4 ms·
Salaries are a dysfunctional market like health care. No market can function properly without all parties having the same information. All arguments against sa
by maxxxxx 9y ago
Salaries are a dysfunctional market like health care. No market can function properly without all parties having the same information.
All arguments against salary transparency seem to be that people will be unhappy when they find out that the company has screwed them over and therefore it's better for these people to be ignorant.
- ythn 9y ago> All arguments against salary transparency seem to be that people will be unhappy when they find out that the company has screwed them over and therefore it's better for these people to be ignorant. Why do you assume someone making less is being "screwed over"? Imagine employees A and B. B greatly outperforms A and therefore rightly makes more. However, A is delusional about his skills and thinks he is as good as B. Pay information is made transparent and A sees he is making less. This makes him mad because by all rights he ought to be making as much as B! This type of comparison/resentment might make A want to quit or ask for a raise, whereas before he was both content and fairly paid at his performance level.
- trowawee 9y agoSure, that might happen. But you're invoking a potential problem that might happen, when we have problems (gender and racial pay gaps) that are A. more severe than the potential problem you're invoking, B. already demonstrably occurring, and C. potentially correctable via salary transparency. If we can make a step towards correcting existing problems, and the best argument against it is "this might create a less-severe problem at some point in the future", we should probably take that step.
- argv_empty 9y agoThen A is free to do so, but if he's not actually worth more, then he's likely to find out in his job search that he can't command B's salary. WSJ seems oddly unwilling to let the free market resolve this issue.
- scaryclam 9y agoI really wish this was true, but alas, there are a lot of devs out there who talk a great interview but can't cut it with the real work. They tend to get hired with inflated salaries, screw up the companies systems for a year and then move on when questions start to get asked (but of course, they'll tell themselves the company changed, not that they've messed up). Unfortunately, there are not enough companies out there who can unearth this type of incompetence before hiring.
- 09094920394314 9y agoSounds like the only benefit is keeping A in his delusion, instead of informing him via a competitive market that his skill is not as high as he thought he'd be. Oh, and saving the company money. And making it easier to have private favorites. If someone is in an executive position, and something like you describe happens, it is their fucking job description to resolve the problem. Meanwhile, by having open salaries, everyone has the information needed for a competitive market. Including college graduates, who get screwed over routinely //Edit: Oh, and if A ever DOES need to find a new job and advertises his "delusional" skills, either him or his next company will feel the pain from the lack of price information here
- psergeant 9y ago> saving the company money Companies not over-paying for their resources is generally a pretty critical factor in them staying solvent and being able to employ people, rather than a nice-to-have.
- crdoconnor 9y agoTo put it another way, it's a pretty critical factor in ensuring that more wealth flows into profits rather than salaries and a way to keep sickly companies afloat via the deception of their employees.
- throw2016 9y agoThis doesn't hold. If A is 'greatly outperforming' then a bonus or incentive can be linked to the greater performance leading to a higher pay. Without measurements how can we can say who is delusional, A or B? Ultimately transparency benefits everyone except those who currently non transparently draw greater wages without justification. People will adopt their attitudes, there is no place for immaturity and ego in a professional context.
- dawnbreez 9y agoThe solution is for the manager to sit down with A and tell him to stop being a brat. No, seriously. If A is getting upset because he feels he's not paid "fairly", but A isn't contributing enough to get paid more, then someone needs to tell A exactly why he's being paid less. And if you can't explain why, then you need to reconsider that decision very, very carefully.
- jimbobimbo 9y agoNo, there're other arguments as well. One of which is privacy, for example. Many people value their privacy more than some elusive goal of full transparency.
- vilmosi 9y agoIf you consider that private information. Plenty of people, inside the company and outside, know that information. It's not that personal in my opinion. You can even reasonably guess someones salary based on their job and location, especially a coworker's.
- jimbobimbo 9y agoThere're plenty of ways to learn of one's SSN or birthday date too - this is still private information, which doesn't concern other people, unless the person explicitly wants to share it.
- waegawegawe 9y agoThe same could be said of much private medical information. Guessability, or someone else knowing the information, are not the controlling factors in what is considered private information.
- ycombobreaker 9y agoIt's not private from payroll, but everybody knows that, and payroll is expected to exercise discretion. Precisely the people with hard-to-guess salaries may value that privacy.
- richardknop 9y agoThat doesn't mean it's not private. Lots of private information is known by lots of people. Your health record is known by your doctors and the government presumably. Government knows everything about my taxes, my date of birth, national ID (or SSN in US) etc. That doesn't mean it's not a private information. I don't want to share my salary details with other people unless I choose so.
- 9y ago
- ballenf 9y ago> No market can function properly without all parties having the same information. Salary info is a very small piece of the information needed to evaluate the fairness. The article details quite extensively how difficult it is to communicate the totality of information in all but a few circumstances. If everyone could see every piece of relevant info then I'd agree. One example: my value to the company may be for something you see as worthless. But you don't have the full strategic roadmap of the company's leadership in mind when you devalue my contribution. And the company may have valid reasons for not making the strategy widely known in the company. If you learned that I got a big raise for my success in that area, you'd feel slighted. The problem there isn't lack of info re: salaries, it's the impossibility of every employee having every bit of info needed to make the assessment.
- steveax 9y agoSurely then the company could explain this reason. More trustworthy? Something else? This would give the employee the option of trying to improve that aspect their performance. I’m not saying this is easy, or without pitfalls, but the biggest reason I’m for transparency is that it helps protect against unfair salary discrepancies.
- Shivetya 9y agoNo, you completely discount human nature here. There are far too many people who are more concerned about what others get and have than is healthy. Plus in many work environments you end up with those who either think that one party is not justified in their rate or that they themselves are woefully under compensated. Worse, you have a bunch who will not work beyond what they think is "fair". I like the privacy of my coworkers not knowing my exact compensation, it is not their business. If we follow your logic to its natural end, why not force disclosure of all expenditures each of us make as well? (which on another topic, that is the best reason to never have digital currencies)
- matwood 9y ago> No, you completely discount human nature here. There are far too many people who are more concerned about what others get and have than is healthy. This is a great point, and let me add that it becomes 10x worse when money is involved. Some (many?) people are just flat out irrational when it comes to money. Jealously and envy quickly block any rational thought when it comes to explaining why someone might make more than they do.
- jdavis703 9y agoIn Norway salary information is public, but with a catch. If you ask for someone's salary information they learn who made that inquiry. This might be as good as you can get with getting salary transparency and mitigating privacy concerns.
- robaato 9y agoI think already discussed on HN, but here's one link: https://www.theguardian.com/money/blog/2016/apr/11/when-it-comes-to-tax-transparency-norway-leads-the-field https://www.theguardian.com/money/blog/2016/apr/11/when-it-c...
- walshemj 9y agoI know I once dealt with a case where a senior manger (paid roughly 4x the median wage) was really upset as he no longer qualified for a business needs phone at home which was something like £15 quid a month
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jaredklewis 9y ago> No market can function properly without all parties having the same information What markets function like this? I have no idea what the cost of growing, harvesting, shipping, and selling a banana is. At every step of this process there are capital investments, labor costs, and profit margins that are totally opaque to me. And yet I can look at the price of a banana and decide if I want to spend the money or not. One beautiful aspect of markets is that not everyone has to spend years researching every purchasing decision. The makert sets a price for you. If one company has margins that are too high, another steps in to take some of that profit, by offering at a lower price until it reaches equilibrium. The job market seems similar. I don’t know how companies set their offer price but I am capable of evaluating offers all the same.
- emblaegh 9y agoYou know how much a banana is worth because you've seen how much people charge for bananas from different origins in different grocery stores. Knowing how much your peers are getting paid is important information when evaluate an offer, and helps to ensure a more efficient job market.
- freshhawk 9y agoSo you feel that if you knew that other consumers paid different prices for the same products but that information wasn't available to you that would be fine? That would be the equivalent analogy. That you know you are paying the same price for bananas from the corner store as everyone else.
- lmm 9y ago> If one company has margins that are too high, another steps in to take some of that profit, by offering at a lower price until it reaches equilibrium. Right, but that mechanism is only possible if information is public. You don't know about the pricing of growing, harvesting, shipping and selling bananas - but it's possible to find out, and a company looking to enter the market would find out. You can rely on market pricing because the market lets you outsource your research to other market participants, but that only works if research is possible in the first place.
- 9y ago