16 ms·
John Lasseter taking a leave of absence amid reports of inappropriate behavior
- xwvvvvwx 9y agoThis article has more details: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/john-lasseters-pattern-alleged-misconduct-detailed-by-disney-pixar-insiders-1059594 https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/john-lasseters-patter...
- andrepd 9y agoIt's just so sad to read this. I don't care much for any of the other names that have come up lately, but John Lasseter is my hero :(
- rayiner 9y agoI sincerely don’t understand the idea of having heros. What’s the point of bundling someone’s actions together in the person herself?
- nodesocket 9y agoFood for thought, every single day we see more accusations and finger pointing. It's crossing political, but somehow not weath lines. I'm not saying these things did not happen or that they are not horrible. I'm just saying the frenzy of outrage has reached witch hunt territory. I'm making a point that innocent until proven guilty does not hold true anymore. Once the media or social media writes a story, in the eyes of the "general" public... You're done.
- openasocket 9y ago> I'm making a point that innocent until proven guilty does not hold true anymore. Once the media or social media writes a story, in the eyes of the "general" public... You're done. You make it sound like this is a recent phenomenon. When, in history, has public opinion been subject to a legal standard like 'innocent until proven guilty'?
- s73ver_ 9y ago"I'm making a point that innocent until proven guilty does not hold true anymore." I'm not seeing anyone thrown in jail just because of these accusations.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I'm making a point that innocent until proven guilty does not hold true anymore. Once the media or social media writes a story, in the eyes of the "general" public... You're done. That's been true forever. Innocent until proven guilty has only ever been a legal standard.
- sergiotapia 9y agoOR all these high level hollywood types just keep raping people.
- jim-greer 9y agoThe fact that there are a lot of things coming out doesn't necessarily mean it's a witch hunt. Are you thinking of any accusations in particular?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pwinnski 9y agoThe term "witch hunt" doesn't apply just because there are many bad actors being exposed. It applies when innocent people are caught up in a frenzy of accusations. Sometimes a frenzy of outrage is earned and deserved.
- cjsawyer 9y agoI absolutely agree in this case, but remember that every other “frenzy of outrage” was also thought to be earned and deserved.
- kobeya 9y agoConvicted in the court of public opinion does not mean guilty.
- standupstandup 9y agoLasseter's crime is apparently hugging people. That's not a "bad actor". This is far beyond witchhunt territory. Damn I'm glad I don't work in Hollywood. The entire industry appears to be disappearing up its own backside.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoYou didn't actually read what he did, did you?
- standupstandup 9y agoI read both linked articles. Instead of asking me belittling questions why not describe Lasseter's crime, as it's not exactly obvious.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoJust hugging? Sources say some women at Pixar knew to turn their heads quickly when encountering him to avoid his kisses. Some used a move they called “the Lasseter” to prevent their boss from putting his hands on their legs. A longtime insider says he saw a woman seated next to Lasseter in a meeting that occurred more than 15 years ago. “She was bent over and [had her arm] across her thigh,” he says. “The best I can describe it is as a defensive posture ... John had his hand on her knee, though, moving around.” After that encounter, this person asked the woman about what he had seen. “She said it was unfortunate for her to wear a skirt that day and if she didn’t have her hand on her own right leg, his hand would have travelled.”
- eroccatlun 9y agoI hope you are not implying that poorer people do not get in trouble for sexual harassment or worse. This recent uptick in wealthy people being brought down by it is only newsworthy because they were previously seemingly immune to the normal rules everyone else lives by.
- oliyoung 9y agoIt's not a witch hunt when you actually find people who have done wrong, then it's just “laundry day”
- CydeWeys 9y agoHaha, "laundry day". I love it. Or housecleaning day.
- jandrese 9y agoWe are witnessing cultural norms shift right before our eyes. The line went past a lot of powerful people in the shift and now they're scurrying like roaches. In the old days this was borderline behavior, but not something that would typically get them in trouble. A little butt slap here or innuendo laced comment there was tolerated and sometimes even expected, but those days suddenly ended when even the powerful and influential Harvey Weinstein could fall. One can argue that it might even be blowback from the election of a man who boasted on camera about showing dominance through sexual assault. I'm actually excited about what the housecleaning of the old guard means for the future. Many of the men implicated in these cases should have retired years ago to give the fresh faces some breathing room. The message is coming out loud and clear now: If you sexually harassed your coworkers/secretary/etc... back in the 60s or 70s as was the custom your day of reckoning is coming. Get out now before the scandal hits.
- Alex3917 9y ago> We are witnessing cultural norms shift right before our eyes. I wonder how long until we see folks like Mick Jagger getting forced to resign their jobs due to using their status as rockstars to pick up women. Especially since most rockstars are also producers or executive producers, i.e. the same job that Harvey Weinstein or VCs have.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThere's a critical difference between using your status as a public celebrity to pick up partners (which is fairly noncontroversial) and using your power as someone who can open and shut career doors to pressure people to accede to or keep quiet about your sexual advances. Someone like Jagger or Weinstein may have both kinds of status, but there is still a difference.
- CydeWeys 9y agoYou're eliding the critical issue of consent. There are plenty of people who want to have sex with rockstars. There's no issue with that.
- godshatter 9y agoA witch hunt is a definite possibility, but I haven't seen any evidence of it yet. I think we're seeing a lot of people who had to bottle up their experiences because the climate wasn't right for trying to bring them out in public. The climate has definitely shifted, so a lot of people who faced possible retaliation before can now safely air their grievances. This is a good thing. It will be overplayed when people start using it as an excuse to take down people they don't like or to make a quick buck. I don't think we're there yet, but if you have seen instances of that, please let me know.
- ghostcluster 9y agoCharlie Rose had the best interview show on TV for decades, and is now just gone.
- exit 9y agocharlie rose was awful at interviewing people. he constantly interrupted interesting thoughts. he just had to get a word in at a set rate. yet somehow they consistently booked very interesting guests. i'll give you that, but that's what the show had going for it, not the eponymous interviewer.
- covercash 9y agoSend that booking agent to Hot Ones and get those guests in front of Sean Evans. He digs deep and does wonderful interviews.
- sincerely 9y agoI generally agree with you, but his interview with the Chicken Connoisseur was embarrassingly bad, starting with the choice of setting and the small talk he opened with...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ghostcluster 9y agonah, he was really good at interviewing people and directing interesting longform discussion on a huge variety of topics. better than pretty much anyone else.
- jacobolus 9y agoNo, he was really good at getting great guests onto his show, with a long-enough format to have some time for conversation. He was absolutely atrocious at the actual interviewing part. He would constantly make stupid paragraph-long statements and then at the end ask “don’t you agree?”, then when the guest started to explain that no the statement was wrong or oversimplified, he would interrupt them and repeat his point again. He was constantly shitting all over guests who he disagreed with or didn’t think were cool enough, telling them they were wrong and trying to get them to repeat whatever he happened to think, even if they were world-class experts on some topic he didn’t know anything about. He was constantly kissing up like crazy to anyone he thought was rich or famous or powerful, in a way that was really uncomfortable to watch (his numerous sycophantic interviews with Tom Friedman make my skin crawl). He never seemed to listen very closely to what anyone was saying: I don’t think I ever heard a poignant or insightful follow-up question in the hundreds of his interviews I have seen. Instead he would often interrupt right in the middle of some complicated interesting thought, and throw in a non-sequitur, jolting the conversation to a new (often stupid) topic. My favorite Charlie Rose moment was sometime like 15 years ago when he had on (if I recall correctly) Bill Joy. Charlie made some incredibly banal and obvious paragraph-long statement with a question mark at the end, and then looked at the guest, who was just staring at him. There was a long uncomfortable pause, after which the response was, “well, duh.” If you want to see a stark comparison, find any week where the same guest was interviewed by both Charlie Rose and Terry Gross, and listen to the two interviews back to back.
- macrael 9y agoBuild your heroes out of pieces of many people.
- Apocryphon 9y agoAnd kill your darlings.
- racl101 9y agoi.e. Don't idolize people. Love their ideas and their ideals.
- racl101 9y agoPrepared to be let down. Everyone's legacy is up for review. Nobody is safe. Not even Tom Hanks. Time to stop idolizing celebrities.
- arjunrc 9y agoI'm holding on to this single strand of hope that Tom Hanks is above these recent allegations. If it comes out that he was also a sleaze bag along with Charlie Rose, Al Franken, Jeffrey Tambor, (along with an incredible family movie director in the rumor circles) I don't know what to think of Hollywood and my childhood heroes anymore. Tom Hanks, if you have to say anything, do so now rather than later!
- paganel 9y ago> One longtime Pixar employee says Lasseter, who is well-known for hugging employees and others in the entertainment community, was also known by insiders for "grabbing, kissing, making comments about physical attributes." Multiple sources say Lasseter is known to drink heavily at company social events such as premiere parties, but this source says the behavior was not always confined to such settings. Seems like it doesn't. It may be that I'm from Eastern Europe, where the social aspects are a little bit more pronounced compared to more puritan countries like the United States, but wtf is wrong with hugging? Honest question. Also, I know I used to drink heavily at "company social events" and thank God I was not let go because of that. Well, to be honest almost all of my co-workers should have been let go if I were to judge them based on their drinking outside of working hours.
- VeejayRampay 9y agoI'm French (and we're not exactly puritan about sexual undertones in the social context) and I guess it all boils down to whether or not the huggee actually wants to be hugged by the hugger. Hugging by itself is harmless, but when you're physically embracing someone and forcing a hug on them (especially if you're in a position of power) you're basically robbing them from their chance to exercise free will, which is of course problematic.
- briankelly 9y agoDisappointed to hear this after I just finished reading Creativity, Inc. by Ed Catmull (Pixar's main founder and graphics pioneer) which attributes Pixar's continued success mostly to a culture of extreme candor and honesty... Considering how long this was an issue I guess some things are too good to be true.
- vernie 9y agoIf you want to be let down further check out the industry-wide wage fixing that Catmull actively participated in.
- briankelly 9y agoThanks for the heads up - some articles for those that are interested: http://www.cartoonbrew.com/artist-rights/ed-catmull-on-wage-fixing-i-dont-apologize-for-this-105855.html http://www.cartoonbrew.com/artist-rights/ed-catmull-on-wage-... http://www.cartoonbrew.com/business/pixars-ed-catmull-emerges-as-central-figure-in-the-wage-fixing-scandal-101362.html http://www.cartoonbrew.com/business/pixars-ed-catmull-emerge...
- digdig 9y agoI worked at Pixar for three years back in the early 2010s, and that book is mostly hot air. There was not a culture of extreme candor or honesty, at least not in the department that writes all the core software.
- rootbear 9y agoI still haven't read it, but I really need to. I was in the Studio Tools group in the late 90s and thought that group functioned pretty well. I also never heard anything about John behaving badly, although it was generally acknowledged that he was a big kid and had to be tutored on things like good female characters. Reading this news about John has made me very sad. I wonder now if any of my female former coworkers were the subjects of unwanted attention from John. Sigh...
- sillysaurus3 9y agoAsk yourself why you considered him a hero. You don't know this person. He's a person, just like you. I went through a similar process a couple years ago. Relevant quote regarding Feynman: …in many ways Richard was a sexist. Whenever it came time for his daily bowl of soup he would look around for the nearest "girl" and ask if she would fetch it to him. It did not matter if she was the cook, an engineer, or the president of the company. I once asked a female engineer who had just been a victim of this if it bothered her. "Yes, it really annoys me," she said. "On the other hand, he is the only one who ever explained quantum mechanics to me as if I could understand it." That was the essence of Richard's charm. It's complex. You can respect their achievements while separating the other half. And until you really know someone, it's not good to lump the two halves together in your mind.
- JustAnotherPat 9y agoFeynman was a pig and will be one day stripped from the history books ala Robert E. Lee. All these 'men' will suffer the same fate.
- klodolph 9y agoSince when was Robert E. Lee stripped from the history books? Not sure what you’re trying to say.
- DonHopkins 9y agoHe's trying to say that he's the victim here, a white man suffering from reverse discrimination, sick and tired of having to tolerate people writing bad facts about Robert E Lee and tearing down his statues, which deeply effects him every day of his life, because tradition. We've heard it all before.
- CydeWeys 9y agoHuh? General Lee was the Commander of the Confederate States Army. No one is stripping him from the history books; he had an important role in history. It's the monuments glorifying him that are being removed from public spaces. Feynman similarly was responsible for actual important works in physics. He won't be stripped from history books.
- standupstandup 9y agoFrom the article linked below: A former Pixar employee requesting anonymity says Lasseter's leave of absence statement is "ridiculous" and "trivializing this behavior." The employee adds, "To sum this up as unwanted hugs is belittling and demeaning. If it was just unwanted hugs, he wouldn't be stepping down." I am baffled by this bizarre logic. Belittling and demeaning who, exactly? And how on earth can you derive guilt from observing punishment? In today's Hollywood culture it is easily believable that the man who built the company could be forced out - even if only temporarily - for simply hugging people. Or is this anonymous person trying to imply Lasseter is actually a horrible rapist and nobody is willing to anonymously say so? Seems deeply unlikely at the moment. How many successful companies are going to self-destruct by giving in to this sort of collective madness? Lasseter liked hugging people? 15 years ago he put his hand on a woman's knee? What message does it send that vast success for huge numbers of employees counts for nothing when put against people who are offended by this?
- lotso 9y ago>15 years ago he put his hand on a woman's knee? It seems like he has a history of groping women. I'm not sure why anyone should put energy into defending that behavior.
- jeffjose 9y agoThis is an easy trap to fall into. Try to think from the victim's perspective. Countless women had to suffer mental and emotional distress due to Lasseter. Who knows, without such stress, some of these women could have been even bigger than Lasseter himself. The ends never justify the means.
- standupstandup 9y agoI don't believe any mental or emotional distress was suffered. I also don't believe there were any "victims". Being hugged does not make you a victim, sorry. These people who are complaining need to toughen up. I mean where does this end? Accidental contact in a corridor as two people pass each other ends careers? That sort of thing now seems entirely thinkable. Who knows, without such stress, some of these women could have been even bigger than Lasseter himself. Someone who can't tolerate the "stress" of being hugged is never going to be able to pull together Toy Story.
- JabavuAdams 9y agoThis smacks of damage minimisation and failure to take responsibility. While we shouldn't be applauding these guys, I found that at least Louis C.K.'s confession seemed genuine (after the denials).
- Santosh83 9y agoEither looking up to someone or holding them in contempt are very binary positions. People are complex. One can admire a person for the good they do and criticise and oppose them for the deliberate bad things they indulge in. I mean... none of us are purely black or white...
- rxhernandez 9y agoIt's only binary because the actions they've done are so egregious that we have no other choice but to condemn them. Most people are able to stop themselves at the mere thought of committing actions such as these. And yes, while everyone makes mistakes there is a huge difference between mistakes that might hurt someone a bit and mistakes that make people feel violated. I've never made anyone feel violated and I'm sure most other people can say the same. Here's a 3 step process for anyone who finds it difficult and if at any point you answer no, stop what you are doing: 1. Do you know this person well and do they respond enthusiastically positive toward you? 2. Have you discussed your feelings towards them and have they responded enthusiastically positive towards them? 3. Have you discussed the things you want to do and have they responded enthusiastically positive towards them? As an average looking guy who has had no trouble finding many romantic partners, let me say this, if your success hinges upon overwhelming surprise then you are doing something VERY wrong. If you are worried about it no longer feeling in the moment after asking for consent, let me assure you that if they want you as bad as they should, it won't be given a second thought.
- ralusek 9y agoAren't the actions egregious on a case by case basis? Do we actually know what he's been accused of? It sounds like he's a little bit overly friendly...and that does not push somebody into a binary 0 for me. Dude makes good movies.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoYes, we do, in the linked articles. The Polanski Standard is a bad one. Someone can make great movies but if they are a creep, they're a creep. If he made bad movies would it be okay to judge him? I've gotta believe you can be a decent person and still do great things. Otherwise, what's the point? No need to excuse bad behavior, maybe by excusing it, we make it possible. If predators got run out of industries instead of being allowed to stick around for decades (Hastert, Weinstein, Paterno, Spacey, Trump, the media is even starting to turn on Bill Clinton), then we wouldn't have to be so disappointed. It's not acceptable.
- mudil 9y agoSo what is next? Washington Post sits down with 18 women and men and they report that Keith Richards screwed them the wrong way after the concerts in 1960s and 70s, and demands pile up from the "public" to remove the Rolling Stones from the streaming services and stop the concerts? Where is the end to this madness?
- mozumder 9y agoRashida Jones has given a response denying the allegations: http://www.eonline.com/news/895644/rashida-jones-denies-leaving-toy-story-4-over-john-lasseter-misconduct-claims http://www.eonline.com/news/895644/rashida-jones-denies-leav... "We feel like we have been put in a position where we need to speak for ourselves. The break neck speed at which journalist have been naming the next perpetrator renders some reporting irresponsible and, in fact counterproductive for the people who do want to tell their stories. In this instance, the Hollywood Reporter does not speak for us. We did not leave Pixar because of unwanted advance. That is untrue. We parted ways because of creative and, more importantly philosophical differences." It looks like The Hollywood Reporter didn't follow through by talking to the original victims.
- benzible 9y agoPer the HR article: THR made repeated requests for comment to Jones and McCormack starting on Nov. 7 but received no response. The story does quote other victims and witnesses, so I don't think your characterization is accurate. It looks like solid journalism.
- vidarh 9y agoIf so they could have left out those names and revisited it in a future article if/when they had confirmation.
- rblion 9y agoBummer. I wonder how common these issues are across the board, in all industries, not just entertainment/tech/finance/politics.
- ncallaway 9y agoFrom listening to the women in my life: extremely common in most (all?) industries.
- kelukelugames 9y agoI've heard far worse stories from finance, legal, and consulting than tech. And I know many more tech workers than the other industries.
- int_19h 9y agoIf you want to hear some really nasty horror stories, ask women who work in blue collar jobs...
- eps 9y agoIn related news - John Draper (Cpt. Crunch) is dropped from tech conferences for similar reasons. https://arstechnica.co.uk/tech-policy/2017/11/iconic-hacker-booted-from-conferences-after-sexual-misconduct-claims-surface/ https://arstechnica.co.uk/tech-policy/2017/11/iconic-hacker-... Comments are interesting. Apparently his was a known issue and people were explicitly warned to stay away from him at the conferences and such.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CleaningWithMud 9y agoI heard the warnings in 2000 at Defcon, though I had no direct contact with him.
- kelukelugames 9y agoWow, what a shitty non apology. A longer version of "I'm sorry you felt offended." “That was never my intent,” he wrote. “Collectively, you mean the world to me, and I deeply apologize if I have let you down. I especially want to apologize to anyone who has ever been on the receiving end of an unwanted hug or any other gesture they felt crossed the line in any way, shape, or form.”
- fictionfuture 9y agoWhy is making someone uncomfortable at work somehow a newsworthy topic? Why are people supporting this? It's clearly a farce.
- wiz21c 9y agoLasseter says : " No matter how benign my intent, everyone has the right to set their own boundaries and have them respected." It's dead wrong. The boundaries are defined by society as a whole. The way he puts it basically says that if you don't set your boundaries, then don't complain if you are hurt.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoNo actually, whether certain behaviour or moves are acceptable or not depends entirely on the individual. Sales people and socially awkward people are told to reach out and touch people on the shoulder and such, for example; I don't like people touching me, but apparently it should be socially acceptable. I could make it a battery or sexual intimidation case if I wanted to. Then there's people that actually like being touched, especially by close friends which, yes, can be colleagues, and can be people above them in the chain of command. TL;DR it's a minefield, best to do nothing and stay away from people.
- wiz21c 9y agoHow do you deal with the fact that for some behaviors, most of the people who disagree with it just stay silent. Since nobody complains individually, does it make the behavior acceptable ?