11 ms·
MasterCard Ending Signature Requirements
- miles 9y agoWhy not link to the credited source[1] or even better, to the original source[2] credited by same? [1] https://consumerist.com/2017/10/19/mastercard-ending-signature-requirements/ https://consumerist.com/2017/10/19/mastercard-ending-signatu... [2] https://newsroom.mastercard.com/2017/10/19/no-more-signing-on-the-dotted-line/ https://newsroom.mastercard.com/2017/10/19/no-more-signing-o...
- mikestew 9y agoBecause I saw it on /. and thought the Fast Company link was the original source. Turtles all the way down, or something; should have paid more attention.
- dang 9y agoOK, we'll change to that first one from https://www.fastcompany.com/40484347/mastercard-has-finally-realized-that-signatures-are-obsolete-and-stupid https://www.fastcompany.com/40484347/mastercard-has-finally-....
- interfixus 9y agoSignatures? Is this an America-thing? Me and my MasterCards go back sort of a long way, pens and paper never involved.
- rietta 9y agoYes. We have to sign for purchases over $25 at retail. It's like the signature on the bottom of the check. If there is a fraud claim they'll trot out the signature as one of the evidences and compare to the card holders - at least in theory.
- peterwwillis 9y agoAnd only for retail. And the store is supposed to check your ID if there's no signature on the card (which is stupid, because they're not comparing your card's signature to your current signature). It's just a way to push back fraud charges onto the merchants.
- megaman22 9y agoIt varies wildly whether you will have to sign when using a credit card, and where and what size of purchase requires it. Some places, I have to sign for a $0.99 pack of gum, other places I can buy $200 worth of groceries without a signature. Sometimes it's even different at the same places day to day.
- korethr 9y agoAs far as I can tell, it is an US thing. I can't speak for other countries in the Americas, but when I was in Europe briefly a few years ago, what few purchases I made with a card were all done chip & pin. In the US, that signature is a on a line right next to the words "I agree to be bound by the cardholder agreement", or some similar language. If I had to guess, the signature was originally supposed to be a mini-contract that yes, you're going to pay back the card company for what they just paid on your behalf. I don't know if such has ever been been taken to court to be enforced, however.
- stronglikedan 9y agoWaiters will chase after you if you forget to sign your check, because they must provide a signed receipt to their merchant account provider if you initiate a chargeback, if they want any chance of fighting it. I'm not sure why they just don't scribble a random signature in for me, because that's all I do when I sign it.
- monster_group 9y ago>>I'm not sure why they just don't scribble a random signature in for me.. Because that would be financial fraud for which they can go to jail.
- yammajr 9y agoProbably because that's called forgery, and if they were caught doing it it would be a much bigger deal than not getting their money from that transaction.
- stordoff 9y agoIf the intent is to fight chargebacks, then a false signature seems even worse. A signature that isn't remotely similar to the cardholder's seems less likely to be successful than a blank signature, and presenting such a document may well be fraud.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoIt's for fast food or retail, the idea is you never put a pin for your purchase.
- tluyben2 9y agoAnd a lot of Asia. Even after chip+pin.
- yahna 9y agoYes. America is stuck in the stone age when it comes to this stuff.
- pro_zac 9y agoIt is an American bank thing. When I use my American Visa card in the UK, I still get asked to sign. They end up not having a pen because locals never need to sign. I started using apple pay to avoid this. Contactless payment is much more popular in Europe.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoAh, but some terminals will still require a signature with Apple Pay.
- al452 9y agoYes it is an America-thing. If you're in the rest of the world move on, nothing to see here,
- rconti 9y agoYes, as covered every time credit or debit cards are mentioned here.
- peterwwillis 9y agoIf my barista is busy and I'm supposed to sign the Square tablet receipt, I sometimes leave a little doodle of a bunny sitting under a tree, or seagulls soaring above my sig. It's actually a great way to de-stress.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoFor a while I've been making the joke that you could draw a flower when asked for your signature and nobody will care. I've had to pay with other people's cards and signed in print. Nobody cared each time.
- esMazer 9y agountil you go to Europe.. make them search for a pen for your 'American' card and you do a simple signature and they look at you (and even tell you) their incredulity to your signature! (happened to me more than once a few months ago, one cashier actually got upset at my simple signature)
- ben174 9y agoAt grocery stores with the old dot matrix signature pad, I sometimes like to scribble until I've completely blackened every dot.
- artursapek 9y agoYou must live in a small town
- bradknowles 9y agoWhat I don’t comprehend is how you can do that quickly enough for it to be useful as a signature. If I was going to draw a bunny or a seagull, it would take at least several minutes, if not an hour or more. And even then, it would be horrible looking.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Personally, I have been known to sign on the dotted line with a doodle of a piece of tofu and no one has ever stopped me, because signatures mean very little in this digital age." This has absolutely nothing to do with us being in a so-called "digital age". Signatures have been completely ignored by virtually everyone except autograph hunters since basically forever. The problem is that the person receiving your signature usually has no way to verify that the signature belongs to the person authorized to whatever it is you signed for. In the case of credit card signatures, the best they can do is try to match your signature to the one on the back of the card. I think I've had that happen exactly once in my life. Even there, the possessor of the card can easily replace the signature on the back with another one with minimal forgery skills, or even scrawl something vaguely resembling the signature on the back of the card and get away with it. Nothing "digital" about this forgery or the lack of attention or care from the people receiving it. Banks are really in the best position to verify signatures on checks that they get. They could potentially access a huge database of authentic signatures from previously cashed checks and do some sort of AI pattern-matching against the signatures they get before cashing them. But do they? I don't know. But I very much doubt it. Besides, at least in my case, my own signatures vary pretty widely from other ones I've signed in the past. Sure, there's some resemblance, but they're far from exact copies of each other, and a forger wouldn't have to try very hard to sign a similar one after glancing at a sample.
- stronglikedan 9y ago> I think I've had that happen exactly once in my life. Heck, back when you had to hand over your card for the cashier to swipe it, I'd write "check id" on the card's signature line, and I had maybe three people total ever ask me for my ID.
- traviscj 9y agoWhat's the thread model here? You lost your card/it was stolen, but you haven't noticed and canceled it yet? Isn't it more likely that your card data is scraped up in a data breach or something, in which case your card is still in your wallet? Even if it was very recently lost/stolen, you're not liable for illegitimate charges as long as you report them promptly, so wouldn't it be better to just keep track of your cards?
- obeattie 9y agoMastercard did not just “finally” realise this. They realised it back in the 90s when they were involved in the creation of EMV, which replace the “signature” method of cardholder verification with PINs. Signatures have been all but obsolete for purchases in Europe for years; I can’t even remember the last time I used it here. Everything is contact or contactless EMV now, authenticated by PINs.
- Kelbit 9y agoCanada as well. We transitioned later than the EU, the big push started in the late 2000s and they just recently finished the last of the liability shifts to the merchant (some gas pumps got an extension since they were more expensive to upgrade). Aside from BC Ferries, I haven't had anyone swipe my card in years, and most transactions are contactless.
- sergers 9y agoI hate that chevron stations require pin input, don't support tap inside or at the pump. I guess the tap does defeat the pin as a security measure
- abrowne 9y agoWhen I was in Belgium last year, with my American chip-but-no-pin credit card, the terminal would just spit out an extra long receipt and the slightly confused cashier would say, "oh, you have to sign ... somewhere" since there wasn't a line or spot for it.
- Macuyiko 9y agoSimilarly, every time I am in America (although last time was a already a long while ago) with my Belgian chip-and-pin credit card, the terminal would show a cryptic error message with a slightly confused cashier saying, "sorry, your card doesn't work" (or sometimes: "is refused"). Queue me pointing to another terminal: "don't swipe the card, insert it in the sleeve and let me enter my pin." Same problem at shopping malls in China, by the way (where the language makes the explaining even more fun).
- Fizzadar 9y agoI'm visiting the US currently from the UK and am bewildered that signing is still how the majority of transactions are handled. Chip and pin has been the standard for years at home (and most of the EU, and more). How/why has it taken so long for the US to catch up? It's like going backwards in time... (the NY subway ticket system is similarly archaic!)
- mercutio2 9y agoThe US was the originator of credit cards, and the number of merchant deployments here was one or two orders of magnitude bigger than in Europe when EMV was standardized, so the cost to retool was dramatically higher. Next, credit card fraud in the US is currently limited through various Orwellian big data measures, whereas Europe was rife with credit card fraud when EMV was originally deployed, so the cost benefit analysis made it much more appealing in Europe. Basically, path dependency is a thing. Americans routinely use checks to pay rent for similar reasons.
- bradknowles 9y agoMy wife has to pay her rent at her office via check. The landlord requires it. We were dumbfounded at first, but then we just accepted that we have to play by his rules. Prior to that event, I can’t think of any transaction we have had in decades here in the US where we were required to pay by check. Cards or electronic payments of one sort or another have almost always been available to us.
- kalleboo 9y agoBut now they've gone through the cost and effort of implementing EMV chips, and they're still not using PINs.
- mercutio2 9y agoPINs require you to remember them, and they aren’t actually required to solve the main fraud problem. The card companies decided Americans would spend less if presented with the hassle; who knows if they were right. Physical credit card theft is a negligible source of fraud, it’s all about card cloning, which EMV does a moderately good job of preventing.
- Havoc 9y agoMore accurately the American system is obsolete and stupid. (Yes I know downvote away). Last time I signed anything card related was 2012 (their card reader was malfunctioning). Oh and of course my 2017 US trip...signed lots of things there. Enjoying the UK system. Especially their tubes & trains allowing contactless. Very convenient with a corporate card that pulls through to expense system. That way I know anything on there = I meant to expense that when I took the trip.
- rconti 9y agoTo be fair, it's always worse when you travel. In canada, I have to sign for things for my US card I wouldn't have to sign for in the US.
- PagingCraig 9y agoWon't downvote the truth.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jedberg 9y agoI've been drawing dinosaurs for years. Sometimes my wife draws them for me (for purchases on my card, in front of the cashier). No one seems to care.
- Fwirt 9y agoAt my local food cart station, I've had to sign for transactions on a sticky 4-inch iPhone screen held in the vendor's hand. She told me most people just drawn an X. The usefulness of signatures as a means of verification reminds me of the scene from The Fugitive where Kimble saves the kid's life by scribbling an illegible "doctor's" signature on a medical order: https://youtu.be/nxotPpVYVcc?t=95 https://youtu.be/nxotPpVYVcc?t=95
- teilo 9y agoFor important documents, I have a neat and legible signature. But for CCs, I've been doing this for a long time now. Just a wiggly line, whether on screen or on paper. No one's ever challenged it.
- fenwick67 9y agoAn X is a legal signature. Signatures are really only useful as an indicator that you agreed to something in entirety, it clears up legal grey areas. So, when a judge asks "did you agree to this?", you can't say "I agreed to X not Y". Instead they can say "is this your signature?" and the intent is clear. It's really just a symbol of total agreement.
- m00s3 9y agoAs a Canadian, I haven't signed my name on credit card receipts in years, like the past 10 at least. The only time I do that is when I visit the States.
- mwexler 9y agoBefore we pop the champagne, note that we still have minimal PIN penetration in the US, even with EMV cards, and it's up to the merchant to decide whether or not to require the signature. Legalities could mean that merchants feel safer still requiring a signature, so until PIN comes through everywhere (or alternative auth/verification/etc. approaches), we may not get the ease we are hoping for immediately.
- teej 9y agoIf MasterCard isn’t going to offer lower rates for card present w/ signature vs card present w/o signature then you can guarantee smart retailers will choose to opt out of signatures. Instantly shave 5-30 seconds off your average transaction time.
- mjcl 9y agoAnd you no longer have to store the paper / electronic signatures.
- criddell 9y ago> Instantly shave 5-30 seconds off your average transaction time. McDonald's clearly cares about this. They have the fastest card readers around. I've always wondered if they are actually running the transaction in real time, or just collecting the card info and running it later, accepting the losses from the occasional bad read.
- jlgaddis 9y agoYep, I have a half dozen credit cards in my wallet and a few more in a drawer and I have no clue what my PIN is for any of them (or if I even have one). The only PIN I know is the one for my ATM card.
- timdellinger 9y agoThe question I ask is: do signatures reduce fraud? I don't have any data, but my expectation is that fraudsters are less likely to go for it if they have to sign... i.e. the psychological barrier is more important than the obvious unenforceability of the signature as a bona fide. Fraudsters = people trying to get free stuff, as well as merchants putting through bogus or altered transactions
- troydavis 9y agoBy the time they’d need to scrawl a line on a receipt, a thief has already stolen a credit card or purchased a number and printed/magnetized a card. A signature at checkout isn’t going to deter that person.
- Broken_Hippo 9y ago...but my expectation is that fraudsters are less likely to go for it if they have to sign. This won't work if they've worked retail and realized that most cashiers don't check (it isn't worth it) and that most folks scribble their signature so sloppily - or with a line - that it doesn't seem to make a difference anyway.
- seretogis 9y agoFor years I've ignored the signature field on the back of my credit card and put "SEE ID" instead. In the event the cashier actually checks it, they'll be prompted to check my identification. I've been asked for ID in this way probably a dozen times, in as many years.
- usaphp 9y agoI have not had a signature on the back ofnmy cards at all for many years and nobody ever said anything to me as well.
- KGIII 9y agoThat's a great idea, actually. I keep ID at the ready and my cards are all unsigned. If they want signature verification, the back of the card is a silly place to look for it - as it can be signed by anyone. It could be a fake ID, but that's more difficult and less likely. Sadly, very seldom does anyone even look to confirm it is even signed. Methinks I'll try your solution. Thanks!
- notlob 9y agoIt isn’t a great idea. I used to do it (See ID), but it is actually not compliant with the credit card agreement. The post office by me refused to accept cards marked like that.
- KGIII 9y agoWorst case, I'll just use cash. I always carry currency, as well.
- rcdmd 9y agoBy writing "SEE ID," a malicious cashier can now get your credit card and ID-- enough info to impersonate you in some scenarios, make online transactions, deliver things to your address and steal them, etc. Yes, you have to show it in some transactions (purchasing alcohol, for instance), but those are rare. If you're asked for it for any reason at all (ex-- "to prevent fraud") that's a red flag, and a violation of the vendor-card agreement. It's not like the "SEE ID" thing would protect you from fraud when so few cashiers actually look at it anyway.
- andrewstuart 9y agoAustralia recently went through a very strange process in which signing was removed as a requirement for credit cards, with a pin being required instead. Goodness knows what it cost but there was a giant campaign to get everyone to ensure they had a pin number on their cards. And at the same time, you can use PayWave to just wave a credit card for a transaction with no PIN required - presumably for smaller transactions. Even so it was strange to go through this giant campaign of ensuring your card has a PIN and then not needing it. "IMPORTANT! Ensure you have a PIN on your credit card! (although you won't need it)". https://www.lifehacker.com.au/2014/01/credit-card-pin-number-changes-in-australia-everything-you-need-to-know/ https://www.lifehacker.com.au/2014/01/credit-card-pin-number... I've wondered what sort of security issue PayWave is..... what if somehow a criminal got a PayWave reader and surreptitiously touched it to everyone's bag and pocket on a crowded train? Is there a possible exploit there somewhere?
- d4l3k 9y agoI'm pretty sure the wireless tap is some form of challenge response/one time password so it's probably not a huge issue. It's not like they can make unlimited purchases just by reading it. It's slightly more secure than just a credit card number.
- ryukafalz 9y agoThere was a video on that a few years back that you might find interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRXb-FZ6WFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRXb-FZ6WFM Basically - yes, it's more secure than just a credit card number, though if it works the same way it did in 2012 there's still all sorts of shenanigans you could pull.
- jazoom 9y agoHow recent was this? I've been using PIN only for at least 7 years. The limit for just tap and no PIN is $100.
- inferiorhuman 9y ago> I've wondered what sort of security issue PayWave is..... what if somehow a criminal got a PayWave reader and surreptitiously touched it to everyone's bag and pocket on a crowded train? Is there a possible exploit there somewhere? Yeah, I thought about that too. On the plus side, Apple Pay works pretty much anywhere PayWave is accepted, and Apple Pay requires a fingerprint or face.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoApple/android pay simply can’t come soon enough. Let the authentication be handled by the phone for tokenized transactions.
- zanny 9y agoThere are two grocery stores in my town, one takes Android Pay and the other does not. Considering the price advantage changes week by week, the sole major differentiator in my routine is what payment methods they accept, and that makes me to go to the one with Android Pay almost exclusively. I really hate how a year ago it seemed rollout was better than it is now. Every damn store and restaurant is trying to use their own app as a payment system rather than just using Android Pay, its bad enough that the local Burger King told me they the Android Pay no longer worked on the terminals and to use the app instead, which wasn't NFC based and required me to reenter my card info to start using it...
- grandalf 9y agoI draw a cute little animal on the signature line (the species of which I'll keep confidential for security reasons) and nobody has ever noticed or questioned it.
- wink 9y agoGerman here - I'm not hugely paying attention to this and also mostly using a PIN for Maestro/EC and Credit Card - but cashiers here more like 80% at least look at the signature and the back of the card. Then again, even writing weirdly never really triggered a response...
- latchkey 9y agoI've been signing my name on credit card statements with a smiley face for years now. Living in Saigon Vietnam now, doing anything out of the ordinary like that always makes people smile.
- Simulacra 9y agoI used to sign my name as the president on digital signature screens for credit cards. Not so much this year
- stevewillows 9y agoI've always assumed that signatures were purely for some form of potential legal proceeding where they court can ask, 'did you sign this?' -- and nothing more.
- spondyl 9y agoI paid for "Signature required" delivery once on an item and received an email that it has arrived. I was confused because the courier site showed a digital signature that wasn't mine and obviously I hadn't received the item. It turns out the driver, running late presumably, had been signing deliveries well before delivering them.
- sundvor 9y agoSignatures? Haven't signed anything card related in Australia for years. NFC and pin if over AUD100 is how we do it now, mostly (there are still a few left overs where you must insert the chip).
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoI don't remember the last time I signed a payment slip. It must have been the last time I visited the US, some 10 years ago. I live in France and my VISA and Mastercard cards have a chip which is universally used in Europe (France is at the low end of CC use, discovering contactless payments since two or three years. Germany is even worse. At the other side you have Estonia or Poland which could well be cashless). There is still a place for a signature, which I leave empty or write "check ID"