10 ms·
Y Combinator Cuts Ties with Peter Thiel After Ending Part-Time Partner Program
- LeoJiWoo 9y agoRumors are swirling that Thiel is gearing up for economic/regulatory war on silicon valley. So I can't say this is surprising but I find it all extremely confusing. EDIT: Mostly rumors I hear from happy hours with some politicos in DC. Sorry, its just meat space rumors.
- pault 9y agoWhat would he have to gain from such a war?
- hobofan 9y agoThe ones who profit the most from more regulations are usually the big existing players (in the case of general regulations). He has a lot of investments in big players, so the motive would be good old monetary gain. In the case of more specialized regulations targeting single players can be used to take out the competition (e.g. hurting Google might be good for his stake in Facebook).
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoRegulatory lock for both Palantir and Facebook. Regulations can be very good for large businesses as they erect enormous barriers to entry into certain spaces that only established companies can hope to surmount.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- krylon 9y agoI am not willing to believe that on such scarce evidence. I not exactly a fan of Peter Thiel, but I am not convinced he is that ruthless. However, if it were true, it matches so perfectly the article he wrote for WSJ a few years ago. It was literally titled "Competition is for losers". [1] I still do not think that he basically wants to bully all the competition away so he can make more money and become more powerful. And I will not even go into how likely it is that could actually succeed with such a move, if he did. But still - if the rumors should turn out to be true, we cannot say that nobody could have seen that coming, in fact he told us himself what he was going to do. If. And at that point truth has become indeed stranger than fiction. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-losers-1410535536 https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-...
- creaghpatr 9y agoI mean, it's straight out of his book Zero to One, something about being "last to market"
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoThe high falutin fancy pants term is regulatory capture[0]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- burntrelish1273 9y agoThiel is clearly a libertarian nutter of the Bannon varietal, from his statements and interviews. To them "all regulations == bad," lacking nuance and honest reality in preference to utopian illusions that align with the interests of unlimited greed.
- briandear 9y agoIt’s clear you don’t know Thiel. Comparing him to Bannon is just ridiculous.
- randyrand 9y agoA few large silicon valley companies have a large concentration of power. Libertarians like distribution of power among smaller entities.
- hobofan 9y agoThat doesn't sound like the Peter Thiel I have heard about. If his writing is any reflection of his beliefs, he is a big fan of monopolies (unless he doesn't own them).
- majormajor 9y agoMy impression of Thiel is more the "superman" type approach to libertarianism. Power should be concentrated among the worthy (aka me).
- bbctol 9y agoThat's not a great summary of libertarian beliefs, and the exact opposite of Thiel's stated beliefs.
- s73ver_ 9y agoBut that's not Thiel at all. He does want power concentrated; he just wants to be one of those it's concentrated with.
- alexanderstears 9y agoHe wants power to be as concentrated as it should be when people are free to gain and lose power as consequences of their decisions. That's contrasted with bureaucratic insulation whereby power isn't gained or lost with bad or good decisions.
- s73ver_ 9y agoNothing I've seen indicates that's even remotely close to the truth. He wants power to be concentrated with him.
- api 9y agoIf this is true and not just rumors, my guess would be that it's political. SV tends to lean left or left-libertarian.
- defen 9y agoRighteous vengeance? He seems like the kind of guy who enjoys that kind of thing. He took a ton of flak for supporting Trump, and I'll bet a lot of people burned bridges, certain of a Clinton victory. But then against all odds Trump won and all of a sudden Thiel has a lot of friends in high places, and it's payback time.
- non_sequitur 9y agoWhat kind of rumors? Any links or anything that would give some context?
- htormey 9y agoApparently an AG that Thiel gave money to is investigating google for antitrust stuff in Missouri: “But it’s not the first time Thiel has handed cash to an AG who went after Google over monopoly concerns. Missouri Attorney General Josh Hawley announced Nov. 13 that his office was investigating Google to see if the Mountain View tech giant had violated the state’s antitrust and consumer-protection laws. The Missouri attorney general said he had issued an investigative subpoena to Google. He’s looking at the firm’s handling of users’ personal data, along with claims that it misappropriated content from rivals and pushed down competitors’ websites in search results.” http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/11/15/is-billionaire-vc-peter-thiel-trying-to-break-up-google/ http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/11/15/is-billionaire-vc-pete...
- dopamean 9y agoWhat does this mean?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sillysaurus3 9y agoCan anyone provide context to this? Sam has been on record saying that he wouldn't cut Thiel solely for political affiliations. Was there another reason?
- tptacek 9y agoCan we save ourselves a really long, pointless political argument? They ended the entire part-time-partner program, and transitioned some of the part-timers to advisor roles. Thiel is one of multiple part-timers not to become an advisor. You are not going to get an answer, or more "context", from YC about the political implications of this change. No matter how many times you ask and how carefully you word the questions, you're not going to pry loose any first-hand drama from this situation. I'm happy Thiel's no longer involved with YC. I'm disappointed that it took this long, but we can't always get what we want. There are people here that disagree with me on both those things. We all knew that about each other. We probably don't need to beat it to death.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSure, let's not argue. But it's fine to be curious. Sam has said that he won't cut Thiel for political ties. Thiel is cut. Does this represent an internal shift in momentum, or an external shift in appearances? Combine that with some recent news regarding Thiel. I wish I'd paid more attention to it. It was something like, Thiel was making a move against a certain company. So maybe it has nothing to do with politics, or that politics are an incomplete answer. If we won't get an answer, that's fine. But it's unnecessary to shut down the conversation so harshly. There could very well be a non-political reason for this move, and HN is one of the best places to shake loose counterintuitive truths. I guess what bugs me is the lack of curiosity here. Everyone is acting relieved to be rid of Thiel. The underlying dynamics are interesting, and there's no reason it has to be an argument or polarizing.
- imustbeevil 9y agoIt's not really a conversation if people just say whatever they believe with no evidence. It's much closer to noise.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoLet me try to pull some intellectual gratification out of this: A source close to Y Combinator said that the company ended its part-time partners program, which Thiel was a part of, some time last year. While some other part-time partners moved over to a program called "experts," which provides advice to Y Combinator entrepreneurs, Thiel did not join. It's legit fascinating to me to watch this in action. Let's say hypothetically you wanted to get rid of Thiel. How could you do that? "Just form another group, then don't invite Thiel to the new group" didn't even occur to me. That's smart. Can this be seen as something other than an accusation or a political talking point? I'm trying to make commentary about overall emergent social phenomena. Maybe nobody cares about that, but personally I think group dynamics are really interesting to witness.
- owens99 9y agoThis post does not appear to contain any evidence that YC has cut ties with Peter Thiel. They ended the program that he, and many other individuals, were a part of. Just because he is not in this program anymore, does not mean they no longer have any ties to him. There is also no evidence of any connection here to Trump or Thiel's support of him with the ending of the program or Thiel's lack of involvement in a different official capacity with YC. I wish I could have the five minutes back it took to read this click bait.
- fleitz 9y agoIn the future just avoid anything on buzzfeed, it’s all clickbait
- racer-v 9y agoThe page literally says: Edit: Peter Thiel is no longer affiliated with Y Combinator. That means they at least cut some ties. https://blog.ycombinator.com/welcome-peter/ https://blog.ycombinator.com/welcome-peter/
- m333t 9y agoSo Y Combinator now has a party affiliation. Good to know.
- craigkerstiens 9y agoWhile I know most of these things never get a truly transparent answer, and often for valid reasons. I am very curious for some response from YC. It may have been politically motivated, and it may not have been. I'm also not aware how much Thiel was involved vs. other partners. Additional insight into much of this could shed good light to those that appreciate much of what YC has done and aims to continue to do. Some response from YC would be a big win, but also just may not be an option.
- evangelista 9y agoI am still really puzzled over exactly why Peter Thiel so so hated. I believe the level of hatred is completely unwarranted. From my understanding, it boils down to this: - He is remotely associated with Trump - He helped take down Gawker - ....something something something...but he backed Trump! For the Gawker part: Gawker outed him without his permission. Outing a gay man is something the tabloids used to do in the darkest time period of the United States. Finding someone was gay and making that known publicly was a tool used by very, very unpleasant people to destroy careers and lives for years. Given how Liberal the tech industry is, it is genuinely puzzling that people would rise to the defense of "Freedom of the Press" to use someone's sexual identity to try to discredit or embarrass them and destroy their career. This is not freedom of the press, its bullying. If a media outlet did something to you personally and you had a few million dollars to spare to shut them down, you would do it too. Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences. So Peter Thiel helped shut down an abusive tabloid that outs gay men against their will and regresses the tech sector back to the 1970's and 80's. That doesn't seem sufficient to warrant the hatred. Then he was associated with Trump. He dared so say things like: "Our middle class has been gutted by globalization and we are being eaten alive by China." Bernie Sanders ran on this exact platform. Almost word-for-word, Bernie Sander's political platform economically had many things in common with what Thiel was promoting. So that leaves one final option: The reason that people hate Thiel is because he made enemies in the Liberal press, they smeared him relentlessly and people internalized this without doing their own independent thinking or research. I don't like that Y Combinator was expected to "Apologize" for not firing someone for holding political beliefs that align them with 42% of the United States population. I feel the tech industry is now a worse, less free place when demonization of this type has become so endemic.
- danans 9y ago> - He is remotely associated with Trump I don't think his association with Trump deserves him anything beyond disapproval from someone who also disapproves of Trump, definitely not hatred. And I've almost never seen any hate-filled comments directed towards him on HN that weren't downvoted. But to suggest that he is only "remotely" associated with Trump seems like a blatant misrepresentation of his activities during and after the election.
- neo4sure 9y agoIn my opinion, this was long overdue. Anyway, Ycombinator maybe strategically getting ready for a world without trump. Having people who supported this type of a Person won't be a good look in the future.
- ssijak 9y agoSure, lets all think the same. Do you play football with people who dont like to eat what you like?
- zimpenfish 9y ago> Do you play football with people who dont like to eat what you like? I appreciate that trivialising the issues to score cheap slippery slope points is de rigueur these days but you must surely see the yawning dichotomy between "people who don't like to eat what you like" and "people who believe other people are lesser beings less deserving of rights, money, health, protections"
- ssijak 9y agoPeter does not think that
- jacquesm 9y agoWhat about Milner?
- xupybd 9y ago>YC is not going to fire someone for supporting a major party nominee. This is awesome. I had no idea this had been said. I have a lot of respect for anyone bringing that sentiment.
- johnrichardson 9y agoI'm a big fan of Peter Thiel, and of anyone who's a divergent thinker and has well thought out opinions that run contrary to mainstream ideology (e.g., Noam Chomsky). If YC ended its relationship with Peter because of his political affiliations, I'd find that extremely unfortunate. Any institution which closes itself off to outside information, challenging viewpoints and diversity of thought risks becoming an ideological echo chamber and ultimately weakening itself in the long run.
- ubernostrum 9y agoAny institution which closes itself off to outside information, challenging viewpoints and diversity of thought Do you make sure to attend flat-earth meetings?