4 ms·
Massive population density increases. JR also has a decent income from real estate. Train stations are in prime locations, and have a lot of foot traffic, so t
by kalleboo 9y ago
Massive population density increases.
JR also has a decent income from real estate. Train stations are in prime locations, and have a lot of foot traffic, so they build malls around them.
- ruddct 9y agoI suspect it's more of a cultural/political problem than a density problem. NYC has a considerably higher population density than Tokyo and has an abysmally expensive/inefficient rail system. American public transportation systems, even here in the densest part of the country, are easy political whipping boys. Blame whatever you'd like (cars, highways, unions, politicians, etc), it appears that Americans don't care too much about fixing their transportation infrastructure if those fixes don't involve cars.
- GolDDranks 9y ago> NYC has a considerably higher population density than Tokyo It's the other way around, Tokyo has higher population density: New York City: Land area: 784 km2 Population density: 10,431 ppl / km2 The Special Wards of Tokyo: Land area: 619 km2 Population density: 15,146 ppl / km2
- luckyt 9y agoThis comparison seems a bit unfair -- the special wards are the most densely populated parts of Tokyo. You should compare either New York City <-> Tokyo Metro Area, or Special Wards of Tokyo <-> Manhattan.
- timr 9y ago"This comparison seems a bit unfair" It's not just unfair, it's completely absurd. Tokyo sprawls like crazy, and a big percentage of the population lives in the outer wards. The special wards are high density, but expensive. As soon as you go outside of the Yamanote line, the population density of Tokyo falls dramatically (probably to Brooklyn levels). Take the train 10-15 minutes outside of that, and you find lots of detached houses and open land. Yet it's all "Tokyo", and this land area is counted when you see the huge population of the city referenced online. Tokyo has become a fantasy for people in America who think that urban density solves all problems. Most of these people have not ventured outside of the tourist regions of the city.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoTo be fair, NYC technically includes Long Island. It isn’t obvious how to compare the two cities at all.
- gowld 9y agoOnly a small part of Long Island. Are you thinking of Staten Island?
- majormajor 9y agoThis is an interesting comparison in its own right. Manhattan: 27,799/km2 and 59.13 km2 So that's denser than the overall special wards area, but also vastly smaller in both land and total population. Basically 1.6 million people vs 9.4 million people. Probably significantly easier to have an extensive train network when you're consistently dense for that large an area. But I would agree that the main reason the US's public transit infrastructure is lacking is just that we like our cars too much. I expect this to get even more pro-car in a self-driving-car world, too.
- gpvos 9y agoAll around Europe train stations are turning into malls for the same reason.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mullen 9y ago> JR also has a decent income from real estate This is actually a big money maker for them. Train stations are malls in many cases and JR makes a lot of money from them.
- 6t6t6t6 9y ago> Train stations are in prime locations In Japan, in general, the closer your land is to the station, the more expensive it is. So, therefore, the stations are on the most expensive land of each area. ;) Population density is also proportional, a lot of times, to the distance to the nearest station.