12 ms·
An Open Letter to the FCC
- batmansmk 9y agoIf you are ready to steal identities at large scale, don't you think you are capable of faking logs, bribing judges and do whatever you want as well? It's funny to see how trustful we are in America that the rules will save us all from people not playing by the same rules. Changing the referee is the real solution right? Impeachment should be the focus.
- TheRealPomax 9y agoNo, I don't. Do you? If so, you might need to read up on the slippery slope fallacy.
- batmansmk 9y agoI never heard of slippery slope fallacy before, but I read the wikipedia page about it. Thanks for the info! But I miss where it applies to the reasoning I shared. Maybe you can help me. Do we really believe key people at FCC are persuaded to support the people with this decision? That is just a matter of showing the truth about those comments? I think it is just a farce and we are wasting our time and energy opposing the FCC. The bigger problem is the constant attack against our democratic process.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bluetwo 9y agoGood luck.
- sigmar 9y agoDo others read this as an indication AG Schneidermann is getting ready to sue the FCC to get info on the fake comments?
- pm90 9y agoI hope he does. It seems really shady. Impersonating citizens is probably a criminal offense, and the agency/person responsible for doing so could be charged with that crime. Now, if it was foreign actors though, I don't think much can be done. Maybe Congress could enact more sanctions. But if it was a domestic operation, carried out by one of the big telecos... wow this will be huge.
- revmoo 9y agoLikely it was a private "mercenary" consulting firm behind the activities, paid out by telcos.
- epistasis 9y agoIt's been really interesting to see the interplay between State Attorneys General and the federal executive branch over the past decade. I don't know enough legal history to know if this contention is new or has always happened. But the contrast between what happened with regulation of carbon and coal is fairly striking. The federal judicial brach said that it had to be regulated in order to meet the laws that the legislative branch had passed, executive branch followed through with regulations based on science and input from stakes holders. We ended up with regulations on coal plants that are weaker than Chinese restrictions on their own plants. State AGs revolted, to little effect. In the last year, regulatory decisions at the FCC, EPA, and DOE are being made by fiat, without any of the typical study and justification that typically goes into them. In particular, DOE suggestions to FERC have been denounced by nearly everybody in the energy industry, by nearly every interested outsider, and in a bipartisan fashion from lots of prior FERC commissioners. The general whims of a single person are taking precedence over having market principles, or really any other principle at all. The only parties in favor of the regulations at all are those who directly benefit by guaranteed payments, and they only justify their favor of the regulations through a massive and legally questionable expansion of regulatory power of the regulatory agency, something that these particular partisans are usually against. With the FCC, we see something similar, an impulse to make regulations without much reasoning behind those regulations except that they favor a small group. This type of regulation, where particular parties are favored, rather than particular principles, is madness.
- nerdponx 9y agoCan states regulate ISP activity within their states? Could the New York state legislature pass a law stating that ISPs who offer services in New York must provide net-neutral services?
- bognition 9y agoThey could try but the FCC would almost certainly contest that the states do not have the right to pass such laws. Additionally there is nothing stopping the FCC from passing rules forbidding states from regulating net neutrality.
- wmf 9y agoSchneiderman is doing far more for net neutrality with his Spectrum lawsuit than the FCC has done (even pre-Pai, the FCC did nothing about peering extortion for example). But this stuff about fake comments seems to be nothing more than procedural bikeshedding since the FCC ignored all the comments anyway.
- jjoonathan 9y agoNormally I'd agree, under the premise that the party who manufactured the comments had the competence to hide/obfuscate their trail enough to make it not worth following. However, the FCC's position is striking: they're not even maintaining the pretense of caring. This suggests sloppy execution and makes me revisit my priors regarding assumed competence. I think Schneidermann is right to spend resources on this angle, even if the chances of success are far below 100%.
- ordinaryperson 9y agoThe revocation of the Net Neutrality rules became a foregone conclusion once Donald Trump was elected. The sad reality is there's not much we, Eric Schneidermann or anyone else can do about it. There are 5 FCC commissioners but only 3 may be of the same party. Ajit Pai, Brendan Carr and Michael O'Rielly are locks to vote in favor, so it will pass, 3-2. At this point the best thing people can do is prepare to vote in 2018 and 2020, whether that's registering voters or forming groups to get lazy liberals or independents to vote to send better people to Washington. One side aspect that I think hasn't been covered: FCC Chairman Ajit Pai is a former Verizon lawyer and probably plans to parley his government experience into a lucrative gig at one of the big telcos once the Republicans are inevitably thrown out of office, so he stands to personally profit from this decision. As Donald Trump would say, SAD.
- jjtheblunt 9y agoYou're rather convinced Trump belongs to big telecom...i'd suggest more skepticism and waiting and seeing.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoTrump belongs to the wind.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- djtriptych 9y agoHow is "waiting and seeing" more reasonable than "assuming the worst" at this point?
- tzs 9y ago> At this point the best thing people can do is prepare to vote in 2018 and 2020, whether that's registering voters or forming groups to get lazy liberals or independents to vote to send better people to Washington. There should be some effort to get more moderate Republicans involved. There are plenty of Republicans who support net neutrality, but do not consider that as important an issue as other issues on which Republicans and Democrats differ, such as immigration, taxes, gun rights, abortion, and many others. I think that most of the less moderate Republican voters who oppose net neutrality mostly do so because their representatives and party officials tell them to. It's not like, say, their opposition to abortion which they came to on their own and then used that to help choose their party. If that is true, it should be possible to move the GOP to a place where net neutrality is something that a Republican candidate can either support or oppose and still have a chance of winning a GOP primary or caucus.
- 0xB31B1B 9y agoMore and more we see state agencies standing up to regime change in Washington (ex: CA and environmental regulations). Regardless of your personal politics, I wonder how this dynamic will affect democracy in the US.
- angersock 9y agoThe issue of federalism is not the settled matter that most people seem to be thinking it is.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoWhich way do you think most people think it has settled on?
- creaghpatr 9y agoWell up until election 2016, Democrats were vehemently opposed to states authority, and concentrated far more power in Washington during the Obama administration. It's nice to see them coming around.
- swang 9y ago(not) surprisingly, republicans have all but disappeared from that chat. at the federal level, both parties only care about state rights when it suits them.
- gfodor 9y agoThis is true for about every facet of the Constitution.
- creaghpatr 9y agoGun laws, abortion, the trans bathroom thing in NC...all recent issues that the GOP sided on states rights vs. federal regs On healthcare policy in particular the state specific policies continue to be enforced by the GOP. These aren’t positions I agree with btw I’m just pointing out recent examples. I think it’s fair to say Democrats would rather have centralized healthcare, gun laws, lgbt policies, and abortion access, rather than leaving it to the states to decide.
- abvdasker 9y agoDoes anyone know if the server logs and other info the New York AG requested would fall under the Freedom of Information Act?
- sillypuddy 9y agoHis last name is misspelled in the title, only one training n.
- pm90 9y agoCan Congress pass legislation to make net-neutrality something that the FCC cannot touch? If that's the case, it might be possible to pass such a law when(if) dems take over the House/Senate next year right?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Can Congress pass legislation to make net-neutrality something that the FCC cannot touch? Yes, if they have support of the President or a veto-proof supermajority in both houses. > If that's the case, it might be possible to pass such a law when(if) dems take over the House/Senate next year right? Unlikely, for the reasons stated above, though tying it to something the President isn't willing to veto might work. Or, I guess, if after taking both houses of Congress (and, critically, electing a new Speaker) they also impeach, convict, and remove the Vice President and President, and the Democratic Speaker succeeds to the Presidency, then it would be doable.
- s73ver_ 9y agoOr, also within the realm of possibility, Trump flip flops on his positions to side with the Dems, just because he doesn't want to be seen as being out of power.
- pm90 9y agoDammit, I had no idea Congress needs 2/3 majority in both houses to override a veto. That seems to make it impossible, even if the Democrats do take control of both Houses.
- wmf 9y agoYes, but Congress hasn't wanted to tackle net neutrality for the last ten years so it's not clear why this time would be different.
- nxc18 9y agoHow is refusing to participate in an identity theft investigation not obstruction of justice? Surely Ajit & co travel to NY from time to time... why isn’t there an arrest warrant? Why are the states being so toothless in responding to rampant criminal behavior? I’d like to see how I would fare if I participated in mass scale identity theft and refused to participate in the subsequent investigation.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe federal government is the superior sovereign and does not have any obligation to answer to a state investigation. Further, withholding cooperation from an investigation is not obstruction of justice, it is your God-given right as an American. You generally only have the obligation to cooperate when you are presented with a court order. And even then, you have the right to challenge the validity of that court order.
- JTon 9y agoPerhaps because the behaviour in question is not actually criminal. Since Ajit is a lawyer, I suspect he knows very well where the lines are drawn.
- cwkoss 9y agoI suspect he also knows very well how to go past the line without leaving enough evidence to be convicted.
- rhino369 9y agoRefusing to participate isn't obstruction. It's not obstruction of justice if you refused a cop who came to your office and asked for business records. That's what happened here.
- aalleavitch 9y agoWhat they need to do is subpoena the FCC.
- dsl 9y agoThe New York AG just needs to have a judge issue bench warrants for the head of the FCC and its general counsel. That is normally what happens when you refuse to provide evidence for a criminal case.
- rottyguy 9y agoAre there any legitimate arguments for anti-net neutrality proponents? Or is it just more "republicans prefer less regulations"?
- krrrh 9y agoYou can hear Pai defend his position here: http://reason.com/blog/2017/11/21/ajit-pai-net-neutrality-podcast http://reason.com/blog/2017/11/21/ajit-pai-net-neutrality-po... He claims that 80% of smaller ISPs have said that they delayed investment in infrastructure due to the costs associated with the net neutrality regs, and also that there was a reduction in overall broadband investment in the last two years and that has never happened before, outside of a recession. He thinks that this has hurt efforts to bring connectivity to rural and underserved areas. Personally, I think the argument for net neutrality is strong in the present situation where we have less competition, but he believes that the FTC governance previous to title 2 puting ISPs under the purview of th FCC was already protecting consumers adequately. The new proposal also enforces a transparency requirement on any traffic shaping, or filtering.
- buerkle 9y agoHis claims about lack of investment after the 2015 rule changes are wrong. https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/05/17/sorry-chairman-pai-your-investment-numbers-dont-add https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/05/17/sorry-chairman-pai...
- krrrh 9y agoThanks for providing the counterpoint. I would like to see Pai back his claims up in a more detailed manner, because I found them pretty surprising.
- openasocket 9y agoI don't really understand how net neutrality can hurt smaller ISPs. Net neutrality just prevents ISPs from using certain monetization schemes. It's not like you have to buy special equipment for net neutrality reasons, or maintain records to prove you're compliant, right?
- perseusprime11 9y agoTo play devil’s advocate, are we really ready for Internet to be regulated like a public utility? Like water, we will need to pay more the more we consume. You and I can pay but what about poor people? Will this discourage Internet usage?
- wmf 9y agowe will need to pay more the more we consume Not necessarily; under utility pricing your bill might be $49 for maintenance of the network and $1 for usage.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThe marginal cost for additional bits through an existing hookup is tiny - likely not worth charging for. We'd likely pay based off the bandwidth available to us - and we pretty much already do that today, there's higher-bandwidth tiers available.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> To play devil’s advocate, are we really ready for Internet to be regulated like a public utility? Yes. > Like water, we will need to pay more the more we consume. We already do, though it's more noticeable for mobile broadband. Also, not all public utilities are metered—I’ve lived in places with unmetered public water, for instance, so the connection you draw between metering and public utilities is false. > You and I can pay but what about poor people? Public utilities are often subsidized for the poor (that's actually one way that broadband is already treated like a public utility).
- perseusprime11 9y agoNot where I live. Public utilities like water and electricity are run by private companies and no subsidies are offered.
- lordCarbonFiber 9y agoI think this the fundamental problem: so few people have any idea how the internet works. Sending packets is nothing like consuming water. The marginal cost of internet use is 0. But, because all you can get across to people is "series of tubes" the ISPs make out like criminals charging for for bits. With any luck the next generation will look at bandwidth caps the same way young people today are shocked anyone was so stupid as to allow companies to charge per SMS message.
- throwawaymanbot 9y agoSince all these fake people have been "Emailing" in to the FCC, Shouldn't the feds be involved? Isnt that A federal offense?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- orthecreedence 9y agoFocus your energy on getting your town on municipal fiber. Muni fiber means anyone in your town can start an ISP, which means you'll have 20+ companies competing locally, which means Net Neutrality doesn't need to be regulated at all because there is actual market competition.
- monkseal 9y agoThis letter has nothing to do with the substance of the regulations. It amounts to finger pointing about "illegal conduct". Probably the next thing, we will hear the Russians are behind all of this... Why can't the FTC regulate or prosecute monoplies, which is its job, instead a bunch arbitrary rules by the FCC?
- s73ver_ 9y agoNet neutrality is not an arbitrary rule.
- learc83 9y ago>Why can't the FTC regulate or prosecute monoplies, which is its job, instead a bunch arbitrary rules by the FCC? Basically the FTC doesn't have regulation authority over telcos because they are common carriers and thus statutorily exempted from regulation by the FTC.
- diebir 9y agoMeh. The sons of bitches will do whatever they want. Bend over, America!
- hysan 9y agoI'm one of the people who has had part of their identity used to submit false comments. Found out when a journalist emailed me asking me to do a survey and some additional comments months ago. I proceeded to sign up for an API key[1] to confirm what was being claimed and turns out, it was true. The API is a bit limited, but I was also able to do searches using the falsely submitted comment to find others like it as well as what looked like a lot of fake submissions. I already contacted all of my representatives to investigate this, but with the approaching FCC vote and now this AG Open Letter, I fear that nothing will happen until it's too late. What is a citizen to do when they try to do everything in their power and play by the rules - vote, submit comments, call representatives, contact press for help, and repeat - results in nothing? The FCC has effectively ignored the rules and stalled their way to victory. I'm not even sure how to describe our government anymore... [1] https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/public-api-docs.html https://www.fcc.gov/ecfs/public-api-docs.html
- jryan49 9y agoOne thing we could do is have everyone go in on a lobbyist. haha
- smellf 9y agoDonate the the EFF, it's basically the same thing as you're suggesting except that the organizational structure is already in place.
- ghrifter 9y agoThe FCC has effectively ignored the rules and stalled their way to victory. Nawh, they are following the power delegation given to them by congress. They dont have to do fuck all for public comments, other then recieve them, document them, and say "we got feedback but fuck yall we going forward"
- jedberg 9y ago> They dont have to do fuck all for public comments That's not true. As a nonpartisan federal agency, the must show how they accounted for public comment and why the choice they made is either in line with the public comments or why it is justified to not be in line. They have to do more than just accept the comments. But by allowing all the fake comments, they were able to say "see everyone wants this, what we are doing is in line with the public comments".
- cmurf 9y agoDo we have any idea what position on net neutrality these fake comments were taking?
- LukaAl 9y agoThey were allegedly against Net Neutrality according to the journalist investigation done [1]. Also, an analysis done by the Knight Foundation for the 2014 proceeding showed that the highest number of unique comment where pro Net Neutrality while the only comments against NN where from templated answers [2] [1] http://www.zdnet.com/article/a-bot-is-flooding-the-fccs-website-with-fake-anti-net-neutrality-comments/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/a-bot-is-flooding-the-fccs-webs... [2] https://knightfoundation.org/features/netneutrality/ https://knightfoundation.org/features/netneutrality/
- brightball 9y agoI wonder what it would take to really create ISP competition in the US? I thought I remembered seeing somewhere that the big ISP's use the legal system to essentially drive up entrance costs for smaller players. Would the EFF be able to help with something like that? The only real long term solution to stuff like this is more competition, because without it you never have the option to "vote with your wallet."
- fastball 9y agoAll we really need is municipal fiber. Then ISP's would just be connecting towns/areas, and the barrier to entry would be a lot lower if necessary.
- moosey 9y agoWe've had it before, and the way forward is very simple: Internet Service resale at cost. The major internet providers would be forced to resell to other internet providers access at the costs to the company, including labor, maintenance, etc. Resellers then compete with the company to produce the lowest overhead.
- rhino369 9y agoThat would get you very cheap ISP with terrible speeds and a lot of downtime. There is no incentive for investment if they have to resell at (or near) cost. And we've seen this in action. DSL service was covered by Title II originally, which meant it had to be unbundled and resold. But cable internet had no requirement. Investment flooded to cable rather than telecom. Why would Verizon invest billions in a network that benefits third parties? Well they didn't. It was only after Title II repeal that Verizon went forward with Fios. Because it didn't have to resell. It's possible to do this sort of thing, but you have to build in a fat profit margin. But even then, the companies wouldn't have any incentive to provide good service.
- moosey 9y agoAnd that situation would push us towards internet as public utility, or at least internet infrastructure as public utility. Also, investment into additional infrastructure could be baked into the resale cost. In my opinion, internet as public utility is not a bad thing, although I'm sure there will be many detractors to the idea.
- user-on1 9y agoSeems like america is going to loose its freedom until next president ALREADY LOST - to pick a internet plan of their choice which is affordable and reliable to them. ALREADY LOST - to have privacy. LOOSING - what people will watch in their internet, so basically you will be target fed specific info and some info you will never come across leading to people will be kept in dark like the sugar news forever. if we were celebrating July 4th for the freedom over internet then we can stop celebrating it from 2018 but luckily its not that. May be american citizens will stop being submissive and not take whatever is thrown at them and start to make their power and presence felt and be an example to other country citizens.
- weirdstuff 9y agoI don't think it matters much who occupies the oval office. I fear the U.S. is in a systematic regression due to deeper economic issues that so far are being totally unaddressed and unidentified in public. I hope other nations can begin exerting pressure on this country so that we are forced to begin considering substantial reforms (apparently a long-lived fiscal crisis isn't enough); otherwise these issues may worsen and spread elsewhere as they have already begun doing. (Divest away from U.S. securities, for example. Challenge the status of U.S. dollar.)
- tstrimple 9y ago"I don't think it matters much who occupies the oval office." That sort of ignores the fact that Trump is undoing work done under the Obama administration. Clearly it matters who is in office.
- saladeen 9y agoMan, reddit's frontpage was almost 100% links to battleforthenet.com today. I'd like to point out something not widely mentioned: battleforthenet is ran by org called 'Fight for the Future'; they are funded by Open Society Initiative, which is George Soros's organization. As soon as I see his name involved, I assume that a) the appearance of a 'grassroot movement' is completely fake and just part of his playbook, and b) the end result will not benefit the common man, it will just negatively affect the economy and make more money for him. We are talking about a man that was literally willing to destroy economies of whole countries just to make a quick buck.
- albinofrenchy 9y agoThe George Soros demonization is one of the odder things I've seen lately. This isn't some psyops nonsense. Net neutrality isn't some George Soros conspiracy meant to cripple capitalism while making him rich.
- saladeen 9y agoGeorge Soros needs no demonization.
- bigphishy 9y agoHey I couoldn't find any citation or reference. Could you please find a citation for that claim.. it is very fishy.
- saladeen 9y agoCitation or reference to what? Go to the site, scroll all the way down, it says 'built by Fight for the Future', and even links to it: https://www.fightforthefuture.org/ https://www.fightforthefuture.org/ On that site, go to 'Supporters' page: https://www.fightforthefuture.org/supporters/ https://www.fightforthefuture.org/supporters/ Open Society Foundations is listed there.
- saladeen 9y agoHere's an article about it too: http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/soros-ford-foundation-shovel-196-million-to-net-neutrality-groups-staff-to-white-house/article/2560702 http://www.washingtonexaminer.com/soros-ford-foundation-shov...
- eecc 9y agoWhat I’m most worried - as an EU citizen - is that shit happening on the western shore of the Atlantic eventually blows over this side. Thankfully TTIP was thrown under the bus - for now, tomorrow who can tell? - so it won’t be easy but I’m not feeling that safe. The same greedy multinational corporations sponsoring this public spoliation in the USA are massively present in EU and I don’t think Chinese Walls are a meaningful property of their structures...
- user-on1 9y agoMay be God's plans goes like... 2020 should be the most awesome year of humanity ever. And he was piling up many good things for 2020. But then he felt like there can be more good things for 2020. So some angel suggested he will create some bad thing in few years before it and then solve those bad things in 2020 that way the awesomeness of 2020 will increase. And God was like great idea, lets go for it.
- deadmetheny 9y agoWhy the title change? It's less descriptive now than it was before.
- AdmiralAsshat 9y agoStop appealing to Chairman Pai's humanity. He has none. You stop him the same way you stop corporations: legislation, and lawsuits.
- aeontech 9y agoSo, if I as a private individual ignore and refuse to provide information to an active investigation by a State Attorney General, I am liable to be charged with something (obstruction of justice perhaps)? Are there no additional avenues to escalate to compel compliance from FCC, other than writing this type of public letter?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Hannahsbaby 9y agoYou all need to convince Trump supporters to call too. They hate 330 page document. Ive gotten alot of feedback saying they'd support a 2 page version that promised dumb pipes and not the other 328 pages of nonsense.
- _justinfunk 9y agoSo... what did the fake comments say? I'm suspicious that in his open letter he never addresses the content of the fake comments.
- z3t4 9y agoHe is basically asking for more surveillance and less anonymity ...