9 ms·
Why can’t we cure the common cold?
- zeristor 9y ago"Scientists today identify seven virus families that cause the majority of colds: rhinovirus, coronavirus, influenza and parainfluenza virus, adenovirus, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and, finally, metapneumovirus, which was first isolated in 2001."
- maga 9y ago> ... experiments have shown that low temperature neither increases the likelihood of catching a cold, nor the severity of symptoms. > Adults suffer an average of between two and four colds each year, and children up to 10, and we have come to accept this as an inevitable part of life. I live in Europe and go through one or two flu seasons a year on average. I don't recall catching cold/flu ever since I started using cold water exclusive year-round, as I wrote previously[1]. I was pessimistic about this practice at the beginning, and truth be told this enhanced immune system is the only benefit I'd attribute to cold showers, yet there it is, no cold for quite a few winters despite people around me getting it on schedule. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8808859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8808859
- amelius 9y agoA few years back, I tried finishing my showers with a minute of cold water. But after a few days I got a cold, and I'm not normally very susceptible to the cold. My experiment stopped there. Perhaps I should try it again.
- maga 9y agoTry gradually lowering the temperature of your water over say a month or two. What helped me, perhaps, is that I started during hot summer and the tap water got cold gradually till winter allowing me to adopt to it.
- interfixus 9y agoMileages vary. I indulge in hot showers - and full blast heating in winters. I haven't had a cold or any other infectious malaise since 2004. I am also in Europe. Mind you, I am probably more mindful about disease vectors than most. Avoid shopping-trolleys and -baskets, keep my fingers clear of mouth, nose, and eyes at all unwashed times.
- maga 9y agoI agree, avoiding catching it is a better strategy than putting the immune system to test every time. I didn't do much to avoid it, though, a few times I even had to nurse close ones through their colds fully expecting to catch it from them, yet nothing.
- Kluny 9y agoI got a similar result from quitting dairy, for a couple years at least, but correlation =/= causation.
- maga 9y agoAbsolutely! The correlation is strong in my case, though, I was on alert waiting to get cold for quite some time at first, and I also didn't change anything else in my routines at the time, so I attributed the results to cold showers. I must say that I didn't notice other benefits that people expect from the practice: no weight loss, no boost in testosterone, etc.
- albertzeyer 9y agoWell, that's an anecdote, and so maybe I add mine: Whenever I go more frequently to the sauna (e.g. like 2-3 times per week), and do more sport (like about 7-10h/week), I don't really feel ill at all, for years. When I reduced it (no sauna at all anymore, maybe only sport for 3-5h/week), what I did 3 years ago or so for a few month, I got a mild cold soon after. But not sure how useful such anecdotes are. My memories are also not perfect. It depends on many factors, such as age, your immune system condition, stress, general health, etc.
- dingaling 9y agoI've been doing cold showers year-round outdoors for two years and for the past three days have been laid-up in bed with a cold.
- patall 9y agoInteresting read. Unfortunately it then comes to a sentence like this: "For his PhD on asthma, Johnston developed a technique called polymerase chain reaction, which magnifies DNA so that viruses can be identified more precisely." which make me not sure what to believe: Is that bad spelling or has the author not even basic knowledge of modern biology?
- hanniabu 9y agoI'm not well educated as I have no idea what you're referring to, mind pointing out what in specific was misspelled or not correct.
- danieltillett 9y agoThe problem with the quote is Jonston neither invented the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) nor are most cold viruses DNA viruses (most are RNA).
- patall 9y agoExactly. PCR is THE backbone of modern biology, I would suspect an author writing about it know at least what it is. I assume she meant 'adapted' instead of 'developed' but still, it sounds fishy and makes you unneccessarily question every other sentence of the article.
- mrob 9y agoThe reporter also called cholera a virus. You can't expect too much from science reporting in mainstream newspapers.
- bhickey 9y agoThe writer is mistaken, but cholera pathogenicity is caused by a virus. A temperate phage carries the genes for cholera toxin and infects cholera bacteria.
- danieltillett 9y ago
- sametmax 9y agoI've always wondered if the common cold is not something that we just need from time to time. I mean, it seems so universal, and the reasons we catch it so random sometime it seems like the body just decide "ok let that in".
- guilhas 9y agoAgreed, like a mostly harmless disease that we get occasionally to keep our defense mechanisms working and ready for possible worse problems. Like a natural health check up.
- sleavey 9y agoSo a promising treatment for the cold was dropped by the drug company because it was too expensive to develop, and the potential payoff too small. Drug companies' profit models pretty much require them to focus on developing drugs that people have to use for the rest of their lives - that manage a condition rather than treat it. Is there a good reason why we shouldn't club together as rich countries and fund a not-for-profit drug research body that does fund this sort of thing?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Drug companies want to make drugs that people have to use for the rest of their lives - that manage a condition rather than treat it Recent evidence contradicts this statement. Notably, the pay-off to Gilead for its hepatitis C cure [1]. Besides, TFA outlines non-conspiratorial reasons underlying pharmaceutical companies’ nervousnous around developing vaccines. (TL; DR people are unwilling to pay as much for prevention as they are for a cure; also development is expensive and risky.) EDIT: [1] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/02/04/business/sales-of-sovaldi-new-gilead-hepatitis-c-drug-soar-to-10-3-billion.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/02/04/business/sales-of-sova...
- danieltillett 9y agoDo you think insurance companies are going to be willing to pay $100K per person to cure the common cold?
- tempestn 9y agoNo, but it would be reasonable to pay ~ $1000 per person, which could mean hundreds of billions of dollars of revenue. Pretty good for $1B in R&D.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Do you think insurance companies are going to be willing to pay $100K per person to cure the common cold? This is a straw man. Millions of Americans contract a rhinovirus strain every year [1]. The number is closer to 30,000 for HCV [2]. A rhinovirus cure thus has orders of magnitude more potential customers across which to spread fixed costs. On the demand side one has, on one hand, 7 to 10 days of the sniffles; on the other hand, fatal liver failure. Nobody would pay, nor should expect a third party to pay, $100,000 to cure their common cold. The article eyeballs the value of the vaccine market. It’s approximately the present value of 8.7 hours per year * your marginal hourly earnings over your remaining working years. [1] https://www.cdc.gov/features/rhinoviruses/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/features/rhinoviruses/index.html [2] https://www.hepatitisc.uw.edu/pdf/screening-diagnosis/epidemiology-us/core-concept/all https://www.hepatitisc.uw.edu/pdf/screening-diagnosis/epidem...
- danieltillett 9y agoThe most important thing from this whole article is that the brute force approach works. Just make a vaccine against all the different common cold viruses (250 to 300) and vaccinate everyone. Done. Of course this will never be done because the system for developing vaccines is so broken that it is impossible to make money selling a vaccine for the common cold. You could make a magic vaccine that was 100% effect with zero side effects (no vaccine is magic) and it would be impossible to develop and sell under the current regulations.
- polskibus 9y agoCa you elaborate why would it be impossible to develop and sell under the regulations?
- danieltillett 9y agoBasically it is impossible to prove the vaccine is safe enough to give to the general population for a disease that is not normally lethal. By the time you had finished the studies to the satisfaction of the FDA your patent would have expired and each vaccine would need to cost $100K per person to pay back the development costs. If pharmaceutical companies thought there was a fortune to be made curing the common cold they would be doing it.
- mft_ 9y agoDo you have any more information to explain this further? For example, how are 'flu vaccines approved each year? Is it because 'flu can be lethal in rare cases?
- danieltillett 9y agoThe reason flu vaccines are approved each year is they were first developed in the 1940s and we just keep using 1940s technology. If were to try to develop a flu vaccine today it would be impossible.
- hannob 9y agoThe frustrating thought I had when reading this article: If we'd spend all the money that people spend on OTC cold remedies that almost certainly don't work on developing a vaccine we probably could have one soon.
- eric_h 9y agoOTC cold remedies do not cure your cold, but they certainly do work by treating the symptoms. Ever taken an airplane with congested sinuses without taking a decongestant?
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThe palliatives do work, but there are a lot of things that claim to actually shorten the duration of a cold, e.g. Zicam, Cold-EEZE that have little to no evidence that they work.
- tcj_phx 9y agoWhat if our approach to viruses is basically-wrong? I grew up before children were vaccinated against chicken pox. When I was about 5-6 years old, I had a case... Mom counted 12 pox, which was enough to assume that I'd be immune for the rest of my life. Some children are covered with chickenpox... Heard a story of someone who scratched their eye out. The mother of six children told me her oldest had a horrible case, but her subsequent children each had a less-severe case than the previous. One theory is that winter diseases stem from decreased sunlight... Less ultraviolet light -> less vitamin D. Red light is also important. A few years ago there was an outbreak of chickenpox amongst some baseball players who came from Central America, where chickenpox is not a problem. On account of my experience with chickenpox, and the institution of mass vaccination of children & adults against the horrible chickenpox virus (99.99% survivable)... Shouldn't we be looking at what makes people vulnerable to colds? Virus exposure might not actually be important. From the article: > In 1984, researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison decided to investigate one of the best-known ways of catching a cold. They infected volunteers with a cold virus and instructed them to kiss healthy test subjects on the mouth for at least one minute. (The instruction for participants was to use whichever technique was “most natural”.) Sixteen healthy volunteers were kissed by people with colds. The result: just one confirmed infection. (emphasis added) I heard of an investigation in Central America that found providing clean water, outhouses, and basic nutrients was the most important public health intervention that could be done for a village.
- hennsen 9y agoWhat the article says nothing about is the usefulness of taking Vitamin C in high doses - it only mentions shortly regular doses probably something like 100-200mg a day. This is enough to prevent Skorbut an ensures basic need. But there are studies that high doses can help a lot with colds. EDIT: examples: http://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/9/4/339 http://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/9/4/339 https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2017-03/uoh-ldo033017.php https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2017-03/uoh-ldo03301... https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/high-doses-of-vitamin-c-shown-to-reduce-duration-of-colds-033117.html https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/high-doses-of-vitamin-c... After reading about it i tried this, and confirm that high doses help to cure colds much faster. In 2 of three cases i managed to get over a cold which otherwise lasts 7-10 days for me in just 3-4 days with much lower symptoms. The dose at which this begins to work is 3g (yes 3000mg!) per day - i take 6x1g the first day, then 3g/day a few days more. Pure Vitamin C powder with no other additives(many products nowadays are combinations, in spain where i am right now, the pure powder is hard to get, in Germany it’s in every drugstore). It works even better with herpes i sometimes get on the lips. Here, the success rate of making the illness last 2-3 days instead of 10 is 100% since i started do treat it that way a few years ago, with much less symptoms, just a little itching, no big wounds for many days like many suffer from (and i did) when getting a herpes push. I can clearly understand why this is not researched and communicated much - a pot of 100g Vitamin C powder, good for about 5 such treatments costs just 3€ ... not much money to be made. EDIT: This is my personal experience - for which I don't claim general applicability for everyone. But I find it very interesting that some people see the urgent need to downvote a post where someone reports personal experience, without saying it must be generally applicable.
- rwmj 9y agoThis has been debunked extensively, eg: http://www.yalescientific.org/2015/03/mythbusters-does-vitamin-c-really-help/ http://www.yalescientific.org/2015/03/mythbusters-does-vitam... https://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/pauling.html https://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/pauling.h...
- hennsen 9y agoOh really - It has been proven that it does not work for me personally exactly as i wrote? I didn’t see the researcher team coming through my door... I didn’t say it works for everyone, but only report how it turns out for me. Interesting that some find a personal report enough reason to downvote... How do we know the research you point at is not sponsored by those with an interest in selling more expensive stuff?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Eridrus 9y ago> Sixteen healthy volunteers were kissed by people with colds. The result: just one confirmed infection. This doesn't sound like a debunking of what people think at all. If the chance of getting infected from a kissing for a minute is 6%, and you spend a week around an infected person and you kiss them repeatedly, you will almost certainly get sick with that infection rate.
- wink 9y agoTo deduct a general 6% infectionrate because 1 person got infected by 1 other person is kind of not what I believe. People's immune systems are so different... before I believe that I'd want to see every sick person kissing every healthy person or something. I don't even know how that would work with incubation times. Lock people away and just allow contact every 2 days for 3 weeks? But then all the sick people would probably be healthy again already. My head explodes just trying to think about this kind of trial, mixed with statistics :P
- Eridrus 9y ago> To deduct a general 6% infectionrate because 1 person got infected by 1 other person is kind of not what I believe. Sure, I'm just saying this was not a very strong result in terms of disproving the fact that kissing doesn't spread cold viruses.
- Feniks 9y agoViruses laugh at man's feeble attempts to eradicate them. They will adept. And possibly give you more than a runny nose.
- eip 9y agohttp://orthomolecular.org/resources/omns/v05n07.shtml http://orthomolecular.org/resources/omns/v05n07.shtml