14 ms·
Overweight and obesity are linked to cancer
- ransom1538 9y agoEating kills you. Heart disease kills 614,348 people per year & cancer kills 591,699 per year [i]. Heart disease has been linked to saturated fat for years. Cancer is your own cells that have mutated. Each new cell is just ticket to the cancer lotto. Obesity = more cells. Cancer & Heart disease kill over a million per year. But we spend most of our media time on shootings and snake bites, in reality it's that bag of Cool Ranch Doritos (which are a curse on humanity). [i] https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/282929.php https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/282929.php
- artellectual 9y agoDose of reality most people don’t want to hear right there.
- jtmarmon 9y agoa bag of cool ranch doritos has 1 gram of saturated fat. saturated fat is not linked with heart disease http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736%2817%2932252-3/fulltext?ex_cid=SigDig http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-67... Total fat and saturated and unsaturated fats were not significantly associated with risk of myocardial infarction or cardiovascular disease mortality.
- andrewflnr 9y agoRather the opposite, in fact, which is kind of hilarious to me. > Intake of total fat and each type of fat was associated with lower risk of total mortality...
- jtmarmon 9y agoIt is hilarious, although I left it the lower risk of all type mortality since OP was specifically talking about saturated fat being linked to heart disease. But yes people should probably eat less pasta and more steak
- KitDuncan 9y agoYeah. Lets all go on a Keto diet and sustain 400 million americans on steak. Do you people ever stop and think about the consequences of your diet?
- michaelhoney 9y agoI think it’s the number of people which is the problem. Also, there are not 400m Americans. Yet.
- maloney 9y agoKeto is a high fat diet not a high protien diet. Replace "keto" with "Atkin's" and I have no issue with your comment, in fact i would agree.
- Cheezmeister 9y agoFunny, if you flip to any recent thread about climate change, you're likely to come across someone advocating less steak and more pasta. Why? Producing meat is incredibly resource-intensive; cows are the biggest offenders. They literally shit greenhouse gas. Which is not to say I don't enjoy a nice juicy cheezburger. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
- maxerickson 9y ago1 gram per serving. Most of their packages contain multiple servings. Even the smaller packages that you usually see on the shelf are 3 servings, at least in the US.
- log_base_login 9y agoThe fun size bags have one serving, but even so I doubt that doritos, en masse, are to blame for obesity. It's the accompanying sedentary lifestyle that is the real culprit. If we want a food source to blame, look at high sugar content foods like soda or the slew of 'Little Debbie' type snacks (I'm preferential to Nutter Butters) that can be consumed in one or two sittings if you aren't calorie conscious. But, just to reiterate what's important, if we all just got a solid hour of exercise each day the rate of cancer and heart disease would drop appreciably.
- matwood 9y ago> if we all just got a solid hour of exercise each day the rate of cancer and heart disease would drop appreciably. But people really want a magic bullet, "X is bad, Y is good". People generally do not like to exercise so they'll keep looking for something else.
- novia 9y agoConversely, junk food companies love to shift the blame to the consumers not getting enough exercise.
- mattnewton 9y agoI don’t disagree that the sedantary lifestyle is the primary cause. However the processed food industry is a dangerous trap; Doritos and their ilk are almost as dangerous as those other sugary snacks, they are just a different kind of addictive, using fats, salt and MSG instead of sugar http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/10/01/dining/nacho-graphic.html?=ref=dining http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2013/10/01/dining/nacho-g...
- 9y ago
- runeks 9y agoThe link between saturated fats and disease is dubious at best. Here’s[1] a meta-analysis with 350,000 subjects that failed to show a link between saturated fat, coronary heart disease, stroke and cardiovascular disease. Many meta-analyses[2] fail to show a correlation, and many remain unpublished. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2824152/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2824152/ [2] http://www.bmj.com/content/351/bmj.h3978 http://www.bmj.com/content/351/bmj.h3978
- ISL 9y agoand many remain unpublished. Citation?
- legulere 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publication_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publication_bias
- ransom1538 9y agoThe scientific consensus is that saturated fat is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, having been endorsed by many medical, scientific, heart-health, governmental and intergovernmental, and professional authorities, such as the World Health Organization,[1] the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academy of Medicine,[2] the American Dietetic Association,[3] the Dietitians of Canada,[3] the British Dietetic Association,[4] American Heart Association,[5] the British Heart Foundation,[6] the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada,[7] the World Heart Federation,[8] the British... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovascular_disease https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovasc...
- walshemj 9y agoActually a lot of these xx Is bad for you are dubious or just well marketed fads eg lo salt as my specialised NHS dietician (for chronic kidney failure) commented they don't tell you what C$%^ the put in to replace salt
- 9y ago
- kmm 9y ago> Obesity = more cells That's not true. Not only do fat cells just grow bigger (a skinny person has just as many as a fat person), you'd expect the increase in cancers to be mostly liposarcomas ("fat cell cancer"), which stay very rare. Other organs might be distended or enlarged, but they don't contain more cells. The reason obesity leads to cancer is not very well understood, but it's probably a complicated process involving abnormal hormone levels usual in obese people, and the constant low-grade inflammation their body is usually suffering from
- killjoywashere 9y agoThe low grade inflam and hormones are definitely causal. Another that biologists don't really from is the simple increased temp these people live at due to fat being insulation: Simple thermodynamics starts to creep in over 50 years.
- mcculley 9y agoHow can that be true? Don't fat people at least have more skin cells than skinny people? Also, I can't imagine that enormously obese people just have larger fat cells than skinny people. I have read that it is harder to get rid of fat cells once they shrink, but not that we don't get more of them.
- ztjio 9y agoA common misunderstanding is that organs are made up entirely of "cells" but, they are not. There are other materials involved, such as collagen. We call these names like "connective tissues" and they take up a lot of the space. That doesn't mean they aren't involved, proteins can go wrong, but, that is usually associated with other types of diseases besides cancer.
- mcculley 9y agoThat still leaves me confused. A skinny adult who becomes obese has the same number of skin cells? That sounds hard to believe.
- aviv 9y agoAdd to that #3 on the list, the 250,000 Americans that die each year from medical errors.
- jasonwelk 9y agoThis might be completely inaccurate, but I've always thought of the body as a machine, and it has moving parts. And as with any machine, the more its parts move and get used over time, the sooner the machine will wear out. And if you eat more, regardless of whether it's healthy or not, just the quantity itself, you are going to make the parts inside you move more to process the digestion. Eating less puts less stress on your system over time, as long as you are of course not under p-eating by an alarming amount.
- bachaco 9y agoBut that would mean a direct relationship between physical exercise and death, which I believe is not the case.
- jasonwelk 9y agoI don't follow. The body spends much more time digesting food than is normally spent exercising. I've read that constant digesting gets in the way of the body doing nightly internal cleanup processes that detox your system, as energy is diverted to process food instead. That might be another source of problems.
- bachaco 9y agoThe more exercise you do the more you have to eat to maintain your body. If you are following a healthy diet you will need to increase even more your total amount of food due the fact that generally healthy food has less calories. Also, there is nothing more stressful for the body than exercise.
- jasonwelk 9y ago> there is nothing more stressful for the body than exercise I think you are postulating. There was an article here a week or two ago that showed how bodies frequently in motion tend to live longer and be healthiest. There are different types of effects on the body from activities, and I'd be willing to bet that a body that's constantly in a state of digestion is stressed more than one in natural motion. However, I say this with a disclaimer that I'm guessing based on recent articles posted here. But if you really think otherwise, you should just provide a source. Also, unless you are training for the Olympics, you do not need to linearly scale your food intake in proportion to your exercise. The average diet for many people does not need to change much after introducing exercise because the average diet already is usually too many calories.
- FLUX-YOU 9y ago>But we spend most of our media time on shootings and snake bites, in reality it's that bag of Cool Ranch Doritos (which are a curse on humanity). We really going to worry about a bag of chips when so many people still smoke?
- evgen 9y agoSmoking has been falling constantly and it is now 1/3 the level it was 40 years ago. Not only is it falling, but the rate at which it is declining is increasing. OTOH Americans apparently cannot, under any circumstances, stop shoveling Oreos and Twinkies into their mouths. There are far more obese Americans than there are Americans who consume tobacco products and the obesity rate is going up. Any resources spent on reducing obesity will deliver greater returns than that spent on reducing smoking, even given the greater risk that smoking represents at the individual level.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 9y agoMore cells + a compromised system* = Problems. The problem is people aren't interested in health. Oreos are a God given right, evidently. And it's easier to blame the healthcare system than to face the truth. That is, you are what you consume. *The report is just cancer, but diabetes will be just as happy to kill too.
- Toine 9y agoIn other news, fire burns.
- marindez 9y agoIn what way is it obvious that obesity leads to cancer?
- Toine 9y agoGoogle « obesity cancer », you’ll find many. It’s just that I thought it was common knowledge by now..
- dreamdu5t 9y agoBecause like smoking it’s obviously unnatural to eat like crap and sit on the computer/couch/car all day. If not obvious then not surprising. Obesity is the epitome and result ohf an unhealthy lifestyle of no exercise and eating junk food.
- marindez 9y agoObesity is obviously unnatural and unhealthy and I still don't see how it is obviously linked to cancer.
- flachsechs 9y agoi'll go out on a limb and agree with you. it's not "obvious" that obesity is linked to cancer unless you view the world through hindsight-glasses. skinny athletic people get cancer too. it wasn't even "obvious" for most of the 20th century cigarettes gave you cancer. people have short memories. a contemporary example: is it "obvious" right now that sugar gives you cancer? because to a lot of people it is blindingly, astoundingly obvious, and to some that sounds like conspiracy theory nonsense. i don't understand this aversion to doing "obvious" science -- we have to do science to make things obvious, not the other way around.
- jlebrech 9y agoputting more unhealthy things into your mouth causes cancer, pretty obvious
- tyingq 9y agoCurious if it's cause, or shared effect. Like perhaps the diet of an obese person generally has a higher amount of carcinogens, or lacks in some key antioxidants...in addition to making you overweight.
- tosstossy 9y agoObese people probably produce elevated levels of insulin-like growth factors over time due to their dietary choices. IGF-1 is already understood to increase cancer rates. Intermittent fasting studies tend to focus on IGF-1 levels in the interests of slowing aging, which is of course strongly related to cancer prevention.
- DoodleBuggy 9y agoThis type of data is going to upset the fat acceptance movement.
- Simon_says 9y agoDoubt it. They didn't arrive at their opinions via a measured dispassionate analysis of the medical literature, so why would any of this affect them at all?
- DoodleBuggy 9y agoSociety appears to be moving to a post-fact era, where opinions and feelings matter more than evidence and data.
- brainfire 9y agoJust like all those stubborn meat eaters ignoring the science that eating meat increases cancer risk.
- qazpot 9y agoI don't understand why any comments in support of this article are being downvoted. Is it now politically incorrect to support agree with scientific studies? Reminds me of climate change deniers.
- ransom1538 9y agoYes it is hilarious. I posted the article to overwhelmingly large scientific community that acknowledges the link of saturated fats to heart disease - I have never been so downvoted. I am waiting for the bush did 911 comments. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovascular_disease https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat_and_cardiovasc...
- vixen99 9y agoDiscuss the arguments and the data not a consensus of opinions. Science isn't done that way. Not so long ago, margarine (industrially hydrogenated fat) was touted by a majority of recognized experts as a healthy option while butter and eggs were supposed to be the route to heart disease and stroke. Merely adopting a consensus view is a dice game.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoBut we've had the science. That is, we know that extra weight compromises the human system. For example, diabetes. This report isn't new. It's not a surprise. We already knew that if you make the body do something outside the norm of natural (e.g., smoking) the odds of bad things happening is going to increase. Sure it's nice to have micro proof of a cancer connextion. But at the macro level this is just new chapter in a pattern we've proven plenty of times before.
- kbutler 9y agoSo is long distance running natural? Periodic fasting? Living on no meat? Sitting on an elevated seat to defecate? Eating bananas in the wintertime? Or in non-tropical regions? Living surrounded by 1,000,000 other people? Sleeping in a heated (or air conditioned) room? Modern medical care when you're injured or ill? We really have no idea what "the norm of natural" would be. And some things that are not "natural" are clearly beneficial.
- rammy1234 9y agoirrespective of cancer being linked with being Obese, it is always better to remain active. naturally our body is not designed to have a sedentary lifestyle. So study can be taken as a reminder to stay active and not being a couch potato. take frequent breaks and have some active lifestyle.
- patcheudor 9y ago"More than half of Americans that overweight and obesity can increase their risk for cancer." Sorry to be 'that guy', but I'd expect official statements from the CDC to be better proof-read as this sort of thing really does impact the credibility of the message.
- jknoepfler 9y agoYou might want to append a (sic.) to the quote. I assumed you made the typo until I read the follow-up.
- sabujp 9y agoit doesn't really matter if it is or not, some studies say yes others say no. Bottom line is it sucks to be fat and overweight, e.g. you have less energy and life is just less fun.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoI used to weigh well over 300lbs, and I eventually took up a hobby that made me want to lose it badly enough to go through the trouble of making my body eat half of itself. I don't get to order pizza. I don't get to pick up something from a fast food joint on the way home. I can't go to a restaurant with friends. I have to avoid gatherings where free food will be present. I dread the days a coworker brings in donuts. I've had to get used to going to bed hungry. I usually don't have much energy at all because my caloric intake has to be restricted so much to prevent me from gaining weight back, so I take stimulants to suppress appetite and make it possible to get through the day without falling asleep at my desk. I am a slave to the scale. So I guess what I'm saying is that I disagree with your statement. Oh, it sucked to be fat alright, because people treated me like shit just for existing and because it was embarrassing every time I broke a chair, but I wouldn't say I had less energy and I definitely wouldn't say I had less fun either.
- droopyEyelids 9y agoWhat about stuff like how after losing weight I notice myself running to catch a bus? I _never_ would have done that in the past. Or even the other day I realized I was taking steps two at a time! Woah! That is Not the old me.
- xinyhn 9y agoMy personal experience is very similar and you described it in a way better than I could. And then add on to that the requirement to do that day in and day out for the rest of your life. Thank you for sharing.
- musgrove 9y agoPoint taken, but who wrote that? It's hard to establish credibility when your authors write like a 3rd grader.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoFrom the sidebar: > good health is the best prescription for preventing chronic diseases That's bad enough to approach self-parody, but in a way it's very illustrative of the fact that apart from smoking cessation and arguably some other forms of drug addiction treatment, we have very little in the way of demonstrably effective lifestyle interventions to prevent chronic illness. There are mountains of epidemiological associations and sometimes even plausible physiological mechanisms for many of these things, but it often turns out that the obvious intervention just defies the correlation instead of changing the outcome (cf. Goodhart's law), or changes things in a statistically significant but practically underwhelming way. As far as I know, obesity is mostly significant as a public health issue because it makes many conditions modestly worse, not because it's the primary cause of any given problem. Losing weight might mitigate an illness such that you cross some diagnostic threshold and are thus "cured", but you're still in a much different state than someone who wasn't at risk of that illness at any weight. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try to maintain a healthy weight, just that it's wishful thinking to expect that doing so is going to solve all or even most of your problems. In general, it's important to recognize that health is a complex topic and not fool ourselves into thinking we've found the key to good health.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoPut another way...if you have a serious medial issue being overweight can be the difference between life and death. Instead, we have Oprah selling "love your body" as if that love will save you went a health crisis comes knocking.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoLoving your body while you're overweight and getting to a healthier weight are not at cross purposes. Shame causes people to dissociate with their bodies which makes exercise and healthy eating harder. The fact that we are encouraged to think of being overweight as a personality flaw makes it much harder for people to lose weight. They take their weight as evidence of their weakness which causes a detrimental cycle. It's also true that popular notions of "healthy weight" are medically inaccurate. Many people who are a normal healthy weight and have no medical reason to lose weight still think they are overweight. There are lots of good reasons to encourage people to think of themselves as healthy at non-skinny sizes.
- fasteo 9y agoSlightly OT, but I was just reading some fascinating comments in [1]. The post was about cancer and mitochondria. Particularly for me, the series of comments about how the nervous system can play a role in cancer development (via inflammation promoting activity) is fascinating. There are even some comments from Carlos Monteiro, a controversial cardiologist. He postulates that cardiac glycosides (used to treat cardiac problems) are also a potent anti-cancer drug. [1] https://joshmitteldorf.scienceblog.com/2017/10/01/is-cancer-a-mitochondrial-disease/ https://joshmitteldorf.scienceblog.com/2017/10/01/is-cancer-... [2] http://www.infarctcombat.org/cm/homepage.html http://www.infarctcombat.org/cm/homepage.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- quickoats 9y agocancer = mold. nature collects garbage by recycling unused things by means of disease, insect, etc. just use your body and mind together all the time.
- jakeogh 9y agoRelevant (fascinating!) talk from another thread[1]: https://overcast.fm/+FaTQX2SRE https://overcast.fm/+FaTQX2SRE [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15424339 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15424339
- baldfat 9y agoThe more the cells the higher the chance for a mutation? The older we get the more opportunity for cell mutation?
- nonbel 9y agoCell division is not perfect, each time there is a chance of error. This is why anything that results in a net increase in cell division will be linked to cancer. Obesity means you have more cells than other people... to have more cells there must have been more cell divisions. The role of mitogenesis in cancer has been realized for many, many years[1], so I'm not sure why there is still any controversy about it. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC54830/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC54830/
- stewbrew 9y agoNot exactly news but worth being mentioned from time to time.
- nikolay 9y agoObesity is due to the Metabolic Syndrome, i.e. it is strongly linked to diabetes. Watch the presentation below, which I recorded at our church, which is about the leading UCLA research on linking diabetes and cancer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSo-p7DafpA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSo-p7DafpA
- vorotato 9y agoand mental health issues (ex: depression, anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), binge eating disorder, and night eating syndrome.) are linked to obesity.