effect if it does not come with some form of caloric restriction.
- waibelp 9y agoWeight is lost in the kitchen.
- scotty79 9y agoNot worth it. If you excercise hard for an hour daily you can triple your rate of breathing during that hour. So you get 26 instead of 24 hours of usual fat burning. Not much of a difference. Skipping some food can do much more.
- loco5niner 9y agoI would venture to guess that it's not necessarily just that you are breathing in out out more often, but that the composition of the air you are breathing out changes.
- scotty79 9y ago> composition of the air you are breathing out changes. Apparently experiments show it pretty much stays the same. To remove more CO2 from your blood your body just breaths faster. Maybe the process of exhaling can't achieve higher concentration.
- maxerickson 9y agoHow much weight does a typical person breath out in a day though? (if you figure ~2000 calories worth, it doesn't seem like the breathing weight out is so much the issue...)
- mikeash 9y agoAccording to the article, a typical person will breathe out about 200 grams of carbon per day. (The oxygen in the CO2 comes from oxygen you breathe in, so doesn't contribute to any net weight change.) A pound of fat is about 3500 calories, and typical sedentary metabolic rate is about 2000 calories per day, so you'd expect to lose about 0.57lbs ~= 260 grams per day if you didn't eat. The article says that CO2 makes up 84% of weight lost (the rest is water), so that fits fairly closely to the 200 grams/day of CO2 breathed out.
- xisbad 9y agoSo does that mean that sitting on the couch is more environmentally friendly than exercising?
- stepanhruda 9y agoNo it means not eating is more environmentally friendly.
- mikeash 9y agoThe food you eat will turn to CO2 one way or another. If you let your food become fat rather than CO2, that fat will eventually turn into CO2 after you die.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoNo, but turning the thermostat down a bit can be (though worse in summer). You can use up a lot of energy just keeping warm.
- _jal 9y agoSave the planet - sequester carbon in yourself!
- sillysaurus3 9y agoIt's better for HN to let the reader dig for information. It attracts the curious. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=by:dang%20%22work%20a%20little%22&sort=byDate&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?query=by:dang%20%22work%20a%20little...
- mikeash 9y agoI respectfully disagree. The only reason I didn't use the word "clickbait" is because it's apparently the actual title of a scholarly paper. A lot of the titles that turn up in your search are what I'd call clickbait.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoIt's part of HN's cultural fabric. It'd be a shame to lose it. A useful exercise: What's the difference between answering the title and writing a tl;dr? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7789697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13028168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13028168
- mikeash 9y agoI've been posting here for years and this is the first I've heard of it. It doesn't seem like a very important part of the site's culture. Or maybe I'm just oblivious, it's possible. The difference between answering the title and writing a tl;dr is that the former doesn't use the character sequence "tl;dr." Apparently this is important. From your first link: > PeterWhittaker's comment is fine without the "tl;dr". The concern is the symbol—symbols matter. I'm a bit confused as to what happened in the second link. Going up the comment chain, apparently the original title spelled out what happened but was editorialized, so it got changed, and "There's a downside to spelling things out completely" was part of the explanation of why it was OK to switch to a less editorialized title with much less information in it. Yet the title of the post is the one they said they changed. Did they change it back later?
- 9y ago
- adekok 9y ago2 pounds a day. That's how much CO2 you breath out, and the hard limit for weight loss. You can lose more than that, (see boxers before a weigh-in), but that's all water loss, and is temporary. And, with a strong likelihood of death.
- leshow 9y agoI'd suspect the more exercise you do the more that number moves up, you'd be breathing harder. I'd hesitate to try and put a 'hard limit' on anything like this.
- ransom1538 9y ago"For anyone coming straight to the comments looking for an answer to the question: it turns into CO2 (and a bit of water) and you breathe it out." That is why you weigh less when you wake up in the morning (pre-bathroom -/+ yes some sweat).
- kgabis 9y agoAlso water vapor from you breathing.
- killjoywashere 9y agoThe water is the vast majority of the overnight weight loss. pCO2 of 40 mmHg is normal. Resting tidal volume is 500-600 mL, and a breathing rate of 12-14 (officially 10-20, but really, more like 12-14). I'll let someone calculate the mass of CO2 exhaled in 8 hours.
- mikeash 9y agoThe article claims that 200 grams/day lost as carbon in CO2 is typical. (The oxygen comes from breathing in, so doesn't count for anything.) That implies that the amount lost in eight hours of sleep is somewhat less than 67 grams.
- xhruso00 9y agoCan I lose weight by breathing faster instead of excersizing?
- mikeash 9y agoMerely breathing faster won't help. Each breath will just remove less CO2. What you need to do is produce CO2 faster, which means increasing your metabolic rate somehow. That generally means exercise.
- bluGill 9y agoThat is a form of exercise, so in that sense yes. It isn't significant, even on the scale of a year, but it is something we can calculate. For practical purposes no. When you breath faster your body just gets rid of less CO2 per breath. The amount of CO2 your body creates for a given exercise level can be considered a constant.
- arikrak 9y agoMeanwhile the reverse happens when a tree builds itself by pulling out carbon from the co2 in the air
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoTrees (and other plants) are almost entirely air and water. Very little soil gets incorporated, and almost all of that is trace minerals dissolved in the water.
- loco5niner 9y agoCurious. I've heard this about trees. What about tomatoes? Cucumbers? etc? Or is this comment only referring to the "substance" of a plant and not its fruit(or similar)?
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoIt applies to fruit and similar. All the sugar and other carbohydrates are air+water primarily. There's a bit of nitrogen from the soil, and everything else is extremely small trace elements. Carbon, Hydrogen, Oxygen, Nitrogen (CHON) are the four most common elements in all Earth life. Plants get the hydrogen and oxygen from water, and carbon (and more oxygen) from CO2 in the air. Cellulose is CHO only. Same for glucose, fructose, etc. Nitrogen is mostly found in the proteins, with a bit in DNA, RNA, and ATP. Humans are about 3% nitrogen by mass, plants are a bit less (lower protein concentration).
- zappo2938 9y agoI sometimes ask the deep philosophical question, why does a tree not sink into the ground it grows out of? It blows people's minds when I explain that the reason is because the tree is mostly water and CO2, a gas and a liquid coming from the sky.
- WkndTriathlete 9y agoTrees don't sink into the ground because (a) a tree's root system is as large in the ground as it stands out of the ground and (b) the pressure of the weight of the tree is distributed across the (large) surface area of that root system. Trees aren't light, by any stretch of the imagination. That solid mass is mostly water. Try lifting up a 1' or 2' section of a tree trunk that's 1-2' in diameter sometime.
- MatthaeusHarris 9y agoI believe gp meant, "if the bulk of a tree's mass comes from dirt, why isn't the dirt around the tree used up as the tree gains mass?"
- fleitz 9y agoThat's because the ground doesn't hold up trees, trees pin down the ground. Also, trees grow into the ground, not out of it.
- darrenf 9y agoI've lost 16kg this year, which I attribute to 3 things: 1. being fairly strict with calorie intake - though I have gone over my limit a whole bunch of times 2. upping my running game - 80km+ most months 3. being diagnosed asthmatic (after 40 years of merely "you've got shitty lungs, sorry") and prescribed a morning+night inhaler Dieting isn't new to me, I've been a fat bastard all my adult life. Previous attempts at losing weight have involved doing (1)+(2) and each time I lost weight and got faster. But with the diagnosis at the start of this year, and despite a higher calorie allowance, I've smashed my PBs at various distances - multiple times - and lost more weight (NB. because I started higher; I'm not at a record low, yet). So it seems pretty intuitive to me that "I'm better at breathing" has played a hell of a part.
- rconti 9y agoI highly recommend a meal tracker app for anyone who's looking to lose. I avoided it for ages. I didn't want to be "one of those people". I felt like I ate fairly well and was working hard enough, I shouldn't have to stoop to that level. I started bike commuting over 3 months ago now, but my weight was only increasing, and I was pretty sure my diet was the same as ever -- healthy breakfast, fairly healthy lunch, healthy dinner -- mostly homemade, rarely eat out, etc. My only real "sin" was drinking, but it didn't seem to matter if I drank every night or cut back to weekends only (which I had when I started biking, working out more, and again seeing no real benefit). So I finally broke down and started using one a few weeks ago and it's made all the difference in the world. The biggest advantage is the immediate metrics. I HATED the idea that I could work my ass off for a week or three and see my weight go up, or down, and really have no idea what was happening on a day to day basis. By tracking my meals (plus workouts and commuting between Strava and Apple Health sync), I can immediately see if I'm ahead or behind. It's the feedback I had been craving for years. Where I thought the point of one of these apps was to try to learn what's healthy to eat and to be calorically restrictive (which was unappealing.. again, I don't want to be "that guy"), it's really the realtime data that's useful. In my particular case, I've learned I actually eat amazingly well for the most part, and it's very easy to run huge caloric deficits during the week. Without even trying I was seeing a deficit of perhaps 1500kcal/day (during the week). What was killing me was beer (on weekends, but then again, 3/7 days is almost half the days of the week) and the occasional big consumption day. You know, have a big breakfast on the weekend, a big lunch, some drinks, and pretty soon 1 day could almost kill a whole week's progress. The tracking has given me the ability to say actually, yeah, one more beer really WILL push me over the edge from a deficit to a gain. I don't really need that 3rd bagel. And so on. And given that I tend to consume more on weekends, and typically I only got a single short run in one weekend day, those weekends were just killing my progress. On the other hand, it's made me mind snacking a bit less -- the deficits I run during the week are so big that a couple fun size bag of Skittles (we just ran out of halloween candy at work) make almost no difference in my daily progress. I'm just starting out with it, but again, the realtime feedback has made me realize how much EASIER it's going to be than I ever expected. When I felt I had nothing left to easily cut or change, I actually found the solutions were far easier than I realized, and it's helped me to quantify things that I knew were bad but didn't really appreciate the magnitude of. And because I no longer have to just "do my best" or a month and hope it shows up on the scale, there's no more disappointment/discouragement.
- scotty79 9y agoThunderf00t had a great take on this showing why excercise is pretty much useless for weight loss. You exhale same percentage of CO2 no matter how active you are so to burn more fat you have to make yourself breathe faster. You can do that with excercise which, if it's intense, can triple your rate of breathing. But if you do intensly excercise for an hour each day you just burn 26 hours of fat instead 24. Not much of a difference. You can do much more with skipping some snacks or soda you ingest daily.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoMost people want to add some muscle mass too, not just remove fat stores.
- scotty79 9y agoFat people usually have plenty of muscles. They need them to lug the fat around. I'm not saying you shouldn't excercise to get healthier or build some muscle but don't expect to loose weight from excercise.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hammock 9y agoSimilarly, when a tree grows, where does most of the mass come from? a) the soil b) water c) the air d) other
- fleitz 9y agoYou can also piss it out in the form of ketones.
- infogulch 9y agoI was under the impression (admittedly I don't know from where) that the process of burning fat actually dehydrates you and that you need to drink extra water if you want to facilitate it. But here you remind me that the process of burning hydrocarbons nets some water, making me question myself. Of course metabolizing body fat is more complex than that, so this doesn't disprove it, but now I'm wondering if anyone else has more concrete information.
- ssfsa 9y agoDont forget that you need to cool your body, so you sweat when you work out. Also, as you breathe harder, you'll loose more moisture through your lungs (the water activity of your whatever parts in the lungs being higher than that of dry air.) If you were to exercise outdoors during a cold rain, you'll probably not loose any water at all. But what do I know? I've never exercised in my life.
- thecity2 9y agoAnd heat!