8 ms·
If they had done so by presenting a product that was picked up due to it's merit and continued to gain traction based on that then I'd be rather impressed. Ins
by munk-a 9y ago
If they had done so by presenting a product that was picked up due to it's merit and continued to gain traction based on that then I'd be rather impressed. Instead the story of MongoDB seems to be how extremely well targeted marketing and sales can build a so-so product into a huge IPO, there have been performance comparisons showing it isn't even the best at what it does so this IPO is riding on the network effect of those early stages of marketing alone.
In our economy this is sadly an entirely valid route to making money but their mindshare is going to continue to collapse as the warts on their product show more and more.
So the admiration you have should probably be directed at the wool the marketers behind MongoDB managed to pull over your eyes.
- wnevets 9y ago>how extremely well targeted marketing and sales can build a so-so product into a huge IPO Thats how most products succeed if you ask me.
- munk-a 9y agoI don't disagree, but we haven't seen them close the distance in terms of performance. Let me clarify a bit, I'm not saying that this tactic is invalid or inefficient within our current system, in fact this is a great way to land a good payday if you can pull it off. My point was more that MongoDB is going to implode when their performance shortfalls become visible to the wider populace, if that happens, of course. It's still possible they take the earnings from this IPO and dump heavy into R&D investment to make up the lost ground, but it's also very possible they take this payday and ride out the tech until it breaks down.
- jameskilton 9y agoAh, right, like RethinkDB? As much as I'd love this to be true, the #1 measure of success is if people even know you exist and #2 is if you solve enough of a customer's problems that it's worth using your product. MongoDB hit these two points hard right out of the gate and are now very successful because of it.
- noncoml 9y agoMongoDBs clients are much more simple to use than that of RethinkDB. Imho that was the number one reason it didn’t gain traction.
- mfjordvald 9y agoI'm curious what you mean by this. We use a combination of RethinkDB + Deepstream at work and it's amazing to work with with really simple querying language. I might very well be missing something, though, as I'm not the main developer so not too deep into it.
- noncoml 9y agoFor one is the extra database handle and run I have to use every time, instead of the commands being methods to the db handle object. The repetition of males code more verbose. Secondly, it’s the ReQL. It’s not native but not JSON based either. A weird hybrid mix. But it’s only my personal opinion based on my taste.
- takeda 9y agoI think it all comes down to what definition is of solving a problem. What Mongo did is implementing these features just well enough so they can put checkpoint in their marketing brochures. When you actually start using it you learn that most of it is either performing slow, does not work correctly or once in a while corrupts your data. Yes they hit these points hard, but only from marketing point of view. They are now universally hated by ops and developers because these people now have to deal with fallout. RethinkDB actually is an example that database is something that's not good as a base for a startup[1], and the Open Source approach (like PostgrSQL) is more suitable. MongoDB is example that you can base a startup on a database technology and succeed, if you can sleep well at night that your product can cause people to lose data. [1] The reason RethinkDB failed was because they refused to provide half solutions like MongoDB, everyone expects startup to start making money, but building a reliable databases is not something that's easy and can't be done quickly.
- rburhum 9y agoMost people forget that with startups, what you are trying to create is a business... the technology behind is only one element to it. It is extremely difficult to do good marketing and sales and they did it. Solve a customer problem while building a healthy business... a success story in my book.
- gxs 9y agoAgree - I think there is a perception that if you build an awesome product it sells itself. There is so much work to running a successful business, especially at that scale. Marketing, Sales, Implementation, Support, on top of G&A, and that's not even touching on HR and retaining employees in a competitive market. There is a reason some people are known as the "business" guys, I think expertise in that area is underrated, especially among people who've only worked at smaller companies or startups. Edit: Genuinely curious to know why I'm being downvoted. Care to elaborate on why you're downvoting?
- nopzor 9y agoHave no idea why you're being downvoted. I think your point is salient and under appreciated. Certainly from my own experiences it's easy to get caught up in the product and the tech, and not focus enough on the biz side of things. Ie. Sales and Marketing. Basically I'm in complete agreement with you, and feel this is a hard learned lesson.
- KGIII 9y agoSpeculation: You were being downvoted because software types often express ideas that can be summed up as business is easy and the people doing the business aspects aren't important. They seem to think that everyone and anyone can do it and, when they hear success stories as examples, it reinforces those ideas. A good example is some of the comments that software folks make about the sales department. They are different skillsets and people have varied abilities in each. The business aspect is not actually easy. It is also not always done well. The software end isn't always done well, either. My guess would be that is why you were being downvoted. I notice a number of votes are emotional in nature. They aren't based on logic. I see some that are most easily explained as, "I don't want to know." The comment is factual, not confrontational, and topical. The vote is still negative. Meh... I don't mind it when it happens to me. I have karma to spare and don't actually make comments for the points. I say what I feel needs to be said and try to stick mostly within the guidelines. (I do meander off topic sometimes.) But, no... I don't comment for the points. I comment for the replies and thoughts. They are usually quite brilliant and insightful.
- derefr 9y ago> their mindshare is going to continue to collapse as the warts on their product show more and more I'm not clear on why you think this—software products with huge mindshare and an open contribution model, get their warts fixed, usually by programmers sponsored by corporations repackaging the software (Redhat and Canonical with Linux) or running the software in a SaaS model (Cloudant with CouchDB.)
- capkutay 9y agoHow did MongoDB go to market differently than the other enterprise NoSQL DBs (MarkLogic, DataStax)?
- pja 9y agoI’m told they absolutely flooded tech meetups in the SV area and with advertorial talks - talks on NoSQL (that just happened to use MongoDB of course), lots of FUD about SQL vs. NoSQL etc etc. I’ve no idea to what extent this was true, or if it was whether it was their main marketing approach, but it might have been quite an effective strategy: talks at meetups are often 'trusted' to a greater extent than other ways of reaching devs & if you can find a new generation of devs who are just starting out and hook them on your product before they get the chance to explore other approaches then it could work. High cost of course (someone has to pay for all that time) but if it gets you a leg up on your competitors in a $billion business then that’s what the VC money is for...
- VintageCool 9y agoMongoDB was huge at hackathons, too. People could implement an app in a weekend using MongoDB because it had no integrity checks and none of its drawbacks manifest themselves in the first two days of development.
- munk-a 9y agoI totally get this, but a hackathon is a one time software build and you don't need to lean heavily on a schema if you've only got one state your data has ever existed in, MongoDB is great for templating like this. However, when it comes to writing software that's meant to survive changes and versions the schema ends up providing a safety net that ensures you can ignore the data that exists and assume that the structure described by your schema is consistent. Data integrity is key to maintainability and those constraints are what keep your data clean.
- pja 9y agoI wouldn't be at all surprised to discover that they seeded the hackathons with ringers too: Devs on payroll that turned up & implemented a website/app in a weekend that naturally 'just happened' to use MongoDB. Makes you wonder what other meetup/hackathon visible tech is really covert marketing...
- takeda 9y agoEven minor things like picking a product name had impact. They also implemented most desirable features (the gotcha was that they were half assed, but if your evaluation was also half assed as is usually done you won't notice it) I actually chose it back in 2010 project and on paper MongoDB looked better than other databases. MongoDB name as they mentioned originates from Humongous Database giving false impression that it can scale well.
- GenericsMotors 9y ago> Even minor things like picking a product name had impact. They get zero points for this. It pretty much reads as "Retard"DB in Portuguese, Spanish, and IIRC German.
- sigzero 9y agoNot that it is 100% reliable but I put "mongo" in Google translate for all three of those languages and it comes out "mongo". Unless mongo is "slang" in those languages.
- GenericsMotors 9y agoIt is slang, short for "mongoloide". https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/mongo https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/mongo Interesting this isn't the case with English.
- zimpenfish 9y agoEnglish would be "mong". Probably because we got lazy with our abusive terms in the 70s and 80s. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/mong#English https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/mong#English (Etymology 3)
- tsilva 9y ago- "We are better then you are. We have better stuff..." - "You don't get it, Steve. That doesn't matter!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBri-xgYvHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBri-xgYvHQ
- adrianN 9y agoThat seems to be the business model of all "enterprise" products.
- amazingman 9y agoGood for them. I hope their longer-term employees who likely traded lower salary for stock options get a nice windfall from this.
- rogerb 9y agoLol. Yes, you customers of mongodb ! You’re all wrong and duped by pretty pictures! If just you could achieve the enlightenment of munk-a ! Lol. I’ve seen this idiotic response from the very beginning days of mongo (I worked there). Marketing at mongo did little more than maniacally focusing on making sure our customers and users where tied into the community and supremely supported on any issue they might have. But go on - keep predicting imminent failure, your sentiment is shared by a lot of people who have never build a company and frankly never will.
- nagarjun 9y agoWhat would you consider to be a "top-notch" NoSQL database?
- darkr 9y agoDynamoDB, Cassandra
- Arnt 9y agoIt was picked up due to merit, IMNSHO, just not the for the factors you think highly of. It didn't do ACID, not even nearly, but it did other praiseworthy things, with "laser focus on four critical things: onboarding, usability, libraries and support" (https://www.nemil.com/mongo/2.html https://www.nemil.com/mongo/2.html). Please don't be disparaging about any of those four.
- hodgesrm 9y agoAmen to that. The first time I used MongoDB it was stupid easy to get started. We implemented data replication from MySQL into MongoDB in a 3 hour hackathon, something that would have taken at least a week for a relational database. For a full description of the experience see: http://scale-out-blog.blogspot.com/2011/05/introducing-mysql-to-mongodb.html http://scale-out-blog.blogspot.com/2011/05/introducing-mysql... Don't put down 'easy'. It's incredibly hard to do well. P.s., I'm DBMS guy and have lived and breathed Jim Grey-style transactional consistency for decades. I'm still impressed by what they did.
- timthelion 9y agoHas MongoDB improved post funding? I got involved in Docker early and invested about a year of work into a project based on Docker. Docker was slow and had warts and my project ultimately is almost unusable due to Docker's slowness and warts. I knew about the warts near the beginning, but I assumed that when they got $40million, they would fix the warts. They didn't. Indeed, it seems that quality has not changed since they got funded, perhaps it has even decreased! If nothing else, it has certainly gotten harder to install on linux. I think that it is often the case that a user base buys into an idea and funding comes and there is a vision. There is nothing wrong with that, so long as the company actually invests the money into achieving that vision. I mean, lots of people have bought into Tesla's vision, that vision hasn't been achieved yet, it's still mostly just marketing, especially the self driving part, but no one is going to hate them for marketing the vision if they DO succeed, or at least try valiantly.
- dominotw 9y ago> it has certainly gotten harder to install on linux. Downvoted for this. I haven't used docker much but I just did > yum install docker-ce and started the service. took me less than 2 mins.
- timthelion 9y agoI recently was at a seminar where the lady sitting next to me was a network analyst. Her laptop was running debian and she needed to install docker to be able to work along in the seminar, so she did the logical thing which was to go to docker.com and opened the "Get docker" menu. Under that menu, there are two main options, "Mac" and "Windows". She managed to get down to the "for servers" section and click "debian" at which point she was directed to "download docker from the docker store" at which point she was lost for a while. Then she managed to get to this document https://docs.docker.com/engine/installation/linux/docker-ce/debian/ https://docs.docker.com/engine/installation/linux/docker-ce/... at which point I had to help her, because she didn't know which exact version of debian she was running and didn't know how to find out. I would say it was pretty much a catastrophe, as she spent about half an hour trying to get docker installed. You ran "yum install docker-ce" you were lucky that you knew the name of the package. I didn't know the name on Fedora, and looking here https://docs.docker.com/engine/installation/linux/docker-ce/fedora/ https://docs.docker.com/engine/installation/linux/docker-ce/... didn't help one bit. Indeed, that page doesn't include a line with "yum" in it at all!
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoJavascript, x86, MySQL, DOS.... the market victors in this industry are often just "good enough" technologically speaking and sometimes even kinda suck. Add MongoDB to the list. Its "good enough", and marketed well.