8 ms·
Kurzweil just seems like a snake oil salesman to me. Ranging from wrong or overly broad predictions to advocating theories of the mind and brain that are reject
by Barrin92 9y ago
Kurzweil just seems like a snake oil salesman to me. Ranging from wrong or overly broad predictions to advocating theories of the mind and brain that are rejected by neuroscience to well.. his literal supplement sales websites.
The 'futurist' title seems to reside somewhere between science fiction, pop culture with some business credentials thrown in. I don't know what to make of it.
- Analemma_ 9y agoIt was bad enough in the 90's and early 00's when it was just him, but now he has kicked off an entire subculture. Kurzweil, de Grey, Hanson, Bostrom, Yudkowsky... all total cranks, and inexplicably popular among ostensibly intelligent people. It's embarrassing.
- yters 9y agoMaterialists got religion.
- pmoriarty 9y agoHe didn't even come up with the singularity idea. Vernor Vinge originated it, and a whole bunch of people were discussing it at the time. Kurzweil just jumped on the bandwagon and started hyping it up to such an extent that many mistakenly believe the idea originated with him. It didn't.
- goatlover 9y agoAnd I.J. Good before Vinge regarding the intelligence explosion.
- Jach 9y agoAnd all three (Good, Vinge, Kurzweil) views of the Singularity are different. This stuff is old: http://yudkowsky.net/singularity/schools/ http://yudkowsky.net/singularity/schools/ It's amazing that people want to lump in anyone associated with it, or just related moral ideas like "death really sucks, what's a general way to end it?" as cranks of the same sort. Or worse compare it to a religion (http://archive.fo/6oI0u http://archive.fo/6oI0u)
- pmoriarty 9y agoYudkowsky is another self-promoting hype machine, in the vein of Kurzweil. I wouldn't take him as the most unbiased source on the history of the singularity idea or how "his" ideas differ from the rest.
- drcode 9y agoIt seems like you're basically just saying that any attempt to predict the future is crankery. I think it would be a sad world if everyone just said "If I can't see it in front of my eyes and it isn't relevant to me today it's a waste of time"
- eesmith 9y agoCould you explain how you got that conclusion? Those people have overlapping views. For example, many of them are associated with the Future of Humanity Institute. I think it's more reasonable to conclude that Analemma_'s "crank" comment refers to only those in that subculture, and cannot be extended to all people who are making "any attempt to predict the future." In fact, a quick check of Analemma_'s history show this comment from 16 days ago, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15577671 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15577671 : "if you are always predicting disaster, then your predictions are neither useful nor credible, since you will be wrong most of the time as the long-term trend of the market is upward." I think it's certain that Analemma_ does not consider this sort of future prediction as part of the same crankery subculture as Kurzweil, etc.
- drcode 9y agoWell, I guess the question basically boils down to whether Analemma_ or you can name futurists that are not cranks... if you can't, then it seems to me the beef is with the notion of futurism itself, not with an individual subculture of futurists. It seems to me that Analemma_ (and likely yourself) are proponents of the view "the future will be mostly the same as the present with minor inconsequential variations" which is a very sound and reasonable view to hold, but also kind of sad and unambitious in my view.
- eesmith 9y agoAlvin Toffler, Daniel Bell, and Marshall McLuhan. I think that "futurist" is only a subset of those who make "any attempt to predict the future". For example, the Congressional Budget Office routinely makes predictions about the future effect of new legislation, though they are never called "futurists". As to your second paragraph, I have no idea of how you concluded that that is my view. As a kid I enjoyed James Burke's "Connections" which, quoting Wikipedia, "explores an "Alternative View of Change" (the subtitle of the series) that rejects the conventional linear and teleological view of historical progress", and that viewpoint has stayed with me. Personally, I'm of the view that the late 1800s - the Belle Époque - contained much more significant technological and cultural changes than the late 1900s, and that people like Kurzweil end up minimizing the large transitions brought about by the telephone, phonograph, the vertical filing system, punched cards, lighting system, etc. Concerning just lighting, Paris got the nickname "The City Of Light" because of its early installation (in the 1860s) of gas lighting, and night-life started around them, enabled first by limelight and then arc lamps.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoCynically, "futurist" might be well understood in the category of celebrities who are famous only because they are famous. Kurzweil, though, might perhaps be more accurately viewed as a spokesman for a new religion.
- philipkglass 9y agoI see Kurzweil as a sadder figure: someone who achieved a lot as an inventor, and whose overblown prognostications about the future come (largely) from overestimating how quickly everyone else can improve technologies and adopt them. It's sort of a revenge of the mediocrity principle. If you are exceptional, assuming that other people are basically like you can produce disastrously skewed mental models of the world. I'm reminded of the complaint that startups are disproportionately geared toward solving the problems of highly educated, able-bodied adults who have more money than spare time. "I'm like this, my friends are like this, and by the principle of mediocrity we're not unusual... therefore, iOS could use another food delivery app." You need to measure, rather than guess, whether you are unusual relative to large numbers of other people. On top of that Kurzweil appears to have some good old fashioned self-delusion about death: believing he can "bring back" his beloved dead father as software, the life extension supplements, etc. (I don't believe in souls or uncomputable quantum woo in brains. I have no problem in principle with "brain uploads." I think that the obstacles in practice are extremely formidable and typically underestimated by people who have spent more time with computers than with biology.)
- pishpash 9y agoSame with Wolfram, I suppose.
- shobith 9y agoHow's Wolfram similar? what thoughts of his are "overblown"? I'm curious because I don't see the parallels between the two, while you seem to imply some obviousness.
- WorldMaker 9y agoThere's at least somewhat a sense that Wolfram's rabbit holing down Conway's Game/Cellular Automata and calling it "A New Kind of Math" was relatively overblown. Certainly Wolfram has his ego in play/blinders on about certain subjects, and in that way you can easily draw parallels between Wolfram and Kurzweil, depending of course on what your own personal take/opinion on their various pet projects happens to be.
- trgv 9y agoI don't think "snake oil salesman" is apt at all. I don't know the guy, or follow him closely, but I don't think he's dishonest, I just think he's wrong. There's a distinction between a snake oil salesman and someone who actually believes in what they're selling.
- yters 9y agoThe best liars believe their own lie.
- stouset 9y agoHe literally sells supplements that he suggests will provide longevity. It’s irrelevant if he believes in their efficacy or not. Alternative health practitioners certainly believe in their remedies. Gwenyth Paltow certainly believes in… whatever absurdities she’s peddling nowadays. The Food Babe probably does too. None of that makes them any less snake oil. Edit: A quick search on Wikipedia shows me I’m wrong. Apparently it’s only snake oil if the seller is aware the product is fraudulent. TIL. Edit 2: I might not be as wrong as I believed. A snake oil salesman can also be a quack who promotes medical practices based upon ignorance, which would definitely encompass Gwenyth Paltrow and the Food Babe.
- tim333 9y agoThe supplements thing is a bit of a hobby, not his main business.
- trgv 9y agoI think "snake oil salesman" only applies if the target of the epithet is knowingly perpetrating a fraud. You could (accurately, in my opinion) describe the things Kurzweil is selling as "snake oil" but I wouldn't describe him as a "snake oil salesman." A whole lot of medicine practiced throughout human history has been based on ignorance, but I wouldn't describe medieval doctors (or whichever era) as "snake oil salesmen" because they believed in what they were selling. This is a pretty important distinction, in my mind.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]