4 ms·
> Those who appear to get their money 'for nothing' the same as the 'scroungers' and then flaunt it by buying expensive stuff. How someone got their money is i
by pc86 9y ago
> Those who appear to get their money 'for nothing' the same as the 'scroungers' and then flaunt it by buying expensive stuff.
How someone got their money is irrelevant, but it's much better for the economy that they spend it, even on garbage, than let it sit in a brokerage account. Every person with a trust fund spending $400k on an Aston Martin is sustaining (not creating) jobs and distributing wealth to some degree.
- neilwilson 9y ago"but it's much better for the economy that they spend it," Generally it isn't - because that tilts the economy towards producing goods and services that are wanted rather than those that are needed. Trickle down has been shown over the last 30 years to be largely a myth. For example if you have public healthcare and private healthcare and there is a shortage of doctors then the wealthy "crowds out" the public healthcare system by purchasing private healthcare. Essentially they are using their wealth to jump the queue. Like the 'priority queue' at a theme park.
- dandermotj 9y agoConsumption through spending is economically beneficial to everyone. You misunderstand what 'trickle down economics' is.
- Boothroid 9y agoSo then let's have permanent war because all that spending on bombs is economically beneficial to everyone, right?
- dandermotj 9y agoSay hello to the military-industrial complex
- dnautics 9y agoWe just have to have some aliens threaten to invade our planet to goose the economy. It'll be great for everyone!
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoAnd pushing people to ever more overuse of resources can't go wrong because we have an infinite supply of all resources, it can't fail. /s
- dnautics 9y ago>Consumption through spending is economically beneficial to everyone. What about the externalities of destruction of the environment due to consumption?
- chii 9y agoOnly if gov't didn't apply environmental regulations when they should've.
- snarf21 9y agoI think there were talking more about the velocity of money than trickle down. If money is in the market and it sits, there is no taxation on it (yet). If they buy a car, that money pays people and parts and taxes are paid. They spend what is left to other people who also pay taxes, etc. So money can be taxed multiple times as it powers the economy instead of sitting in an asset that is deferred.
- neilwilson 9y agoThe paradox of thrift is solved by the source of liquidity. Let them count their coins if they feel like it.
- wolfgke 9y ago> because that tilts the economy towards producing goods and services that are wanted rather than those that are needed Who has the authority to define what is needed?
- neilwilson 9y agoGenerally those that are elected to do so. Assuming you're in favour of a modern democracy, rather than a technocracy, an epistocracy, or the wild west.
- wolfgke 9y ago> Generally those that are elected to do so. > Assuming you're in favour of a modern democracy, rather than a technocracy, an epistocracy, or the wild west. This argumentation is pettifoggery.
- norswap 9y agoThe rich spend a lesser percentage of their revenue than the poor scroungers, your argument seems pretty flawed.
- ams6110 9y agoThey invest their money though. It's not just cash in a vault somewhere. So it does benefit the economy.
- maxxxxx 9y agoOr it drives up asset prices. See housing.
- neilwilson 9y agoActually it is somewhere. After the portfolio adjustments are made somebody ends up with cash in a vault somewhere (or more likely bank money). Very often on the asset side of a foreign central bank which they then use to discount into their own currency (hi China)
- maxerickson 9y agoLiteral cash and similar assets are the only dead money in the economy. Even low and zero interest savings accounts are used by banks to back loans. So for example, when someone buys gold or bitcoin, they are isolating that money from the productive economy. When they buy a share of a business, they are participating in the financial backing of that business (they generally aren't actually directly contributing to the business, but the business can do some types of business against its value on the stock market).
- to3m 9y agoWhen somebody buys gold or bitcoin, they are giving money to somebody else, who will almost certainly spend it, or, failing that, at least put it in the bank.
- mdemare 9y ago> Even low and zero interest savings accounts are used by banks to back loans. Only if banks have more lending opportunities than deposits, and that hasn't really been the case, (depending on which country we're discussing) since the crisis.
- neilwilson 9y ago"Even low and zero interest savings accounts are used by banks to back loans." No. The loans are made out of nothing. Saving is the end of the loan process, not the beginning. That has been made clear by the Bank of England. http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarterlybulletin/2014/qb14q1prereleasemoneycreation.pdf http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarte...
- lkozma 9y agoIsn't this the broken window fallacy?
- pc86 9y agoNo
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThat money might well be invested in Aston Martin providing them with needed liquidity to run their business. I'm really not sure which is more productive. I suspect what parent is talking about is the rentier class that has grown substantially in the UK over the last decade. 10% of the population now own at least one rental property.
- kamaal 9y agoThere is nothing wrong with renting your property. Not sure why this is sold as a vice every time this discussion comes up. Somebody has to pay to buy lands and build a home. Also these people need to answer what they think about infrastructure bonds, which is more or less the same as renting a home.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIt's become a problem in the UK because housing supply is so constrained, there is a whole class (or generation) that is getting fat on the back of this constrained supply and has been voting for policies that continue the situation. This isn't buying land and building homes, it's about people leveraging their existing housing to out bid people just looking for a home. This has led to the age of a first time buyer reaching 32 and left many people with a precarious housing situation. So yes, there is something wrong with it.
- mdemare 9y agoNo, that completely depends on in what economic climate they'd be in. Exuberant spending in 2009 creates jobs, but in 1999 crowds out more sensible use of resources.