16 ms·
Why We Must Fight for the Right to Repair Our Electronics
- xahrepap 9y agoHere's a related thought: what if the law stated something along the lines of, if DRM/hardware locks/etc prevent you or a 3rd party of your choosing from repairing, then the party who owns the lock should be responsible for the repairs (including costs) Then a company can decide if they're in the business of licencing or selling, and make their decisions accordingly. it could also help establish a line between ownership of the device vs of the license.
- freedomben 9y agoI like this idea. I think it strikes a good balance between the rights of both sides and provides incentives for opening things up (which I believe is important to consumer freedom). But if a company doesn't want to open it up, they still have a reasonable path forward.
- cconcepts 9y agoMe: "My phone broke randomly" Them: "You dropped it in water didn't you?" Me: "No, I didn't" Them: "Yes, you did" Me: "Nope" Them: "Yep" Me: "Nope" .......
- Spivak 9y agoI don't see how it changes the situation. Even if the owner intentionally damaged the phone they would still be entitled to having it repaired for $parts + $labor.
- cconcepts 9y agoGenuine replacement screen: $450 2 hours labour from highly trained apple certified screen replacement technician: $180. "....but I shouldn't have to pay these exorbitant fees - I didnt drop it in water...." "Yes you did"
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoShouldn't a $1000 phone be waterproof?
- burntrelish1273 9y ago<sarcasm because="Poe's law"> Owners of $1000 phones don't go near water or need cases. They never make mistakes. </sarcasm>
- coldtea 9y agoIsn't this behind the point? For one, still not all $1000 phones are waterproof, and second, this can apply to all kind of other devices, like laptops, who can't be or is very difficult to make waterproof without major compromises (e.g. heat dissipation).
- nsomaru 9y agoAnecdote: dropped an iPhone 6 to the bottom of a pool. Failed spectacularly bringing it back up a few times. Total about 2-3 minutes submerged at around 2m. Put the phone in a rice bag for 2 days, charged and it's working fine :)
- ams6110 9y agoI've seen the rice treatment work also, but chances for success are reportedly better if you do not try to turn the device on first.
- r00fus 9y agoDo iPhones still have the water sensitivity marker?
- pls2halp 9y agoYep. It became a lot more pertinent after the iPhone 7 was water resistant, as the markers seem less protected than the boards.
- burntrelish1273 9y agoThat red strip on iDevices that changed in temporary high-humidity conditions. If Apple actually produced good PCBs and conformally-coated them and capped their JTAGs, water damage and corrosion would be much less likely.
- coldtea 9y ago>If Apple actually produced good PCBs and conformally-coated them and capped their JTAGs, water damage and corrosion would be much less likely. If? In what world they don't, and compared to which alternative?
- everheardofc 9y agoThey currently don't have conformal coating. The alternative is having conformal coating.
- crispyambulance 9y agoWhy do say they don't produce good PCB's? Conformal coating introduces problems too and, moreover, makes repair intractable. I don't know if conformal coating even works properly with the very fine pitch BGA's that cover much of the surface area of the PCB in an iPhone.
- Spivak 9y ago> (including costs) How about at a rate of $parts + $labor? If the device was defective and broke then it would still be the manufacturer's responsibility to fix it. But if it breaks due to wear and tear, accidental damage, or intentional damage then the user should reasonably foot but bill (either out of pocket or with insurance).
- fghvbnvbnfe 9y agoThe idea here is to make a clear split between owning and licensing. If the company decides they are selling the items themselves then the items should be repairable by the new owner. If the company decides they are merely selling the rights to use the items then it is reasonable for the user to be unable to repair it, provided the owner (the company) is willing to keep it in working condition. That should absolutely include wear and tear as well as accidental damage. Intentional damage is an issue, but there shouldn't be much motivation for it under such a system.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoThat doesn't work for the simple reason that there is no market, therefore there is no way to determine that price. The whole point is essentially that the manufacturer can only have the monopoly on repairs if they are free, if they want to charge for it, they have to allow competition. As for intentional damage, I think that should not be handled based on costs at all, but simply based on depreciation. Based on normal durability of the device, if you damage the device, you have to pay the remaining value in order to get a new device.
- sokoloff 9y ago> As for intentional damage, I think that should not be handled based on costs at all, but simply based on depreciation. Based on normal durability of the device, if you damage the device, you have to pay the remaining value in order to get a new device. I think I'm not understanding your proposal here. It seems that under such a scheme I could take a $1000 phone that is reasonably expected to last 3 years, intentionally destroy it on day 1, and pay less than a dollar [1/(3*365)] to get a new device. How would manufacturers not be bled dry under such a system?
- CamperBob2 9y agoDRM has always represented an attempt on the part of content owners to seize more territory than the framers of US copyright law intended. Copyright was supposed to be a bargain between the creators and the commons. In return for the rightsholder's agreement to release the material into the public domain upon expiration, the government would grant a temporary legal monopoly. Unfortunately the first part of the copyright bargain is implicit, not part of the law. With DRM, rightsholders get to have their cake -- our cake -- and eat it too. Not only is the protection granted by copyright now effectively perpetual, but they've purchased additional legislation such as the DMCA and endless copyright term extensions that punish people who are trying to claim their half of the bargain. IMHO copyright should not apply to anything with DRM. Rightsholders should be forced to decide whether they want a temporary legal monopoly with no technical protection, or a permanent technical monopoly with no legal protection.
- smaddox 9y agoCopyright is not, and never was, for creators. It's for publishers.
- ryandrake 9y agoMore specifically, it's for copyright holders, who rarely might be creators, but are more often than not publishers.
- cyphar 9y agoCopyright was for authors a very long time ago[1]. It's been slowly corrupted by the greed of publishers over a very long time, but it is important to remember where copyright actually comes from and to reject emotional arguments about the rights of publishers (in truth, they don't deserve rights over creators' works -- they abuse creators enough as-is). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Anne
- monocasa 9y agoUhhhh.... > These restrictions were enforced by the Stationers' Company, a guild of printers given the exclusive power to print—and the responsibility to censor—literary works.
- userbinator 9y agoThat does not fix the e-waste problem. E.g. Apple has always been willing to repair or replace under warranty. See this item: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14175771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14175771
- shakna 9y agoApple has also fought consumer laws in other nations to ensure no more than a 12 month warranty. If they feel like including DRM in this hypothetical law situation, require the warranty be twice as long as otherwise.
- 3131s 9y agoAnd there are many countries where iPhones are popular but there are still no official Apple-sanctioned repair centers.
- esmi 9y agoWhat counts as a repair and how would properitary components be made available for the repair? Under what markup do components need to be made available? An example: If I’m Apple and I’m supply constrained on fancy new FaceID sensors I’m not going to want to loose an iPhoneX sale because I have to make a sensor available to a repair depot (internal or external). And the customer that was supposed to get that sensor is not going to like waiting even longer for their phone.
- falcolas 9y agoIn such a world, if they can’t repair or replace a broken device, they should offer a full refund.
- Nullabillity 9y ago> What counts as a repair and how would properitary components be made available for the repair? Under what markup do components need to be made available? The bare minimum would be to require an infinite warranty. So free, and with compensation to the customer for the repair time. Don't want to deal with that? Get rid of the damn locks already.
- esmi 9y agoWhat is a lock and how does it prevent repair? I think we would both agree that iPhone 7 is DRM laden. However iFixit, who is quoted in the parent article and gives iPhone a repairability score of 7 of 10, seems to think there are some things which are repairable at the component level on an iPhone 7 even to a layman at home. https://www.ifixit.com/Device/iPhone_7 https://www.ifixit.com/Device/iPhone_7
- Nullabillity 9y agoDo they glue stuff in? Use special screws and connectors just for the hell of it? Use software checks to prevent the system from operating correctly if components have been replaced?
- 9y ago
- reitanqild 9y agoCould work for media as well: DRM? Then you have to provide clients, including bugfixes and security upgrades for all paying customers on all platforms. No DRM: Oh, you just sold a file? The customer can then run it in whatever SW they want.
- damontal 9y agoReminds me of how AT&T used to basically own your telephone and wouldn't allow other companies to make things you could attach to the phone to improve or augment it.
- sliken 9y agoSeems laughably unlikely. Would be nice is somebody like the EU at least required a user replacable battery. Seems insane to replace a top spec phone made out of aluminum and glass just because a battery has died. Imagine if cars (starting at only 10-12 times as expensive) were thrown away when they needed an oil change. They would last just about as long as phones do.
- rayiner 9y agoIf you want to buy a phone with a replaceable battery, then do that. Why force everyone to put up with the extra bulk and weight? And at least with apple, replacing the battery does not require replacing the phone.
- michaelmrose 9y agoThere is no reason to suppose that making the battery easy to replace increases bulk and weight to a degree you are capable of detecting in a blind test given identical hardware. Its about decreasing the lifespan of devices to sell more.
- vacri 9y agoIt does increase size a little, as you need to account for the extra thickness used to make the compartment wall and the inside wall of the battery pack. Additional constraints are that these compartments generally have to be straight-walled; you can't realisitically 'build through and around' a modular compartment like you can with an inbuilt component.
- andrepd 9y agoThe "bulk and weight" FUD needs to stop. There is no reason that user replaceable batteries need to be heavier and bulkier than soldered batteries.
- userbinator 9y agoPerfect example: http://www.gizchina.com/2013/09/18/exclusive-hands-video-stainless-steel-jiayu-g5/ http://www.gizchina.com/2013/09/18/exclusive-hands-video-sta... http://www.gizchina.com/2013/09/24/jiayu-g5-teardown/ http://www.gizchina.com/2013/09/24/jiayu-g5-teardown/ Almost identical in dimensions and appearance to an iPhone 5, yet has expandable storage and a 50% more capacity removable battery. If some small Chinese company can make such a phone, so could Apple, but they deliberately chose not to.
- gt_ 9y agoI have been living in rural Kentucky for 4 months and casually asking farmers about the issues with John Deere tractors. They are all familiar with the problem but the ones I have spoken to seem to think it is necessary. I think these are smaller scale farmers, though. The heavy machinery mechanic next door disagrees, and says the company he works for buys a certification for the right to repair. I got the impression they somewhat depend on it. At least, he doesn't seem to put up a fuss. He is a neighbor so I didn't put him on the spot.
- forapurpose 9y ago> the ones I have spoken to seem to think it is necessary Why do they think it is necessary?
- gt_ 9y ago2 of the 3 here said they own equipment that only John Deere can work on and they do not like it. Their impression appears to be that “nowadays” the tractors have computers in them, which necessitates a technician with skills beyond that of a country mechanic. I get the sense they either have bigger problems or that they just feel helpless so would rather not know. In the case of the latter, they are probably right but I don’t think I have the heart to tell them. Similar to the neighbor, I see these guys at the local cafe somewhat regularly. I am very much a city folk haha, just visiting.
- flukus 9y agoWhat is it that locks them into buying John Deere products? They seem to be mostly NA focused so I assume there are international competitors even if there aren't local ones. Most of the worthwhile patents should be decades old, etc.
- kop316 9y agoTo me what is frustrating is the planned obsolescence can just as easily be accomplished by just abandoning software support. Many older phones will never have new software because cendors cannot (or will not) allow electronics to upgrade to a new kernel, functionally limiting it to an old one and limiting what it can upgrade to. I would like to see some sort of law where if the electronic is abondoned, the software can be relased to allow consumers to update it.
- scarface74 9y agoIn the case of iOS, update it to what? By the time Apple drops iOS support for a device, it's already starting to show its age. I have an old working 1st gen iPod Touch that can only handle simple web pages like HN and most apps that require a back end can't connect to the server like Netflix and YouTube. My old 1st gen iPad fared a little better - you can still download "the last compatible version" of apps and use many of the streaming apps but it's crash prone trying to display complicated web pages. Sooner or later smart phone advancement will get to the point where computers are now - a 10 year old computer * can run most modern non game software but we aren't there yet. Neither of my old iOS devices needed "repairs". While I had long since abandoned my iPod Touch, I just replaced my first gen iPad as a PDF/Ebook reader with a 2017 iPad. * My parents still use my 2006 era Core Duo 1.66 Mac Mini with Windows 7 and my current Plex Server is 2008 Dell Laptop 2.66Ghz Core 2 Duo running Windows 10.
- frik 9y ago> My old 1st gen iPad fared a little better My iPad 2 runs on iOS6 and has perfect battery time, and runs as fast as in 2011. Only some ad-laden websites crash the browser from time to time, but that's a problem with all 512MB memory devices (both iOS and Android). Everyone that upgraded their iPad 2-4 and iPad Mini 1 to iOS7+ regretted doing so. iOS7 was a major slowdown for those hardware devices. It basically got unusable slow. iOS6 on the other hand works great and fast, but most apps on the AppStore don't work anymore (apps that require iOS7). Yet all old installed apps still work fine. On a Samsung Android tablet from the same year (2011) you still can install the latest apps, and get the latest AppStore and Google app updates (but stuck in old Android 4.x) - those AppStore updates slow down the device more and more. So it's not black and white.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- awakeasleep 9y agoIt's a shame that none of the policy suggestions for something like this would leave Apple's Activation Lock unscathed. Activation lock caused something like a sustained 50% drop in phone thefts the year it was implemented. Before that, stealing phones was starting to look like stealing shoes in the 90's. It even had its own slang, "apple picking".
- pxeboot 9y agoMaking replacement parts and repair manuals available wouldn't meaningfully hurt device activation schemes. Sure, somebody could buy and replace the logic board in a stolen phone, but criminals are already able to do that with used or stolen parts.
- andrepd 9y ago>Activation lock caused something like a sustained 50% drop in phone thefts the year it was implemented I'm extremely skeptical about that. Can you post sources? And why do you say that these proposals are not compatible with Activation Lock-style schemes?
- wvenable 9y agohttp://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-usa-smartphone-killswitch/smartphone-theft-drops-in-london-two-u-s-cities-as-anti-theft-kill-switches-installed-idUKKBN0LF09320150211 http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-usa-smartphone-killswitch/s...
- shakna 9y ago> Thefts involving smartphones have declined dramatically in three major cities since manufacturers began implementing “kill switches” that allow the phones to be turned off remotely if they are stolen, authorities said on Tuesday. > Johnson, San Francisco District Attorney George Gascon and New York state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman were among numerous officials arguing for new laws mandating the kill switches. So phone theft decreased in cities considering mandating remote kill switches. That seems less Activation Lock, and more: > So far, Apple, Samsung and Google have implemented kill switches on their smartphones, and Microsoft is expected to release an operating system for its Windows phones that has one this year ... the fact that everyone is bringing such a technology to market at similar timelines. --- As for the claimed 50% drop: > The number of stolen iPhones dropped by 40 percent in San Francisco and 25 percent in New York in the 12 months after Apple Inc added a kill switch to its devices in September 2013. In London, smartphone theft dropped by half, according to an announcement by officials in the three cities. That's an average below 40%, but those aren't stats. They're rounded figures. And only in three cities, over the whole world.
- WaxProlix 9y agoCan someone from the American Libertarian cadre on HN chime in on this? I see some examples of people talking about how this might be 'necessary' (see gt_'s comment(s)) but I'm interested in an ideological assessment of this situation.
- freedomben 9y agoThis is an issue that kind of splits Libertarians. However there are a few fairly commonly accepted points: 1. This is a big issue because of DMCA requirements, and DMCA should not exist (that is enough to address the problem according to many Libertarians) 2. The government should not be getting in between transactions between two private entities (public corporations are considered private entities in this context, because they are not government controlled), unless there are externalities that warrant such intrusion. It could well be argued that there are externalities in this (the waste created as a result of it is a great example), though I think that's a slightly different argument. Here's a couple of brief but interesting discussions on reddit: 1. https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/4spfwf/the_fight_for_the_right_to_repair/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/4spfwf/the_fig... 2. https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/36c857/thoughts_on_digital_right_to_repair_acts/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Libertarian/comments/36c857/thought...
- pitaj 9y agoA lot of the issues people have seem to relate to two things: licensing as opposed to ownership, and IP law. Some licensing schemes may just count as ownership under common law, so would be unenforceable. The really awful ones only exist because of a lack of competition, most likely due to patents and copyright, which I holistically oppose, along with copyright and most copyright law (some exceptions, like certain trademarks, exist because they are essentially fraud).
- KGIII 9y agoThere are many, many varied beliefs in Libertarianism - even within America and within the Libertarian Party. On the political compass, it is opposite authoritarianism. Taken to extremes, it is anarchy. It can have left or right components. It's quite a spectrum. That said, the commons must be protected. The right to repair would qualify as the commons. At the same time, forcing companies to excessive standards isn't always the best answer. In a perfect world, we'd have perfect information and rational buyers. We don't have that. As the other poster suggested, getting rid of the DMCA would be a good start. I'd say companies should not be allowed to actively prevent repair or modification, but doing so renders the warranty invalid. I'm pretty far over in the left side. I'm probably best defined as a libertarian socialist, not too far from the social democrats of Europe.
- bluetwo 9y agoIf you want to influence lawmakers, you have to bring their attention to the issue when they are running for office. MAKE IT A CAMPAIGN ISSUE!
- sandov 9y agoWhy not better educate people about the fact that some devices are easier to repair than others?. If they care about it, they will naturally buy stuff that's repair-friendly, even if it's a niche market. I care about repairing my stuff, and avoid buying anything that is intentionally designed to being unrepairable. I've specifically not bought any Apple product because of that.
- acuozzo 9y ago> Why not better educate people about the fact that some devices are easier to repair than others? People are far more likely to care more about devices that are easy to use than ones that are easy to repair. My father, for instance, just barely has sufficient skill to make use of his iPhone, but it has considerably improved his life. I don't imagine anyone could convince or train him to use something different solely on the basis of it being easy to repair. He's going to have to pay someone to repair it for him anyway, so what does it matter if it's Apple or someone else? I imagine he'd happily exchange it for whatever the latest model is if a technician were to imply that an upgrade would fix his hypothetical problem. One important consideration here is that smartphones are of use to a market which includes people willfully resistant to relearning.
- reificator 9y agoMy Surface Pro 4 no longer detects its own internal drive. Is the connection loose? Do I need to replace the drive? I don't know because I can't open it up easily. This is weird for me because I've always been able to reliably do my own repairs, even on my previous MacBook Pro. To now realize that my Surface is worthless unless I'm still barely within the warranty period is unsettling.
- snuxoll 9y agoOh man, don't get me started on doing any repairs on the surface line. It took me FOREVER to safely replace the battery on my aunts old Surface RT because it bit the bullet, and the only choice for a replacement was an after market Chinese battery I don't fully trust. I warned her of the risks, but she didn't want to spend the money on a new device - so now I'm just hoping it doesn't catch fire before she finally replaces it.
- reificator 9y agoOuch, that's actually scary. Good luck.
- bproven 9y agoUnfortunately, Macbooks and Macbook Pros are like this now too :( Apple will say it is necessary to make it as thin and efficient as possible. But that has a smell to it. My Dell XPS 15 9550 can be easily serviced : the SDD, Memory, wifi card and battery are all accessible and it doesn't sacrifice (much) thinness or weight to accomplish. I sometimes wonder if the customer would be OK with Macbooks being 1mm thicker with user replaceable parts. There is only so thin you can go... If Apple wants claim to tell a sustainability story or to be "green" this planned obsolescence stuff needs to go.
- reificator 9y agoYeah, I brought up the MBP specifically because they've always been kind of unpleasant to work on. But at least you used to be able to. My surface died yesterday and if I don't have a warranty still, it's dead to me. I'm not sure I'm even going to try opening it up based on what I've seen.
- acidtrucks 9y agoI would love to see a company whose business model is making generic and standard consumer electronics parts that are small and powerful, with options to boot. I would love it if I could build & maintain my own mobile computer (AKA smartphone) just as I would build my own PC. Since taking my kindle voyage apart, I realize that this must be very doable. That thing is way less sophisticated than a raspberry pi, it just happens to be a form factor that I like to hold.
- TylerE 9y agoThere's a huge gap between an ereader and a smartphone.
- sohkamyung 9y agoProbably not what you are looking for but I'm keeping an eye on Fairphone [1], a company that tries to ethically source for phone parts and ensures that you can repair the phone you buy from them. [1] https://www.fairphone.com/en/ https://www.fairphone.com/en/
- jpindar 9y ago1. small 2. powerful 3. with options 4. easy to work on without special (possibly custom) equipment choose two
- acidtrucks 9y agoI would rather have a larger handheld device than my Nexus 5x if it meant I control the hardware and software on it. 2/3/4 I think can be worked out by the consumer market as long as standards can be crafted for modularity.
- mmphosis 9y agoI would love it if I could build & maintain my own mobile computer (AKA smartphone) just as I would build my own PC. I would love to build and maintain my own PC, but I assume that Intel Management Engine (ME) or the equivilent is going to come with the CPU for the PC I build.
- Entangled 9y agoI wish I could install whatever I want on my phone without jailbreaking it. Let us have an option hidden in the settings (just like developer options) so we can install anything we want without permission or without the app expiring in a few days. It's my damn phone!
- scarface74 9y agoYou can install any piece of code you want on your phone. If it's open source, you can download XCode, compile from source and put it on your own device without paying for a developer's license. I'm not going to install some random piece of closed source software that couldn't make it through Apple's review process. No I'm not treating my phone differently than my computer. I have no random software on my computer from untrusted sources. I even bought my last Dell from the Microsoft store so I wouldn't have random crapware on it.
- michaelmrose 9y agoYou can install anything you want supposing the developer releases it in the wild as source with no hope of making money off AND no hope of normal users making use of it. Doesn't sound useful to me.
- scarface74 9y agoHow much money do you really think a developer can make without going through the App Store? Can you name one successful profitable Android app that isn't sold in the Google Play Store even though Android devices have been able to sideload for years?
- flukus 9y ago> How much money do you really think a developer can make without going through the App Store? A lot. Your mistake here is in thinking that all software is direct to consumer. Being able to install software without going through a store is very important for a lot of small to medium business that have custom or customized software. You can do it with android, you could do it with windows mobile in the 90's, it's mostly just apple that want to exert so much control over you.
- arca_vorago 9y agoI wish people on hn wouldn't be so opposed to GPL and copy left licensing, because the four freedoms as presented by RMS really saw this coming a long time ago. The same principles apply to hardware. I think its a salient point that the same companies opposed to or abusing copy left are the same ones locking users out from hardware repairs.
- jordigh 9y ago> RMS really saw this coming a long time ago And one of the reasons for GPLv3: the anti-tivoisation clause. You should be allowed to install modified software in your own devices. People have misconstrued anti-tivoisation that to mean that Apple can't keep malware out of your iPhone by key signatures, but that's not what it means, nor was it the primary reason why Apple wanted to prevent their users from installing unsigned software. It's about giving control to users and giving them both the key and the lock and letting them decide what goes on their own machines. Trying to paternalistically tell users what they can and cannot install has culminated in a method of control for repairs and obsolescence.
- abritinthebay 9y agoThat isn't what it means but the problem with it is that it has extra knock on effects. There is a reason GPL v2 was incredibly popular and GPLv3 basically killed all momentum and it wasn't because GPLv3 was better. At least not from a business point of view. And that, at its core, is the issue. In a world where the only licence is GPLv3... it works. But in a world where people can choose other licenses - it won't be the choice of most. It's a shame because I love the GPLv2 but I'll never use GPLv3 and honestly it's just less hassle to chose MIT for most companies.
- tree_of_item 9y agoWhy is the "business point of view" relevant here? It's the business point of view that got us DRM in the first place.
- 9y ago
- userbinator 9y agoInteresting article coming from the IEEE, who has historically been very pro-DRM, anti-consumer. Back in 2012, Toshiba told laptop repair tech Tim Hicks that he needed to remove 300 PDFs of Toshiba’s official repair manuals from his website, where he was offering the information for free. To avoid being sued, Hicks complied, and now fewer people have the guidance they need to repair Toshiba laptops. Of course, you can still find the manuals if you know where to look, and even complete schematics --- no doubt leaked by those in the far East who actually have access. There's always been an underground repair movement, sharing manuals and other information and reverse-engineering as necessary[1][2]; but that's getting rarer as things get more "secure", and the sites themselves being DMCA'd or otherwise taken down. Perhaps LibGen/SciHub could start a subsidiary specifically for hosting such leaked/"samizdat" repair information, given how they seem to be staying alive despite copyright... [1] https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=446 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=446 [2] https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=1970 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=1970
- sohkamyung 9y ago> Interesting article coming from the IEEE, who has historically been very pro-DRM, anti-consumer. The article was written by Kyle Wiens (from iFixit) and Gay Gordon-Byrne (from Repair.org ). It might not represent the opinions of IEEE Spectrum (the magazine which published the article). Do you have a link or references to the 'pro DRM' or 'anti-consumer' stance of the IEEE? As an IEEE Member, I would like to know about such things about the organisation.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoNot specifically about DRM, but just their general attitude towards transparency and implementability. Making standards non-public (as in, for anyone to look at on the web for free) is a pretty anti-consumer thing to do, as is creating standards that include patented technology. The usefulness of standards for the consumer is interoperability. Both of those things actively prevent interoperability.
- 9y ago
- sumitgt 9y agoThe pressure from consumers is in the favor of slimmer, sleeker gadgets. This causes manufacturers to use production techniques that make repairing impossible. So even if companies made every little detail about the internals of the product public, it's gonna be of not much use to repair today's cellphones that are held together essentially by glue. I understand what the EFF is trying to say, but frankly, consumers have chosen with their wallets on this one.
- tzmudzin 9y ago> The pressure from consumers is in the favor of slimmer, sleeker gadgets. This causes manufacturers to use production techniques that make repairing impossible. How does that apply to the John Deere tractors or your next car?
- Kadin 9y ago> consumers have chosen with their wallets on this one. There are plenty of situations where we do not simply let the default selection made by consumers stand, because often that choice is suboptimal or intensely shortsighted. Particularly when economies of scale often push the preferences of a small number of early-adopter consumers onto the rest of the market, whether they have the same preferences or not. More generally, expecting a consumer operating with very limited information, limited time, and limited interest and incentives, to make a purchasing decision that may have substantial unaccounted (and unpriced!) externalities is foolish. We should stop treating the consumer's off-the-cuff decision of what to purchase as holy writ, given the many examples of consumers happily trading away the "right" to purchase shitty products in an unregulated market for higher quality products in a regulated one.
- sixdimensional 9y agoSo, I work in obsolescence trying to support systems that operate for upwards of 20-30 years. It has been a real learning experience, as I have a much longer product lifecycle to support, and yet, we burn through material for repairs. There is very little actual board repair or similar, more pull out a entire assembly, toss it and put it an entire new assembly. Wasteful, just like Apple or similar saying to just throw out the entire device (or recycle it). I don't like it, but ultimately I can see our disposable consumer culture really manifested through this situation. Most commercial-off-the-shelf components are not made to last for time to market, material and cost reasons. If they were, the pace of technological development might decrease and cost would probably increase. Sometimes I wonder if we have progressed "enough" technologically to step back and use the power we have to build some long term support/sustainable technology infrastructure. Yet I fear unless our hand is forced, we will persist in the current trends of using a lot of energy and raw material to produce something that doesn't last long enough, and then sell "recycling" as the solution. Can the recycling chain really make up for all the energy, and activity consumed and pollution/byproducts produced throughout the process? Sometimes I wonder if we spent more time on modular, upgradeable designs, long term support components, etc. we might fair better. Easier said than done? Sustainable engineering/manufacturing is a complex, emerging science. Still, obsolescence is a many headed hydra, whether you do long term support or planned obsolescence. I don't see any easy answers but I'm looking!
- penglish1 9y agoThanks IEEE. While we're at it, we'd also like it if you opened your standards process, and included the general public and especially security researchers in all your drafts.
- kwiens 9y agoFair point! I wrote this long before the KRACK vuln but I've been very uncomfortable with the closed nature of IEEE standards that I've participated in. But I've still contributed, so I reckon I'm still complicit. For what it's worth, that's why we published essentially the entire oManual spec for free online so you can build compatible products to IEEE 1874 without having to purchase the standard. http://www.omanual.org/ http://www.omanual.org/
- amckinlay 9y agoWhat about the right to use our electronics? Google has been silently pushing their "SafetyNet" APIs into Android, including an "attestation" API[1] that dynamically fetches and runs an opaque binary program[2] served and signed by Google that collects whatever data they deem necessary to verify the "integrity" of a device. Devices that are rooted will not fail to attest via the API. Devices where the user has chosen to install a custom ROM will fail to attest (even with a locked bootloader and no root). Apps from Google Play can use these APIs to decide whether to work on a user's device. This is macOS SIP taken to a different level. You can't watch Netflix and whatever other app decides to use these APIs unless Google has complete control over your device, including the ability to remotely collect and transmit opaque and arbitrary data at any time. This is a dishonest attempt to disguise a draconian DRM scheme as pro-user, pro-safety, anti-virus/rootkit. We're at the point where you don't even own your own filesystem anymore on a Linux device. I think this is a step beyond traditional DRM, including traditional hardware content protection. [1] https://developer.android.com/training/safetynet/attestation.html https://developer.android.com/training/safetynet/attestation... [2] https://koz.io/inside-safetynet/ https://koz.io/inside-safetynet/
- farhanhubble 9y agoNot only mobiles, PC OEMs are going to extreme lengths to tie down the users into using whatever crap the manufacturer installs by default.
- sspiff 9y agoCare to explain what you mean by that? As far as I can tell, vendors ship crapware as software installed on Windows, and you can always remove it by reinstalling Windows or often just uninstalling the bundled software. Do they ever go beyond that?
- inapis 9y agoLenovo used the UEFI/BIOS tables to load crapware back into a fresh retail user-installed windows setup. The bios table was named Window Platform Binary Table
- feelin_googley 9y ago"Bowing to public pressure, Apple apologized and fixed the broken phones with a new [software] update. But a precedent had been set. Previously, Apple had made it difficult for people to fix its products by restricting access to parts and service information." "When you buy such a machine, the hardware becomes yours. But if you ask manufacturers, theyll say that the software inside still belongs to them." Apple's strategy has been to make repair difficult by restricting information and access to parts. They can send C&D letters to anyone who publishes information about repair. But what about users, who are not publishing information about repair? Apple cannot send C&D letters to users, who are free to use the hardware however they wish. Apple may have IP covering manufacture and modifications to the hardware, they may have IP covering information about the hardware, but they have no IP on the use of the hardware that they could assert against users. However because users rely on Apple-controlled software, Apple could manipulate the use of the device via automatic software updates. And that is exactly what they did. The solution for the user is to select hardware that allows users to install their own choice of open source software instead of giving away control over the hardware to a corporation via corporate-controlled software and "automatic updates".
- kwiens 9y agoWell that's the point of iFixit — we have hundreds of thousands of people around the world writing their own repair info to fill the void that the manufacturers left. It's working out pretty well so far.
- threatofrain 9y agoWe must push for the right of comprehensible ownership, not the right to repair your electronics. We must stop the consumer trend of not really owning things, but instead buying a license to use something. Consumers don't keep track of every little law or right, and must rely on intuition to guide their sense. Ignorance of the law is a most forgivable excuse to forgetting you have some right or protection in the first place, and a "license to use" breaks a lot of citizens understanding of their legal relationship to the goods they acquired from the market, and the kind of protections their society offers them. Most citizens don't imagine that they cannot repair or break apart their Ikea furniture. Of course I'm not saying that ordinary people want to break open their phones or laptops, but they may want to take it to a repair shop.
- pimmen 9y agoThe big problem is that manufacturers want to eat their cake and have it too. Imagine if the CPSC would require that they pitch accurately: "And for just $699, you can sign up for an indefinite license to use this magnificent product, ladies and gentlemen! Yes, for that price, you'll be a lucky phone-renter!" If you want to tap into people's desire to own a phone you can't tell them you're filling that desire and then turn around and say "well, what is ownership anyway?".
- npsimons 9y ago> Consumers don't keep track of every little law or right This came up in a similar form in the discussion about IoT devices and privacy. We hold doctors and civil engineers to standards to protect the public, why shouldn't we do the same for software and hardware that could ruin your life? If you don't think this is a problem, or businesses have a "right" to pursue profits at all costs, you are a part of the problem and need to kindly find another industry to harm.
- threatofrain 9y ago> If you don't think this is a problem, or businesses have a "right" to pursue profits at all costs, you are a part of the problem and need to kindly find another industry to harm. You might have a romantic model of the medical system, but I certainly don't think that any business in any industry should be able to pursue profits without any moral restraint.
- IndrekR 9y agoWhat about the right to repair our software? Running a electronics engineering house here and we can easily see 9:1 ratio of software:hardware people-time ratio in bringing a device to the market. Varies heavily from project to project, but solutions in SW tend to scale better.
- pasta 9y agoI have mixed feelings about this. Somehow people think they have the right to buy the brand they like. But this is not how the market works. You can always choose not to buy it. Don't like how Apple solders everything to the main board and glues the screen glass to the body? Just don't buy Apple. But this can be a difficult decision because of things like 'status', vendor lock in, greed, and what not. The feeling that you can't live without Apple, Facebook, Android, Instagram, and so on, is a strange thing. And it's one of the things I don't like about todays society.
- mk89 9y agoIs it so hard for a company nowadays to produce average phones in a sustainable way and that are consumer-oriented? I think this is what’s missing: a player that simply reads about frustrated users and creates product for them. I am quite sure it won’t be as successful as Apple but not as bad as the last failed company. I read recently that material costs for a Samsung phone increased of 10% in 5 years. Now, why can’t a phone be sold for 400 usd and be respectful for consumers? I get it that companies live out ot money, but i can’t believe that there is not a single company doing differently!
- chii 9y agoThe problem is that such measures aren't important to the 'average' user, which means your market for such libre phones aren't going to recover the capital costs needed to invest to start-up the operation!
- mk89 9y agoIt would be interesting to have numbers here, because I think that people are becoming more and more aware and tired of buying a 3-400 euro phone every 2 years. What are the improvements these new phones carry along? I have a relatively old phone, but the only features I see with newer phones are the following: - better hardware, like more cpu, more ram, better camera - support for fingerprints - android updates There is actually an alternative, I wasn't aware of it: https://fairphone.com/en/ https://fairphone.com/en/ But hell, no, 2017 and they still offer Android 6.0! And it seems that they are more related to "fairness" in production, etc. It's the "eco" phone which is probably sponsored by green parties :) That's not actually what I meant in the parent comment, where I was asking for a company that produces simply "average" consumer-oriented phones. If these guys do it, why can't another company do the same?
- MrQuincle 9y agoThere are so many rights we have to fight for first (saying from a company that builds open source hardware products). + The right to have your data not being used in ways you wouldn't give permission for. + The right to have your data and devices properly protected against malignant actors + The right to be able to use your devices as you want, resell them, use them years after you bought them + The right to expect standards to apply. If you are relying on 110V, it should not be 180V. By the way, just standardization for power plugs/outlets would already save more money and resources than you can probably imagine. Especially if we enforce same grid voltage and freq everywhere in the world. Electrical engineering is too important to leave to individual nation states. There are other non-rights, like usability, look and feel, and prestige that are much more important to everybody than anything w.r.t. fiddling around with your stuff.
- DoubleGlazing 9y agoI know a few people who bought Smart TVs from various manufacturers a few years ago and the Smart functions have one by one been withdrawn as the manufacturers no longer supports them. E.G. YouTube, Netflix and other media player apps. Eventually you are left with a TV with a pretty basic, slow and probably insecure web browser. We got nearly 30 years out of Teletext, nowadays expecting a Smart TV app to be supported for five years is being optimistic. And will the manufactures open up their TV OSes to allow 3rd parties to offer support. Of course not, but they will helpfully let you know how great their new TVs are.
- acuozzo 9y ago> I know a few people who bought Smart TVs from various manufacturers a few years ago and the Smart functions have one by one been withdrawn as the manufacturers no longer supports them. This is the #1 reason I restricted myself to purchasing a Smart TV which uses Android TV rather than something written by the OEM.
- moocowtruck 9y agoDILLY DILLY!
- npsimons 9y agoI'm happy that IEEE is recognizing this, but there's a reason I'm no longer a member: IEEE supports software patents. Might want to remove that beam from their own eye first . . .
- zbentley 9y agoThe article and some other comments here honestly just made me nostalgic for the first Apple computer I owned, an early generation "unibody" cast aluminum MacBook Pro. It was, bar none, the easiest modern laptop to open up and service I've ever worked on, and I did that professionally for several years. Simple screws, minimal variation in screw size, solid steel parts, no silly plastic tabs, and nothing that felt like "this didn't need to be taped in, but using tape/glue/whatever sure makes it easy for official warranty support people to tell if you've been tinkering around in there." Replacing entire logic boards, or doing even trickier work like re-cementing CPU heatsinks, was incredibly easy and intuitive even without a manual (which was fortunate, since the official maintenance/manual documentation was pretty expensive to get access to legally). Apple gets a lot of crap for the declining serviceability of their laptops, but remember that it wasn't always this way. Things have gotten way worse, and for pretty transparently dumb reasons. The "tamper-proof" screws were the stick that broke the camel's back for me; I was willing to give Apple the benefit of the doubt regarding hyper-restrictive hardware compatibility checks and proprietary connectors, but when they made the physical tooling itself pointlessly expensive/difficult to get (torx was already a widespread standard; why give pentalobe, already a bastard stepchild, more market share?), I started being a lot more suspicious. Where were the people surreptitiously opening up laptops and stealing RAM? Or installing hardware keyloggers? Instead, "tamperer" turned out to be basically the same as "hobbyist", "non-blessed repairman", or "curious kid who wants to know what the inside of their computer looks like". And the party line I've heard from colleagues who work for Apple is inane: "it damages the reliability of the brand to let anyone poke around inside; they can break stuff!" Any hobbyist, aspiring geek, or unsanctioned technician knows what they're getting into. Anyone in those groups, or anyone handing their computer over to such a person, isn't going to blame Apple when tinkering/inspection causes issues (if they do, they'll be laughed at by anyone who hears them). Either it was broken and the maintenance/tinkering fixed it, it wasn't broken and it was after being opened up, or it was broken and remained that way. Sigh. End rant. I miss the good old days, I guess. Snow Leopard and hardware that was elegant, simple, and easy to fix and use. I'll go back to working on my lawn now, so I can tell kids to get off of it. Monsanto considers it an illegal modification and TOS violation to water the MiracleGrass I planted, so now it's all dead and I have to seed it again.
- arpgy 9y agoThe way the situation is evolving is that they are NOT 'our' electronics. We think we are buying them to own them, but in reality what it gets you is the right to use the device only for as long manufacturer wants, and only in a manner deemed appropriate by the manufacturer. It's more than a fight about tinkering or repairing, it's a fight about ownership.
- MR4D 9y agoI’m curious: when everything electronic is printed in a level 4 clean room and printed together at nanoscale, will this even be relevant? For instance, computers went from chips on boards (think Apple II) to basically just chips (any cellphone). What happens when thins are even further integrated? Will this even matter? I honestly don’t know the answer. Maybe we all just hack chips with our local x-ray fab down the block. The future is getting weirder.