5 ms·
Fact Checks
- sedeki 9y agoSupercool idea! I wonder what the W3C has to say about it though.
- quotemstr 9y agoWhat could possibly go wrong?
- worldsayshi 9y agoI guess there's no point in trying? /s
- Spivak 9y agoRight, but when the most likely outcome is that it will make the problem worse rather than solving the argument for not trying becomes a little stronger.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoThis leads to this interesting page: https://support.google.com/news/publisher/answer/4582731#satire https://support.google.com/news/publisher/answer/4582731#sat...
- age_bronze 9y agoThis will be abused by trolls more than used by the "good guys". It's just a matter of time before some trolls decide to use this feature to create more lies about elections, hitler, holocaust, immigrants, and every conspiracy theory out there. You're going to search "who did 9/11" and have false websites trying to "fact check" the top pages (which at least today seem to be sane).
- mitchty 9y agoYep, 4chan will have a field day with this. I think the goal of this is to harness the wisdom of experts, but can't help but think the end result of this will just be more noise in signal to noise search ratio. Without human input as to what is correct and real of these inputs, its just another input that can be gamed.
- username223 9y agoPretty much. Google was sad when it realized that 10^x layers of "Deep Learning" couldn't detect propaganda, and it will be sad when trying to get people to do it for free doesn't work, either.
- jkeat 9y agoI could see this working if sites with a good track record were trusted more when making claims. A site's trustability could be punished when one of its fact checks is flagged for review and discovered to be wrong. Will be interesting with Wikipedia in the mix. It could be the web's fact checking backbone.
- JetSpiegel 9y ago> I could see this working if sites with a good track record were trusted more when making claims. Google mentions this in the docs, but if it's page ranking, that can be gamed, and if it's "pay us to be a fact checker", well...
- olivermarks 9y agoI'd love to know how you would check 'true or false' on logic based speculation such as this article on the recent Las Vegas shootings https://www.veteranstoday.com/2017/10/20/las-vegas-massacre-analysis/ https://www.veteranstoday.com/2017/10/20/las-vegas-massacre-...
- waegawegawe 9y ago-1 => "Not even wrong/conspiracy theory" Honestly, this isn't the sort of thing that needs to be fact-checked. It just needs to be tagged as being baseless. It's a little different than the types of things this solution is aimed at.
- olivermarks 9y agoI disagree. this is Google's tools being used to speculate on why there are so many discrepancies and unexplained things in the 'official' narrative of what happened. As I said previously, how do you 'fact check' something which is questioning those logic lapses. 'Being tagged as baseless' reminds me of the old Soviet Union.
- tangue 9y agoWe don't need russians anymore. Google's new mission : organising the world fake information and making it accessible to everyone.
- pizza 9y agoIt's a good thing Eddie Bernays never ran Google
- sitkack 9y agoPretty sure Schmidt has read all of his books.
- idibidiart 9y agoQuasi-distributed censorship.
- cisanti 9y agoIt's absurd for content creators to implement it. Google will leech your work and use it to build their Google brain bigger, when you're not necessary anymore, Google will ditch you. Same with the stupid Google catchas that make me sick.
- exelius 9y agoLooks like this is only for approved Google News sources. It’s a good start, but I’d be worried about relying on something like this.
- geofft 9y agoGiven that Google News literally showed a 4chan thread about an invented Islamic terrorist as a news source during the Las Vegas shooting, I'm extremely skeptical that this will end well.
- Spivak 9y agoSure, but at some point Google has to decide whether they're a search engine and should return relevant results based on what the user is looking for or a publisher that curates results and is therefore responsible for the content that appears in their results.
- gleenn 9y agoI think the trolls will obviously come out to attack this but it seems like a nice extra data point from sites. They aren't obligated to show the data, they could just whitelist sites that they believe are 100% not trolls and then consider other sources based on a history of correctness or human verification. Imagine if they just added the top 10 news sites as valid sources. Then I bet some site like Snopes would pop up as valid because they had a history of agreement with some credible source. It's like Pagerank with trust instead of inbound links.
- monocasa 9y agoGoogle has a logistical leg up here, in that the internet isn't a sea of faceless IP addresses like it might be for a startup in the same position. Google has a lot of information on us explaining how to rate this new information.
- patrickaljord 9y agoI wonder how far they are willing to go with this. How about these kinds of claims: "Increasing the minimum wage helps improve the economy" * Fact check by Conservative-example: false * Fact check by Progressive-example: true Another good one: "God exists": * Fact check by Conservative-example: true * Fact check by Progressive-example: false This is going to be fun. This is typical of Google, providing a technical solution to a human problem that can't be solved easily. Not everything can be tweaked with an algorithm.
- darawk 9y agoYes, but that's actually a great thing. It allows Google to discern controversy. If people disagree about a fact, that's fine, Google can choose how to present facts that have that property. For the ones people do agree about, they can present them as truth.
- trendia 9y agoThere are things that are false that everyone believes and things that are true that nobody believes... Google's algorithns weren't designed to tell the truth, only to tell what's popular.
- synesso 9y agoOtherwise known as "common sense". If this in an engine to promote common sense then we're just digging ourselves a bigger hole.
- wallace_f 9y agoThank you. For example, one of the worst forms of evidence, that is not permitted as science, is eye witness testimony. People are too fallible be relied on. We only forget that because of our judicial system, unfortunately. But what's even worse than that is what's next in line: a collection of testimonial opinions, or a democracy on truth, especially one run by a non-opensource algorithm. Maybe nothing bad will come of this, but every step Google makes has me worried that they will abuse their power. There's something that seems dangerous about a nation of people fact checking primarily via a single corporation. Remember when NASA burned up the Challenger space shuttle because of the groupthink that prevented a couple engineers from letting everyone know that they knew this would happen? And NASA is not evil, nor have incentives to allow this, which is why we need to work together to be dilligent to protect ourselves from these problems--they easily sneak in.
- swanson 9y agoEveryone: "We've got a problem with fake news and journalistic integrity on the internet." Google engineers: "Oh, I can make an API for that!"
- worldsayshi 9y agoWell, this is a problem caused by technology to begin with. I don't get the negativity directed to the intention of this. Sure you can criticise the particular execution.
- Spivak 9y agoIt's a problem that has always existed. We are only now more aware of it because there are fewer barriers to communication. Technology is an easy scapegoat for what are very human problems.
- jkeat 9y agoIt's a problem that can't be stamped out, yes, but we should try to mitigate it, no?
- swanson 9y agoPartisan fact checking -- which this effort intends to standardize and elevate -- is part of the problem, not the solution.
- zimpenfish 9y agoCan you explain this?
- gweinberg 9y agoThis sounds very useful, and I can think of at least one claim I would very much like Google to fact check. It involves an alleged difference in the distribution of personality rates between men and women.
- smsm42 9y agoFact check: False. Verified by: You want to be fired, don't you?
- icebraining 9y agoWhat's a personality rate?
- gweinberg 9y agoI meant to say "traits". I'm not even going to try to figure out how that came our as "rates".
- taysic 9y agoThat assumes such a question could be definitively answered. First you’d need to quantify the scale of personality traits. Too much of the discussion around this is hand wavey.
- dwaltrip 9y agoMy understanding is that the big 5 personality traits have been shown to be fairly robust and quantifiable. Caveat: I have only recently begun digging into this area.
- tomcam 9y agoNice try, Mr. Damore ;)
- droopybuns 9y agoThe only winning strategy is skepticism of all claims. The idea that computers will help discern absolute truth in matters that mostly are based on opinions and prejudice is pitiable and arrogant.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zitterbewegung 9y agoThis is an interesting idea that seems like a good attempt in informing others . But the big issue people don’t believe facts whether they are presented with information that refutes it. They believe facts because it aligns with their ideology.
- Spivak 9y agoBut of course you are above that sort of thing. Condescension isn't an argument.
- westurner 9y agoIndeed, fact checking systems are only as good as the link between identity credentialing services and a person. http://schema.org/ClaimReview http://schema.org/ClaimReview (as mentioned in this article) is a good start. A few other approaches to be aware of: "Reality Check is a crowd-sourced on-chain smart contract oracle system" [built on the Ethereum smart contracts and blockchain]. https://realitykeys.github.io/realitycheck/docs/html/ https://realitykeys.github.io/realitycheck/docs/html/ And standards-based approaches are not far behind: W3C Credentials Community Group https://w3c-ccg.github.io/ https://w3c-ccg.github.io/ W3C Verifiable Claims Working Group https://www.w3.org/2017/vc/WG/ https://www.w3.org/2017/vc/WG/ W3C Verifiable News https://github.com/w3c-ccg/verifiable-news https://github.com/w3c-ccg/verifiable-news
- westurner 9y agoIn terms of verifying (or validating) subjective opinions, correlational observations, and inferences of causal relations; #LinkedMetaAnalyses of documents (notebooks) containing structured links to their data as premises would be ideal. Unfortunately, PDF is not very helpful in accomplishing that objective (in addition to being a terrible format for review with screen reader and mobile devices): I think HTML with RDFa (and/or CSVW JSONLD) is our best hope of making at least partially automated verification of meta analyses a reality.
- eradicatethots 9y agoSuppose a left leaning fact checker is more critical of conservatives? Many believe this is common. "Conservatives just lie more" Suppose they are more critical regardless of this (of truth) And what about statements which can be interpreted as false by an uncharitable reader? This is extremely common.
- cateye 9y agoSomeone at Google should have read and understand this first: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology
- chiaro 9y agoA good attempt, and it's good to see some CSR in this domain along with the demonetization drive going on in youtube. Kids (and adults) may be slowly getting better at discerning truth from motivated narratives in advertising, but these critical literacy skills are some way underdeveloped with regards to making such a discernment when truth is algorithmically generated. Whether this will be an extension of this problem or a partial solution, we'll have to wait and see. Those hoping that it will stem some of the reactionary influence we've seen establish itself over the last two years will be disappointed, I fear. A fact checker avails you little against a fiercely anti-intellectual movement.
- taytus 9y agoWe don’t need technology to fix this. We need better education. This is a problem not created by technology but by ignorance.
- Spivak 9y agoArguments that are based on the premise that everyone else is stupid are condescending and wrong. https://xkcd.com/1901/ https://xkcd.com/1901/
- swiley 9y agoI think the best method for detecting propaganda or fake news is to look for rhetoric. If the author is overly verbose or presents something other than basic facts or logic they're probably lying.
- JetSpiegel 9y agoThis a great way to dismiss in-depth investigations and listen only to soundbytes.
- emerged 9y agoBig Brother further pressing their place in defining what is and isn't true.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- noway421 9y agoMinistry of Truth as a Service, now that's something google can get behind! Either way, this factbook would greatly improve Siri, Cortana and the google counterpart.
- tscs37 9y agoI don't really think this is even remotely useful and will probably be abused within the hour. Plus, I'm not sure if I want to trust Google to check what my website or blog says is true. I don't see any extensive track record of being a fully neutral entity when it comes to things they care about, which would only hamper discussion on the topic.
- gcb0 9y agopretty much Google is sending out the message that they have failed. can we expect the overly hyped palantir stocks to crash now that they publicly stated they can't do even basic text/sentiment analysis?
- tmaly 9y agoHow do we solve the issue of trust? This is the fundamental issue I think is at stake here. It reminds me of the two generals problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Generals%27_Problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two_Generals%27_Problem