8 ms·
Amazon gains wholesale pharmacy licenses in multiple states
- refurb 9y agoThis is going to be interesting. Drug wholesaling is a tough business with razor thin margins. Wholesalers don't make much off of branded drugs because the big drug companies have most of the negotiating power. It's not unusual for their cut to be in the tens of basis points. They make the most money off of generic drugs and often use arbitrage as a revenue source when price increases happen. Price increases for generic drugs have been weak lately and it's hurting them.[1] [1]http://www.drugchannels.net/2017/09/drug-wholesalers-struggle-slower.html http://www.drugchannels.net/2017/09/drug-wholesalers-struggl...
- mrep 9y ago> razor thin margins That's everything amazon does besides AWS
- billmalarky 9y agoYeah razor thin margins is barrier to entry that amazon sees as an opportunity not a threat.
- oh_sigh 9y agoNot exactly - Amazon has traditionally entered spaces with...not exactly razor thing margins, but margins with some wiggle room. Even their grocery play was on 'higher end' groceries and not a razor thin market like Acme/Shop Rite/Kroegers.
- billmalarky 9y agoThey then proceed to wrench out that wiggle room to drive out the established players and create an impossible barrier to entry.
- LandoCalrissian 9y agoYou realize they do that on purpose right?
- rgbrenner 9y agoThere's definitely savings that amazon could deliver.. take the (slim) wholesale profits + add the pharmacy profits. They did something similar with books.. they cut out the wholesalers like ingram, and negotiated directly with the publishers.. allowing Amazon's retail price to be equal or less than Ingrams price that small book retailers pay... meaning even at 0% markup, amazon undercuts the small book retailers. (this was even before ebooks) They could do the same here.. giving up the retail pharmacy profits.. undercutting every other pharmacy Plus, at pharmacies efficiency could definitely be improved.. at the very least by reducing the number of $120k/yr pharmacists that are needed.
- pcurve 9y agoThe 3 big wholesalers (Amerisource, McKesson, Cardinal) also own/operate PSAOs that provide various value add services to independent pharmacies. I would say PBMs are far more creative with arbitraging and financial engineering, because they deal directly with plan payers, pharmacists, distributors, pharma, DME mfr, and patients. They offer price guarantee/inflation protection, rebates to payers; they have very granular reimbursement agreement with pharmacies along with performance guarantees or penalties depending on how much generics they dispense, there is copay assistance program with pharma and patients. PBM is a complex business, but there's no huge pool of money sloshing around. Money is in pharma and overall healthcare systems. This is a long game for Amazon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- darawk 9y agoAmazon doesn't need to make money on it, though. They just want to dominate every aspect of everyone's retail existence. I'm sure they're perfectly happy to make zero profit for a long while and figure it out later, when they're the only ones left in business.
- wonder_bread 9y agoIt’s amazing to watch all this happen on the consumer end but how many more industries can they really do this to? Is Bezos not essentially setting up his successor for failure by turning Amazon into a conglomerate with razor margins in so many areas?
- Waterluvian 9y agoThis is the thing that I don't understand about the big companies like Google, Apple, Amazon. What's the endgame? Do you just keep going until you accidentally implode? It's not like there is a finish line they can cross to "win the game". It just goes on forever until something implodes.
- bm1362 9y agoIt literally just (1) keeps printing money for investors and (2) keep some people employed. Ambitious people will take the mantle every 15-20 years and do more of 1 and 2 until they make a mistake. The goal of a successful company is basically serving those two sets of people, Google may enter the retail market or real estate, or McDonalds will take over Cloud Computing -- they're all just trying to get a consistent return.
- kgwgk 9y ago> keeps printing money for investors Amazon doesn't give money to investors. Late investors give money to early investors. (Edit: Amazon has bought back some shares in the past, but that's far from even offsetting all the shares given away to employees...)
- the_watcher 9y ago> a tough business with razor thin margins. If an industry can be described in these terms, it's likely that Amazon is a potential entrant.
- Shivetya 9y agohey, if they could deliver as an add on item I would be happy. still with the the number of grocery and similar around me offering many common medicines for nothing I have done surprisingly well. if it can be delivered, managed without quick degradation of quality, then it probably can be fit into Amazon's distribution system
- nameisu 9y agothey will sell weed also
- dmead 9y agosounds bad for the opioid problem
- CommentCard 9y agoThat's a doctor issue, not a pharmacy issue. Although they're probably going to need some warehouses with higher clearance levels / restricted access to do this. I'm all for Amazon filling prescriptions, healthcare is hugely inefficient and any bargaining power Amazon can wrestle away from pharmaceutical companies probably won't negatively impact the consumer.
- rs999gti 9y ago> I'm all for Amazon filling prescriptions, healthcare is hugely inefficient and any bargaining power Amazon can wrestle away from pharmaceutical companies probably won't negatively impact the consumer. I doubt RX prices will decrease if Amazon enters the market. Wal-Mart, Costco, and Express Scripts buy, warehouse, and dispense millions of drugs to patient members and drugs prices have barely moved.
- esaym 9y agoI don't think they'd be selling controlled substances but who knows...
- rs999gti 9y agoState laws for initial and subsequent RX for opioids and other schedule 2 drugs are very strict - https://www.njafp.org/content/new-prescribing-law-treatment-acute-and-chronic-pain https://www.njafp.org/content/new-prescribing-law-treatment-... I doubt Amazon will want to deal with the laws surrounding their dispensing. According to that NJ law you have to be a documented cancer patient or worse to get any leeway around how drugs are dispensed or prescribed to you.
- nasredin 9y agoFinally my dream of getting my cough legally prescribed meds cough dropped by a drone straight into my hands or mouth may come true!
- excalibur 9y agoLooks like thousands of Afghan children beat you to the punch there.
- frankwiles 9y agoThey're coming for you too CVS and Walgreens.
- shadowtree 9y agoCVS just announced a potential 60bn bid for Aetna. Don’t underestimate them.
- jonknee 9y agoThat’s why CVS is trying to buy Aetna. They’re going to be everything from your insurer, to your walk in clinic to your pharmacy. Maybe they’ll buy a hospital chain and go full stack.
- pcurve 9y agoCVS Health has PBM arm that serves other health plans, so it would be interesting to see how their health plan customers react. Health plan + PBM combo is nothing new, but health plan owning retail pharmacy chain would be interesting. I don't think they will be buying hospital chain any time soon. Many are not for profit, and they are too fragmented to be integrated.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIt's like the systemd of brick and mortar retail.
- jakelarkin 9y agoso Kaiser Permanente, basically
- curun1r 9y agoKaiser still has the "everything in the same building" advantage. There are some down sides to Kaiser, but seeing my doctor, getting immunizations, having blood drawn for labs, having prescriptions filled and being out the door 45 minutes after I arrived isn't one of them. It's damn convenient.
- arkitaip 9y agoBeing able to order their medication and have it delivered the same day is going to be huge for lots of people. Sure, Amazon won't make much money but add everything else they sell and you have yet another reason why you can stay in the Amazon eco system for all your shopping needs.
- teddyh 9y agoJust think of all the interesting data they will aggregate!
- oh_sigh 9y agoHIPAA would like to have a word with you.
- bm1362 9y ago> "It'd be cool if you kept that data encrypted at rest and kept track of every time it's accessed. Oh, you guys have a physical form everyone fills out when they access files? Perfect." - HIPAA in practice
- refurb 9y agoWholesalers don't have patient data. They sell to pharmacies. Still VERY valuable data, but HIPPA shouldn't be an issue.
- rorykoehler 9y agoThis is happening with health insurance companies in Singapore. It sets a worrying precedent where patient/doctor confidentiality becomes obsolete. I'm not against my health data being collected anonymously for research purposes but I sure don't want the researcher to be my health insurance company.
- burntrelish1273 9y agoMaybe to compete against Express Scripts and drugs stores, to a degree, but a by-mail pharmacy has a very steep hill to climb in terms of in-person/telepresence pharmacist expertise.
- revel 9y agoExpress Scripts is primarily a PBM. It's not the same business
- ben1040 9y agoThey did $51 billion in network revenue and $43 billion in home delivery pharmacy revenue in 2016, and their revenue mix has been trending more toward the pharmacy side over the last few years. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1532063/000153206317000004/esrx-12312016x10k.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1532063/000153206317...
- partiallypro 9y agoMy parent's insurance has Express as the preferred provider, because it's cheaper all around. Also it's scheduled. Amazon already does this with supplements, making the jump to prescriptions won't be a problem. Luckily for CVS and Walgreens, the barrier to entry to enter this market should be fairly low if you're already a pharmacy; unlike many of Amazon's other entries that have high costs.
- refurb 9y agoExpress Scripts own Accredo, one of the largest specialty pharmacies in the US!
- rconti 9y agoI hope so. Dear god their service is atrocious. First, they wanted me to fill out some 1980s style book order form to get my prescription filled. Then, for a year, they filled my 1-per-day, 90-pill, 3-month prescription..... every..... 2.... months. Unfortunately it was nothing of any resale or entertainment value. I called them and waited on hold and someone promised they found and fixed the issue. It was not fixed. I harangued them on twitter. They promised to reach out to me and fix it. They did reach out to me, claimed they saw the problem with the previous 'fix', fixed it again, delayed my next shipment by X months to get me back on track, and... it wasn't fixed. The delay worked but I was still receiving 90 pills every 60 days. Ultimately I think it sorted itself out when a prescription had no more refills allowed and had to be renewed and entered as a new prescription number.
- losteverything 9y agoCvs big fear is drone delivery. Amazon will solve last mile.
- AdamJacobMuller 9y agoWhy do they need drones for last mile, they can just use their own existing delivery infrastructure. Drones might be cheaper/better/faster in the long run, but, they aren't required for this to work.
- losteverything 9y agoMy comment was totally anecdotal from a big data insider who said cvs is already extremely concerned drones remove store visits..
- mseebach 9y agoThe "technology" required is the same as the postal service have provided for centuries (think pizza delivery for more urgent situations). Sounds like that insider is spending too much time on pop business sci-fi and too little time understanding basic facts about logistics (and, very likely, regulatory restrictions).
- ryuker16 9y agoDrones would be killer for pharmacies. Low weight and small packages
- vthallam 9y agoApparently better for consumers in general now that there's more competition. One Industry I really really want them to enter is Consumer Airlines. Service in most airlines sucks, like big time. Can't wait for Amazon Airlines with Prime Video and Internet available for all. But of course I know that's a distant dream unless the Prime Air works great.
- aknosis 9y agoIsn't Amazon notorious for bad customer service though? That would prevent them from disputing the industry.
- mjcl 9y agoI think they're a mixed bag, probably depending on some customer profitability / value score. I've heard other people complain about trouble when packages were stolen, but the few times it's happened to me, I've gotten replacements overnighted without even having to talk (chat or phone) to anyone.
- 0xbear 9y agoAmazon is notorious for the opposite actually, at least in their retail business.
- legitster 9y ago??? I've always found Amazon customer service to be amazing. Seriously, I can't think of any other company where it's as easy to get a real person on the phone. Or a refund.
- krrrh 9y agoAmazon's customer service to consumers is exceptional, but the service they give to their merchants is horrible and extremely incompetent.
- javiramos 9y agoYes. Business customer service is terrible.
- seibelj 9y agoIf it takes Amazon to fix American healthcare, god bless them. What a total cluster fuck healthcare is, and if that’s what they want to fix, I’m very supportive. Putting $5k into their stock tomorrow
- rorykoehler 9y agoSerious question: How is a cut throat capitalist company gaining the ability to push pills going to fix American healthcare?
- legitster 9y agoAmerican healthcare is completely non-competitive. No pricing competition, high barriers of entry, and completely entrenched players. Any new players would be a win.
- rorykoehler 9y agoThe main issue with American healthcare besides the price of drugs, insurance and care (which Amazon could help solve but is essentially a secondary conidition) is the philosophy around healthcare in general. It's all reactive. To solve healthcare America needs a better diet made up of actual food (not psuedo-food products), more exercise (cities designed for walking and biking not driving), doctors that aren't incentivized to sell drugs, no drug adverts etc. Basically to focus on prevention not reaction.
- seibelj 9y agoFor starters, doctors are in a modern guild system. They artificially limit the number of medical schools, increasing the salaries of licensed doctors while limiting the supply. As society ages and needs more medical services, the poor are continually priced out as the supply of doctors is limited artificially. Although extraordinary unpopular if you speak to doctors (as I have found), drastically increasing the number of doctors would do wonders. I’m sure there is a percentage (2%?) from poor countries that would pass in America as average quality. Next, transparent pricing. Laser eye surgery has radically improved in quality while decreasing costs because insurance (typically) doesn’t cover it. People want it, but must pay out of pocket, so they shop around and elect to laser eye surgery on their own terms. The result is increased quality at lower prices. Not every medical procedure is this way (such as the emergency room), but perhaps if I needed a knee replaced, and until I did it I merely walked with a cane, I might shop around for the best price and value. Until transparent pricing happens, and the supply of doctors meets demand, we will simply be passing laws to further warp free market incentives. My hope is that amazon increases the influence of free market mechanics into this horrible system.
- aviv 9y agoYep, a pharmacy coming to a Whole Foods near you. Circle of life.
- nyxtom 9y agoDoes this imply that Amazon will be in the place to negotiate drug prices? Trying to understand what could change given how a lot of PBMs appear to be wed to insurance groups (and now CVS looking to buy Aetna). What would be the next step, buy an insurance company? Or is it a matter of exposing the true cost of drug prices and drive the market costs down?
- legitster 9y agoI don't think they would be in a position to negotiate prices anymore than CVS/Walgreens are. Their upside would mostly be changing the delivery method.
- gumby 9y ago> Does this imply that Amazon will be in the place to negotiate drug prices? Very much so. Amazon is clearly playing the monopsony card here, and has an opportunity to drive prices down. Up too of course but Bezos has not shown any predilection for that to date.
- mxuribe 9y agoHey whatever it takes to bring down the awfully (and artificially) inflated prices of pharmaceuticals in this country (USA), the better I'll feel. If it takes Amazon getting in on the act - assuming pricing gets better - I'm in favor of it.
- adventured 9y agoWalmart has a large pharmacy business. They attempted to enter the market and bring prices down (they succeeded in a small way, on a selection of common generic prescriptions). I'm not sure what Amazon can accomplish beyond what Walmart was able to with thousands of pharmacy locations. Hoping Bezos & Co. shake it up though, maybe they'll figure out something new.
- dawnerd 9y agoAmazon Basics generic drugs? That could be very interesting.
- mseebach 9y agoNot really. FDA approval is already the Amazon Basics of generic drugs. If it says Acetaminophen 500mg, that's what you're getting, nothing more, nothing less, within a very narrow tolerance, entirely regardless of brand. Not so with batteries or HDMI cables, and thus brands add meaningful value in that space.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]