3 ms·
Why would light bulbs need to be connected to the Internet for the use case of being turned on at a specific time? They'd just need to be connected to a timer f
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Why would light bulbs need to be connected to the Internet for the use case of being turned on at a specific time? They'd just need to be connected to a timer for this.
I mean, an Internet connected light bulb use-case would a bulb that flashed whenever a stock you owned went down in price, which is ridiculous despite being the least ridiculous example I could think of.
IoT security cameras and an automated kitchen you phone to, to prepared you dinner if you were coming home unexpected seems like the least crazy IoT device an individual could own - most IoT stuff seems more like what a global company would want rather than an individual.
- DanBC 9y ago> despite being the least ridiculous example I could think of. A lighbulb flashes when visitors ring the doorbell, which is useful for people with visual impairment. the doorbell has a hidden rfid reader, and certain guests have an rfid card. the doorbell flashes differently for each visitor.
- GrinningFool 9y agoThat could also be done without network connectivity, even local. A microcontroller with a relay and rfid reader would do it. A fancier version might use bluetooth to let your phone set up new cards and disable/change others - still no need to talk to anything external beyond the phone itself. Take it one step further, and you could trigger it via an NFC read of your vistors' phones. This also would not need to connect to a network (beyond installing the app on the phones). Actually, sounds like it might be a fun project to play with :D
- pdkl95 9y agoThat only needs a local wireless (or whatever) connection between the reader and the light. X10 et al did this over power lines over 20 years ago. Communicating over 802.11 - with or without the internet - adds complexity and exposes the device to the world.
- joe_the_user 9y ago"A lighbulb flashes when visitors ring the doorbell, which is useful for people with visual impairment. the doorbell has a hidden rfid reader, and certain guests have an rfid card. the doorbell flashes differently for each visitor." How is this an example of something that needs to be connected to the Internet. My point is most examples are about local connect to justify a jump into a world-wide, insecure net. I mean, all the light bulb examples are contrived because a PHONE has all information-conveying ability of a light bulb and is designed for information-conveyance. Light bulb are designed for the light-consumption needs of those nearby and examples of light-bulb-control at a distance are either poor substitutes for phones or "weirdness" - haunted houses and art-happenings.
- arcbyte 9y agoIt doesn’t matter whether you know of any use cases or not. Somebody else does. Don’t interfere with their liberties.
- gruez 9y ago>Don’t interfere with their liberties. that's well and good until they cause negative externalities
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> Why would light bulbs need to be connected to the Internet for the use case of being turned on at a specific time? They'd just need to be connected to a timer for this. I already have a network connected to the internet. I don't already have a dedicated light bulb timer, and producing one of those, or buying one that had somehow gotten produced, would be stupid. I had no particular desire for the bulbs to be connected to the internet, but I did want them connected to my home network, and I did also want my home network connected to the internet.
- ryandrake 9y agoExactly. Nearly everyone who tries to explain why I would want Xyz device to connect to the Internet cites a use case that... doesn't require an Internet connection! Turning lights on and off at certain times, buzzing when a doorbell is pressed, thermostats and sprinklers that respond to the weather. Even security cameras don't need an Internet connection when being viewed locally, yet my Dropcam insists on sending all video out to a web service, just so that I can request it all back when viewing on my computer! Insane!
- joe_the_user 9y agoIndeed, You get a combination of a wifi network being the one sort network every person is guaranteed to be already on and every company dreaming of cloud-based-app supremacy "synergizing" every useless whatsit they have access and the IoT nightmare is in full swing. "What could possibly go" - wait, we've seen answers to that one already.