4 ms·
Under a Communist party dictatorship, you don't vastly consolidate power, purge tens of thousands of people on supposed corruption charges, disappear prominent
by adventured 9y ago
Under a Communist party dictatorship, you don't vastly consolidate power, purge tens of thousands of people on supposed corruption charges, disappear prominent business leaders, curtail numerous freedoms, alter the power structure of the party and its influence wings (such as the youth league), and build yourself up as the new Mao or Deng Xiaoping - if your intention is not to seize control for yourself. Xi Jinping was never doing all of that just to hand power to the next leader and it certainly wasn't for the benefit of the Chinese people.
He's their new dictator, most likely until old age removes him. He'll rule China for 20 years.
The short list of people that should be terrified of what's obviously coming next: Jack Ma, Pony Ma, Robin Li. The next step in power consolidation, is to begin taking over greater government control of Tencent, Alibaba and Baidu. It will be necessary to reduce Jack Ma's economic power in China, ultimately these giants are a challenge (or potential challenge) to Xi Jinping's dictatorship. Alibaba + Alipay is increasingly becoming the center of China's economy, more and more of that economy is flowing through those entities.
Prediction: Jack Ma won't last more than another three to five years in his current prominent position. Economic power always falls by necessity to the kind of political power that Xi Jinping increasingly wields.
- bsaul 9y agoIf you scenario is correct (which i think it is), it will be a textbook example on the inability of non-democratic regimes to maintain economical growth in the long run. I say textbook, because as opposed to nazis and USSR , it would have all happened without a war (hopefully).
- ars 9y ago> that should be terrified of what's obviously coming next: Jack Ma, Pony Ma, Robin Li. A ruler can not rule without people. It's more likely he will "convince" them to support him. (Or they might see which way the wind is blowing and not need convincing.) 2nd to the throne is still a very powerful position after all. They should be fine. It's people who are opposed to him that are at risk.
- simonh 9y agoAll the Chinese online services are already subservient to the government, which has deep hooks into their communications and transaction systems to monitor the activities of businesses, organisations and citizens. It's already been done. You don't get to be a fraction of the size of any of these companies without 'opening the kimono', to borrow a Japanese phrase, as wide as it goes. As long as Jack Ma and his cohort cooperate fully with the authorities and continue greasing the right wheels, they will be left alone and in fact will be cherished and protected as the cornerstones of the surveillance state they have already become.
- nopinsight 9y agoIt is possible to interprete his actions as much more benevolent than what your statements imply. Two of the strongest grievances among ordinary Chinese are: 1) prevalent corruption within the party and the resulting unfair advantages among those with connections 2) pollution and environmental degradation, which partly stem from 1). When corruption is so widespread in the whole governing system, there is probably no way to greatly reduce it in short order without consolidating power and using it decisively. My hypothesis is Xi does want to become very powerful and influential but more in the style of a legendary statesman who plays a pivotal role in developing China into a new era. I would bet that he will step down in 5-10 years from now but retain power behind the scene through the people he picks and more importantly the system he reforms and develops. The three Internet giants, including the entrepreneurs who lead them, will likely be safe because Chinese leaders will want capable hands to steer them into dominating positions at the global scale, not least since they will most likely comply with the ideology and wishes of Chinese political leaders without much resistance.
- whatshisface 9y ago>When corruption is so widespread in the whole governing system, there is probably no way to greatly reduce it in short order without consolidating power and using it decisively. Xi isn't consolidating power away from the grocery inspectors that like to be tipped. No one human has the vast reach that would be required to see in to every single government action, down to the lowest levels. The only way to stop corruption is to ensure a free press with an empowered and informed population. That's not the direction that China's going.
- Sangermaine 9y ago>Prediction: Jack Ma won't last more than another three to five years in his current prominent position. Economic power always falls by necessity to the kind of political power that Xi Jinping increasingly wields. Already happening: "Chinese crackdown on dealmakers reflects Xi power play" https://www.ft.com/content/ed900da6-769b-11e7-90c0-90a9d1bc9691 https://www.ft.com/content/ed900da6-769b-11e7-90c0-90a9d1bc9...
- r00fus 9y agoHidden behind paywall.
- fossuser 9y ago"The creatures outside looked from pig to man, and from man to pig, and from pig to man again; but already it was impossible to say which was which." If the allegory in Animal Farm is an accurate representation of the communist party then all of the things you mentioned sound about right.
- mtgx 9y agoAll of that was coupled with a new law that would basically require companies to have backdoors in their products, either directly or through "ventures" with a local Chinese company (pretty much all major US tech companies have already agreed to this), a more aggressive crackdown on VPNs and encryption, including cryptocurrencies, a recently launched advanced video mass surveillance system, and the soon-to-launch "Citizen Score" system. All of that meant to ensure Xi will be able to rule with an ironfist with no questions asked (or if the questions are asked, they will be swiftly silenced). Remember you will be supporting this regime the next time you decide to use a Baidu software framework in your app, or buy a Xiaomi phone. Yes, all smartphones and such are manufactured in China, but at least we can see the end of that road with robotics and automation set-up in other countries. Killing global Chinese brands will be harder, if they are allowed to grow.
- liberte82 9y agoI went to Jack Ma's wikipedia page to learn more about him. It's one of the most strangely written articles I've ever read. It reads like a 7th grader's essay. An excerpt: > In 1994, Ma heard about the Internet. In early 1995, he went to the US and with his friends they helped him get introduced to the Internet. During his first encounter he searched the word "beer".