13 ms·
Dopamine: An AI platform for designing human behavior
- dontreact 9y agoEven if the aims are benevolent, the naming and marketing copy just sound evil to me. They are trying to make it sound like they can turn your app into an addictive drug.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agothey can turn your app into an addictive drug I think that's exactly their elevator pitch.
- RAB1138 9y agoContrarian, not evil, is more of the motto. You don't get anyone to listen if you just talk about an AI SaaS platform for long-term habit formation. It comes off as wonkish. Trust me, we tried ;)
- dontreact 9y agoWell first of all thank you for your reply and actually getting involved in the thread. I have to say, I'm not convinced. Yes of course if you say that your product is similar to a what a drug dealer would offer, then people are going to get interested because of the potential for returns on their money. You're just confirming my suspicion that branding things this way was in order to help get investment. I don't see how you are being contrarian. What is the popular opinion you are rejecting? That addiction is scary/harmful/a terrible thing to inflict on others? You're in a tricky position now as I personally don't see how you can reverse course on presenting the company this way (after thinking about it for a couple of minutes :) )... but I hope you can figure it out!
- tdaltonc 9y agoI think that the thing we're contrarian on is "using software to design peoples behavior is bad," or "Dopamine (the molecule) is first and foremost about Addiction." Dopamine is about learning, and learning only matter because it changes us. The same brain mechanisms and technologies that make facebook captivating and can be used to make fitness, a good diet, and spending time with people who love you engaging too. When we're done building this tech-stack, it will be possible for people to learn themselves in to whoever they want to be. Disclaimer - I'm the CEO of Dopamine
- Grangar 9y agoSo what would ensure you keep using that tech for good? What if no clients turn up and you still need to produce value for your investors? In other words, how would you go about solving the 'just trust us' problem others in this thread have described better?
- alexasmyths 9y agoI don't know if 'Contrarian' is exactly the word - but yes - the company name 'Dopamine' is definitely a smarty-pants branding strategy to get hype. Startups are dead -> they're all rock bands now. VC's are record labels.
- Zarath 9y agoGreaaaaat... Seriously, does humanity really need this?
- RAB1138 9y agoYes. See attached. https://youtu.be/Qsi08xvhaQ4?t=4m21s https://youtu.be/Qsi08xvhaQ4?t=4m21s
- intended 9y agoOk so I actually watched most of that on crappy internet - and there are many places where there are big issues with the underlying assumptions. I think around the 14 minute mark or something you made a statement that people need to be aware of the apps they choose. Prior to that you had argued that (mostly for the first world) behavioral choices are the root of the major causes of morbidity. Your redeeming speech comes at around the 20 minute mark. Issues first: 1) you assume people have a choice - and that inherently Discounts the over size impact of bad actors and antagonists. This point alone, fundamentally changes the constants underpinning the model you tacitly must be running to support your other predictions. 2) people are terrible at making a lot of choices on average. People choosing good apps over bad is similar to hoping people make good life style choices. Unlikely, and far too path dependent. Unless you are highly informed, educated about skinner/conditioning and tech aware and cynical - you won’t succeed. 3) a lot of those behavioral problems have arisen from large firms using old school behavioral influencing to create that situation. There is no basis for hope that more behavioral tools will solve the problem. 20 minutes onwards though, and you have a much better Wicket - at least up to the point I’ve watched. Which is another thing. Very few people are going to watch a 30 minute video of you speaking, especially when we’re on a text based forum.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoI am just waiting for a lawyer for someone with Internet Addiction (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3480687/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3480687/) to sue this company over one of their supported apps. This is the kind of thing that I fear will prompt a backlash from the people and government and destroy the entire online ads regime that underpins the current Internet.
- nrjames 9y agoYou may not have noticed that their other product is the exact opposite. Maybe that gives them some legal protection? http://youjustneedspace.com/ http://youjustneedspace.com/
- ehnto 9y agoPotentially, but this is all new ground anyway. Is there even a law that would cover it in this context? It also doesn't strike me as benevolent to offer a service to fix the problems your other service caused.
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoThats despicable. They sell both the disease and a cure for double the money.
- RAB1138 9y agoBruh. Did you even look at the price on Space?
- onion2k 9y agoTo quote Andrew Lewis, "If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product." You'll know when a user of a Dopamine-backed app installs Space, and that's useful to you. Measuring people trying to give up an addiction feeds back in to understanding the causes of addiction, and in your case presumably gives you quantifiable information you can use to make Dopamine more effective. Saying you made it and give it away out of the goodness of your heart seems a little underhanded.
- the_common_man 9y ago> While Brown condemned the behavior that’s been attributed to Sacca — and expressed disappointment that Mazzeo found the same troubles at his would-be new home, Binary Capital — he said that it didn’t dissuade him from taking Lowercase’s money. Yup, people always take a high moral stand.. until there is money involved.
- Y_Y 9y agopecunia non olet
- alexasmyths 9y agoThis is what cigarette companies have been doing for years so why no tech? I'm wary that this will improve anything at all, but make things more annoying and addictive, as opposed to actually increasing productivity.
- BayesStreet 9y ago>Dopamine’s founders argue that they reserve the right to deny service to specific companies whose work seems to be off the level... Just "trust" us. There are obviously many teams working on doing this, but never so audacious. These things are definitely not a value add to society, yet very profitable, like e.g. heroin if that doesn't sound too hyperbolic.
- api 9y agoA casino is usually more profitable than a hospital too. It's probably the central problem of capitalism. Monetary systems draw no distinction between wealth creation and wealth extraction, and the second law of thermodynamics guarantees that the latter will always be much easier. When you design chips, cure diseases, or build rockets you are fighting entropy. When you addict, misinform, and con people entropy is on your side.
- Houshalter 9y agoHealthcare is a much larger percent of GDP than casinos for what it's worth. But your comment does remind me of http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/
- dredmorbius 9y agoAnd if you add the FIRE industries to that? Or the addiction-feeding elements of healthcare -- opiates and other-than-therapeutic interventions. https://www.selectusa.gov/financial-services-industry-united-states https://www.selectusa.gov/financial-services-industry-united...
- BayesStreet 9y agoThis article made me pretty sad and made me think of this too. I think what an ethical investor needs to do is not deploy capital to any industries that don't add real economic value or wealth or whatever you want to call it. Also, ethical founders should refuse capital from orgs that fund these projects. Basically starve these projects out, but that's sort of idealistic.
- 013a 9y agoThe same company sells an api to help make your applications as addicting as possible [1] and a service for users to help control their addiction to applications [2]. This organization is disgusting and is evidence enough that our industry has no sense of ethical responsibility. When massive regulation lands on Silicon Valley and we whine about the impact it has on innovation, remember companies like Dopamine Labs who truly deserved it. [1] https://usedopamine.com/ https://usedopamine.com/ [2] http://youjustneedspace.com/ http://youjustneedspace.com/
- Torn 9y ago100% agreed on the ethics note. Calling it 'dopamine' is also pretty remorseless. Interestingly, the creators of the like button and pull to refresh, and others, are pushing back against this 'attention economy': https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/05/smartphone-addiction-silicon-valley-dystopia https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/oct/05/smartphon...
- RAB1138 9y agoPaul (author on that piece) is wonderful! Not so much remorseless, we were just shooting for contrarian and attention grabbing...And here we are....knee deep in front page of HN hate mail...
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoYou are making the world a worse place.
- Grangar 9y agoCalling negative comments hate mail speaks volumes about you.
- ivm 9y agoYou are building a Zynga-like company and writing vague comments instead of direct answers here. Why do you expect positive replies?
- 9y ago
- Fricken 9y agoBefore I even got through the first paragraph I was reminded of B.F. Skinner and his book 'Beyond Freedom and Dignity', which I read in high school. So it's pretty funny that they named their AI after him. Dopamine labs may be evil, but at least they're self aware.
- RAB1138 9y agoWe love that one! Required reading. His work on why you, me, everyone on this thread, and every species that's part of the subphylum Vertebrata shaped the course of thinking from contemporary Machine Learning techniques like Q-Learning to us! Not evil, have done our reading though ;)
- leggomylibro 9y agoNo offense, but I do not believe you. I can't, on something like this. Talk is cheap.
- RAB1138 9y agoWhat on the evil part? Or that we make the whole team read Skinner? It's a thin book.
- leggomylibro 9y ago...really? Welp, there's another one on the 'never touch with a 10-foot pole' pile. Yikes, your promotional account sounds like a grinning glassy-eyed sociopath. Serious goosebumps.
- intended 9y agoA good sociopath would have been charming. I think they’re very aware of the problems and they would rather be in the good side of the issue. I think he just doesn’t know how to convert this or talk about it in a forum setting well.
- 9y ago
- Turing_Machine 9y ago"if a technology like Dopamine can actually encourage retention on apps aimed at self-improvement, that’s an inarguably good thing." No, it absolutely is not. Some of most horrifying abuses in the history of the human race have occurred under the guise of "improving" other people for their own good.
- RAB1138 9y agoThe men and women who write your software control the boundary conditions for your experiences there. They control what and how you can think, feel, and believe in that experience. When Twitter doubles the numbers of characters you can tweet, they're making a decision about the quality and size of thoughts people can express - and in turn what depth of dialogue we have there. Analogously, when someone designs a diet app, they're creating the boundary conditions of a new behavior pattern for users. Their use of Dopamine aligns well with their end user's goals: in the same way that you hold friends close because you know they rub off on you, so too should we think about our software. Having an app on your phone you chose to let close to your mind and behavior - to be a new venue of your thought and future self - is a decision about who you want to become. And if that app can use good design, a good interface, and persuasive tech to help you achieve your health or diet goals: you win. That's an alignment of what tech wants and what humans want.
- Grangar 9y agoYou can't trust people to make that decision themselves. If you keep an app close because of the skinner-esque variable reward ratio I'd argue that's not a conscious choice.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoLetting a person choose 140 or 280 characters (which originally was done for technical reasons -- 140 octets was the maximum length of a classic SMS message) is an entirely different thing from cold-bloodedly psychologically manipulating them. Entirely.
- lawnchair_larry 9y ago
- nixpulvis 9y agoFuck this shit.
- tw1010 9y agoGee, the founders can't have been happy with that title (different than on HN). What can founders do to avoid being represented in a negative light like this by the press, HN? Try to be the first to frame the conversation? Or is all press good press and it doesn't matter?
- sitkack 9y agoThey just got a ton of press, reaching the exact markets they want to hit. Their fax machine is probably ringing off the hook right now.
- sitkack 9y agoHire these guys for TV! I wish them success, all the big players are doing the same thing with more people. Keep on innovating, disrupting. Here is to your next cache hit.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RAB1138 9y agoI tried to emoji fistbump you here, but HN won't let me.
- sitkack 9y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=emoji+fistbump https://www.google.com/search?q=emoji+fistbump Thanks man! 1138 is one of my favorite documentaries about the future. There are a lot of naysayers around here, but only because of the high fidelity mirror you present them with. It is only their own self loathing.
- anigbrowl 9y agoThe originator of this project discussed in brief on HN a few months back, and I assume is reading this thread. The reactions here could tell you that this is a really Bad Idea. Working or investing in this is a terrible choice and will forfeit baseline level of consideration you could normally expect from other people.
- RAB1138 9y agoHi! Founder (Brown) here. Appreciate the traffic! Also, would love to clear up mob misconceptions about: -Why did we pick lightening-rod branding? -Why was this the most humanitarian use of a neuroscience MS/PhD? -What quality of people must we be to do this? -What is design's ethical imperative that, 100 years ago when most died of infections diseases, that this year the majority of people over 50 will die of strongly behavioral-based diseases? [1] -How come the Founders of the Push Notification teams aren't part of the cultural dialogue? -What does Tristan Harris think?! -What is our pricing model and can your startup get a discount? (YES!) [1] soundcloud.com/digital-mindfulness/89-the-science-of-addictive-technology-with-ramsay-brown/s-YQzyZ
- meeton 9y agoAssuming this is being sold to companies other than strictly self-improvement apps, how can you consider this to be an ethical thing to have created?
- RAB1138 9y agoHi! Because we don't sell to apps that would hurt people. See manifesto on usedopamine.com/team/index.html. ~100 years ago, the most frequent causes of death in the US were pathogens for which we barely had a name. Pnemonia, Flu, Cholera, Fevers. And it was only after we developed a rigorous technology of the body (modern medicine) did we lift millions of people out of suffering simultaneously. Today, if you are under 50, you're mostly like going to die of opiates. Over 50? Type-2 diabetes, stroke, cardiovascular disease, obesity and its complications, and stress-related illness. Every single one of these has strong behavioral components. Building a smartphone-first, AI-powered rigorous technology of the human mind gives us all an above-the-table, democratized chance at designing scalable technologies that stop this. It spreads better across national, sex, gender, and SES lines than most other behavior-change oriented solutions. And as we enter an age of an excess of cheap energy, food, and data, we NEED a rigorous way to help us better align modern aspirations with an ancient brainstem.
- Grangar 9y ago
- waterflame 9y agoI guess it's a win-win situation both ways: - it can make people more addicted to apps to the point where we all fall off cliffs or get run by an app addict while crossing the road using our phones. - or it can push people to the limit where they get so much addicted to their apps that they actually call for interventions, completely abandon their phone, or seek help; introducing youjustneedspace.com </sarcasm>
- RAB1138 9y agoThanks! We think so too! Also, you have a close sarcasm tag with no open sarcasm tag. Dude that's bad form.
- waterflame 9y ago'Also, you have a close sarcasm tag with no open sarcasm tag' -- sarcasm does not start by priming people of what to come. Especially those who would take you words seriously and start to relate to your comment.
- tempodox 9y agoRuthless business models like this seem inevitable in a society that values making money far above anything else.
- ProAm 9y agoSuch a terrible name for a company.
- headcanon 9y agoIs this an accurate framing of your statement then? If we can think of the addictive nature of apps as "brain hacking", you aim to be white hats? Using the same techniques to protect through understanding, instead of attack for personal gain? You say you only work with certain clients based on their ethics. Can you name some examples of an application for this that has the potential to be profitable? I, and it seems many others here, have a hard time understanding how this science can be used both ethically and profitably.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yters 9y agoIt's what TV advertising is all about. Why aren't we complaining about that?
- dredmorbius 9y agoExamine your premises. We are. And have been for a while now. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_arguments_for_the_elimination_of_television https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_arguments_for_the_elimi...
- yters 9y agoFlipping out about a company that claims to modify behavior seems a little odd when they most likely consume hours upon hours of behavior modifying TV ads every single week. If behavior modification is the real concern, the majority of the angst should be directed at TV ads.
- golergka 9y agoSo many accusations about 'evil' here, without any significant evidence. As I see it, this middle-ware is a tool that you can choose to use for evil or good - the tool doesn't get a moral value because of it's use. There is, of course, an argument that any manipulation of human behaviour is inherently evil, but it's a very weak one - if you manipulate a person to eat well, exercise, donate to charity, call their parents and vote for a [insert a political cause that you believe to be inherently moral], is it still an evil thing to do?
- Grangar 9y agoManipulating people into donating to certain charities (churches?) could certainly be an evil thing in my book. And ESPECIALLY VOTING FOR A POLITICAL CAUSE. That is not okay. Fact is that morals are relative and software companies shouldn't be the arbiters of that.
- willytobler 9y agoThis company should be call heroin. And they all should go to jail 30 years for dealing with addictive substances.
- Stenzel 9y agoSo some positive feedback gets an app more attention - I get that, apps than infantilize their users are getting popular. But does it really have to be presented at precise intervals, calculated by a clever algorithm made by neuro-scientist? I doubt the impact will differ when triggered at slightly sanitized random intervals instead.
- neelkadia 9y agoI guess now I need to take break from Hackernews!
- intended 9y agoafter this discussion I realized that there is no more safety, and plan to dump my smart phone for a nokia.
- reilly3000 9y agoThere was a great Dilbert comic that said ~ ‘If marketing we’re only slightly more effective it would be illegal.’ I am aware of 1960’s era laws against subliminal advertising. Are there any enforcible laws that limit how people are influenced with media and technology? More questions: If there is a technical definition of illegal influence, what would be the test of legality work? Would would enforce it? Who would be in violation of those laws today? Are any of the archaic laws about advertising/mind control that could be applied to today’s tech/media/security firms? Finally, in a hypothetical scenario where a state actor was able to influence the mentally fragile into turning into mass shooters, how would nations and individuals start to protect themselves against such attacks?
- gpestana 9y agoAlright, so that guys has the guts to say “It’s our job to make sure that everyone gets treated as a human, not as an object.”.
- jamesrom 9y agoEveryone is over hyping this. It's a silly company that drives engagement by inserting short gifs after user actions. It has an edgy sounding name and just enough marketing buzz to scare you. This company is not around in 5 years. Good UX > whatever they are selling.
- VesnaOgneva 9y agowill see. People now are really crazy about phones
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe irony of the VC firm backing this venture imploding due to the dopamine-seeking, short-term thinking, failure to contemplate consequences behaviour of its principals is ironically ironic.
- tnzn 9y agoAnd then a certain Nobel Prize believes "nudges" will be used for our own good. Ha-ha.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- legacynl 9y agoIf everyone in the US has on average 5 apps on their phone which use your service, and it makes people on average engaged for one extra minute... What would the cost be of all the lost productivity? Does the extra engagement lead to more revenue? How do the 2 compare? Also, if this is designed to release dopamine or any other neurotransmitters, is there a risk that this will ever be classified as a drug? Or at least be treated legally like a drug?
- freeflight 9y ago> Also, if this is designed to release dopamine or any other neurotransmitters, is there a risk that this will ever be classified as a drug? Or at least be treated legally like a drug? This whole topic is gonna be huge soon, it's in the same vein as increased use of gambling style "loot boxes" in video games designed to be skinner-boxes.
- tdaltonc 9y ago>What would the cost be of all the lost productivity? What if it was a productivity app that you were spending more time in or interacting with more efficiently. Or what if it was a fitness app that got you to do extra stretches throughout the day? Is that just economic dead weight? Disclaimer - I'm the CEO of Dopamine.
- kolbe 9y agoEven though their product borders on pure evil, I have a certain admiration for how they aren't even trying to hide it.
- freeflight 9y agoThis feels like such a pandora's box. On one hand, it's important we get a better understanding of what makes us tick, on the other hand, I fear what such understanding might enable us to do to each other.
- tdaltonc 9y agoDisclosure - CEO of Dopamine That's the exact same way I feel. There is definitely a end game here where everyone has more autonomy and dignity, and that's the one we're fighting for.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- freeflight 9y agoHow does that endgame look? And how do you intend to get there by further commercializing, thus monopolizing, such knowledge? It's not like you are doing anything new here, the only new thing here is your approach of being dead honest about what you are doing, kudos to that. But besides that I don't see how any of what you are doing there results in an endgame of "more autonomy and dignity for everybody", it rather seems to be reinforcing the current trend where such knowledge and practices are sold to anybody who can afford it, leaving those who can't out in the rain.
- stillsut 9y agoDid you do something nice for a coworker today? When's the last time you said more than 'hello' to a neighbor? The only substitute for Social "Media" is a Social Culture. The reason most mature adults are checking their phones all the time is nobody interacts to any significance anymore in the public sphere. When we're in public we are: A. trying to get somewhere else, and frustrated at being impeded by other people, B. Trying to buy something to consume or C. trying to sell something. The best way to fight the screens and the apps is to provide a better alternative, IRL.