14 ms·
China Busts a $3B Underground Bank
- thrden 9y agoThis country is an enigma to me, I hear conflicting and convincing arguments as to its economic strength and weakness, that it is on the precipice of collapse or overtaking the United States. I tend to believe that they are weaker than they are strong, but this is based in bias rather than sound evidence. The party leadership appears to be tightening their control over the party and the very wealthy. To me this feels like they are preparing for upheaval by eliminating their likely competitors before a catalytic event.
- ProAm 9y agoIt's one of the first tenets in The Art of War, which applies fairly directly to business: > Appear weak when you are strong, and strong when you are weak. China is very strong, maybe not supremely organized but they are still growing and have been for many years. Especially a country that actively manipulates its currency to reflect its apparent strength or lack of... its anything but unintentional.
- mistermann 9y agoThey are doing a superb job of giving the impression they have little control over money leaving the country. I'd love to read history books 50 years in the future when they are the undisputed and final ruler of planet earth. Smart communism >>> capitalism.
- timthelion 9y ago> They are doing a superb job of giving the impression they have little control over money leaving the country. Well, the US tries to promote the ability of Americans to engage in foreign investment, because foreign investment is a great way to suck money out of a country. If I buy a countries companies, then all the profit from that country goes to me. It's actually in China's interest to have "money leaving the country". And it is more in China's interest to have no one fight back.
- mistermann 9y agoIt depends on where the money is going, and if it is ever coming back. I happen to believe a lot of it is people who covertly working with the government in order to establish significant presence in countries throughout the world, similar to what the US has done, only more economically efficiently. Pure speculation of course, but if they can pull it off... Capitalism and freedom has a giant Achilles heel.
- ryacko 9y agoYes, but foreign investment in China's case depletes foreign reserves. China is also printing money to maintain the current exchange rate, and this is leading to inflation. Their economy is going to result in recession, or they might go to war instead.
- mistermann 9y agoInflation isn't a big concern for China, keeping the manufacturing and technological advancement machine running and public satisfaction high is what matters. And keeping the American public uninformed, but their politicians have that well under control. China is way too smart to go to war, they can assume leadership without having to engage in significant conflict as long as they make sure they share the wealth with the proper people. They actually deserve world leadership, I think they've earned it.
- jmknoll 9y agoDoes it have to be one thing or the other? Like the United States, China is a large and complex country. Pollution is horrible, there is a serious shortage of professional skills, and a looming demographic issue. However, at the same time, growth is strong and the country is still very much a developing economy, which means that there is a lot of low-hanging fruit that can be modernized for economic gains. I don't think it needs to be an issue of China either taking over the world or collapsing. In all likelihood, China will continue to develop along its current track, with China becoming the largest economy sometime in the next 20 years, and presumably the largest military power sometime thereafter. It feels like the real issue is in the US. The United States needs to come to terms with the fact that, for the next generation, it will have a geopolitical and strategic rival of roughly equal strength and influence, and needs to start building a coherent industrial policy to match that reality.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoPollution is probably a price that a country needs to pay in its early stages of modernization. Militarily, China is checked by Vietnam, South Korea, Japan....and drum roll...INDIA. No large country like India wants a military monster next door, so India will have to get strong. Plus the counties in the South China sea have beef with China. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_China_Sea#Territorial_claims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_China_Sea#Territorial_cl... On the other hand, India might have to deal with Pakistan and South Korea with North Korea. Russia is also not a fan of China, Siberia once was Chinese and it's virtually free of people. https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/07/03/where-do-borders-need-to-be-redrawn/why-china-will-reclaim-siberia https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2014/07/03/where-do-bo...
- freeflight 9y agoYou make it sound like all these countries are eternal enemies, unlikely to ever cooperate when the future could actually look quite different. Because I don't think it's an accident that the BRISC New Development Bank is located in China, it's also no accident that Putin has been very vocal about removing the US$ as the world reserve currency and establishing a "bipolar world order" to replace current de-facto US hegemony.
- analyst74 9y agoI wonder how much of that bi-polar reporting is due to Chinese government manipulation, which it does a lot of; and how much of it is due to the feeling that China is the enemy, so it's either weak (contempt) or strong (fear).
- cylinder 9y agoIt is very hard to accept this, but economies can be strong in very imperfect countries.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoFunnily, I could say the same about the US seen from outside. On the one hand, rising poverty and inequality, third-world healthcare with people dying because they fell $50 short of their insulin crowdfunding, industry disappearing, cities practically abandoned like Detroit, and a madman president posting unbelievable tweets and advocating absurd policy, make it seem that it's in on the precipice of collapse. On the other hand, you still have the top universities in the world, the best innovative countries, and the most exciting projects with a potential to bring noticeable progress for humanity (Tesla, etc.) making the US seem like a leader that won't be overtaken. Who knows.
- muninn_ 9y agoLook I think healthcare insurance in the United States is beyond stupid but calling the healthcare “third-world” is a bit extreme.
- cletus 9y agoSo when I was a kid I noticed that countries that name "People's" or "Democratic" in their full names tended to be brutal dictatorships (eg GDR (East Germany), PRC (China)). Those that had both were brutal dictatorships on steroids (ie DPRK aka North Korea). I found this interesting because it was an early lesson in how people will coopt words to hide the true nature of things, something that happens all the time. For example, if the US government enacts a new piece of legislation and it has the name "patriot" or "freedom" in it, you can bet your last dollar it's going to take away your rights. Another version of this is the now conflated term of "free trade". Free trade in its purest form is freedom of goods and services to cross borders without quotas, tariffs or other artificial barriers to entry. We largely have that now yet countries like the US want to impose a legislative agenda on the rest of the world through large multilateral treaties like the TPP and TIPP all under the guise of "free trade". Now either economists and politicians have forgotten what free trade actually means or they're wailfully ignoring it for their own idealogical agendas. I find this [1] a good account of the conflation of "free trade" and the "free movement of capital". Back in high school economics I learned about the foreign debt trap where instead of trade outflows from your trading partner, the money came back as capital to buy assets and the means of production. Have such basic principles really fallen out of favour in the blind devotion to the free movement of capital? So the developed world clamored for China to join the WTO, probably sensing a giant opportunity to sell goods to a new market of a billion Chinese. Thing is, despite claims to play fair, China has basically cheated at every step along the way. For example: - Not opening their markets to foreign companies; - Blatant IP infringement; - Theft of military and scientific knowledge; - Pegging their currency to the US dollar rather than letting it float so they could accumulate giant hard currency reserves; and (more recently) - Restricting capital outflows. I'm really surprised (even concerned) that the West (in particular) doesn't demand the same access to China that China gets to the rest of the world. And we could go further into China's many other transgressions: no freedom of the press, the annexation of Tibet, Tiannemen Square, human rights violations, labour camps, material support to North Korea and so on. [1] http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/ http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/
- throwaway613834 9y ago> For example, if the US government enacts a new piece of legislation and it has the name "patriot" or "freedom" in it, you can bet your last dollar it's going to take away your rights. First thing that comes to my mind for "freedom" is the Freedom of Information Act, which fails that test?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ggm 9y ago$3b would be chump-change in the worldwide black economy. I'm guessing that this extra-legal money is quite happily parked in legal low-tax economies earning interest. So.. if we're taking the moral high ground, isn't there room for some whataboutism or tu coque here?
- tryingagainbro 9y agoI'm guessing that this extra-legal money is quite happily parked in legal low-tax economies earning interest. I'm certain that even if they're losing 2% they are quite happy to have it out of China. This is not a Chinese farmer taking his money out of China, most likely you're talking about corrupt politicians that make $20 million with the stroke of a pen.
- xbmcuser 9y agoThis is just signal to the remaining 1-2 trillion Underground banking sector to get out of it. If China goes after all of it at once it will crash it economy or at least stall it. These Busts and other signals have been coming out of the Chinese government in the last few weeks after the twice a decade party conference.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sasas 9y agoSo is this one mechanism of how Chinese nations get their money out to afford million dollar properties in Australia? > Australia's money laundering watchdog investigated more than $3 billion in suspicious transfers by Chinese investors last year, including $1 billion in property transactions. [1] Considering they can only take out 50k USD per year [2] I'm sure many can agree it's disgraceful that the Australian government is turning a blind eye to an incredible amount of money laundering... which some may argue is contributing to the incredibly high housing prices in Melbourne and Sydney. There are no median house prices left in Sydney under half a million dollars. [3]. A friend witnessed a Chinese national at an auction try to pay their deposit with a suitcase of cash. The real estate agent had to explain (through a translator) that they can't accept that amount of cash in a suitcase. Sorry can't give a reference here, but other HN'ers who have witnessed the auction frenzy in Australia may attest that this scenario is plausible. Note, I'm not implying the Chinese are the direct contributor to the current situation, I am simply suggesting there is contributory related forces at play... Australian Financial Review - "Of China's $47.3 billion (investments in Australia in 2016), $31.9 billion will go into real estate mostly in residential development assets." [4] [1] http://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/australian-economy/chinese-investors-pumping-billions-of-dodgy-cash-into-australian-property/news-story/cdab9af854d70d805a5b51cf881e40c9 http://www.news.com.au/finance/economy/australian-economy/ch... [2] http://www.cityweekend.com.cn/china/article/how-to-get-your-money-out-of-china http://www.cityweekend.com.cn/china/article/how-to-get-your-... [3] https://www.domain.com.au/news/there-are-now-no-suburbs-left-in-sydney-with-a-median-house-price-under-500000-20171016-gz1sxj/ https://www.domain.com.au/news/there-are-now-no-suburbs-left... [4] http://www.afr.com/real-estate/chinese-investment-in-real-estate-grows-to-32bn-firb-20170509-gw0sla http://www.afr.com/real-estate/chinese-investment-in-real-es...
- cakeface 9y agoI feel like you may have a bit of an axe to grind about local real estate prices. Yes, they are money laundering in the sense that they are avoiding regulations from their home country. But they aren't trying to avoid Australian regulations right? These investors generally have legal businesses in China, as much as that is possible in a state like that. "I'm sure many can agree it's disgraceful" is a particularly choice piece of rhetoric that I am still trying to unpack. Also I like how you over attributed your comment as an appeal to authority. There is a whole ball of string that you find when you start pulling the thread of your argument. That ball of string can be called globalization. Many people around the world are just coming to terms with the trade offs involved in the the way we have structured the world today. You can see some of this in the nationalism of Trump and Brexit. It is a complicated problem with complicated answers. I just want people to watch out for situations like this and not think that "whoah, this is clearly disgracefully wrong".
- chairmanwow 9y agoThe Chinese art of selectively enforcing their laws to the detriment of those that won't play ball with the government really makes it hard to believe Xi's press-tornado of successful anti-corruption measures. The government has been actively extorting international companies into "joint" ventures. These ventures essentially require "treats" (as an insider told me) every several months. These treats would be manufacturing processes, engineering drawings of proprietary IP, or technical training for their engineering staff. Boards of Directors can't ignore the scale of the Chinese market, but it comes at the cost of essentially giving away your business prospects within the country inside of 15 year window. China's current long-term strategy seems to be: 1) Spend an egregious amount to woo top talent [1], [2] 2) Learn from them over the next 5-10 year period [2] 3) Transcend the need for foreigners in China It's a pretty terrifying environment and many Chinese investors are desperate to get their money into foreign investments [3]. Instead of laundering illegally earned money, they are laundering legally earned money that they can't get out of China. At least that is the hearsay that I've heard from several different sources (VC events, friends of friends etc). [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/04/world/asia/china-soccer-xi-jinping.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/04/world/asia/china-soccer-x... [2] Qi Lu, Baidu's COO YC interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSydk0XzxEE&t=351s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSydk0XzxEE&t=351s [3]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-03/china-drills-down-into-forex-transactions-as-money-exits-abroad https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-01-03/china-dri...
- Retric 9y agoAnti corruption is a classic measure to shift weath from one set of former insiders to the new set of insiders. One time pushes are almost meaningless without the creation of new long term institutions. For companies the pressure for managers to create the illusion of progress causes a lot of structural problems. I find companies that stay out of China are better long term prospects and tend to have far better upper management. PS: The other option is to sell one or two generations back so copycats start at a significant disadvantage internationally.
- adamiscool8 9y agoDoes this mean China's recent declaration that "Foreign Firms Won't Be Forced to Turn Over Technology" [1] is not to be believed? [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-11-10/china-says-foreign-firms-won-t-be-forced-to-turn-over-technology https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-11-10/china-say...
- coliveira 9y agoChina is absolutely doing the right thing in cracking the power of the private banking system. Having a powerful private banking system is the recipe for disaster, since the predatory (rentier) nature of banking suffocates the development of industry and even the long term survival of a consumer base. It is funny that this was very well understood by economists an politicians as far back as the 19th century but it has been largely ignored throughout the 20th and 21st century. Now we see the US and the EU largely controlled by banking interests, with very little if any taxes applied to financial gains and little support for industrial development. It is not a surprise that practically the entire industrial complex has moved to China, with the exception of highly subsidized industries such as weapons production.
- Buge 9y agoI was under the impression that the move of industry to China was due to cheap labor, not due to different banking regulations. Is it possible to get a loan in the US and use it to build a factory in China? How about vice versa? Because if so, then I don't see how banking regulations would change where a factory would be built.
- coliveira 9y agoWith few exceptions, you cannot get a loan in the US to do anything productive. Most of the loans given to business nowadays are to buy back stocks, private equity (M&A), or to speculate on real estate.
- landryraccoon 9y agoI’m sorry do you have a citation? I was able to get a line of credit and an installment loan from a bank for my small business. We didn’t do stocks, private equity or real estate.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSo that’s two more things than you can get a loan for from a Chinese bank if you aren’t an SOE (they only support real estate speculation).
- known 9y agoI think its https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawala not a Bank
- contingencies 9y ago$3B. OK. So how much did HSBC launder for druglords? The fine alone was $1.9B. Yet another NYT/Washington Post China hitpiece.