15 ms·
Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke'
- SCdF 9y agoNot to bang on about it, but this kind of thing is why I use an ad-blocker. It's barely even about ads in the traditional sense anymore, it's about being able to read a fucking article without having half the internet downloaded in the background while every nano of my being available is processed and analysed by 30 different tracking companies simultaneously.
- MetalMatze 9y agoCouldn't agree more.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoIts not as sexy a name, but I think ad blockers should be primarily described as tracking blockers. Its sounds as important as "anti-virus" and i think it could drive a few more people towards using them.
- fredley 9y agoI'd agree with this. I would be more likely to allow ads, particularly on sites I want to support, if I could have assurances that those ads aren't harvesting every available datapoint they can. Make ads dumb again.
- dhimes 9y agoYep. So much this. I don't mind ads. I mind tracking. Oh, and advertisers: I've never bought anything because I saw it on facebook or in a google ad or anywhere else like that. I'm not sure what you think you are doing with all that data, but it's not working. Ads are not how I learn about new "needs."
- theorique 9y agoI've never bought anything because I saw it on facebook or in a google ad or anywhere else like that. Can you be certain that this is true? Perhaps you didn't click through (I don't either), but what if your unconscious mind saw an ad that you did not register consciously.
- dhimes 9y agoYou can never falsify that, obviously, and I think a lot of the web-ad industry like to keep that FOMO in front of the advertisers. But I'm fairly certain. Vacations? Nope: I have my way of deciding and that's how I do it. Car? Nope. Calendar/planner? Nope. Pencils? Pens? Grill? Pants? Nope Nope Nope Nope. I'm hard-pressed to think of the last brand I learned of from an ad. Books? Usually from here (also planners, cars, etc.)
- davchana 9y agoMost of the the the ads I see by Google or Facebook are the ones for purchases I already made. Few weeks ago I already booked a hotel on booking.com, and then searched about that hotel's official website and facebook page, and boy, for two weeks every google ad and facebook ad had that hotel name.
- dhimes 9y agoLOL exactly. It's ridiculous. I accidentally cost my buddy a click when his ad appeared on my feed (his ad has no business being on my feed)- I was on mobile so of course accidentally clicked it. The ad industry is just so damn broken that it's ripe for a huge disruption. The whole hypothesis of Google- that people will want to see ads centered on what they are searching for- seems to be erroneous. But it's been taken as gospel for what- a dozen years?- that everybody has piled on to the idea that we can know what people want to buy based on the type of information they seek. I think that except in explicit cases- searching for 'umbrellas that can withstand high winds' for instance- it's not true. As I've said before here, when I'm ready to buy I'm searching Amazon, not Google.
- jdietrich 9y agouBlock Origin describes itself as "a wide-spectrum blocker which happens to be able to function as a mere ad blocker". It has the explicitly stated goal of allowing the user to personalise their browsing experience in whatever way they choose. https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock
- westmeal 9y agoFor finer grained control of the scripts, XHRs, and media being accepted by your browser I'd recommend installing uBlock Origin && uMatrix. uMatrix allows you to blacklist or whitelist everything on a page with some pretty good defaults.
- rightos 9y agoYou can get a lot of uMatrix's functionality just by enabling the "I am an advanced user" checkbox in uBlock Origin. I actually find it a better interface, but that's a personal preference.
- nothrabannosir 9y agoI second the recommendation for uMatrix. Recently switched from noscript due to ff57 and boy, what an improvement. The matrix model works very well. It makes total sense to only allow certain types of resources and/or/from certain domains per level in the dns hierarchy. The defaults are much more usable than noscript and the UI is great once you “get it” (won’t take more than a day or two).
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoI run one as a malware blocker, because if I don't then my computers get attacked at least once a day, often by reputable sites. It's probably more important than an antivirus for stopping malware.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoIt's definitely more important than antivirus but I don't think the general population has figured that out.
- clouddrover 9y agoFirefox and Brave have tracking protection built-in. Not sure if any other browsers offer this out of the box.
- saiya-jin 9y agohow good is it though? I couldn't care less about "non-intrusive ads" of adblock plus for example, that's not very efficient. microBlock origin on the other hand, that's pretty much required these days, especially on tiny mobile screens.
- jasonkostempski 9y agoFirefox doesn't really have tracking protection built-in. There's "Do not track", but that's worse than worthless and off by default, and you can turn on blocking thrid-party cookies but, again, off by default and only covers a small area of concern. I don't even know what to say about Brave other than the business model feels very wrong. Firefox + uBlock Origin is the right level of protection and you can get it on desktop and mobile (Android at least). I've come across a few sites that were still using affiliate links and uO didn't block them. I'm not sure if uO has a policy of not blocking them but, to me, those are the only type of "acceptable ad" and CPU cycles shouldn't be wasted trying to detect and eliminate them.
- skymt 9y agoI believe clouddrover is talking about this tracking protection feature, which uses Disconnect's list of tracking scripts: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tracking-protection https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/tracking-protection
- dhimes 9y agoI use noscript and am pretty happy with it. I also use Adblock Plus because I'm ok with the idea of allowing certain types of ads through the adblockers. I was kind of thinking that we could get sites to stop doing the tracking bullshit if we put out a list of what is acceptable and blocked the rest. I guess it wasn't well executed?
- cptskippy 9y agoWhy don't we just call them malware blockers? What we refer to as tracking or analytics code has evolved well past the point of understanding and has crossed over into manipulation. That's ultimately what advertising is these days, a means to manipulate you into spending your money.
- fhood 9y agoHonestly I don't care what is be tracked, but until it is no longer the case that 60% of webpages slow my computer to a crawl for about six seconds I am not turning mine off, no matter how many times the website asks politely.
- andrewaylett 9y agoThat's Privacy Badger's USP: https://www.eff.org/privacybadger https://www.eff.org/privacybadger
- beejiu 9y agoI hope you do not use Google Chrome, if you are worried about privacy.
- ams6110 9y agoWell that's debatable. The technology of chrome (better sandboxing) is an advantage. I've alternated between Chromium and Firefox. Some sites seem to work better in one browser or the other.
- joosters 9y agoI think the parent comment was because Chrome does its own user tracking and reporting to Google.
- drdaeman 9y agoWhat exactly does it do? I've re-read their whitepaper and while there is some data one may consider sensitive, it's not something like "user tracking and reporting" beyond the performance metrics and search suggestions (which all other major browsers do as well). There are optional features which may result in private data being sent to Google, e.g. keeping history with Google without local encryption - but you have to opt-in, which feels OK to me. https://www.google.com/chrome/browser/privacy/whitepaper.html https://www.google.com/chrome/browser/privacy/whitepaper.htm...
- libertyEQ 9y agoI think using Chromium makes sense when sites have a preference, and there are attempts to remove the Google tracking from the core of the project: https://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium/releases https://github.com/Eloston/ungoogled-chromium/releases
- dahart 9y ago> this kind of thing is why I use an ad-blocker While ad blockers do stop a lot of third party ads and iframes, and probably some tracking, I don't think that ad blockers are stopping most tracking by web sites. Not the kind this article is talking about, anyway. It's quite simple for sites to track user activity in ways that ad blockers can't easily stop. And I suspect it's becoming more likely quickly, purely on the anecdotal number of sites I visit that now detect ad blockers. Some of this article seems like FUD though. It's pretty hard to think of what keystrokes you would type into a web site that you don't want to send the web site. The main thing they're getting by tracking keystrokes that they didn't get before is typos and form activity that you start and then decide to clear and bail out. I'd speculate that this is being used and is most important for sales conversion pages, where they monitor your activity to try to figure out if you started out interested in buying something but then decided not to buy. Web sites cannot track your keystrokes when you're using a different site / tab in your browser, they can't track keystrokes when you use another program besides the browser, they can only track when you're interacting with the site. So what sensitive data can they get that you weren't already giving them?
- djsumdog 9y agoI was at a University that paid for some tracking software we self-hosted. It showed a highlighted webpage showing gradients over the most common places they scrolled too. Adblock lists are community maintained, so whether this stuff is blocked depends a lot on people who actually enjoy having their network debug panel open. Facebook's tracking pixel their e-commerce affiliates use is insane. It sends most mouse movements and they use it to determine what words users hover their mouse over! Their AI/marketing engine is pretty advanced, to the point where their predictive analysis is accurate enough people swear Facebook/Instragram are sending microphone data. Sure they cannot track you across tabs and browsers ... directly. But they do. If 30% of the pages you visit have some kind of Adobe Omniture or Facebook pixel, they do in fact gleam a ton of data about you. This AI is so powerful it can predict products you want, potentially before you even verbally announce them. That's incredibly powerful predictive analysis ... used to cure cance---oh no wait. It's not. It's just used to sell you shit. What a waste of tech honestly. I know a lot of people here use uBlock Origin since there are concerns with Ghostery/AdBlock/etc either allowing in certain ads for a price or selling some of your data to be viable. The only real solution for tech people is to run a Javascript blocker like NoScript, and explicitly white listing what you want to run .. which is honestly a ton-o-work.
- zeveb 9y agoThe problem isn't just ads, though: first-party JavaScript can still record every keystroke you type, so e.g. if you accidentally type your login password into a browser window (even if no input field is focused) then you must change it. The problem is that most of us are reading what should be static content which is instead a dynamic program written in a general-purpose language.
- phrygian 9y agoI simply disable JavaScript. Only when I’m on a page that I think I really need JavaScript capabilities to I open it in another browser that has JS enabled. Of course some in the latter category do nasty stuff but only those I explicitly allow get to run JS with Adblock enabled.
- apostacy 9y agoIf javascript is allowed to persist in the background, read the keydown and cursor location, and keep a socket open back to the server, then that won't matter. Personally, I do not understand why this has become acceptable, if all I am doing is viewing text and static images. Ideally, I would like it so that the browser suspends everything if a tab is not visible in the foreground, unless I pin it.
- hpaavola 9y agoAbout 6 months ago I got tired of all the tracking and fingerprinting that is going on and installed NoScript. Surprisingly few web pages require Javascript. Give it a try, you might be pleasantly surprised.
- ekianjo 9y agoThat's not the case at all if you go to a site that uses React. For those, you are welcome by a blank page with NoScript.
- zaarn 9y agoPersonally I prefer uMatrix since that tool usually allows first party scripts be default (unless you configure otherwise), so most JS sites work on a basic level.
- lucideer 9y agoThis is somewhat moot as (a) I think most React devs don't do this, and (b) if they do, the resulting page may still not be very useful. However, any React developer worth their salt (probably still a minority, as mentioned above) should be using ReactDOMServer which will render the page fine without browser JS being enabled.
- plif 9y agoI thought this was mainly used to improve first load speed. The site won't be very useful if you can't interact with it beyond that.
- lucideer 9y agoWhile it does depend on the purpose of your site, even in the purest examples in the "web app" category, I can think of very few sites that are guaranteed to be absolutely 100% useless without interactivity. Certainly not as useless as a white screen. In most cases though, you should be able to present a pretty useful static page by default without too much effort.
- ourmandave 9y agoMakes me want to search StackOverflow to see who asked how to reverse the order of a keystroke log file, so they can see if anyone backspaced off "your site sucks" in the comments box.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThis is why it is absolutely mandatory that any browser I use has Privacy Badger and uBlock Origin in dynamic mode with all 3rd party scripts and 3rd party frames blocked by default, in addition to the static block lists. Dynamic mode is the somewhat hidden feature that makes uBlock Origin as powerful as NoScript, and more flexible when it comes to differentiating between whether to allow content from a domain globally, or only on specific sites. https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dynamic-filtering:-quick-guide https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dynamic-filtering:-qu... Highly recommended.
- tombrossman 9y agoLong time NoScript user here, and I had to remove it today as it is completely broken and unusable. I cannot even get the preferences to open so I can export my whitelisted domains to uMatrix, which I'm testing as a replacement. I would like to combine uBlock and uMatrix, but I'm not sure I can replicate the functionality I want. Your mention of dynamic filtering is interesting and I wonder if others are using it and can make a recommendation? I need all JavaScript off by default (including first-party) and the ability to block both ad-serving domains and filters such as /ads/ that work across all domains. Is this possible to do entirely within uBlock Origin?
- beckler 9y agoLooking at the uBlock dynamic filtering, it looks very similar to uMatrix. To block all scripts in uBlock, you'd probably want to block inline scripts, 1st party scripts, and 3rd party scripts with global rules which is possible with dynamic filtering. However, if you're using chrome, you should have the ability to disable it from the browser altogether.
- tombrossman 9y agoI'm using Firefox and I need an easy way to toggle JS on for specific domains, which NoScript used to allow and uMatrix does, but I think I'll have to do some further experimentation and get used to the new add-on.
- djhworld 9y agoThis is what worries me a bit about browser extensions like 1 password and other password managers. Could a website that has a keylogger in it potentially pick up these keystrokes when I put my password into an extension?
- plif 9y agoNo. They only have access to anything inputted within their site's window. I think this article is a bit sensationalist. These sites already have access to all of your data (stored in their databases!). There's nothing additional they are gaining from this aside from how you input that data. That is much less sensitive information and I can't think of another usage aside from improving their site's UX.
- notzorbo3 9y ago> These sites already have access to all of your data (stored in their databases!) The assumption for most people is going to be that they have the data that you explicitly sent them. Implicitly gathering and sending data is equivalent to snooping on people without consent. It's all about expectations.
- djhworld 9y agoIs there a risk of information leakage? Say for example a website asks me for something (e.g. an address, phone number, bank account number), I type it in (thus registering my keystroke presses to the keylogger) and then realise oops I didn't mean to type that, I meant to type something else Does the website then submit the logged keystrokes for offline analysis?
- plif 9y agoYes, theoretically in the case you mentioned. All responsible implementations of this won't actually log PII. It's pretty trivial to withhold certain inputs. All of the services mentioned in the article have easy ways to flag an input field as private / do not log. I'd wager a lot of money that these sites are interested in gathering UX data and not scraping for accidental form input. I suppose there's a certain level of trust involved, but I don't think that's any different than when you make an online purchase. /shrug
- Banthum 9y agoNot that I agree with the practice or anything, but I have to call out the how obviously maximally-outrage-inducing the headline is. From the middle of the story: >They found that 482 of the world's top 50,000 sites used scripts provided by one of these firms. Less than 1% of the sites did this. God I'm tired of this kind of "journalism".
- toomanybeersies 9y agoAnd this is why we need the GDPR. The potential for the sheer amount of sensitive personal information that this can hoover up is extraordinary.
- rwmj 9y agoAn EU regulation for data protection (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Data_Protection_Regula...) for anyone else who was wondering.
- jerf 9y agoIf you are a tech-type company doing business in the EU and this is news to you, hie thee hence to a lawyer forthwith. The GDPR has teeth. You are not going to want to discover you're in violation the hard way.
- jacquesm 9y ago2018 will likely not see active enforcement, a couple of stern warnings and maybe a single case to court to show they mean business. But I fully expect the hammer to come down in 2019 and frankly I can't wait. I look at a lot of companies professionally and the range goes from: "GDPR? What is that?" to "Sure, we're ready, here is what we did and we are already compliant.". Most companies are somewhere in the middle between those two, they are aware that something is changing but they are still trying to figure out the impact on their business. Lawyers are - unless their specialty is privacy law and they have boned up on this - pretty useless and generally tend to know even less.
- gnu8 9y agoIt's our fault for turning the web into the monstrosity it has become. Web browsers are for displaying hypertext documents. DOCUMENTS. Why on earth are we executing code at all?
- oblio 9y agoFor the same reason all major document formats execute code. PDFs execute code, DOC(X)s execute code. Users want features: interactivity, automation of various bits, etc. Features = users = money. Money > anything (security, privacy, etc.).
- mrob 9y agoPDF code execution is an implementation detail. It's there for data compression purposes, not interactivity. DOCX macros are disabled by default. Code execution by default in HTML documents is unusual.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoJavascript was tacked onto PDF a few years back for interactive display.
- jacquesm 9y agoPlenty of that could have been achieved by slower but more consistent and secure development of extensions to HTML. That wouldn't give you Google maps, docs or gmail, but the vast majorit of SAAS products could have probably been created in one way or another with the restriction that no code could execute client side. More and more pages that could have worked just fine now render as totally blank because client side frameworks are now being pushed from every angle. As an end user there is no clear advantage to this.
- umanwizard 9y ago> That wouldn't give you Google maps, docs or gmail So, it wouldn't have given you three of the most important and useful applications in the modern world, used every day by millions of people.
- edwhitesell 9y agoOnce again, this is why I've blocked javascript for years. Browsers really need to start offering this without add-ons or extensions.
- notzorbo3 9y agoWhenever someone complains about a website not working without javascript enabled, someone inevitably responds "it's 2017, you can expect javascript to be enabled". I think that piece of knowledge is outdated: - Late 1990's: static html documents + forms - early 2000's: shitty DHTML scripts that added nothing - early 2010's: javascript + gracefully downgrading sites - 2015/16: required useful javascript everywhere - early 2017: trackers everywhere, html5 popups, trackers, spywhere, trackers, bitcoin miners, trackers, etc, etc. 2017 is the year where you NEED a javascript blocker. What's the use of having any security at all if you're going to leave the biggest attack vector in modern times completely unprotected? Plus, the web has become completely unusable without a script blocker.
- pjmlp 9y agoI used to be big into webdev back in the .com wave. Nowadays I always push for HTML5/CSS3 with minimal JavaScript, preferably with server side rendering. For anything really complex I usually try to see if it can be done as native app instead.
- umanwizard 9y ago> the web has become completely unusable without a script blocker. When you exaggerate like that, it diminishes your point. I use the web all day, every day and I have never installed a script blocker.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoMaybe not outright unusable, but certainly really fucking annoying. Not to mention hazardous.
- ams6110 9y ago
- mattzito 9y agoI agree that this can be used for ill, but there's a number of very valid reasons to use these tools: - Heatmap views of where people hover and start to type - capture of individual sessions to research support cases - Better understanding of user flows through a site or web app And all of these tools, at least the reputable ones cited in the article, allow you to mask fields or parts of the screens so that PII isn't captured, and reputable companies do that. The other part of this is that I don't think the article captures well is that these tools aren't used for targeting of ads or personalization or "spying" in the sense of malice, but to try to better understand users, what they're trying to find on a site, and clarify pain when using applications. I also think the people that use these tools, generally speaking, are perfectly fine with blocking them, since it's meant as a diagnostic and analytic tool.
- Brotkrumen 9y agoPasswords, medical records and credit card information are so sensitive that it's irrelevant that there are good uses for the tech that captures them or that at some point in the pipeline they get masked.
- mattzito 9y agoSo, to be clear, the way at least the tools I've worked with operate: - websites implementing these tools need to specifically opt-in text fields they want to capture the inputs for - for HTML-side capture, the javascript will obfuscate PII before sending it to the servers - some of these tools will not capture password fields under any circumstances Does that address some of your concerns?
- Brotkrumen 9y agoNo. There's too many parties involved I'd have to trust to a) want to keep my data save and b) don't mess up. And even if both are true, I have to accept yet another way with several points of failure where bad agent could exfiltrate my data.
- ordinaryperson 9y agoWe use HotJar at work, and it's super useful to see heatmaps of what people click on and what they ignore. This article is a little clickbaity- it implies your passwords and other private info are being stolen, instead of just webpage clicks. Maybe people can hack those tools for ill but that's true of almost any web software platform.
- atonse 9y agoThat's because they ARE being stolen. Maybe not intentionally, but when you log every keystroke, and the user happens to type passwords and other private info in those keystrokes, those are bound to get captured.
- noxToken 9y agoI don't want to be alarmist, but just because it's not stolen doesn't mean that it isn't logged. I've worked with Dynatrace. I've used it piece together bugs that QA had found but couldn't reproduce a second time around. It's truly powerful software. After a set of test data refresh, we lost some of the new test passwords associated with some of the new data. Then it clicked: Dynatrace has keylogging. I searched for login events of those users, and sure enough, there were the keystrokes for the passwords of each of those users. Yes, this kind of software is a godsend for debugging, but improper usage, storage or transmission of data is a real concern.
- mattkevan 9y agoBit hypocritical of the publisher to be decrying intrusive analytics when their site is running Comscore and Chartbeat tracking. Not to bash the BBC – all web publishers are using this stuff and loads more. The BBC are unusually good actually, as their sites don't run adverts and all the adtech crap that comes with them. As someone who designs and builds websites, the data provided by platforms like Hotjar etc. are very useful. And the advertising stuff is required if you want to keep the lights on (unless you have another source of funding like the BBC). As a user I block it all with extreme prejudice.
- flukus 9y ago> Not to bash the BBC – all web publishers are using this stuff and loads more. The BBC are unusually good actually, as their sites don't run adverts and all the adtech crap that comes with them. Recently I was surprised to discover that the Australian equivalent that also has no advertising has half a dozen trackers on there main page. Plus twitter integration and CDN material.
- hashkb 9y agoThis is sensationalized, fear-based reporting. Classic case of someone publishing a strong opinion about something they don't understand. Unless she is trying to imply that security issues are inevitable, session replay tools are used to improve user experience in 95% of cases.
- tzahola 9y agoIs there a browser or extension which doesn't enable mouse and keyboard events by default? I would like to see permission alerts for mouse and keyboard listeners similar to location permission requests.
- Dowwie 9y agoThe Princeton study: https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2017/11/15/no-boundaries-exfiltration-of-personal-data-by-session-replay-scripts/ https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2017/11/15/no-boundaries-exfil...
- steveeq1 9y agoWhen they "record every keystroke", do they mean: a) every keystroke on that particular webpage? b) every keystroke of any webpage on any tab of the browser? c) every keystroke on the laptop itself? If it's b or c, I have a MAJOR problem with this.
- Exuma 9y agoDoes uBlock origin block these recorders without having to do all kinds of crazy advanced config? Edit: TO anyone else wondering the same thing, the answer is no. However, Ghostery does block it. I didn't like ghostery before because it broke all kinds of sites, so this time around I re-added it except I ONLY selected the "Site Analytics" category and left all the others blank (which can be handled by uBlock origin)
- KozmoNau7 9y agoDitch Ghostery, they collect and sell your information (how ironic). Use Privacy Badger instead.
- Exuma 9y agoThat didn't block the inspectlet demo: https://www.inspectlet.com/hello/capturedemo https://www.inspectlet.com/hello/capturedemo Do you have a source for them selling data?
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThat demo doesn't record anything at all here, or at least it certainly cannot play anything back. I'm using Privacy Badger and uBlock Origin (with dynamic mode on). In all fairness to Ghostery, it seems they've cleaned up their act after being bought out by Cliqz: https://adexchanger.com/data-exchanges/ghostery-sheds-ad-tracker-sells-off-plug-focus-compliance/ https://adexchanger.com/data-exchanges/ghostery-sheds-ad-tra... Specifically, it was the Ghostrank feature that was troublesome: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghostery#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghostery#Criticism I don't know how the current version of Ghostery behaves.
- rahimnathwani 9y agoIt's more than hundreds. I'm guessing that each of Inspectlet, Hotjar, Mouseflow, Crazy Egg and Full Story has hundreds of customers. But it's not 'every keystroke', but keystrokes you make whilst interacting with a page on that particular site.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thrillgore 9y agoMany a year ago, an ad firm used to track the words you highlighted with your cursor. I wrote a userscript that highlights every letter repeatedly to spell out "FUCKYOU" when it loaded that company's JS. I mean why do advertisers think its impressive to do this? I swear they increase their intrusion and in return more and more people tune into ad blocking. And don't even ask what I do about sites that insist I turn it off -- I blacklist them.