10 ms·
Opaque and sky high bills are breaking Americans, and our health care system
- festidious 9y agoThe problem is US health care providers are immune to true competition: 1. They often enjoy state-sanctioned monopolies in the form of overly restrictive licensing laws. They're basically unions that enshrine certain false assumptions about what form of training is necessary to accomplish tasks. 2. They don't even have to be held to any cost agreements. How can you have competition or any kind of viable health care economy when no one actually knows the price of a service until it is set by the provider after the fact, and there is no way of offering an alternative means of offering the service? It's absurd. I don't even understand how most of this is legal. The price should be set beforehand, or at least there should be an estimate on request, and the final price should be with in a small fraction of that estimate, and licensing should be dramatically loosened or eliminated, to allow providers who are competent but have alternate educational paths (e.g., optometrists expanding their practice, or psychologists prescribing, or nurses or pharmacists increasing their role).
- amoorthy 9y agoThere is a downside to pricing being front-and-center. It encourages the patient to make a judgement call on what procedure to undertake based more on cost than on need. Since they are not qualified to assess need they rely on cost more than they probably should. The result may be poor short-term decisions which leads to health complications down the line. Healthcare is a service like none other. The consumer is not knowledgeable about the details and trusts a third party (doctor). They often buy the service when they are not in the best frame of mind. They may not have the ability to exercise choice in location or provider in an emergency situation. All these factors make it hard for consumers to make a rational decision when it comes to healthcare services. Since these factors are unlikely to change I don't think we should rely on a traditional market-based approach where competition will solve all ills. More important than transparent pricing is a singular price for a procedure regardless of if the patient has insurance or not. That alone will solve many problems.
- DenisM 9y agoYou could go to one doctor to receive recommendations and to another to perform procedures. The former will have no incentive to over/under recommend, unless they are in cahoots. Also known as “second opinion”.
- csydas 9y agoBut then again, the opposite of this is they're also not equipped to make a judgement for non-critical operations or and they also are provided with absolutely no information as to the costs they're about to undertake for procedures that otherwise would be in their right frame of mind, and they have poor ability to understand how their insurance will work each time they undergo a procedure, whether it's a routine check or a critical procedure. Already prior to the affordable care act people were performing their own medical procedures since they could not get medical coverage due to pre-existing conditions, making equally bad decisions because they had no means to determine how costly a procedure would be and they still lacked the ability to know whether or not a procedure was required. The information asymmetry is bad for many reasons, as I do appreciate what you're saying that we really don't want people self-diagnosing; but at the same time, should we really have people going into debt just to get a minor biopsy done? My last biopsy cost $6300 when it was all said and done and insurance refused to pay any of it on the basis that it was "unnecessary", never-ending that three separate doctors were extremely concerned as they had no idea what a lesion on my leg was and they were fearful it was cancerous. I'm not really sure how that can be deemed unnecessary; even from a straight cost perspective, $6300 out of their pocket now means saving potentially hundreds of thousands on costs later. I live abroad and my work colleagues are continually flabbergasted when I explain how health care and insurance works in the US - they cannot fathom the idea of paying for a service that can just decide not to hold up their end of the bargain for whatever reason, or that the answer to the simple question "Let's say I break my leg - how much can I expect to pay to get it fixed?" is "I really can't say, it depends on a lot of things." Here, they're used to pretty dead set figures; an X-Ray is this much, a cast is this much, each follow up visit is $X, and this is all provided ahead of time so that they know the total cost up front. So yeah, I do get what you're saying - we don't want people just going to WebMD and thinking they have SuperCancer. But the alternative is people terrified of the potential costs and having absolutely no idea what they're getting billed for or why, and an Insurance system that just dictates prices to them.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> How can you have competition or any kind of viable health care economy when no one actually knows the price of a service until it is set by the provider after the fact, and there is no way of offering an alternative means of offering the service? It's not that nobody actually knows the price of a service because it's set by providers after-the-fact. It's that it's infeasible to predict what an individual patient will be required to pay until after it's submitted to insurance. That generally happens before the service is provided, particularly for outpatient services or planned procedures. Providers can't feasibly predict how much patients will be responsible to pay for a whole number of reasons, one of which is that they themselves don't always know how much they'll be paid by the insurers.
- nradov 9y agoProvider licensing restrictions isn't the major issue. Other countries have similar restrictions and don't end up with the same problems. We are already seeing Nurse Practitioners and Physician Assistants delivering more basic care. This saves a lot of money compared to using Physicians for every little thing.
- pxeboot 9y agoLack of transparent pricing is a huge issue with US health care. I dispute almost every bill I get. Prices get reduced or insurance agrees to pay more in almost every case. They are banking on people just paying.
- tdburn 9y agoI'm gonna try that out!
- noobhacker 9y agoHow does one dispute a bill? On what basis can we say that this bill should have been $X instead of $Y? I'd love to start doing this but I don't know how.
- creaghpatr 9y agoFirst step is to ask for an itemized bill, usually comes out to be a couple pages in a hospital. Then check for anything that looks wrong or charged wrong. 90% of medical bills contain at least one error. There are also advocacy companies that will do this for you, a solid investment if you're paying 10k+.
- noobhacker 9y ago"Check for anything that looks wrong or charged wrong." Could you clarify against which should I check? The original problem is that no price is published in the first place.
- jbob2000 9y agoI'm getting tired of the passive journalism around american healthcare. Lots of sob stories and lots of statistics, but nobody saying the right things. Why have I never read "when hospitals charge you too much, they are telling you that you don't deserve to live". $25,000 for an MRI??? That's basically the hospital saying "fuck you, die".
- wmeredith 9y agoIt sounds like you're looking for an opinion piece when what you're actually reading is reporting of facts or human interest stories.
- jbob2000 9y agoI guess that's what I was trying to get at - you can report facts and human interest stories til the cows come home, it's just noise at this point, we've heard these stories thousands of times. If journalists want any hand in the healthcare revolution, they need to be more than just mouthpieces.
- tiggybear 9y agoIt's not the hospital, it's the doctors and other healthcare workers that enable it... see how easy it is to pass blame around? I see your point, but whose fault is it really? They couldn't charge that much if the health care workers didn't agree to it.
- KekDemaga 9y agoHospitals are forced to provide services in emergencies like the situation you described, so it's more like "fuck you, don't pay any of the bills we send you and it will be off of your credit score within seven years" Much less dramatic but more accurate.
- tcj_phx 9y agoSometimes doctors do good work, sometimes the medical-industrial complex makes work for itself. When insurance is paying the bills, no one has to care about effectiveness or costs. Elisabeth Rosenthal recently published An American Sickness. These lines from Insurance policy: How an industry shifted from protecting patients to seeking profit [0] concisely summarize the medical industry's current business model: >> The very idea of health insurance is in some ways the original sin that catalyzed the evolution of today’s medical-industrial complex. >> The people who founded the Blue Cross Association in Texas nearly a century ago had no idea how their innovation would spin out of control. They intended it to help the sick. And, in the beginning, it did. >> A hundred years ago medical treatments were basic, cheap and not terribly effective. Often run by religious charities, hospitals were places where people mostly went to die. “Care,” such as it was, was delivered at dispensaries by doctors or quacks for minimal fees. [0] http://stanmed.stanford.edu/2017spring/how-health-insurance-changed-from-protecting-patients-to-seeking-profit.html http://stanmed.stanford.edu/2017spring/how-health-insurance-... Court-ordered psychiatry is the biggest racket of all because the doctors (who think they know what they're doing) don't have to get their patients' informed consent [1] before hurting them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informed_consent edit: 'racket' above changed to 'business model'
- occultist_throw 9y agoI would love for someone to explain how keeping the pricing information away from me, for weeks or months equates "Informed Consent"? Because if I would have known the price, I would have chosen not to "consume" the services. I would love to see a lawsuit based on this very area, with complete lack of informed consent with regards to cost and health benefit. Because the way it's currently handled is like if I went into a Walmart, loaded up with lots of stuff, and walked out the door. Then 3 months later, I get letters saying I owe X*$1,000 on threat of all sorts of things (garnishment, lawsuit, etc).
- tynpeddler 9y agoPrice transparency is the number 1 hurdle facing American healthcare. How are you supposed to fix a cost problem if you don't know what anything costs? Worse yet, how can there be a market for a service if there are no prices??? Less than 10% of healthcare expenditures are emergencies, that leaves a lot of room for shopping around. I'm also really glad that people are starting to realize that Obamacare had critical conceptual failures. There was nothing in the ACA that tackled healthcare costs, it was only concerned with spreading healthcare costs. Affordable healthcare is not the same thing as affordable health insurance. The Democrats are certain that they already know the right answer, lack of data be damned. The Republican leadership on the other hand doesn't really grok yet that there is a problem (or rather currently they think that Obamacare is the problem, when in truth Obamacare is neither the problem or the solution).
- wmeredith 9y agoI tend to agree. Pick any healthcare service and call around to your local hospitals and try to get them to tell you what it costs. Half the time they'll tell you THEY don't know. The other half of the time they'll just refuse to tell you. It's insanity, and I suspect it's because you are not the customer. The insurance companies are. The incentives are all wrong.
- neaden 9y agoIf they do tell you it's not like they'll fine it binding either. Or good luck finding an error in billing in what they give you and then successfully contesting it. There area also all the ways they slap on random charges. The article mentions a $40 holding baby fee! I think a big part of why this isn't seen as a bigger problem is most people don't have direct experience with it. I've managed to be healthy and avoid any surprise medical bills so far in my life so it would be easy for me to assume this stuff would be taken care of by my insurance if anything happens. I know enough people who have horror stories to know that isn't the case though.
- Cacti 9y agoI believe the fees like 'holding a baby' are a result of them determining an overall cost to charge you, average, per hour, then itemizing it out for legal or tracking reasons. So you weren't being charged $40 to hold the baby for a minute, it's you are being charged $40 for a minute, during which you held the baby.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThe number one thing that should be done is to require medical providers to post public prices and their billing to be detailed enough to tell what the charges are for. I have seen bills "Lab services: $12000". How is a patient to tell if this is legitimate or not?
- wmeredith 9y agoSerious question: can anyone point me to some good stories where someone just told these hospitals to fuck off when they try to charge hundreds of dollars for a band-aid or an aspirin? I suspect that would be my response. What happens? Do they just wreck your credit by turning you over to a collection agency? Another question: Can they be sued for price gouging? I'd love to see them legally justify before the court some of this garbage pricing that varies by tens of thousands of percent between providers for commodity items like saline, bandages, and generic drugs. When I read some of these horror stories, I suspect that I would declare bankruptcy out of principal were I to have this misfortune to get hit with one of these bills. The whole health care industry in this country has become a cancer on society. What's the hidden cost of the stress and anxiety this causes in our day to day lives. When an ER visit can financially ruin you for years, how much better is this than living without modern health care at all?
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Serious question: can anyone point me to some good stories where someone just told these hospitals to fuck off when they try to charge hundreds of dollars for a band-aid or an aspirin? I suspect that would be my response. What happens? Do they just wreck your credit by turning you over to a collection agency? No, and in fact, self-paying (ie, uninsured) patients can pretty much always tell the hospital, "No, I'm not going to be able to pay $10,000, but if you give me a discount to $500, I can pay in cash today". Of course, most patients don't know they can do that. > Can they be sued for price gouging? I'd love to see them legally justify before the court some of this garbage pricing that varies by tens of thousands of percent between providers for commodity items like saline, bandages, and generic drugs. It's not really price gouging the way we generally use that term. Hospitals lose money per-patient on Medicare and Medicaid patients that they treat, and they have to make it back somehow. They way they do that is by marking up the rates for private insurers. By law, they can't present different initial prices to patients (or their insurers) based on their insurance status, so that means that uninsured patients end up seeing an initial bill that's really intended only for private insurers. Hospitals are able to discount that later on, but of course most patients don't know to ask for this. Medical billing is separate from health insurance, and it's a whole complex messy beast in its own right.
- ianbicking 9y agoI'm surprised that HMOs haven't become more of a thing. I.e., systems where the insurance and care are combined in one private system. It seems like HMOs should be politically acceptable to all sides, and are akin to a privatized single payer system. HMOs would seem to address the pricing issue.
- hnal943 9y agoI thought this was tried in the 90s. Everyone hated HMOs because of the byzantine restrictions they placed on care without lowering costs.
- mjevans 9y agoThe only real way to drive down prices is competition. I honestly don't understand why we can't make the military's medical system available as such a source of competition; if government waste is so rampant and procurement so expensive, surely private companies can easily beat them on price if they are also in the market.
- xenihn 9y agoI was recently billed $6500 for an MRI. I ended up being completely fine, but I'm really annoyed with what happened. An MRI is typically $500, but I went to UCLA's radiology facility because I was referred there by a UCLA specialist at a clinic. The $6000 was a hospital fee that was tacked on because the radiology facility is located on hospital grounds. The explanation/itemization from UCLA is that it's because hospital equipment was used, but it wasn't any different from equipment at any other radiology center. My insurance paid most of it ($4000ish) and I'm "only" responsible for around $500, but I'm extremely soured by the experience. I've had major surgeries that cost around that much. An MRI anywhere else would have cost me $50 total. I feel completely bilked by UCLA and I wish I could avoid giving them any more money, but I don't have very many choices around their campus when it comes to accepting my insurance. It makes me never want to set foot in a hospital again unless I'm literally dying.
- sjg007 9y agoAn MRI is considered lab imaging which is typically a flat rate copay line item. So was the $500 your copay + coinsurance (with the coinsurance on the hospital fee portion)? And the normal MRI copay is $50?
- xenihn 9y agoThe $500 I owe is JUST for hospital fees. I paid $550 total.
- rconti 9y agoSomething similar happened to me, except my insurance company helped me dodge a bullet. My doctor is at Stanford so when an MRI was recommended, they just scheduled me at their facility for an MRI in a couple of weeks. Well, a couple of days after my initial visit, my insurance company had someone call me and say "hey, just so you know, we authorized your MRI at Stanford, and we will cover it to the tune of 90%, but the price is higher than most in your area, so we want to make you aware of more affordable options." I'm a pretty stubborn person, and I hate feeling like my insurance company is trying to screw me, so I thanked him for his time and declined. Then, after a few minutes, I started coming to my senses. Yes, I have good insurance. Yes, they'll pay. That said, should I really have a $5000 MRI instead of a $750 one? Yeah, I can afford the $500 copay, but do I really want to? I'm used to just taking whatever services are recommended, but this time I went ahead and cancelled the Stanford MRI and took the $750 one instead. Saved myself some money, saved my insurance company a lot of money, and sent all of those dollars to a provider giving me a service at a reasonable cost. (sort of related, my wife was recently in an accident where she went to the Stanford ER and was in the hospital for almost a week, plus some surgery. We accidentally gave the wrong insurance info so of course I got an Explanation of Benefits from my insurance company a few weeks later, saying "you owe your provider: $200,000" which is quite a funny thing to receive. Maybe it it was $20k it would be stressful, but once it hits the hundreds of thousands you realize you're not going to pay for it anyway. Amusingly, I think it didn't even include the surgery, or at least not the anesthesia, so I'm quite sure the true cost was north of $300 or $400k, and wouldn't be surprised if it broke a half million dollars after followups)
- alistproducer2 9y agoThe "free market" is just a terrible solution to providing health care. There are some cases where it can work, but as a general solution it doesn't. Roads are the same way. Does a private, market solution (toll roads) work sometimes? Sure. Could we build our entire network of roads using tolls. Of course not. In a way this is a bit of a cop out because no one can/will up end the entire system.One thought experiment I like to run is what happens to prices if we use to government to subsidize supply of services? Provide free schooling and other government benefits for people willing to train to become medical workers. Take the rural dentist crisis. IMO the government should be training people who live in those communities to become dentists for free. We have limited examples in places like Cuba. I'm not saying that full on socialism is a magic bullet, but I think smartly applied it works better for markets like healthcare.
- mjevans 9y agoYes, I believe competition can exist, but the time for competition is the 'market' setting the proper price for a procedure (in something like a dutch auction contract). A single payer system can (and should) still have competition. Not when someone in need of services is going to a doctor, but when the single "insurance plan" is deciding which local doctors to contract with at a given rate.
- justwantaccount 9y agoI'm in the healthcare industry, so I try my best to pay attention to it through news and blogs and such, though I don't claim to be an expert in the field. My impression is that price transparency is the least of the healthcare industry's problems. On aggregate, Medicare pays out about 25% of what the hospital or physician asks for, and private insurances apparently about 50%. The pricing for the uninsured is the initial price that hospitals/physicians set to get the maximum they can out of different insurance companies, and are not meant to be the charge for uninsured patients. There's been studies talking about how price transparency doesn't change physician behavior in hospitals that tried it out. Some patients report trying to compare prices for procedures across physicians and hospitals, but didn't get the quality of treatment due to picking the cheapest one. Instead, the #1 concern you hear about all the time is EHR (electronic health records). It's the #1 reason physicians give for feeling burned out, according to some surveys. The popular opinion on electronic healthcare records seem to be that they're glorified cash registers for keeping track of claims data to bill insurance, but doesn't contain much clinically relevant data - for example, I hear physicians complaining online about how they can find when a patient went to an ER and through what means, but they have trouble finding what clinical reasons the patient went to the ER for. Granted, apparently a few percentage of physicians think that their EHR contain clinically relevant data, but most EHR systems that people are using right now aren't that sophisticated, usually due to cost and to the stupid time it would take to update to the new system and train people to use it properly. Word is that it takes years for a practitioner to learn how to use the EHR system (EPIC, Cerner, etc.). Different hospitals use different systems, which makes interoperability impossible, since there aren't good standards for recording EHRs, or they're over-complicated, or something according to people who develop EHRs. I also hear hospital C-level people talking about how expensive EHR systems are - one hospital reported upgrading to a new one cost about half a billion dollars, which was a third of their net patient revenue. Independent physicians are opting for direct primary care models (where you directly pay the physician some monthly fee, circumventing insurance) or to be employed by larger hospitals or physician groups, because the federal government requires that you try to implement some level of EHR, which is too expensive for independent physicians that can't afford hiring IT people on top of everyone else. Some surverys say that physicians spend half their time on looking at / putting data into EHRs, which can be twice as much time as they spend on seeing patients face-to-face. Health insurance billing being extremely complicated doesn't help, either. You have to learn CPT/ICD-9/ICD-10 codes to bill correctly and get reimbursed, and it's so complicated that apparently some people get paid ~$40,000 a year just to convert diagnoses/procedures to CPT/ICD-9/ICD-10 codes. Hospitals/physicians end up needing to pay for those jobs as well, on top of IT people for maitaining/upgrading EHRs. In fact, there's a lot of consultation groups out there that advise you on how to bill insurance / submit required documents for Medicare / set up EHR. There's a lot of other administrative overhead costs that contribute to healthcare costs seems to need higher priority, to me.
- MR4D 9y agoImagine you go to get an oil change for your car. You ask how much it will cost and hear back that it’s $20. So you get the oil change, pay the bill, and go on your merry way. One week later, you get a $30 for environment remediation. And other week later, and you get a $15 bill for an engine-rev specialist and another $2 bill for an oil plug specialist. One month later you get a statement (not a bill !) from your car maker that the $187 cost is partially paid by them. You don’t know why, and still aren’t sure how much you owe. So you ignore all the bills and continue on your merry way. 60 more days later you get a letter from a debt collector. You have not paid $103 in oil change bills, and you have two weeks to do so or your credit score will be impacted. Nervous, you call them up, and a very rude woman tells them you better pay the bill or else! This, ladies and gentlemen, is healthcare in America.