6 ms·
”Some lines are at only 500 cars a week.” That sounds better than what Tesla claims. http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/5492937854x0x962149/00F
by Someone 9y ago
”Some lines are at only 500 cars a week.”
That sounds better than what Tesla claims. http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/5492937854x0x962149/00F6EB90-2695-44E6-8C03-7EC4E06DF840/TSLA_Update_Letter_2017-3Q.pdf http://files.shareholder.com/downloads/ABEA-4CW8X0/549293785... (emphasis added):
”Other lines, such as battery pack assembly, body shop welding and final vehicle assembly, have demonstrated burst builds of about 500 units per week and are ramping up quickly.”
If you can do burst runs of 15 km/hour, that doesn’t mean you can run a three hour marathon.
”The company burned $1.4 billion and has $3.5 billion in cash. Raising money shouldn't be necessary.”
To get that $1.4 billion in revenue, they will need to sell 40k Tesla 3s at $35k each, or 3,000 a week. To get it in margin, even assuming the average model 3 will sell for $50k, they will have to sell 12,000 a week or so (at 20% margin)
=> If things go as planned, I guess they will need about half their money in half a year or so before turning a profit. That doesn’t leave very much in case things go worse than planned (for example, they plan for 25% margin on model 3, but currently don’t have that on their more expensive models, and they plan to sell more of their expensive models, but can decrease production, so, presumably, they have quite a few of them in inventory)
Tesla may have a fantastic future ahead of it, but it also may fail spectacularly fairly soon, or just have a decent future ahead of it that doesn’t warrant its current share price.
- asdfasdfasd333 9y ago"Tesla may have a fantastic future ahead of it, but it also may fail spectacularly fairly soon, or just have a decent future ahead of it that doesn’t warrant its current share price." lol. "it might go up, might go down, or might stay the same!"
- ant6n 9y agoHey at least you know it's not certain to be only one or two of those options.
- kristianp 9y ago"To get that $1.4 billion in revenue, they will need to sell 40k Tesla 3s at $35k each, or 3,000 a week. To get it in margin, even assuming the average model 3 will sell for $50k, they will have to sell 12,000 a week or so (at 20% margin)" It seems like you're assuming that the cash burn will stay at 1.4billion. Expenditure should go down once the production line tooling is complete.
- Aron 9y ago"Capital expenditures were $1.1 billion in Q3. The majority of capital expenditures were attributable to Model 3 and Gigafactory 1 production capacity increases. "
- inventtheday 9y agoI don't think any of the upfront investment or capital expenditure is included in the 1.4 billion calculation. Thats purely operating loss.
- kgwgk 9y agoThe $1.4bn is $300mn cash flows used in operating activities + $1.1bn capex.
- wott 9y agoSo, can we assume that if the production has to be multiplied by 10, the cash flow used for operating activities should also be multiplied by almost 10, giving expenses of way more than $1.4bn?
- inventtheday 9y agoNo, because a huge cost for them right now is underutilization of assets (factory, tooling, some workers, etc.). Their utilization rate will improve, and so operating costs should not scale linearly with revenue growth. "Should" being the key word.
- paulpauper 9y agomuch of those expenses are one-time cap ex
- awakeasleep 9y agoTesla originally planned to run two production lines but had to drop to a single one, and they're doing it in an expensive and unusual manner, and a second won't fit in their fremont plant, and they still plan to build out the second line in the same unusual 'cold' manner. This leads me to expect it's reasonable their burn will continue at the same rate. Furthermore, it's estimated they won't reach 3k a week till the end of 2018. https://dailykanban.com/2017/10/source-tesla-responsible-model-3-production-hell https://dailykanban.com/2017/10/source-tesla-responsible-mod...
- mcbrit 9y ago"If you can do burst runs of 15 km/hour, that doesn’t mean you can run a three hour marathon." Once you're in 3 hour marathon territory, what you can do for 1 mile is a lot more relevant to what you can do for 26.2 miles than you might think. One of the tent poles of effective marathon/half marathon training is to make your race pace into a drumbeat. You want to feel your race pace in your bones. Very effective workouts look like: take your marathon race pace, and run 5 minutes easy/5 minutes hard (~race pace) for 60, or 10 easy/10 hard for 80. Tesla is talking about burst builds that last for a week. That sounds like very effective training that will prepare them for race day.
- cjhopman 9y ago"Tesla is talking about burst builds that last for a week". Was that in the call? Their statement says "Several manufacturing lines [...] have demonstrated a manufacturing ability in excess of 1,000 units per week during burst builds of short duration. Other lines, [...] have demonstrated burst builds of about 500 units per week...". AFAIK, "short duration" != "a week".
- Someone 9y ago”In Q3, we delivered […] 222 Model 3 vehicles” Assuming they didn’t produce a lot more than they delivered, if they had even one week in which they produced 500 Model 3s, they also must have had weeks in which they destroyed them.
- coolspot 9y agoProbably has something to do with pair particle production [1]: 500 virtual Model 3 is produced along with 500 anti-Model 3 then they are immediately annihilated. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pair_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pair_production
- Animats 9y agoMost auto production lines produce nearly 500 cars per shift. Normal cycle times in an auto plant are about one minute. Here's a Mercedes production line.[1] That's a vehicle on a par with Tesla's products. Something is terribly wrong in Fremont. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbfTlwm248k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbfTlwm248k
- Fizzer 9y agoMost auto production lines don't need EV-size batteries. The post above specifically says batteries are the bottleneck, so it isn't really evidence that something is "terribly wrong"
- coldtea 9y agoSince batteries are the whole selling point of a Tesla, I'd say it remains evidence that something is "terribly wrong".
- api 9y agoIt's almost like Mercedes has been doing this for a long time.
- coldtea 9y agoThat's a moot point though. If you want to compete in a market, you got to play at the speed/quality/prices of the market -- there is no slack given for being new.
- Retric 9y agoTesla's profit margins are fine, this is all a question of ramping up to cover demand. Which tends to be much simpler when you are already a huge company. Their real risk is if the Model 3's reliability is bad or they need a recall thus reducing their profits significantly.
- 9y ago