5 ms·
It's not just boats that have safety-critical UI design problems. The avionics in airplanes are becoming so complicated that managing the avionics is almost mo
by lisper 9y ago
It's not just boats that have safety-critical UI design problems. The avionics in airplanes are becoming so complicated that managing the avionics is almost more difficult than flying the plane.
I'm a private pilot who has been flying a Cirrus SR22 for twelve years. In that time it has gone through two major glass cockpit avionics revisions. In the first revision, called the Avidyne, the autopilot was either on or off. In the current revision, called the G-1000, the autopilot can operate in two modes: AP mode, where the autopilot is actually flying the plane, and FD or flight-director mode, where the autopilot does all of the calculations to figure out where the plane should be flying and displays a target on the primary flight display, but the actual control of the plane is still in the hands of the pilot.
If the plane is stable, it is very easy to get fooled into thinking the autopilot is flying the plane when in fact it is not. There are only two visual indicators that tell you if the autopilot is actually flying the plane: a small green LED on the autopilot console, which is down near your right knee, and another small annunciator on the primary flight display. It looks like this:
http://is3.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple71/v4/9a/36/ad/9a36ad6e-3ab6-a48c-3f67-d5318ba1f66b/source/552x414bb.jpg http://is3.mzstatic.com/image/thumb/Purple71/v4/9a/36/ad/9a3...
The autopilot indicator is indicating AP mode in that image. See if you can spot it.
It has happened to me more than once that I thought I had the autopilot engaged when in fact I had only turned on the flight director. I predict that one of these days someone will die because they made this mistake in instrument conditions.
- rangibaby 9y agoIs there a purpose to the display being so colorful? If AP were the only green thing and the others were monochrome it would stand out more.
- lisper 9y agoSome of the colors do have a rationale. The blue and brown background are actually the attitude indicator display. Blue is sky. Brown is ground. There is now an option available that renders the terrain you're over so you can "see" outside via the PFD even in clouds, e.g.: http://glasspilot.com/2008/08/is-synthetic-vision-a-game-changer/ http://glasspilot.com/2008/08/is-synthetic-vision-a-game-cha... But the other colors I think are just "because they can." There are a lot of IMHO stupid aspects of the G1000 UI design. (To be fair, the G1000 has to many features that designing a good UI for it is a real challenge.)
- btgeekboy 9y agoMost of the colors on that display have a rationale. For example, on the speed tape on the left, the white, green, and yellow colors all map to colors of a standard airspeed indicator. That the course (CRS) is green instantly tells me I'm navigating by a ground-based VOR, not GPS (which would be magenta). Same with the green diamond on the right by the altitude indicator. The waypoints at the top are all GPS-calculated, therefore also magenta. At the top, the green radio frequency is the one you'll transmit on. The blue airport icons in the Nearest page (bottom left) indicate towered airports (matching those found on standard aeronautical charts). (In case it's not obvious, I've got a few hundred hours behind the G1000. AMA.)
- FabHK 9y agoDo you have any opinion on the G1000 (and subsequent Garmin flight decks) vs competitors, such as Avidyne Entegra? My feeling has always been that the Garmin UI was somewhat clunky and suboptimal, possibly because they tried to keep it similar to the UI of previous smaller devices (such as the GNS 430); a bit like if the iPhone hadn't come along and we'd still scroll by putting our finger on a little arrow in a scroll bar on mobile devices. My impression was that other manufacturers had a better UI, but somehow didn't make it in the marketplace.
- btgeekboy 9y agoI'm not familiar with the Entegra. I've played with stuff by Dynon and Advanced Flight Systems though. If you think the G1000 is clunky, try the Advanced system. I'm really not a fan. Perhaps it's for that exact reason (that Garmin products all work somewhat similarly), but I've been up in a friend's RV-10 with the Advanced system in it, and I find it to be much more clunky. The GTN650 keeps a bit of the GNS430 feel... and those are, in my opinion, the best parts. I hate scrolling through the alphabet by dragging my finger across the screen. I have a similar disdain for trying to select stuff in-flight on my iPad in ForeFlight.
- abaillargeon 9y agoI think there's some truth to your GNS 530 theory... Pilots are not typically that interested in stylish/modern UIs, and they're not thrilled when a familiar UI changes. There are so many features now that it's a challenge to find room on the PFD. I'm curious, which other UIs do you prefer? What do you think of the G1000 NXi?
- FabHK 9y agoThe colours have significance. There's a famous talk by a AA training captain, Capt. Warren VanderBurgh, about the dangers of over reliance on automation, and it's called "Children of the Magenta" (magenta being the colour with which the computer generated navigation guidance is displayed). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pN41LvuSz10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pN41LvuSz10 https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/children-of-the-magenta-automation-paradox-pt-1/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/children-of-the-magen...
- FabHK 9y agoWhile the "AP" indicator is very important, such that overlooking it, or rather missing its absence, could lead to loss of control and death, the same holds for many other of the items displayed.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoThat's actually a great point: "missing an absence" is far harder than "noting a presence of opposite indicator".
- lisper 9y ago> the same holds for many other of the items displayed Like what? I really can't think of anything that has the same ratio of danger to visual subtlety.
- FabHK 9y agoI didn't (and wouldn't necessarily) claim the same ratio. But clearly airspeed is critically important, attitude is, a wrong heading can kill you (eg Varig 254 [0]), a transponder that's off can kill you (eg the Embraer/GOL accident [1]), wrong altitude can clearly kill you, etc. But you've got a point, it's a pretty small indicator for a pretty crucial function. However, making everything else monochrome doesn't strike me as a realistic or preferable alternative. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varig_Flight_254 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varig_Flight_254 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gol_Transportes_Aéreos_Flight_1907 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gol_Transportes_Aéreos_Flight_...
- lisper 9y ago> airspeed is critically important, attitude is, a wrong heading can kill you Losing track of airspeed/attitude/heading is a whole different category of error than losing track of which mode the autopilot is in. > a transponder that's off can kill you Not without a whole pile of other errors stacked on top of that one.
- pmikesell 9y agonice! Also an SR22 pilot (though I just sold mine a few months ago). Here are some other G1000 confusions I remember: - Flying down the ILS expecting to click the "go around" button on the throttle and see the missed approach cycle .... only to find out that the autopilot didn't know I started the approach because I had the wrong leg selected as "active" when I across the IAF (and I've been tracking the green ILS instead of the PINK gps for the approach) - Given "vectors to final" from ATC, selecting "vectors to final" on the MFD, and then have ATC issue a speed restriction up to some waypoint ... which has now just disappeared because "vectors to final" doesn't display any of the waypoints (I think the logic is that you shouldn't need them, except in this case when you do) - Doing an approach that has a IAF and IF with a holding pattern. Am I starting the approach from the IAF (in which case I do the hold), or from the IF (in which case I proceed directly to the FAF)? Once I've coordinated that with ATC .... I forgot to tell the autopilot who helpfully started planning for the holding pattern. Honestly I think the solution here is more automation not less. These systems got so bad because pilots correct for them all the time.
- scott_karana 9y agoAir France 477 was caused by UI stupidity, too. Linked controls (nobody realized the junior copilot was making opposing inputs, which were then averaged with the pilot's) plus poor autopilot UI that they were accustomed to ignoring, made it stall and crash after a single wind speed sensor iced up. If nobody had touched the controls, autopilot would have flown safely through the storm. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_France_Flight_447
- thomasz 9y agoThat's a very simplistic interpretation. The article is really worth a read. The whole accident is a prime example for a very minor problem (loosing air speed indicators) spinning completely out of control, with the crew being making every possible mistake all the way down, all three people in the cockpit completely ignoring 47 stall warnings.
- scott_karana 9y agoAgreed, I was just paraphrasing from old memory. Only intended to get people interested in further reading. :)
- lisper 9y agoLosing airspeed indicators can be a minor problem, but not in a jet at altitude at night, which was the case for AF477. You can fly a small plane without an ASI, particular in visual conditions, because the margin for error is large and you have other visual and auditory cues to tell you whether you're in the ballpark. But Jets at altitude fly in a very narrow envelope between stalling and over-stressing the airframe (look up "coffin corner"), and in instrument conditions you have no way to tell whether you're in the zone or not. Furthermore, without reliable airpseed, the autopilot stops working properly. AF477 was not just a case of the crew being stupid or bad UI. It really was a very serious situation aerodynamically.
- IshKebab 9y agoWow that UI is truly terrible. It's like they said "we need all this information on the screen" and then just dumped it anywhere. Who knew Microsoft Flight Simulator 2.0 was so accurate?
- lisper 9y agoMSFS is amazing. So is X-plane. The latter has aerodynamic models accurate enough to simulate flight on other planets! https://what-if.xkcd.com/30/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/30/
- wmeredith 9y ago"managing the avionics is almost more difficult than flying the plane" The same goes for modern cars. The electronics is a nightmare. HVAC controls locked away behind touch screens menus. It's awful.
- lisper 9y agoOh, so much this! The whole UI world seems to have jumped the shark about 2-3 years ago. I dread the day when my current car (a 2012 model) dies because everything on the market today sucks UI beans. (Actually, the same goes for phones and laptops too. I have an iPhone 4S running a jailbroken iOS 7 and a late 2013 Macbook Pro Retina running Mavericks, both of which I am going to hang on to until either they or I die.)