13 ms·
"affordable housing without a government subsidy is becoming extinct." Was recently in LA, had a very excited Uber driver tell he just bought a house near Tope
by exabrial 9y ago
"affordable housing without a government subsidy is becoming extinct."
Was recently in LA, had a very excited Uber driver tell he just bought a house near Topeka, KS and it was 4 bed, 3 bath, unfinished basement, 2 car garage for $95k, on a 3/4 acre. He was extremely excited about moving. That's a massive house. There is plenty of cheap housing elsewhere in the USA, you have to be willing relocate.
The title should be "How did relatively small areas in California in the grand scheme of the USA make housing so expensive most people can't live there?"
- Top19 9y agoLocal control of housing and zoning should be taken away and placed at the State level or above. Over time that will probably become just as corrupt and it will need to revert to the local level again. I am amazed what people will complain about on my Nextdoor group. There is not one ounce of sacrifice in these people for even a 30 second increase in traffic or a change in the student:teacher ratio from 21:1 to 21.3:1. Maybe we’d have more money for schools if we didn’t keep having to deal with all the externalities developed by expensive housing and long commutes. Reminds me of that lady in SF who opposed a housing development recently because she said it blocked the sunlight to her zucchini garden. Now many YIMBY groups are adopting the zucchini as their logo...
- xapata 9y agoThat lady may have purchased her place in order to have a sunlit garden. It's frustrating there's not an easy way for that housing development to simply compensate the gardener fairly for her loss of sunlight, along with everyone else nearby who is adversely affected. Of course, she could also be charged a fee for the benefits of increasing density -- more restaurant options, etc. -- according to how much she appreciates them. It's tough to calculate these things. So many aspects of our society seem forced to either-or situations when some compromise would benefit all parties more.
- jdavis703 9y agoThere is an easy way: the developer just writes her a check equivalent to whatever it takes to rent a garden patch somewhere for 50 years. Not that a developer should have to do that for the land they have rights on, but if they want to take away her argument that's one method.
- fraserharris 9y agoYou're implying that in purchasing a property you acquire a perpetual right to the sunlight that exists on the day you purchased. There is no such right. If this gardener wanted to retain that sunlight, they should have purchased the lot next door, put a building-height covenant on it, and resold it. They would incur a loss due to the covenant, but that is the cost of legally gaining the right to that sunlight.
- dagw 9y agoThere is no such right. Perhaps not in California, but it's worth noting that some places, England being among the forefront in this[0], do recognize the right to light is an important property right. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_light https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_light
- makomk 9y agoUltimately, if buyers believed that it would be necessary to go to that extent to to maintain sunlight in their own back garden, the original developer would've done so and we'd just end up talking about how states should override covenants instead in the HN comments about how people shouldn't have a right to sunlight.
- athenot 9y agoSolar easements exist in many jurisdictions now (typically for solar panels). For Georgia: https://law.justia.com/codes/georgia/2010/title-44/chapter-9/article-2 https://law.justia.com/codes/georgia/2010/title-44/chapter-9...
- xapata 9y agoWhile it's possible for any individual to put a price on just about anything, it ain't always easy (as you just explained). We've decided that it's the government's responsibility to help put a price on some of these ineffables -- air quality, etc. For a well-functioning market that doesn't get bothered by protests and other political machinations, the government needs to provide an easy mechanism to pay for whatever it is you care about. Any market which is restricted to folks who can afford high-cost lawyers and custom legal contracts, that market will be inefficient. Saying, "put a building-height covenant on it" in effect means "let's spend money and time on political advertisements and protests so neither of us are happy."
- whyenot 9y agoI'm not sure it's a good idea to take away local control of zoning and other planing just because the result is something that YIMBY groups don't like. There is something very undemocratic about doing that. More housing and more density doesn't always make communities better. The people who live in an area, are voting in local elections and are paying local taxes should have a say in how their communities develop. Shouldn't they? Isn't that how our system of government is supposed to work? I mean I empathize with the YIMBY point of view -- I make about $56,00 a year as staff at a state university. That's right on the edge in the bay area. There will come a time when I can no longer afford to live here. I'm OK with that. That's how the market works. I don't think you have a right to live in San Francisco, or Malibu, or Los Gatos, etc. if you can't afford to live there. Everyone can't own a Ferrari. Everyone doesn't get to live where they want to.
- door 9y agocities should be for everyone, especially cities like SF,LA. a city that is an enclave for the rich is a sad community. this isn't "how the market works". centralization of wealth and especially wealth in the form of housing is and has always been a result of state power. the fact that SF is unaffordable is the result of policy, not just the invisible hand of the market. And even if it was, that wouldn't make it OK
- ardit33 9y agoA city/town/neighborhood is part of a state and doesn't live in isolation. If you live in SF, your water comes from.... drum roll, Hetch Hetchy damn, which is a 3 h 49 min (177.7 mi) away. Now image if the people living where the pipes come along, decided not to have them in their backyard..... because of democracy, they vote to tear them away. No water for you.... Democracy can't exist without limits, otherwise you run the risk of 51% controller what the other 49% do in every way... Zoning laws are restriction on the rights of what can be build in a property, and they should exist in a Macro scale, Otherwise, your neighbors might decide against water pipes to come in your house, because democracy...
- exabrial 9y ago
- jseliger 9y agoThat's true and Tokyo is a good example of this: https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-...
- downrightmike 9y agoZoning would be the ultimate gerrymandering. Don't like your voters? Not only can you define specific areas to give your party the advantage, but you can now control who lives there, if anyone does at all.
- tdb7893 9y agoI think a lot of it is that pay scales on cost of living. It allows prices to go to crazy amounts and also disincentives moving to cheaper areas. If pay didn't scale on cost of living then tons of people would move from those high cost areas. I'm making 70k a year but I'm putting 14k into my 401k and investing an additional 14k each year (saving up for a down payment on a house) and that's while having hobbies and travelling some
- derefr 9y ago"Affordable housing" implies that there is a job at the destination that can pay a wage that can pay the mortgage. Sure, $95k isn't a lot—but what do jobs in Topeka pay, and how many of them are there?
- kasey_junk 9y agoFollowing the ‘normal’ 3x wage, gets you an anticipated 32k needed yearly income. For a double income family that’s right around the federal minimum wage. Now minimum wage jobs don’t actually support a house of that price due to health care, child care, crap hours, etc. but the idea that there aren’t jobs that allow you to easily buy that house in Topeka is ridiculous. To the point where I want to say “leave California” to you.
- derefr 9y ago> the idea that there aren’t jobs that allow you to easily buy that house in Topeka is ridiculous I was more expecting "number of job openings available" to be the problem, rather than the pay for any given job opening. Though, admittedly, I don't live in the US and don't know its geography very well, so until I looked it up just now I was assuming Kansas was part of the infamous US "rust belt" where towns were depopulating and there were fewer job openings than people. I guess that's only happening toward the east coast?
- pxeboot 9y agoDespite what many Americans and foreigners think, there are many nice towns and cities in the Midwest with vibrant economies.
- merpnderp 9y agoAbsolutely. I live in literally the middle of nowhere and we can't find software engineers even though the cost of living is 90% of the national median. Here a $200k house is a mansion.
- branchless 9y agoGod, hacker news posts. Bad economics, farting soylent green, show and tell depression threads, web site design angst (can't scroll on mobile) and just now and again something reasonable. But not today.
- pxeboot 9y agoI was (and still am) amazed at how cheap housing was when I started looking away from the West coast. While places with really depressed home prices likely don't have any jobs, there are still plenty of cities with growing economies and cheap housing. I moved to Texas last year and meet people all the time that moved here specifically for the low cost of housing.
- Teknoman117 9y agoWe've actually had a few people where I work transfer to the Texas office because they wanted to buy a house. Can't say I haven't thought about it myself to be honest.
- justboxing 9y ago> Topeka, KS. Almost all the jobs I see in Topeka are in retail "Sales Associates" = glorified title for minimum wage jobs. https://www.google.com/search?q=Topeka,+KS+jobs&oq=Topeka,+KS+jobs https://www.google.com/search?q=Topeka,+KS+jobs&oq=Topeka,+K... How does this cabbie intend to make a good wage so he can continue to live in his huge house? Or does he not care, since he bought a HUGE house for $ 95K -- assuming it was all cash. If not, he has a mortgage to pay like everyone else, once a month.
- astura 9y agoNot to mention huge houses have significant ongoing costs - maintenance, insurance, utilities, repairs, taxes, HOA fees, etc. Even if you owned your house free and clear you need cash flow to be able to keep it.
- QuantumYeti 9y agoAre you being sarcastic? Of course all the jobs in Topeka, KS aren't minimum wage. He probably plans on getting one of those. Just like everybody else who lives in a decent sized (not huge) house in Topeka, KS.
- charcoal23 9y agoTopeka is the capital of Kansas. There are jobs with the state government and jobs in businesses connected with the state government. It's also a city of 125,000 people with the usual mix of jobs. Not extremely vibrant economically but not particularly depressed either. Just an ordinary small Midwestern city. Lawrence is the home of the University of Kansas, and is only 30 minutes down the road from Topeka. Quite a few opportunities there, including startups. Kansas City is about 40 minutes away down the turnpike with the opportunities of a 2+ million metro area. No, he's not going to make the sort of money you do in California, but he's not moving to some economic wasteland either. He won't have too much trouble pulling in 50-70,000 in some white collar job and, considering the cost of living, he'll be quite comfortable. Probably more comfortable than a 100k job in SF or LA.
- diogenescynic 9y ago
- pjc50 9y ago> recently in LA, had a very excited Uber driver tell he just bought a house near Topeka, KS The 1,500 mile commute sounds like rather a pain, though.
- exabrial 9y agoStill faster than going from San Fernando to Santa Ana
- zip1234 9y agoIt has never been easier to move across the US and settle somewhere else. The internet has made it much easier to research locations, jobs, housing, etc in advance before moving.
- hycaria 9y agoWho needs this ? Hasn't everyone gotten the message to spend less ressources yet ?!
- AznHisoka 9y agoNot sure what your underlying message is but when you want to spend 1 million dollars on a home in la or nyc it feels like money down the drain if you are just getting a 500sq foot studio with no kitchen.
- hycaria 9y agoI meant on the ecological side of it, sorry for lack of clarity.
- ameister14 9y agoWell, if you have 3-5 children it starts to make sense
- hycaria 9y agoThis also makes no sense, no one needs so many children, except for screwing our world up of course.
- ameister14 9y agoWell, children sometimes die, so you need some spares.
- mrgreenfur 9y agoI think almost no one has gotten that message, though I agree with it. People are (and will always be) out to get theirs. Until there are larger forces at work to steer them, I doubt this will change.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoWhen spending more ecologically costs orders of magnitude less money than spending less? Hell no! Of course, that just means the ecological pricings-in have completely failed to happen.
- rayiner 9y agoI had a cab driver in Austin tell me that he and his friends all bought $150k houses in the suburbs, with great schools, pools, etc., on 15-year mortgages that many had paid off already.
- ikeyany 9y agoSpending 15 years in a cultural wasteland (even with your own pool) isn't appealing to everyone. Sounds like the issue is that our cities aren't liveable in the first place.
- rayiner 9y agoOur cities are too expensive, thanks to NIMBYs, and have terrible schools, thanks to various factors but mostly America's long history of segregation and oppression. Neither of those things will be fixed, probably ever much less any time soon. So the question is, how do you make the best of what you've got to work with? My wife and I moved from downtown DC to just outside the Annapolis city limits. We probably do more culture/community stuff now, because thanks to Uber and a low cost of living, we can easily justify trying those things out. If I could find a comparable job in Topeka, I'd totally try that out. Yuppie cultural amenities are everywhere these days. Yeah, it won't be New York, but only New York is New York, but somehow the rest of the country manages to get by with their second-string versions of things.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]