8 ms·
Saudi Arabia detains 201 princes, businessmen in $100B corruption probe
- tome 9y agoIs Saudia Arabia changing its PR strategy? So much good news coming from this kingdom at the moment ...
- dx034 9y agoYes, they are getting ready for a life after oil. They'll still have large inflows for another 1-2 decades so if they start now, they can be a highly developed economy with sizeable tourism, education sector and tech once oil dries up (or becomes less profitable). They recently announced to build a city solely focused around renewables and self driving technology, a future version of Dubai basically.
- oblio 9y agoWell, they could be a solar power house, I imagine.
- dagw 9y agoIs this good news? By all accounts this seems to as much a purging of political enemies by the new leaders and them cementing their grip on power as anything to do with corruption.
- gwright 9y agoThose aren't mutually exclusive.
- dagw 9y agoTrue, but what is the lesson people are taking away? Is it "I better stop being corrupt" or is it "if I want to keep being corrupt I better swear loyalty to MBS and make sure he gets his cut". If it's purely the latter, has anything really been won?
- gwright 9y agoFair enough. I think it is too early to say what the outcome is going to be. I'm also fairly amused at some comments here being critical of the manner in which the changes are happening. An autocratic monarchy is not going to change via committee meetings, legislative votes, or reasoned judicial orders -- not significantly at least. Moving toward more moderate policies or even further to a constitutional monarchy is going to come from the use of brute force.
- dagw 9y agoI think we can all agree that this is a move towards something new and big. The significant questions are will it work, and is that something a 'good' something.
- wils1245 9y agoIt is if the man supposedly cleaning things up is every bit as corrupt as those he’s having arrested.
- charlesdm 9y agoWhether this is a good move remains to be seen. As was said in another comment, this seems more about cementing power than anything else. A corrupt regime is bad, but sometimes the alternatives are worse. Just look at some of the Arab countries that were once relatively stable yet now are (still) in turmoil after the Arab spring.
- Narretz 9y agoWell, it's debatable if the improvements in women's rights and the corruption-related investigations are reflective of core changes to the society or if they are superficial changes in the first case, and moves to consolidate power in the second case.
- emptyfile 9y agoAs another comment pointed out, it is quite naive to consider "corruption purges" in countries like Russia, China or Saudi Arabia to be actually concerned with corruption. But yes absolutely, this is a PR strategy change, but it is primarily concerned with the public image of the crown prince not of the KSA itself.
- jdietrich 9y agoSaudi Arabia is changing, full stop. Mohammad bin Salman is pushing through a sweeping reform agenda, with the explicitly stated aim of returning Saudi Arabia to a moderate Islamic state. We've already seen substantial change. The powers of the religious police have been greatly curtailed, women are allowed to drive, the state-owned petroleum company is being partly privatised and there are major plans for economic modernisation. Whether this reform agenda actually comes to pass is yet to be seen, but I think we should applaud both the rhetoric and the efforts made so far.
- dagw 9y agowomen are allowed to drive Technically they've said that women will be allowed to drive at some time in future, possibly June 2018. As of today women are still not allowed to drive. It's still a pretty major move though.
- clavalle 9y agoThe reform agenda only reaches as far as the door to the throne room. Assuming perfect execution of western reforms we'll still be left with an enormously wealthy, powerful, and ruthless autocratic regime actively trying to spread their power far beyond their borders. Unless they become a constitutional monarchy with severely limited powers I am going to hold my applause.
- pavs 9y agoGradual change is better than no change at all. For a country like Saudi, if you want to make a large scale sudden changes which turns everything upside-down (even if those were good intentions), you will end up with something like Afganistan or Iraq. The pace of change (however slow for our standard), is quite unthinkable for the locals. I think it will take a couple of decades, at least, to see if anything good came out of this.
- baursak 9y agoSaudi Arabia is bombing and starving Yemenis as we speak. It has been destabilizing Syria by funding jihadis. It is still publicly beheading people for sorcery, witchcraft, apostasy, and sex outside marriage. Women are NOT allowed to drive until at least a year from now, for "reasons". This was just a PR bone thrown to the West before starting the war on Lebanon.
- dragonwriter 9y agoA cosolidation of autocratic power domestically combined with escalating it's apparent effort to initiate a larger regional war than it already has are not what I'd call unqualified “good news”.
- rorykoehler 9y agoBlockading Yemen in turn creating the world's worst famine and preparing for war against Lebanon and Iran is hardly what I would consider good news.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- thisisit 9y ago> The purge began overnight Saturday, initially catching 11 princes and 38 officials, military officers and business leaders. They are being held at five-star hotels, including the Ritz-Carlton in Riyadh. Really getting the royal treatment even during probe. Btw, is this in any way related to the pending Aramco IPO?
- dx034 9y agoDetained in a 5* hotel probably feels like prison would be for most of us. In the end, prison is about not having any freedom and that will be the case for them as well. A nice bed doesn't help much if you have no say about your life. > Btw, is this in any way related to the pending Aramco IPO? More likely the handover to the new crown prince (MBS). The IPO could be cancelled anyway but both are driven by MBS to modernise Saudi Arabia and make it ready for a future without oil.
- SirFatty 9y agoI get what you are saying to an extent, but really, if I had to serve time a 5-star hotel vs. a 6x8 cell... yeah, I know what I would choose.
- CamelCaseName 9y agoPerhaps a 5* for them is equivalent to a 6x8 jail cell for us. I would imagine they usually get the best service on the planet, not the best service available for average people.
- dx034 9y agoThat's exactly what I wanted to say. For us, living in flats or houses and owning up to two cars (and no jets), a cell is probably as much of a restriction on our comfort as a luxury hotel room is for a Saudi prince. That doesn't mean that they shouldn't go to a proper jail if convicted but I'm sure they already feel punished.
- adventured 9y ago
- solo1717 9y agoI wonder if any of these guys are linked to the classified parts of the 9/11 probe which indicated backing of the plotters by high level Saudi elements
- arca_vorago 9y agoSome of my conspiracy forums are saying supposedly this is part of a corruption sweep agreement that will include America (rumors of sealed indictments), designed to get "deep state" people to start singing. Not saying its true, but just thought it might add context. Never forget who created the house of saud in the first place.
- LyndsySimon 9y agoI'm seeing the same thing, in relatively mainstream conservative fora. The most convincing part of this seems to be that Alwaleed bin Talil has longstanding ties with the US political system, particularly on the left. His past work with the Podestas has many eyebrows raised. There are also dozens of sealed federal indictments pending, which I'm told is quite unusual. The assumption seems to be that they are related to Mueller's investigation although I've seen no compelling evidence that this is the case, aside from timing and wishful thinking.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> There are also dozens of sealed federal indictments pending, which I'm told is quite unusual. The assumption seems to be that they are related to Mueller's investigation although I've seen no compelling evidence that this is the case, aside from timing and wishful thinking. Neither the total number, nor timing, is particularly unusual; then speculation about Mueller is mostly based on the number in D.C. between the Manafort and Papadopoulos indictments being somewhat higher than would be expected by random chance, but even that is fairly weak. There is basically zero evidence of anything unusual with sealed indictments.
- TwoFactor 9y agoThe parties involved in the sealed indictments are actually leaked in the RSS feed. https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/rss_outside.pl https://ecf.dcd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/rss_outside.pl
- dragonwriter 9y agoConspiracy theories were so much more fun when they were handcrafted artisanal things rather than weaponized administration propaganda.
- dogruck 9y agoI do not think it’s accurate to call this a “corruption probe.” Surely that’s how Saudi Arabia’s leaders and their allies would like it described. To me, it’s a biased headline. Keep in mind that the opposing side is being murdered, or detained, without due process.
- buttcoinslol 9y agoThe KSA is an absolute monarchy that beheads people and severs limbs for thievery. Murdering or detaining the other side without due process is how these states work, it's how you consolidate power when there are hundreds of pretenders to the throne.
- dogruck 9y agoYeah, I understand that it’s a Real Life Game of Thrones. Even so, it sounds like we both agree that this is not a “corruption probe.”
- buttcoinslol 9y agoI agree, but the official story is that it's a corruption probe, and factual news stories aren't and shouldn't be in the business of speculation. An editorial exploring the true motives behind the 'corruption probe' would be appropriate.
- dogruck 9y ago“Official story” according to whom? I agree with your sentiment, but think the headline could simply omit the phrase “corruption probe” without losing any information.
- baursak 9y agoSure, but where is the outcry from Western media and round the clock coverage of this outrage? If anything remotely close to this was happening in any of "official" adversaries like Iran, Venezuela, Cuba, etc., media would be calling for US troops on the ground. It this was in Russia or China, there would be multiple levels of sanctions imposed as we speak. But, hey, this is Saudi Arabia, so let's just treat it with bemused detachment like an extended Game of Thrones season.
- LeoJiWoo 9y agoI'm surprised Alwaleed bin Talal arrest hasn't affected tech stocks yet. The big question to me is what the kingdom will do with all the assets they confiscated. EDIT: I think they'll start liquidating large assets for their http://vision2030.gov.sa/en http://vision2030.gov.sa/en plan.
- adventured 9y agoLet's put it into perspective. Paul Allen is holding $9.5 billion in Microsoft. Paul is worth around $6 billion more than Alwaleed. That position couldn't shake Microsoft very much at all, much less the wider tech world. Alwaleed's position in Apple and Twitter are, basically, meaningless to affecting tech stocks. Apple is a $900 billion company, nearing the worth of Aramco at this point. Alwaleed's entire worth is $17 billion, barely a drop in the ocean versus tech stocks. Not to mention nobody seriously believes those positions are going to be haphazardly liquidated. If Saudi Arabia manages to seize Kingdom Holdings, they'll most likely make gradual maneuvers.
- dagw 9y agoThe big question to me is what the kingdom will do with all the assets they confiscated. They will most likely fold them into the sovereign wealth fund.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- clavalle 9y agoWhen it is all said and done the Saudi Crown is going to have significant stakes in many critical American and Western companies including huge media companies. This makes me very uncomfortable.
- Zelmor 9y agoAre they any worse than your US overlords?
- SerLava 9y agoDid you read the title? It states which country we're talking about. Yes.
- clavalle 9y agoYes. Far worse.
- anbende 9y agoWell, their views on gender equality and religious freedom on average tend to be very different from the vast majority of those in the West. So yes, they might well be worse.
- muzani 9y agoMohammed bin Salman is allegedly a lot more moderate than the past leaders.
- clavalle 9y agoThe policy on gender and religious freedom is only the tip of the iceberg. Freedom as a concept seems to be under direct attack in their Kingdom considering the Crown Prince is rounding up political enemies en masse with complete impunity.
- mangodrunk 9y agoMaybe on certain domestic policies (though I think it's a stretch), but Saudi Arabia is in the dark ages, so it's not hard to be considered moderate there. He has been consolidating power with these "corruption" arrests. He is also destabilizing the region into chaos with an aggressive war against Yemen, a blockade of Qatar [1], and the forced resignation of Hariri [2]. 1: https://www.vox.com/world/2017/11/6/16613088/saudi-arabia-princes-arrested-mohammed-bin-salman https://www.vox.com/world/2017/11/6/16613088/saudi-arabia-pr... 2: http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/lebanon-prime-minister-saad-hariri-resignation-not-all-seems-quits-resigns-surprise-saudi-arabia-a8045636.html http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/lebanon-prime-minister-s...
- _delirium 9y agoThe Prime Minister of Lebanon also turned up in Riyadh and resigned via television on the same day in unclear circumstances (conflicting reports whether he is free to leave or not), which is a particularly weird tie-in: http://edition.cnn.com/2017/11/10/middleeast/lebanon-hariri-saudi-iran/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2017/11/10/middleeast/lebanon-hariri-...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throw2016 9y agoThis is the most backward and regressive country in the world. The fact that Europe, US, western media and other busy bodies can sanctimoniously preach human rights and execute wars and destroy entire countries for decades non stop while supporting a regime like SA is a true reflection of how global news and propaganda works. And exposes the silliness of a 'value' based world that exists simply to provide cover for geo-political objectives to cause devastation and death on the ground. These are crimes against humanity. And mindbogglingly this support has continued even while the Saudis finance the spread of a hateful wahhabist ideology and we spend billions to build surveillance states at home to protect against it. Yet it is Libya, Iraq and now Syria and Iran - all generations ahead on human rights compared to the Saudis - that are targeted while the Saudi's continue uninterrupted with western support. This 'purge' is happening with US and european support so you don't see the usual hysteria about 'rule of law' and 'human rights'. This is a truly messed up world.
- mangodrunk 9y agoWell said! We (those in the US) should really think about who we are, as I think it's harder to be self reflective about our own doings, but we can see how bad Saudi Arabia is. Saudi Arabia is considered an ally. Saudi Arabia is a leading state sponsor of terrorism and has been exporting an extreme ideology which is the terrorism that is wreaking havoc. How can we consider ourselves the "good guys", if Saudi Arabia (a country that is so obviously doing horrible things) is considered an ally and a country which we (the US) have been arming them with weapons?