11 ms·
> In an attempt to keep you connected to Apple devices and services, iOS 11 compromises users' security. No. It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of m
by Terretta 9y ago
> In an attempt to keep you connected to Apple devices and services, iOS 11 compromises users' security.
No. It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of money experienced by everyday users who turn off WiFi when it’s flakey and then forget to turn it back on, costing them cash on their cellular data plan. (And the very real frustration when things don’t work they expect to work, and they don’t know why.)
Meanwhile, the security motivated user will figure out she can 3D Touch or go into settings and meet her more sophisticated use cases.
Consider the normal user’s scenarios and do the math. This saves more users from more loss.
- astronautjones 9y agoThis is such a backwards approach to security in an age where the average user is only less and less informed
- new299 9y agoI just spent a couple of minutes trying to 3D touch to properly disable wifi, then googling how to do this with 3d touch and came up empty. Either it doesn't work that way, or it's well hidden and appears not great in terms of UX. Overall, I agree with you though. I'm personally not clear on the utility of turning off just wifi or just bluetooth. I assume (hope) airplane mode turns everything off. But in any other scenario you're still leaking location and other information.
- mattacular 9y agoThere is no way to 3D touch the bluetooth and wireless radios all the way off in iOS11. You have to manually go all the way into settings.app now which takes quite a bit more effort not to mention longer than the old control center
- nkristoffersen 9y agoYou can 3D Touch the settings app which provides shortcuts to both bluetooth settings and wifi settings.
- mtgx 9y agoSounds like terrible UX. iOS has only gotten downhill since iOS7 in terms of UX.
- codefined 9y agoThis change would be absolutely fine to me if it were communicated to the user in any way whatsoever. The fact that I can upgrade and have no idea the behaviour unless I happen to read an EFF blogpost in the few hours it appears on HN isn't acceptable. Note how they even use privacy as one of the main (at least, in my opinion) selling point for Apple devices[0] ("Every Apple product is designed from the ground up to protect that information."). [0] https://www.apple.com/uk/privacy/ https://www.apple.com/uk/privacy/
- MBCook 9y agoIt IS communicated. If you just pull up control center and tap the button is says “Disconnected from ‘WiFiNetwork’”. If you expand the panel with 3D Touch or a long press under the WiFi icon it either says WiFiName or Not Connected. On the other hand the cellular radio says Off if you toggle it. This isn’t completely hidden. The information is there. And I agree with the other posters that this is a far better setting considering how many people have run up ridiculous cellular bills because of bad Wi-Fi and forgetting about the setting. At this point I’m not sure there’s a need for normal users to actually turn off Wi-Fi. The only real case would be something like airplane mode which already has its own setting.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- developer2 9y ago>> this is a far better setting considering how many people have run up ridiculous cellular bills because of bad Wi-Fi and forgetting about the setting >> I’m not sure there’s a need for normal users to actually turn off Wi-Fi. The only real case would be something like airplane mode which already has its own setting This exactly matches my own opinion. Nearly every single user has no legitimate reason to need to turn off the Wifi adapter (short of Airplane mode). Those who need this functionality (such as dev testing an app whereby Wifi is not available) will know how to fully disable it. The only real argument I'm hearing is this overly sensational concern about privacy. The counterarguments are stretching so far to find any reason to complain about the product, that these are either Android users trying to drum up drama, or coming from legitimate wearers of tinfoil hats. I'm a professional software developer. I'm intricately aware of the tracking potential from walking around with Wifi enabled. It just DOESN'T MATTER. You're only blocking stores from gathering analytics, if that. Your phone provider (and therefore the government) can already track you by cell towers. If you're the type of person who is so concerned with tracking of your Wifi adapter, you're not worrying about the right things. You need to disable Wifi, Cell network, and bluetooth - and then trust that there's nothing else built in to track you. Anything less means you're not serious about your privacy. Such people should probably not even own a cell phone to begin with.
- kazinator 9y agoOr it's a jab at the competition. "So Android spontaneously turns your Wi-Fi off? How silly. Why, you know what? Ours will spontaneously turn on, take that!!"
- panarky 9y ago> No. Yes. It's not just because people forget to turn Wi-Fi back on. Radios are "off-ish" because they remain on for other Apple devices and services, but off for other uses. What actually happens in iOS 11 when you toggle your quick settings to "off" is that the phone will disconnect from Wi-Fi networks and some devices, but remain on for Apple services. Location Services is still enabled, Apple devices (like Apple Watch and Pencil) stay connected, and services such as Handoff and Instant Hotspot stay on.
- heartbreak 9y agoI disconnect from Bluetooth daily because my TV soundbar or wife’s car in the driveway picks up my audio output. I’ve never intended that action to disconnect my Apple Watch. iOS 11 is an improvement for me in that regard.
- siphor 9y agoSince it turns back on automatically at 5am, I have to remember to hard turn it off, otherwise it connects my alarm to my living room bluetooth speaker. Took me a couple days to figure out what was happening. Frustrating for me.
- blub 9y agoI don't have any other Apple devices. And no, long pressing and toggling is not disabling it on < 6s. I think they just fucked up.
- dx034 9y ago> Yes. HN audience doesn't represent the typical iphone user. The typical iphone user appreciates privacy but is less concerned about transmitting devices than about the phone bill. I'm sure there are people who always remember switching wifi back on (or have a true unlimited contract) but most (including me) are not part of that. I see why this feature can be viewed as critical but think it'll be an improvement for the vast majority of users. Ideally, they would've provided a switch in the settings to allow iOS10 behaviour. Maybe they'll bring that with a later version.
- jackvalentine 9y ago> It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of money experienced by everyday users who turn off WiFi when it’s flakey and then forget to turn it back on, costing them cash on their cellular data plan Is there a source for this, or is this your opinion?
- davb 9y ago> It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of money experienced by everyday users who turn off WiFi when it’s flakey and then forget to turn it back on, costing them cash on their cellular data plan. Is the solution here not simply to turn off mobile data when you don’t want to use it, if you’re on such a restrictive mobile plan? The fact is, the behaviour changed in a way that wasn’t made clear at all. That WiFi will reconnect by itself after being off for a period is a security and privacy issue, and is a frustrating change. Hiding things behind 3D Touch is not very intuitive or user friendly. What was once a toggle - on or off - is now a three state option where one of the stares can only be accessed from the settings app.
- servilio 9y ago> Is the solution here not simply to turn off mobile data when you don’t want to use it, if you’re on such a restrictive mobile plan? Or add warning and cut-off thresholds, isn't that alredy possible?
- firloop 9y agoI don't believe there's any way to turn off the wifi from Control Center, even with 3D touch. You must flip the toggle in Settings (TFA seems to say the same thing). Happy to be wrong here, I just couldn't figure it out while fiddling with it.
- lnguyen 9y agoYou can turn on Airplane Mode then turn back on the services you want (except cellular data)
- odammit 9y agoIs that really a concern anymore? (Anecdote alert) I roll over several gigs a month that I don’t use ... This feature has been driving me NUTS because I’m surround by about a 1000 google Starbucks and TCWifi hotspots at home and at work and I connect to them magically and suddenly my phone stops working because I haven’t logged into their service.
- colejohnson66 9y agoGo to the Wi-Fi submenu in the Settings, tap the chevron on the Starbucks network and tap “Forget this network”
- clouddrover 9y ago> resolve the real loss of money experienced by everyday users who turn off WiFi The way I've run every smartphone I've owned is to turn off mobile data, WiFi, and Bluetooth and only turn them on as and when I need them. I prefer it to work that way. The way this works in iOS 11 is now inconsistent and confusing. I can turn mobile data on and off via Control Centre. But, while I can turn WiFi on in Control Centre, I can't turn it off again. The mobile data icon in Control Centre has two states: highlighted for on and non-highlighted for off. The WiFi icon in Control Centre has three states: highlighted for on, non-highlighted for disconnected, and non-highlighted with a line through it for off. For consistency the mobile data icon should also have a line through it. I can turn WiFi off via Settings, but doing it this way is slower and clumsier than it used to be in iOS 10. As a workaround, I've added Settings to my phone's taskbar. Force pressing the Settings icon pops up a menu which lets you get to the WiFi settings directly.
- marcoperaza 9y ago>The way I've run every smartphone I've owned is to turn off mobile data, WiFi, and Bluetooth and only turn them on as and when I need them Okay, but you have to accept that this is a ridiculously small minority use case.
- clouddrover 9y agoI don't accept that. I think it's a common sense approach. I don't want my phone connecting to things without my involvement. If the icons were consistent and there was a setting to toggle the behaviour of Control Centre then it would be a non-issue. I could set it up the way I want and it would work as it used to in iOS 10. But the icons are inconsistent and, as far as I know, there's no such setting.
- neotek 9y agoYou don't accept it on what possible grounds? Do you really think the majority of iOS users, or even a sizeable minority, use their phones in the way you do?
- underwater 9y agoI don't understand why they don't just fix that specific problem.
- jonahx 9y ago> No. It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of money... Naked apologism. So unthoughtful, and delivered with such a righteous tone. If this was their intention, they could have implemented the feature honestly, informing users about what was happening, and offering a clear choice, such as an immediate popup, between "turn off for this location" and "turn off completely." That would have been fine. But the existence of this "pro" to the deceptive and confusing behavior does not justify it.
- IBM 9y agoThey did inform users. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208086 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208086
- beager 9y agoI fail to see how dumping documentation for a cryptic feature at such an unfriendly URL counts as "informing".
- IBM 9y agoThe UI informs the user directly that they're disconnecting from a network. This support document explains the change and how it all works in-depth for anyone who will actually care to know (everyone who reads HN or tech blogs and pretty much no one else).
- flukus 9y ago> The UI informs the user directly that they're disconnecting from a network. The UI (mis)informs the user that wifi has been turned off by greying it out, at the very least it's inconsistent with other toggle buttons. Or are there other things apple decides that you don't really want turned off?
- beager 9y agoCan you describe a reasonable scenario where a layperson would see the support document prior to encountering some sort of frustration with the feature in question?
- donohoe 9y agoNo. It’s not. I want to turn it off. The fact that this is front-page on HN means something.
- Karunamon 9y agoIt means that the minority of techies that read HN found it interesting. There’s nothing to suggest any conclusion broader than that.
- picklerick 9y agoExactly. The average iPhone user is oblivious to the change.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Sniffnoy 9y agoQuestion: Is there some reason the phone can't have some mode where it automatically determines which of mobile data or WiFi is providing the better connection at the moment, rather than having to manually toggle WiFi on and off as using the internet becomes frustrating?
- dx034 9y agoIt does (wifi assist for example) but until the phone has established if the connection works or not, the user already switched it off. When I leave the house I get ~10 sec with wifi but no actual connection. That's long enough for me to notice it but probably not enough for the iphone to detect if Wifi is really not available.
- siculars 9y agoThat’s straight garbage town. There are other ways to remind users that their WiFi is off than tricking users into thinking it is off when it really isn’t. Standard “engineers know best” mentality. Off means off. As in the opposite of on. This nonsense feeds into people (rightful) distrust of technology.
- lathiat 9y agoI'm a generally well educated person in both security, radios, etc. I can tell you that the control Centre Wi-Fi is basically always used by me to disconnect from the current network. And it persistently infuriated me when I would later forget and was on mobile data. I can also see users frequently being confused by things like their Apple Pencil not working. I love this change. You can still turn it off properly in settings. I generally trust Apple with frequent and speedy security updates. Their security track record is industry leading. I'm not remotely concerned. Also most of the time people tell me they want this option they really mean they want to save battery life. I'd suggest just using low power mode for that, it's what it's designed for.
- cassowary 9y agoHi Lathiat. Why do you need to disconnect from the current network? I can think of many alternatively implementations which would meet most requirements that have been proposed, like turning the wifi back on when the battery is charging or at 5am. All the proposals involve compromises, but it seems much easier to make a notice that clearly says "Wifi will reconnect at 5am" then to say "Wifi is still using your battery, but we've disconnected from the current network". I mean, the message itself fits in the same space as the current message, and the icon itself could have a timer band counting down till 5am so you know that it's only temporarily disabled. (I too have accidentally used up all my month's data because I left the wifi off for a few days. It's not nice. I'd appreciate a feature which deals with it. But this one is unpredictable, unreadable and confusing.) Also, are you proposing that low power mode with wifi uses the same amount of power as lower power mode without wifi? If I know I'm not going to see a power point for many hours, I turn my phone onto low power mode and turn wifi off (and the brightness right down and some other things). I might do it as I leave the house in the morning when I still have 95% battery. In these cases, I very often need my phone most in precisely when the battery will be weakest.
- AlfeG 9y agoWindows phones has ability to turn off for a hour/2/4 . Really miss this thing on android
- beedogs 9y agoThe security motivated user probably wouldn't be using an iPhone in the first place. Or any smartphone for that matter.
- mtgx 9y agoApparently the "security motivated" have to discover when Apple has completely changed how their apps and settings work, too. Are the "security motivated" also expected to know if iMessage or FaceTime stopped using end-to-end encryption, too? These things should be communicated. Also, all Apple had to do was make it a 3-toggle button instead of a 2-toggle one. Just keep the normal way of turning-off Wi-Fi and add a new one for Disconnect Wi-Fi, too. Nothing could be simpler. But no, Apple has to be "courageous" in pissing off a large portion of their users each time they do something, rather than implementing a UX change as simple as that without disturbing well learned UX behaviors for their users.
- dx034 9y agoIt was communicated, Apple has a page on that. It just wasn't a big part of the announcement. And the tech press covered it well enough so that it's hard to argue that users didn't know about it (at least those who are interested).
- golangnews 9y agoYou can't use 3D touch to turn off wifi. According to Apple you have go into settings to do so. https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT208086 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT208086 The problems with this change are: It is surprising - grey buttons usually mean disabled permanently, not disabled except for some uses or for some indeterminate length of time. It changes established behaviour without a clear warning to the user. It is inconsistent - disabling bluetooth now disconnects from all devices (except Apple ones!), and it says 'Not Connected' when it is in fact connected to an Apple Watch say. It is inconsistent - other buttons like airplane mode or mobile data do turn off permanently. It's not a huge deal and everyone will adapt, but you shouldn't be apologising for Apple here - this was badly done and not well thought out.
- lloeki 9y ago> You can't use 3D touch to turn off wifi. According to Apple you have go into settings to do so. Indeed, the detailed block of controls does not present the three possible states to the user. In the same zoomed in block, the Airdrop toggle does. Conversely, going to Settings is binary and allows only for On/Off, not that very practical Disconnect state. The difference between Off and Disconnected is a light bar across the icon, which is inconsistently not the case for the Off state of Mobile Data and Airplane mode. The "dumbed down" UI concerns are valid, yet the intersection between security minded folks that will proactively act to disable WiFi/BT upon a security advisory and the ones who won’t know the difference between the two ways to toggle that is close to zero. To me it looks like people are up in arms without even defining the personas and threat models. Get real, this feature is downright awesome and the slight UI hiccup is certainly no ShellShock.
- golangnews 9y agoI agree it's not a huge security vulnerability, just bad design by Apple. There are also a few other reasons for disabling wifi - battery life, tracking, debugging connections, and of course security as well (not in response to specific vulnerabilities, but on the principle of less attack surface being safer).
- helloindia 9y agoFor users with flakey wifi, there is wifi-assist, where the phone uses cellular data along with wifi.
- amigoingtodie 9y agoSo, is this a US only feature? Is excess data usage severely penalized financially in other countries?
- jaclaz 9y ago>Is excess data usage severely penalized financially in other countries? I believe it depends on ISP and on specific plan. My mom has an iPad with a limited to 3 Gb/month dataplan (Italy), a couple of times she managed to go beyond the limit (due to some updates she did when not Wi-Fi connected), since it is a sort of pre-paid account, what happened was that the device became slow as molasses, as bandwidth was reduced to the speed of an analogic modem or something like that. She still had connection, but to access a web page it took like 3 minutes. On the other hand, she changed phone from a "normal" phone to a "smart" Android one (she was totally unaware of this and didn't realize that the cellular data was on) but her SIM (also pre-paid) did have an on-demand dataplan (never used before on the old phone), very, very costly and she managed to burn 30 out of 50 € of credit in a couple days (without using the internet at all, just through the "pings" (or whatever) the Android did in background).
- abricot 9y agoIn Denmark, what happens when you reach the limit (on private plans[1]) is that your speed is limited to something between 64-256kbit/sec depending on the provider. You will never be financially penalized for going over. What is also true, however, is that most basic plans include between 10 and 20 GB of data. You have a really bad plan if you only get 3 GB. [1]The rules are a bit different for company plans.
- misnome 9y ago> No. It is in an attempt to resolve the real loss of money experienced by everyday users who turn off WiFi when it’s flakey and then forget to turn it back on, costing them cash on their cellular data plan This. I read this EFF list of "Terrible things" and thought "neat!" for every single one of these items. The nearly 100% use cases for me turning wifi 'off' is because whatever it's connected to is slow/unresponsive, or some really annoying auto-connection to a pay-wifi in the location I'm currently in. My cell connection is normally good, so sometimes it's days before I notice, or when I get a message telling me that I've used up my allowance, or try to connect to the hotspot/talk to other devices at home. With iOS 11, without reading these complaints, I'd probably never have noticed that this problem had silently solved itself and stopped annoying me.
- cup-of-tea 9y ago> This. I read this EFF list of "Terrible things" and thought "neat!" for every single one of these items. That's because you own multiple Apple devices and feel the need to staunchly defend your purchases.
- darklajid 9y ago50 (SG, less than USD) dollars. 24 GB of data. Can we make sure that we're talking about the same thing? Can we compare global data prices? What are you basing your assumption on? Talking about assumptions: My assumption is that people that buy a recent/new iPhone either a) get it with a (reasonably sized) contract and have enough data b) have a bit of disposable income to pay for data for all these places where you might need it Another fun assumption: Basically ~nowhere~ (not true ofc, but we're both generalizing) in Germany you have hotspots or free wifi. Why would a phone need constant wifi, if you only ever connect it at home, mayyyyyybe at work?
- andrewingram 9y agoIronically, the UI they added for hotspots (which has a similar off-ish setting) actually cost me money, and resulted in several days without internet. Essentially, i've left tethering on more times accidentally than ever before since upgrading to iOS 11, and used up my entire data allowance without realising it.
- vasundhar 9y agoShouldn't a company focus on Security of Normal users ? because advanced ones know to take care of it
- graeme 9y agoIphone se doesn’t have 3d touch. So there’s no way to change this quickly on those devices.
- quotha 9y agoThere is no normal user. I've got unlimited LTE data and leave WiFi off PERMANENTLY. I'm still on iOS 10.
- khana 9y agoNot this guy.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]