18 ms·
Conservatives may generally view this as "good" regardless of the impact because (according to arguments I've heard) "the less globalization, the better." In m
by komali2 9y ago
Conservatives may generally view this as "good" regardless of the impact because (according to arguments I've heard) "the less globalization, the better."
In my mind, however, it boils down to two pretty simple points:
Given that (1) the US is lagging far behind every developed nation in education, and higher education in the US is prohibitively expensive compared to other developed nations, (2) the only way for the US to remain on the R&D playing field is to attract already educated/trained people from other nations with the lure of misc benefits of living in the US (culture, safety, stability, philly cheese steaks). Take away our ability to import talent and there goes the last leg of American dominance in technology.
No more American students that can compete with Chinese, Taiwanese, Japanese, or German ones, leading to less innovation in a generation. No more immigrant students making their money and starting their businesses here (or working for American R&D departments) because they can't get a visa - and possibly even worse, well-trained highly educated Americans leaving because of the obvious end-game (reduced GDP causing all sorts of ripple effects in local economies, safety, etc).
I just don't understand why we wouldn't want to make it as easy as possible to steal talent that another country invested in. We take a 23yo Chinese engineering graduate as he's going to begin peak productivity - the USA didn't have to invest in his k-12, scholarship his university, clean the water he drank for 24 years, etc. Instantaneous social profit. He joins Chevron and is turning a profit for them within the year, pumping out research and getting taxed on his 100k/year salary, spending his money in-country and oh well, maybe he sends a bit (already taxed) home.
Am I being reductive? Seems to be a very poor investment to make it harder for the highly educated to come into this country, without at the very least making a massive push for higher education across the board for our own citizens (which we are not seeing).
EDIT: To clarify my points: There are 2 ways for a country to be technologically advanced - train their own citizens, or steal other trained citizens. Have neither of those and obviously, you will fall behind.
- majormajor 9y agoThe US as a whole (including non-governmental culture, employer preferences, etc) is still making a massive push for higher education, which is a big part of what's caused the arms race of ever-nicer dorms etc. The thing to remember about US education is that it's highly different between the haves and have-nots. That's a problem in itself, but it's a giant oversimplification to jump to "US educations are generally poor." (One of the other high school and college cost-drivers/arms-race-drivers is competing to attract foreign students.)
- komali2 9y agoWell that's just it - using the word "generally," the US does poorly. Gap or no, if a huge swath of your population can't compete, that reflects poorly on your country. There's a gap in China as well but it's made up for by a massive population. Lord forbid they close their gap, that'll be the end of any other country's ability to compete as China and India just throw five hundred million engineers each at their technology sector.
- majormajor 9y agoMaybe I'm coming from an overly lucky position, but if so it's not the one you normally see called out for it: midsize town away from the coasts, public school education, middling state school university. The top 50% of the class has done perfectly competitively the last 15-20 years, even as skilled immigration has been high. Maybe we'd make even more otherwise, who knows. The bottom 50% has gotten fucked by loss of jobs/industries/career paths/debt, but H1Bs aren't helping with that. So if your contention is "we need to figure out how to better invest in the whole population" I agree, but I don't see the other half of the equation being an overly large limiting point. If anything, if we're in the lead industry-wise, does importing young talent, teaching them these things, and making it easier for that experience to be taken elsewhere really help long-run? Almost sounds more like a case for paranoid isolationism immigration-wise. We're never gonna have a billion people in the US in my lifetime, but I don't think that's necessary for there to be enough US self-driven industry to have a nice, happy, productive life.
- ams6110 9y agoAlso, working at a major state university in the US, I don't see that the international students are really very good, for the most part. They certainly are predominant (in a numbers sense) in fields like computer science, but they aren't very good overall. Perhaps due to being barely able to communicate in English.
- maxerickson 9y agoViews on immigration (and globalization) don't really align with the left-right political axis in the US. Zero sum thinking and all that.
- angersock 9y ago>clean the water he drank for 24 years, I mean, arguably neither did the Chinese, depending on where you are and how much they've let pollution occur in that area. I think you are grossly overestimating both the value of these immigrants (it isn't hard to see how much garbage science gets published abroad and how useless a good chunk of international students are) and the entire mechanism for technological improvement and innovation (most of which is market, not PhD, driven). You also don't cite any sources for your claims; this information would be helpful to anybody seeking to agree or argue with you.
- cyphar 9y ago> it isn't hard to see how much garbage science and how useless a good chunk of international students are That statement is true of any group of students, international or local. On the other hand, there are good international students (and there are good local students). Is there any reason why you think the ratio isn't the same (in fact, you'd think that the ratio of good international students would be higher because they have to go through far more rigorous testing than the average local student). And while you might argue they're mostly useless, usually international students make up a large amount of the funding for universities since their fees are usually 5x or sometimes even 10x "local" student fees[1]. So if you like having well-funded universities throwing out international students is a good way to stop that from working. [1]: My data is from Australia (since that's where I am). In 2017, ~1.3 million students enrolled in higher education -- and ~350k were international students. Most universities have a multiplier of _at least_ 4x for international students taking the same courses as a local student. By simple arithmetic, international students make up more than half of the funding-through-fees of Australian universities.
- angersock 9y agoI agree that that statement is absolutely applicable to "native" students as well! And there are definitely some outstanding international students! The author I was replying though doesn't seem to differentiate though, for example, between graduate students coming here to do research and learn cutting-edge things and undergraduates who have wealthy families that export them abroad because of course that's what one does. You've also kind of nailed another issue on the head: it is more profitable, per student, for universities to bring in international students than to teach local ones. This in turn leads to an increase in pricing for everybody (though probably not as much as due to student loan availability, but that's a different thing) and weird campus behavior to accommodate valued country officials (local school of Rice University, for example, hiding Taiwanese flags during a visit by mainlanders).
- pacala 9y agoThe demand for locally trained highly trained people is stifled by the easy access to highly trained people trained by someone else. Reducing the influx of highly skilled immigrants may have the virtuous effect of increasing the demand for local high quality education, which may, in the long term, reduce the the education gap between US and China / Taiwan / Japan / Germany.
- komali2 9y agoMaybe, but I feel it would make more sense to see the writing on the wall, rather than wait for us to feel the pain.
- xraystyle 9y agoThe stated purpose of the H1-B program is to allow companies to fill vacancies with international applicants if they are unable to find US employees qualified for the roles. I've never heard any sane, rational person object to this use case. The issue most people have is that the program seems to be rampantly abused. Companies are replacing US workers with H1-B's sourced from companies like Tata and Infosys at much lower salaries than US employees would normally command. In some cases, they're just bringing in foreign workers for the time it takes to train them, then having them work remotely and paying them even less still. Disney even made their US employees train their replacements before laying them off: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff-at-disney-train-foreign-replacements.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/04/us/last-task-after-layoff... Southern California Edison was another company that did the same: https://www.computerworld.com/article/2879083/it-outsourcing/southern-california-edison-it-workers-beyond-furious-over-h-1b-replacements.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/2879083/it-outsourcing... It's this type of abuse where US companies are simply looking to fire US citizens so they can pay slave wages to foreign contractors for the same work that people are up in arms about.
- majormajor 9y agoEven established companies not in the obviously-sleazy Tata/Infosys abuse buckets play games here. "Write up job description consisting of specialty skills your H1B candidate already has, but that you don't need in your company in that role, then use them as a generic webdev" type stuff.
- ashleyn 9y agoPaleoconservatism/populism isn't concerned about the economic benefits of immigration; it's concerned about "protecting" culture so that immigrants don't have the opportunity to reshape it in any capacity. A sizeable portion of Trump's base believes that they are in danger of becoming a minority in "their own" country and will sidestep the economic benefits of immigration to retain a demographic majority. To these voters, power and influence is a zero-sum game where the many exercise absolute reign over the few (constitutional equality be damned), and sharing the pie with immigrants puts them at risk of becoming the few.
- majormajor 9y agoWhat US Democrats ignore is that practically every damn country in the world does this too, often to a higher degree than the US. So there's a pragmatic question of how to avoid putting yourself at a disadvantage by being comparatively overgenerous that you don't have to be a "paleoconservative" or Trump supporter, or even Republican, to be concerned about.
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat disadvantage are you talking about?
- majormajor 9y agoGenerally churn factors. Stuff like importing young talent opening up further exposure to that talent moving on but also atrophying your in-country educational structures and investment. Kinda the societal version of "publish or perish" - always chasing just short-term dollars, without regard to long-term planning. If you want to import people to do the good jobs, but also want to ship the cheap jobs away, what happens to everyone squeezed out?
- anigbrowl 9y agoWe can retrain and redistribute resources to them, but for some reason the people who are most concerned about short term profits are the least willing to share them with others. You might like to ruminate on teh fact that while Trump demonizes immigrants out of one side of his mouth, the resort he owns at Mar-A-Lago- was able to get 70 H1-B visas to hire hotel staff, despite the availability of some 5000 such people in Florida's state employment opportunities database and a whole lot of US citizens in Puerto Rico that are in search of economic opportunity right about now. Not that you were making a partisan point, but this is a great example of how the rhetorical divisions in American politics do not line up with the business practices.
- bischofs 9y agoTo play devils advocate, at this point in time with the highest rate of immigration in the history of the country (i think 13%) "conservatives" are looking out for the american citizens that are losing out to these high skilled (and low skilled) immigrants. Why is it that we cannot compete with foreign companies with native workers? Why should those countries be okay with losing their top talent? Shoudnt we solve the problem of native workers not having the right skills before we open the borders to everyone else? The other argument I understand is cultural. How much immigration can a society take before it is unrecognizable to the people that live there. You can't say that if you moved 100 million indians to the US ( A fairly small number of the population) it wouldn't look and feel completely different.
- powvans 9y agoThese countries may not be okay with losing their top talent. It's an interesting viewpoint on economic competition though. It absolutely is in the best interest of the US to "brain drain" other countries. Note that this isn't new. During and after WWII the US worked hard to bring scientists to the US to prevent them working for the enemy. Just one example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Paperclip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Paperclip
- and0 9y agoWe're not at the highest point (compared to 1920s) but might be by 2023. We're a very young nation of immigrants, so I find it odd that you wouldn't retroactively apply the grievances about cultural shifts to all the generations that came previously.
- ng12 9y ago> I just don't understand why we wouldn't want to make it as easy as possible to steal talent Because that's not what the H1-B is. The majority of H1-B holders are the IT body shops: Cognizant, Infosys, and Tata are the top 3 by a wide margin [1]. I agree with you in principle but I think the H1-B system is not a good implementation of those ideals. I have a hard time believing it does much more than depress the wages of American white collar workers. 1. http://fortune.com/2017/08/03/companies-h1b-visa-holders/ http://fortune.com/2017/08/03/companies-h1b-visa-holders/
- enra 9y agoSeems the numbers in the graph and article don't are not easy to match up. In the graph, the sum seems to be over 100k for those top 20 companies, while the article states that 40-80k visas were granted. I do agree that I think those outsourcing talent shop should be limited. You shouldn't have majority of your workforce on h1b. As a counter point I don't think Google, Apple, Microsoft etc are not out of line. Also many startups that are founded by immigrants (50%) and often also hire international talent (since there isn't enough local one). Also startups are not able to compete on salaries like larger companies. If the article is beloved, 63% h1bs go to other than these top companies. The OP comment still holds that I think startups and hiring international talent does contribute to the US economy and it's just not for "depressing white collar wages".
- ng12 9y agoMy point is that the system as it currently stands is depressing white collar wages. There are better systems we can adopt to hire entrepreneurially-minded folks or developers who are particularly skilled from other countries. Trump is not gutting the H1-B system (currently). All they did was start asking companies to prove that the H1-B was going to an applicant who actually meets the requirements of the visa. If companies are worried about the change that's pretty clear evidence the program is being abused.
- bduerst 9y ago>The majority of H1-B holders are the IT body shops That's not what the data says in the article you linked. It also lists companies such as Apple, Google, IBM, JP Morgan, etc. as part of the majority. Consultancies like Cognizant, Infosys, and Tata are not even close to the majority of H1B holders.
- xienze 9y ago> the only way for the US to remain on the R&D playing field Are those the people we're bringing in with H1-Bs?
- komali2 9y agoIs immigration in general. I highly recommend a tour around your local university's Chemistry department, as a stark example.
- Draco_Au 9y agoNo you are not being reductive, I appreciate your candid narrative. Bottom line, this is it for America, if we do not open the doors, sign treaties well established and reaffirm our position of leadership to our allies...the petrodollar is next, which means our chances of defaulting are 80%, and with that we will officially become a failed state. Because you let in a criminal mobster, a chauvinist, a loudmouth, a Wiseguy from queens who doesn’t know his place. Add in the hundreds of thousands of Americans who consider Trump a billionaire. I mean i’m Utterly in a state of revolsion. This behavior is abhorrent, a true affront to national security, not to mention the blatant obstruction and mishandling of justice; diluting our separation of powers, the list goes on....popcorn, you’re gonna need lots of it...and a second passport.
- babesh 9y agoBecause Trump does what benefits Trump, rather than the country as a whole. Support him and perhaps not get punished. Don't support him and definitely get punished. It is as simple as that. Capital crosses national boundaries to a great extent so if you've got capital who cares where it is deployed.
- leakybit 9y ago"the US is lagging far behind every developed nation in education" I wouldn't say that for college level education. Why is then the US the top study abroad destination in the world?
- TylerE 9y agoAs with many things in the US, the top end is truly elite, for the small minority that can be accepted/afford it. But the average is mediocre at best.
- learc83 9y ago>But the average is mediocre at best. This just isn't true at all. Average state schools that are affordable to the vast majority of students through income based student loan repayments are far better than mediocre. The US has 1/3 of the top 500 ranked colleges in the world, and nearly 1/4 of the top 5000. http://www.webometrics.info/en/node/54 http://www.webometrics.info/en/node/54 There's a reason that international students flock to even low ranked state schools in the US.
- rb2018 9y agoHollywood - best country marketing ever.
- and0 9y agoI can't research this at the moment but a couple obvious explanations: - The USA is massive compared to every first-world nation (in the West) in terms of size / population / schools. I'd be shocked if a place like Sweden were somehow the top, statistically. - I know a few people who came from India to study here because it put them on a fast track for a visa (or whatever they're using to work here after graduating). So they based it on post-grad opportunities, not the education itself.
- smsm42 9y ago> the US is lagging far behind every developed nation in education I'd like to hear the list of places doing far better than MIT, Caltech, Stanford, Berkeley, etc. in STEM fields. I mean I know there are pretty good schools around, but can you really say MIT is "lagging far behind" them? > higher education in the US is prohibitively expensive That's because when you buy "higher education" in US you buy something entirely different from what is understood by "education" in other countries. But if you want to, you have options to buy the actual education too. It won't be brand-name, but that's the cost of brand names. Here's contradiction with the first propositions - if US brands were so bad, they won't be that much in demand, would they? > No more American students that can compete with Chinese, Taiwanese, Japanese, or German ones There is a subtle fallacy here. You're comparing average US student with top-of-the crop students with the rest of the world. Not every Japanese student competes with US ones - the mediocre ones stay in Japan, the excellent ones go to compete in the US. Of course, mediocre US student would not look that excellent compared to top of the crop from 7bln pool. But that is excellent for the US that they are able to become the concentration point for the top talent. This needs to be guarded and preserved. > I just don't understand why we wouldn't want to make it as easy as possible to steal talent that another country invested in This is another side of what I mentioned before. It is good for the nation, but being mediocre student in that environment sucks. Mediocre Japanese student can remain in Japan and be relatively OK. Mediocre student somewhere in talent concentration point is screwed - he's where the top talent of the world is, and has to compete with them for any nice opportunities. It is hard. And they can't just go to Japan and take the place of those top Japanese students that left for the US (well, some small number can, but in general it's not easy). It is a real problem, and so far we don't have very good solution for it. Until we do, we'll have to deal with this kind of resentment, and telling people "well, it's good for the nation" won't help them much.
- BatFastard 9y agoTotally correct! Most education comparisons are Apples to Samsungs. While the national average might not be the highest, the top students are amazing!
- creaghpatr 9y ago
- learc83 9y ago>1 the US is lagging far behind every developed nation in education It's not as a whole. Parts of it are, Education here is local, and there are states the size of Finland that compare with Finland in education outcomes. >2 and higher education in the US is prohibitively expensive compared to other developed nations Income based repayment ensures that you will never pay more than 10% of your disposable income (income over 1.5x the federal poverty level), and loans are forgiven if you make payments for 20 years. This assumes you only take out federal loans (90% of loan disbursements are federal and are enough to pay for public universities). This is very similar to the system Australia has. Additionally, the US ranks 7th in number of adults with college degree--higher than every European country except Luxembourg. And the US has 1/3 of the top 500 ranked colleges in the world, and nearly 1/4 of the top 5000.
- pnutjam 9y agoThe "poverty line" is a joke. It's pegged to food when the largest expenses for most families are housing and medical care. I know I probably spend about the same on groceries as I spend on health insurance, without taking into account what my employer pays, deductibles, etc. I doubt many families have 10% of income to spare.
- learc83 9y agoIt's 1.5x the poverty level. That's about $37k for a family of 4. >I doubt many families have 10% of income to spare. For a family of 4, it's 10% of income over $37k, not 10% of income. If that family made the median household income of $59k, they'd be paying about $180 a month in loan repayments.
- horsecaptin 9y agoNot too long ago, "the less globalization, the better" was the liberal point of view.
- anigbrowl 9y agoBy definition, not - maybe you could pick a better term?
- damnyou 9y agoIt was definitely the progressive point of view. Trade unions in the US have historically been nativist.
- horsecaptin 9y agoWhich definition are you using?
- anigbrowl 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism
- horsecaptin 9y agoMy understanding is that in America, the Democratic party is considered to be the liberal party. Most people left-of-center vote for the liberal party. They think of unions and worker protections as liberal values. They also oppose globalization because it has the effect of reducing wages and increasing local job loss. And so, these Democratic Party supporting liberal minded left-leaning people are in a bind. The new conservative president at least on the surface seems to be doing more to protect local jobs than the last two Democratic Presidents have. In-fact, their champion in the last election sought to increase globalization.
- anigbrowl 9y ago
- jordanb 9y agoYou have a really mercantile view of things: Team Murika is gonna Win the Trade War by signing all the primo players from the other teams! An alternate way to look at this is that the economy and society of the USA is failing its own citizens by either giving them an inadequate education or not providing them opportunities to succeed. And your proposal is to simply write everyone who's already here off, declare them to be rejects, and import new people over the top of them to be worker bees for the elite. I can say that I'm not really personally concerned with how many billionaires we have in the US, or how many multinational corporations are headquartered here. I'd be fine if that all went to China, so long as the USA stayed the land of fairness and justice.
- jacquesm 9y ago> so long as the USA stayed the land of fairness and justice. That ship sailed a while ago.
- komali2 9y ago>economy and society of the USA is failing its own citizens Yes, and I have completely lost faith in the US's ability, on a federal level, to staunch that failure, as long as the Republican party continues to exist. >write off everyone who's already here I agree that I'm being pessimistic, but I feel that's what the government is aggressively trying to do (by, for example, putting a person hostile to education in charge of the agency that runs education at a federal level).
- Oxitendwe 9y ago>Yes, and I have completely lost faith in the US's ability, on a federal level, to staunch that failure, as long as the Republican party continues to exist. The democrats have had control over the house or the senate for 62 out of the past 84 years, and both of them for 52 years (in total, not contiguously). There has also been a Democratic president for 48 of those years. If you're mad at the way things are, I don't think it makes sense to be mad at the Republican party, unless it's for constantly losing. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Combined--Control_of_the_U.S._House_of_Representatives_-_Control_of_the_U.S._Senate.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/72/Combined...
- agumonkey 9y agoAre USA so far behind the nation you mentioned ?
- komali2 9y agoYes. http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/02/15/u-s-students-internationally-math-science/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/02/15/u-s-students...
- ctdonath 9y agoWe just came off an 8-year period of significant unemployment. People are understandably skittish about anything that prevents citizens from getting jobs - especially when people are being imported precisely to fill available domestic jobs. Your reductions don't address the fact that we DID invest in domestic talent, and would like to put that investment to use. Now that national unemployment has plummeted to remarkably low levels, we may again truly find ourselves needing to import workers.
- jacquesm 9y ago> We just came off an 8-year period of significant unemployment. https://www.thebalance.com/unemployment-rate-by-year-3305506 https://www.thebalance.com/unemployment-rate-by-year-3305506 Peak unemployment during that period just after the 2008 financial crisis was still just under 10%, and it has been steadily decreasing since then. It's not exactly nothing and it sucks if you are one of the unemployed but an unemployment ratio between 5 and 10% is actually not all that bad. Significant unemployment were 2009, 2010 and before that 1982. By 2013 unemployment in the US was already back down below 7%, historically speaking nothing special, somewhere between 3 and 7% is fairly normal.
- jorblumesea 9y agoThis narrative is frustrating because it's just not true. The vast majority of H1B visas are not bringing in that level of talent. The program is gamed by offshoring firms that take the lions share of the available visas. For every super smart foreign student we bring in we also bring in 3 really mediocre and talentless offshoring workers. I completely 100% agree that the US is losing its edge in many ways. And a real visa program would help. But at the moment the H1B program is bad for almost everyone involved, unless you own stock in Infosys/Tata etc. http://fortune.com/2017/08/03/companies-h1b-visa-holders/ http://fortune.com/2017/08/03/companies-h1b-visa-holders/ We need to replace it with a real immigration program that weeds out the crap and brings in the best. As it stands super smart people are getting their visas denied while offshoring firms depress wages and take American jobs while producing sub-par products.
- neeleshs 9y agoThis, I agree with. Immigration should not be stopped wholesale, but at least fixed by stopping the EB-1 games and a salary based criteria. Not foolproof , but certainly seems better than today's system
- Spooky23 9y agoThere’s a lot of alternate reality with work visas, and many, if not the majority of the positions are there because of cost, not skill. The process should be onerous enough that the body shop business that places cheap candidates with marginal skills shouldn’t be a good business, but not too onerous for the high talent individuals for whom it is intended for.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 9y agoThere is no education problem in the US. The observed differences in academic performance are the result of sociological challenges that other countries don’t have (disparities resulting from slavery and segregation of 1/8 of the population, large-scale immigration from countries that speak a different language). Skimming the cream from other countries doesn’t really ameliorate those problems.
- throwayit 9y agoI think the major issue with your line of reasoning (which I mostly agree with it) is you are assuming wealth distribution. I mean, yes it is in our economy's interests to make it easy to steal talent. However, do economic gains flow to Americans? No, not really because we don't have socialist systems in place to distribute the wealth gained from "stealing talent". So yes stealing talent is good, but it really only benefits corporate shareholders and upper class Americans. The unhappy Americans who are voting for "America First" don't see the gains from startups and tech companies; they are geographically isolated from these companies and even if they lived in California (or any other tech center) they lack the skills to be employed. So essentially in my view you have a conflict of interest. It is in the best economic interest of the country to be able to attract talent. However, the US is a democracy and unless the economic gains are spread across the entire population, this will not satisfy, "we the people" So we have really two options in response 1) implement socialist systems to spread wealth to the population or 2) go isolationist to insist that wealth only flows inward It's embedded in American culture that socialism is bad which is why #2 has been the chose solution.
- anigbrowl 9y ago"the less globalization, the better." This is definitely a thing, not only in the US but also from thinkers like Alexandr Dugin in Russia. I believe such reactionary political stances are ultimately doomed, though; we are simply not going to un-invent the internet, air travel, containerization and other things that have made the world smaller and allowed a single planetary scale logistical chain to exist, short of nuclear catastrophe or its equivalent.
- wmil 9y ago> He joins Chevron and is turning a profit for them within the year, pumping out research and getting taxed on his 100k/year salary, spending his money in-country and oh well, maybe he sends a bit (already taxed) home. But that's not the typical H1B. There are "Manager Trainees" at slaughterhouses making 35k. http://h1bdata.info/index.php?job=MANAGER+TRAINEE http://h1bdata.info/index.php?job=MANAGER+TRAINEE Developers making between 30k - 70k are quite common. Putting in an 80k or so wage floor would be a huge improvement to the current system.
- screye 9y agoI think there should be some scaling wrt. to COL (From what I know 80k takes you a long way in some states). But, apart from that I totally agree. If someone is living on sub 60k in the US, their job is certainly not one that requires an H1B.
- bbatha 9y ago> We take a 23yo Chinese engineering graduate as he's going to begin peak productivity - the USA didn't have to invest in his k-12, scholarship his university, clean the water he drank for 24 years, etc. Instantaneous social profit. That's only the half of it. The US gives out far more F-1 student visas than H-1Bs (roughly 3x). That means that US infrastructure trains the student, but then the US doesn't get to take advantage of his or her output. Its really a lose-lose for the US.
- sib 9y agoAlthough, in most cases, the university is using the international students to fund university operations and education (typically without reducing tuition price through financial aid) that brings value to the domestic students...
- grad_ml 9y agoIn the new order, aws infrastructure is same for every one! Consider OPT students getting trained in a early stage startups, do not get H1b after 2-3 years, what would he do? Quite few of them(smart, ambitious ones) will go back home and will compete on the similar products. You can think, schools educated them for quite of money but they got so more in return. I personally believe, every penny invested in CS/math education is worth it.
- stillhere 9y ago>the USA didn't have to invest in his k-12, scholarship his university, clean the water he drank for 24 years, etc. And that's a supposed to be a good thing? Good for the government maybe, but bad for the people. I'd prefer a government which invests highly in all these things and to avoid the capitalist dystopia you're advocating.
- dlwdlw 9y agoTo add something I think is overlooked, many people from China feel very unsafe in the US due to all the news about mass shootings. The previous generation of immigrants came for a better life and a sense of safety is an important part of that. China: + Cultural familiarity, closeness to family. + High pay for engineering. - Pollution - Lack of work/life balance culture. US: - Lack of safety. - Culturally lost. + Higher pay + Better natural environment. + Better future for kids. Schools & stuff. Censorship is a minor concern for the most part except for political activists. It's arguable that that the US is becoming more draconian in this regard, especially due to police being able to do whatever they want once they decide you're guilty of something.
- kamaal 9y ago>>Take away our ability to import talent and there goes the last leg of American dominance in technology. This is known almost forever now. Even the hard core immigrant hating racists know that their social security checks are coming in because of some one generated more than proportionate share of economic value, and by that definition taxes. And that someone is mostly likely a non-white immigrant. They just don't like to be reminded of this fact everyday that their bread comes from the very source they hate.
- Guest1234567 9y agowe are talking about low quality cheap replacements to native workers, undermining the economy and depressing wages and causing "all sort of rippling effects" on culture\safety. Seriously doubt the USA is making the acquisition of world level talent any harder.