5 ms·
False optimism? Old article, but probably still true today: 19% of Americans think they are among the top 1% of earners and 20% more think they will be one day
by ryandrake 9y ago
False optimism? Old article, but probably still true today: 19% of Americans think they are among the top 1% of earners and 20% more think they will be one day [1]. When you introduce a plan that hurts "the rich": 39% of people think they're the target.
1: http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hope-over-self-interest.html http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hop...
- Frqy3 9y agoI think it is a combination of people expecting to move up financially over time, and wanting to keep as large a gap as possible between themselves and the next rung down on the financial ladder.
- blfr 9y agoThis isn't false optimism. It's a surprisingly accurate self-assessment. It turns out that 12 percent of the population will find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution for at least one year. What’s more, 39 percent of Americans will spend a year in the top 5 percent of the income distribution, 56 percent will find themselves in the top 10 percent, and a whopping 73 percent will spend a year in the top 20 percent of the income distribution. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-to-riches-to-rags.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-...
- yorwba 9y agoSo ... 39% think they'll be in the top 1%, when in reality that's the proportion who get to be in the top 5%. How is that an accurate self-assessment?
- lovich 9y agoIt also worse in that 19% of people think they are the top 1% of earners _currently_ which is more off
- blfr 9y agoFor a question about finance to the general public this is a cheating-on-the-test and educators-wept-tears-of-joy level great result.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSo you call it "accurate" because it's not as inaccurate as you think it could be?
- ApolloFortyNine 9y agoIt's pretty close, for people taking a shot in the dark. It's just what these people believed.
- infinite8s 9y agoI think most people vastly underestimate what the tail of this distribution looks like. 0.1% on this income scale is $10 million dollars or more.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoBut that's the answer to a different question.
- JeremyNT 9y agoPeople should be considering wealth though, not income. When you're looking at the "rich," income doesn't tell you very much, since most "rich" peoples' wealth exists in (and continues to accrue via) non-income vehicles. If you earn a high income for only a few years, you won't have the extensive advantages (tax havens, etc) of the truly wealthy, and you certainly won't have all of the hereditary wealth squirrelled away into offshore accounts and invested into capital that's busy appreciating.
- ryandrake 9y agoFrom your article: > Although 12 percent of the population will experience a year in which they find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution, a mere 0.6 percent will do so in 10 consecutive years. When you ask someone whether they will one day be in the top 1%, I don't think they are interpreting that question as "will you be there for a brief moment?" The question implies some level of permanence. So 38.4% are fooling themselves.
- raker 9y ago38.4% still think they are the target. If their dream is to be in the 1%, they may not want to add new penalties or rules for their potentially future selves.
- contrast 9y agoIf you take a period of time, and judge yourself by your best performance over small fractions of that time, then you are very far away from an accurate self-assessment.
- jaggednad 9y agoSpending a year in the top x% isn’t what most people have in mind with their false optimism. They expect to make it to that bracket and stay there. One-time windfalls that put you in a certain bracket temporarily don’t make low taxes on that bracket net benefit you. You’re still getting screwed all the other years in your life
- krona 9y ago19% of Americans think they are among the top 1% of earners and 20% more think they will be one day You attribute that to false optimism, but where's the actual evidence? Here's a more recent article, backed by empirical studies (you can buy the books if you wan't to): https://www.aei.org/publication/evidence-shows-significant-income-mobility-in-the-us-73-of-americans-were-in-the-top-20-for-at-least-a-year/print/ https://www.aei.org/publication/evidence-shows-significant-i... . And the standard point that Thomas Sowell has been making for decades: An absolute majority of the people who were in the bottom 20 percent in 1975 have also been in the top 20 percent at some time since then.
- mrguyorama 9y agoThe top 20% of income distributions in America is so absurdly vast that this is essentially meaningless. At $100k, breaking into the top 20% is barely comfortable living in some parts of the country. This pales with what the top 1% and 0.1% earn.
- Consultant32452 9y agoWhile I think most people have a fantasy of being in the 1% or 0.1%, that's not really the "American Dream." The American dream is roughly a decent suburban home in a safe neighborhood. This fixation/hatred towards the 1% or 0.1% is really not something most people I know care about, at all. They may not articulate it this way, but they don't see the economy as a zero sum game. They don't see Steve Jobs making billions as something that keeps them from making tens or hundreds of thousands, or even millions if they were fortunate.
- mrguyorama 9y agoThe problem is not that Steve Jobs made a billion dollars. The problem is that Steve Jobs pushes for all sorts of negative things that screw over "the little guy" so that he can make another $100.
- Consultant32452 9y ago
- api 9y agoThey are globally. I put my salary into a global salary calculator once and found that I was in the top 0.4% of humanity. I don't feel it because I live in Orange County CA which is one of the richest in the USA. We measure our status relative to other people and I'm surrounded by even wealthier people.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- samirillian 9y agoThis. I think it was Chesterton who said that most Americans think of themselves as momentarily embarrassed millionaires.
- dominotw 9y agoIsn't that a good thing?
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSounds like overestimating your worth to society; which to me is likely to lead to arrogance and irresponsible financial behaviour, at least.
- dominotw 9y agoalso could be a sign of drive and passion to make it. I would take that over being defeated and complacent. I lived in soviet block as a kid and everyone had this defeated attitude which is such a contrast to american optimism. Although, things are changing in America now, more and more people feel hopeless and defeated here too.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIt's not defeatist to be realistic about who you are, to make the most of resources you can afford, we need much more of that if we're not going to implode with pressures from overpopulation. Do you know the tale of the Ant & the Grasshopper? If you 'make it' (produce something that brings great worth to society) first then you're welcome, IMO, to use a little more than your fair share of resources. You don't get to do it the other way around as the majority of Western society appears to be doing (other regions maybe are too, I don't have an informed view on them).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- delecti 9y ago
- TAForObvReasons 9y ago> Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires
- dnautics 9y agoThats such a disgustingly sneering sentiment that belittles the judgement of those without money. Perhaps we should consider that those without means have little expectation that they will be able to successfully extract favor from an organization that doles out trillions for broken fighter jets that are intended to kill people of color in distant lands.
- tshadwell 9y agothis is an article about the UK.
- valuearb 9y agoWhy are we so jealously focused on percentages instead of absolute values? The bottom 10% are wealthier than the top 10% were 100 years ago.