6 ms·
“The Domestic Dog”, featuring two decades of new evidence
- mc32 9y ago""More people may know more about dogs than ever before, but it is often a shallow sort of knowledge that is easily exploited by self-styled dog experts for personal gain,"" Whenever you start seeing somewhat obscure or at least not quite mainstream knowledge take flight in infomercials or get celeb endorsement you know there is snake oil selling going on. But I'm intrigued. Sounds like a solid book.
- DiabloD3 9y agoI see this trainwreck going on in food, too. Like, Paleo and Keto are good things, they really are, I agree with what their tenants are. Together, it is simply don't eat grains, don't eat refined sugars, don't eat legumes, don't eat shitty oils; eat meat, real vegs, some fruit, use coconut oil and olive oil and lard... but with 30g of carbs a day and a slant towards high fat. Where it goes wrong? The words Keto and Paleo on the product packaging (beyond the fact that "product packaging" usually means it isn't Paleo to begin with), and merely slapping the words on products skyrockets the price. The diets themselves aren't snake oil, but the bullshit peddlers showed up to derail Keto and Paleo for their own profit.
- Angostura 9y ago> The diets themselves aren't snake oil Except that there's no proper nutritional evidence that there is any problem at all with eating grains or legumes if you are a normal healthy person. I'm not sure there's any evidence that there's a problem with vegetable oils either. Bullshit is pervasive.
- canoebuilder 9y ago>* I'm not sure there's any evidence that there's a problem with vegetable oils either.* https://duckduckgo.com/?q=pufa+cancer&t=h_&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=pufa+cancer&t=h_&ia=web
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DiabloD3 9y agoExcept you're going about it the wrong way. We've eaten simple unrefined foods for as long as society has existed. For example, what only existed recently has been highly refined seed oils like corn, rapeseed, and canola. It is up to them to prove that they are safe for human consumption, something that they have been unable to do. However, to continue the example, those types of oils are high in PUFAs (and specifically, high in Omega 6), and this has been linked to basically every modern first world disease, including diabetes and cancer. The same applies to grains: cereals such as wheat hybridize in ways that are unusual. There is probably a level of certain chemicals (such as, but not limited to, prolamins, agglutinin, and amylase trypsin inhibitors) that are safe for human consumption, but the hybridization of these grasses for modern commercial production have greatly increased the amount of these chemicals in a given food product. Just like the oils, these hybrids are a recent invention and no science was done before they were pushed into commercial production to prove if they are safe. Unfortunately, more and more scientific papers are coming out that they are not safe and cannot be made safe. I've taken the logical and scientific choice to stop consuming these foods. During this time, although my caloric intake has not varied enough to explain the results, I lost around 130 pounds in a year: the only change I made was removing foods that are on the list.
- dagss 9y agoLook: Feeding the world on Paleo diet is impossible (right now ... with increased use of insects and sustainable ocean farming not based on rainforest soy that may change). When one choice is to recommend a diet that will significantly increase green house gas emissions and yet still be totally unavailable to poor people; and another diet which might be marginally worse, then yes the burden of proof should be on the former. Everyone switching to Paleo diet would be disastrous; and people HAVE attained 100+ years on grain diets, i.e. it is a matter of microoptimization not outright toxicity. (Also you say "only change you made", but did you really measure calorie intake exactly before the change of diet? A lot of diets lead to weight reduction simply due to people starting to think about what they eat and calculate calories...the act of thinking about what you eat and counting calories itself will reduce calorie intake and increase healthiness of food consumed, leaving most people with no comparison point, hence a lot of hyped diets. Did you try using as much mental energy on a healthy diet containing grains as a comparisonr point? Otherwise you do not even have an anecdote).
- TACIXAT 9y agoI'm a celiac and I legitimately believe a lot more people have problems with food than they realize. I'm guessing most people come across one of these diets and end up feeling better than they ever have. It was the same for my dad with the Atkin's Diet. The idea of cutting out carbs was revolutionary to him (it turned out to just be wheat) and solved a lot of his issues. You see the same thing with MSG. I get a sinus headache from it. Many people have no issue with it. From this, you see people claiming online that someone having a problem with it is imagining it, or that it's just a rumor. Doing an elimination diet changed my life. Every single one of my medical issues (daily sinus issues, digestion issues) was caused by things I was eating. I'm now a huge advocate for people experimenting with food and cutting certain things out. If you consistently feel shitty, it might be the best decision you ever make.
- ashtonplayton 9y agoBut ultimately, dogs and humans are innately different. I don't think diet is a good comparison IMO. Just take a look here, you can see that some human foods can be rather dangerous to dogs (https://www.thegoodypet.com/bad-toxic-foods-for-dogs https://www.thegoodypet.com/bad-toxic-foods-for-dogs)
- rjsw 9y agoI think you mean "tenets" not "tenants".
- DiabloD3 9y agoAuto-correct strikes again, and too late to go back and fix it.
- dominotw 9y ago>don't eat grains, don't eat refined sugars, don't eat legumes I eat brownrice with lentils (daal) and chickpeas with yogurt, almost every other day :\. why are these bad?
- dbingham 9y agoThe diets themselves are minor snake oil. When you look at the full evidence, few of the various diets really have any benefit over the others: https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/03/science-compared-every-diet-and-the-winner-is-real-food/284595/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2014/03/science-c... When you actually look at the science, the best advice seems to still be Michael Pollan's mantra: "Eat [real] food. Mostly plants. Not too much. [And get good exercise.]"
- Animats 9y ago"The Koehler Method of Dog Training" is considered the classic. Training dogs isn't very hard. Most dog problems reflect the owner's problems.
- sohkamyung 9y agoThe book isn't a book about training dogs. It's more a book about how dogs came to be the way there are. Quoted from the article: "The Domestic Dog" walks readers through the many questions they might have about dogs. What is up with the wacky genetics underpinning some dogs having itty bitty short legs and others immensely long ones? How can a Chihuahua and Great Dane be members of the same species? How (and how much) do genetics contribute to different behavioral traits, and how is this even calculated or assessed? Is there a relationship between early life experiences and later behaviors? What does it mean when a dog barks incessantly or tears up the house in your absence? What is life like for feral or free roaming dogs living on the outskirts of human societies? How do they get food, and what are their relationships like with other dogs? Those questions represent just a tiny fraction of the issues investigated in this 416-page volume.
- nradov 9y agoSome of the wide variation between dog breeds is made possible because they have 39 chromosomes, rather more than many other species. Thus its somewhat easier for breeders to select for the characteristics they want without getting too many unwanted genes.
- dymk 9y agoI'd say it's not incredibly hard, but it's certainly not intuitive. Training animals (including people) is very much a learned skill. Our primate brains get frustrated easily when a canine brain doesn't pick up what we think should be instinctual, and we're very bad at applying well-timed primary and secondary reinforcers until we're shown how. We're also particularly bad at pacing the jumps in difficulty we should be giving when training new behaviors. I see this all the time, whether it be crate training, heelwork, nosework, teaching commands as simple as "sit" or "speak" on vocal command, etc.
- 9y ago
- dymk 9y agoFantastic, I love reading about canine learning. Seeing Patricia McConnell's (of "The Other End of the Leash" fame) adornment of it is a huge reason for me to buy this book. Training my dog with that book (and Don't Shoot the Dog, by Pryor) framing how I interpret what my dog tells me has been hugely beneficial for both my sanity, and I'm sure my dog's as well.
- clumsysmurf 9y agoYou make like the reading list for dog owners from the Association of Pet Dog Trainers (APDT). There is a separate list for trainers: https://apdt.com/resource-center/recommended-books-dvds-pet-dog-owners/ https://apdt.com/resource-center/recommended-books-dvds-pet-...
- katastic 9y agoCheck out The Intelligence of Dogs. It's literally what the title implies, and a good read.
- chrisper 9y agoI have a dog and I'm amazed every day how well we can communicate with a different species. My dog doesn't understand my words like we do, but he understands my intentions very well most of the time. Obviously this only works very well if you have a deep connection to the dog. Doubt you can communicate with a random dog on the same level.
- cgrand-net 9y agoAccording to http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2016/08/26/science.aaf3777 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2016/08/26/scien... Dogs understand voice and intonation.
- peteretep 9y agoI'm not really a non-fiction reader, but I bought this, and started reading it, and so far it's excellent.
- softgrow 9y agoAny equivalent book for cats? :) Looking on Amazon, a book, "The Domestic Cat: The Biology of its Behaviour" looks to be it, anyone read both books? Incidentally, the pricing for the dog book is a bit odd, with the Kindle edition costing about 2% more than the paperback (also sold and supplied by Amazon). Not what I would have expected, given the lower distribution costs.
- sohkamyung 9y agoThe bottom of the article has a link to books for cat lovers [1] from 2015. [1] "The Best Books for Cat Lovers" [ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/dog-spies/the-best-books-for-cat-lovers/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/dog-spies/the-best-book... ]
- dominotw 9y agoIs there anything specific you'd like to know? All cats are more or less the same. You can watch some big cat nature documentaries and extrapolate to your domestic cat.
- mcguire 9y ago"Incidentally, the pricing for the dog book is a bit odd, with the Kindle edition costing about 2% more than the paperback (also sold and supplied by Amazon). Not what I would have expected, given the lower distribution costs." Welcome to the world of modern publishing.
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoRelevant? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_dogs_in_Moscow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Street_dogs_in_Moscow