10 ms·
Is she Photoshopped? In France, they now have to tell you
- DanBC 9y agoWe've seen first steps toward this in the UK. Ads for mascara now have to say if the image is photoshopped or not. This is mostly policed by the companies themselves, reporting each other to Advertising Standards.
- jaclaz 9y agoThe mascara thing you mention is about avoiding false representation of the effects of the product. This is very different, it is specifically about thinness, I believe that anorexia (or if not anorexia at least the psychological troubles that can lead to it) are becoming very common among teens, so it is more than anything else a "public health" campaign to remove the (false, or retouched) images of impossibly thin models from becoming the "reference model" of the youngers. There was already something similar in a few EU countries, where Laws or Codes of Conduct were made prohibiting to hire fashion models with a BMI lower than 18 for the catwalk: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#Legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#Legislation The debate was at the time (and still is) whether the BMI in itself is a good metrics.
- microcolonel 9y agoAre they going to start telling you when they're wearing makeup or not?
- raverbashing 9y agoYou can tell this is the case most of the time With PS, it's impossible to say when viewing it on print/low-res media if the job was done correctly
- kodablah 9y agoSeriously, or whether the lighting is non-natural to make someone's picture appear different. Prediction: Like with the cookie law and other unnecessary and trivial save-my-dumb-citizens disclosure regulations, they'll just put the retouched-photo on every image and at least alter one pixel every time.
- edent 9y agoThey already do in the UK - to a degree. Here's a mascara advert which was banned because the model was wearing fake eyelashes. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/04/18/rimmel-mascara-advert-starring-cara-delevinge-banned-use-false/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/04/18/rimmel-mascara-ad... A similar case in the USA - http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/14/fashion/Mascara-Ads-Draw-Criticisms.html?mcubz=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/14/fashion/Mascara-Ads-Draw-C...
- microcolonel 9y agoWell that's a bit different. That would be a direct misrepresentation of the product. i.e. you can not make anyone look like that with the advertised product.
- codegeek 9y agoReminds of the Fast Food ads here in the US. Looks Gourmet on TV while the real thing is not even close.
- jaclaz 9y ago>Reminds of the Fast Food ads here in the US. Looks Gourmet on TV while the real thing is not even close. In that case there should be a warning that what is in the images isn't even edible (often wax and plastic replicas are used in photo shoots and videos), and even if the food is real almost anything is added to it to make it look better JFY: https://petapixel.com/2012/08/02/random-things-you-can-use-to-make-food-photos-more-appealing/ https://petapixel.com/2012/08/02/random-things-you-can-use-t...
- gus_massa 9y agoOn the other hand, there was a very interesting documentary of McDonald's about how they prepare the hamburgers for the photo. [tl;dv: It's true food, but it's cooked in a very strange way.] "Behind the scenes at a McDonald's photo shoot" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSd0keSj2W8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSd0keSj2W8 (I remember that it was discussed here a few years ago, but I can't find the submission.)
- c0l0 9y agoI'm disappointed and appalled how this headline is in gross violation of Adobe®'s General trademark guidelines (http://www.adobe.com/legal/permissions/trademarks.html http://www.adobe.com/legal/permissions/trademarks.html). It should read "Is her image enhanced using Adobe® Photoshop® software? [...]" Maybe that's the next thing that should be legally enforced somewhere in this world.
- bpicolo 9y ago> Incorrect: The photoshop pokes fun at the Senator.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoNo the error is using a capital P in photoshopped. The act of photoshopping is a generic term, I use The GIMP or Draw for my photoshopping. By making it a capital P the suggesting only those editing their photos with Adobe Photoshop will have to mark their photos as altered.
- xj9 9y agoi hope not, i actually have the opposite goal: to render intellectual property laws, not only obsolete, but impossible to enforce.
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoThe subtext of the article seems to be that anorexia is a worse public health problem than obesity.
- loceng 9y agoIn France perhaps it is compared to in the US?
- omosubi 9y agoit may not be a worse public health problem, but eating disorders, especially anorexia, have the highest fatality rate of any mental health disorder. source - https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2012/spotlight-on-eating-disorders.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/about/directors/thomas-insel/blog/2...
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoObesity has the highest co-morbidity of any mental health disorder.
- meowface 9y agoIs this illness olympics? Both are bad.
- Godel_unicode 9y agoFacts matter. Obesity is much, much worse.
- e12e 9y agoIn France? With regards to mortality rates of young people?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- d--b 9y agothat's it I'm investing in thinning mirrors.
- atomical 9y agoWhat about a real-time enhancement with AI?
- drdaeman 9y agoThe trick with mirrors (pure optics, rather than image enhancement) is that photos are not "edited" or "retouched" ;)
- drawkbox 9y agoSame reason the photo app/features of instagram and snapchat took off, makes people look really good or even better than they expect themselves with filters etc.
- Xoros 9y ago> It's no secret that images of models are often retouched Well it's not a secret, but it's not obvious for most teenagers. And may be not either for people without high degrees education. A lot of people, and I suppose not only in France, are not at peace with their body shape, even if they're not obese nor anorexic. Been exposed to not really existing bodies images can be painful for self esteem. Of course, computer modified photos are recent, but fashion already used lightning and tricking exposure when producing photos from film since, well, the fashion press exists I guess.
- cJ0th 9y ago> Well it's not a secret, but it's not obvious for most teenagers. Fair enough but the list of things that can harm a teen's self esteem is endless. So in a way there is no way around learning how to deal with issues of imperfection on a personal level. And this, in turn, makes you wonder whether you couldn't spend the money that goes into this project more worthwhile. For instance, you could invest it in free sport programs. That way teens wouldn't just improve their body image but also do something for their health. IMHO these kind of initiatives are mostly egotrips of people who want to make their mark.
- coldtea 9y ago>Fair enough but the list of things that can harm a teen's self esteem is endless. Many things are endless or numerous, that's why people prioritize dealing with a) the most important ones, b) low hanging fruits.
- orinthiscase 9y agoof course, it’s not clear that there’s an actual, rational reason to believe this will have any positive effect, so it’s probably option c) must be seen to try something if they could eludicate the mechanism that has this impact, they would likely also have evidence that violent video games cause male violence, or that bowser kidnapping princess peach causes sexism. my guess is the operative pressure arises from peer groups, and this initiative is pissing in the wind
- igaray 9y agoWe've had that in argentina, in all billboards and magazine ads, for a while, but you need an electron microscope to read the warning.
- gus_massa 9y agoAlso, each and every photo in an add has the same warning, so it's completely ignored by the people.
- indubitable 9y agoThe implication of this article is that agencies would be obligated to use what the article calls "more obtainable" bodies. Is this actually the case? I think it's vastly more likely that this will do little more than sharply increase the demand for people that actually have the bodies that other individuals were being photoshopped to have. It'd be like if a country banned all voice processing software when singing (which has become ubiquitous today). It's not like studios would simply begin accepting people with less than ideal singing voices. Instead they would actually have to seek out talent that can sing without having their voice filtered through digital signal processing software. And in the end, I think this would (and will) be a good thing. Authenticity should be encouraged and incentivized.
- coldtea 9y ago>The implication of this article is that agencies would be obligated to use what the article calls "more obtainable" bodies. Is this actually the case? I think it's vastly more likely that this will do little more than sharply increase the demand for people that actually have the bodies that other individuals were being photoshopped to have. You could always insist that the distribution of bodies shown in a magazine follows the distribution of weights/heights in the general population (with some margin of error). And heavily fine them out of business when it does not. Problem solved. (The voice processing ban example doesn't capture the problem with body photos, because people don't go out of their way to sound like their favorite singers -- auto-tuned or not--, nor does it have many adverse psychological or health effects to have singers voices be unattainable to most people. Whereas body image from ad/fashion/etc models influences the self-perception of billions of people, and leads a multiple-100s billion dollars industry).
- paulddraper 9y ago"Problem solved." I don't think you've predicted this correctly. Does the prominence matter? Size? Adjacent material?
- coldtea 9y ago
- VirtualAirwaves 9y agoIn the United States, Obesity is one of the leading causes of death, with estimates as high as 300,000 deaths/year. (See https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/adult.html https://www.cdc.gov/obesity/data/adult.html ) Deaths from Anorexia are about 150/year (See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11513012 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11513012 ) Yet we're all hypersensitive about telling women they are overweight or obese. It would be like spending weeks in urban schools talking about how to avoid poisonous snake bites and spending 15 minutes on automobile safety.
- paulddraper 9y agoI'm sympathetic to your point, but there are effects other than death. Low self esteem has its own problems.
- coldtea 9y ago>Yet we're all hypersensitive about telling women they are overweight or obese. Probably because that offends/annoys more people (300,000 over 150 times more) than warning about anorexia.
- thatfrenchguy 9y agoAs a French person: stop subsidizing corn, start subsidizing vegetables, stop eating take-out. If you look at a middle-class supermarket in France and in the US you understand why your poor are obese pretty quickly.
- craftyguy 9y agoNot just France, but most European countries.. every time I travel in Europe there's always this initial realization that I'm no longer surrounded by obese people. None of the places I've been to over there encourage the same eating habits that you find prevalent in the US.
- jdavis703 9y agoWell portion sizes are smaller, but most people walk, bike or transit to work. For example this week I haven't done any exercise due to a "sports"-related injury, and yet managed to burn an average of 2571 calories -- and before you think I'm lucky to live near work, my one-way commute is 30 miles. Even just 40 minutes of daily physical activity built into a commute can make a huge difference.
- learn_more 9y agoThis law should be good for the careers of models who actually are nearly perfect looking.
- gus_massa 9y agoNah, if there is a bad shadow or they want to remove a few hairs from the fringe, they have to add the same warning. They ant write "This image is 99% not Photoshopped.".
- zakk 9y ago> any commercial image that has been digitally altered to make a model look thinner This will backfire. Ads will only use ultra-thin models, it's not like there aren't.
- pulisse 9y agoImages of those ultra-thin models are themselves typically photoshopped to remove signs of anorexia and bulimia (arm hair, gray pallor, dental discoloration, pronounced tendons). This is (according to an acquaintance whose day job used to be retouching fashion photos) a frequent enough need that language like "remove visible signs of anorexia" is included in the boilerplate instructions given by agencies to post-production teams.
- paulddraper 9y agoSure, but this law doesn't really cover those edits.
- bitL 9y agoOf course she is photoshopped. All photos you see in magazines are by default heavily photoshopped, even of "flawless" models. You literally don't see a single photo straight out of the camera where retouching wasn't applied when it comes to women.
- gthtjtkt 9y agoGood, now if only they would do the same for male models who use illegal performance enhancing drugs to achieve their physiques. According to many male fitness models, anyone who earns money based on their body is almost guaranteed to be using them. I find it really strange how the topic of "enhanced" male models never comes up, but these articles about women pop up several times a year.
- icebraining 9y agoYes, they should really pass a law to deal with those illegal drugs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bkwills 9y agoAnother law designed to divert public discussion from actual political issues.
- hegojuko 9y agoApparently I'm shadow banned, why? No reason. What a lousy place. Fuck HN moderation.
- GhostVII 9y agoThis will probably just end up being another warning that is stuck on everywhere, and doesn't mean much. Just like the "we use cookies" popup, or all the "x may cause cancer" warnings, it is easier to just add the warning than change the product/advertisement.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoThey'll probably just render a completely digital image instead, no photoshopping involved in that.
- wruza 9y agoLooking how modern game characters look and move, I think ad models will feel the competition very soon.
- caseysoftware 9y agoMy mother and wife were both photographers at some point and basically every photo is modified, touched up, and otherwise "enhanced" in Photoshop or other tools. It doesn't matter if it's a landscape, a room setting, or a person. While saying "this has been modified" might be valuable, without knowing how this seems misguided at best.
- ghaff 9y agoTo be fair, the law seems to be quite a bit more specific than that. It applies to commercial use of models "whose physical appearance has been modified through the use of image processing software to slim down or thicken the model's silhouette" according to the translation on this site. [1] [1] http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2017/08/france-photoshop-decree-coming-up-soon.html http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2017/08/france-photoshop-decree...
- sliverstorm 9y agoIt's not even fair to say they have been modified or touched up, really. Cameras are not true to life. The bare data (straight out of camera) does not look just like what you see with your eyes, and occasionally the photographer also made a minor technical error, leading to a crop or an exposure adjustment or white balance change or...
- ungzd 9y agoWhat kinds of ads are required to have this warning and what kind of edits are counted as edits? Does debayering, remapping brightness or denoising count as "digitally altering"? Then all ads will have such warnings.
- Godel_unicode 9y agoI don't understand, this seems like someone never bothered to learn about anchoring. Is there research that I've missed which shows anchoring doesn't apply in body-image situations?
- abiox 9y agohow do you feel 'anchoring' applies in 'body-image situations'?
- Godel_unicode 9y agoThe underlying problem we're talking about is that people are seeing these unrealistic images of what a body should be, and are comparing themselves to that. I would argue that given what we know about how anchoring works, even if you tell someone that the image they're seeing is fake, the damage has already been done. Consider the Barbie doll; everyone knows that Barbie is a plastic doll and not a real person, yet there was a generation which grew up with that body being the goal.
- watertorock 9y agoStupid. Are they going to tell us when men's physiques are photoshopped too? How about wrinkles or hair color changes or blemish and scar removals? What about wearing makeup? If a picture is printed, it has been edited.
- mschuster91 9y ago> If a picture is printed, it has been edited Well, sometimes if the photo is good enough it gets published as-is. Source: managed to get two of my photos of foul-mouthed Nazis into a newspaper.
- chalupa-man 9y agoIt applies to men and to women, and not to blemishes or colours but to reshaping silhouettes. It's worth taking thirty seconds to read something before attacking it as stupid based on your imagination.
- firefoxd 9y agoI can't find the actual article, but i was reading that the rise of instagram or just selfie cameras has lead to an increased amount of face surgery. Just the fact that people spend all their days looking at the imperfections of their own body and compare it to perfect ones(the photoshoped) will lead to surgery. I think adding a photoshoped disclaimer is a step up, but it is not the ultimate solution. At some point we will end up with a mandatory 200by200 picture of a failed surgery plastered on every doctored photo.
- jimjimjim 9y agoGood.
- randyrand 9y agoi don't see this working. will girls have to label their instagram photos as airbrushed as well? It's much more common than you think.
- notadoc 9y agoHow absurd. Virtually every single photo of every male or female that is printed is photoshopped. A lot of people photoshop their pictures before posting to Facebook even. Should that all be declared too? What about those filters on social media apps that make peoples eyes bigger and clear the complexion? And why the emphasis only on pictures of women when pictures of men have just as much photoshopping? Seems a bit sexist.
- icebraining 9y agoAnd why the emphasis only on pictures of women Where do you see this?
- mancerayder 9y agoThe problem is how to define 'Retouched.' Being an amateur photographer and having met a number of commercial ones, the sentiment and knowledge I picked up over the years goes something like this: Retouching a photo has been done since the (physical, real) lightroom days. Many of the strange phrases and techniques in Photoshop (dodge and burn, and probably crop and most others with photo-specific context) came from techniques in the lightroom. Even the most famous photographers adjusted their photos in the lightroom, making alterations that are absolutely in the 'retouched' category. You can find these online (Cartier-Bresson did this, and many others). Source: https://petapixel.com/2013/09/12/marked-photographs-show-iconic-prints-edited-darkroom/ https://petapixel.com/2013/09/12/marked-photographs-show-ico... Therefore, it's extremely common for any portrait or wedding or any other photographer to retouch. Do 100% do it? Probably not 100%, but damn close. It's not considered cheating to remove an element, lighten or completely darken/render invisible an element of the photo. What the photography community considers cheating is portraying something that isn't there. There's a fascinating conversation with a photojournalist on the topic here with examples: https://petapixel.com/2015/08/04/interview-michael-kamber-on-photojournalism-ethics-and-the-altering-of-images/ https://petapixel.com/2015/08/04/interview-michael-kamber-on... So is taking a model and making her thinner, taller and tanner retouching to the point of portraying something that isn't there? Which is a vague phrase, admittedly. Perhaps. But what about removing a pimple from the face? If you get a portrait done professionally, it'll be almost automatic. Maybe it's not so bad. But if it is, let's say, then what about giving you a better skin tone? Because a bare flash without a CTO gel, or the mid-day sun, with a daylight white balance, is going to make you look potentially weird (if you're caucasian in this example; you might look ghostly). A lamppost nearby, or a store sign nearby might change your skin tone too. So what if you change the white balance in Photoshop/Lightroom/Gimp/whatever and make it look a little bit like sunset? Is that cheating? But if you do nothing, there's automated settings in cameras that will auto-set skin tone and adjust lighting conditions. Is that cheating? It's all extremely vague because the BBC article failed to explain the criteria for retouching: the word retouching is too broad. This is an endlessly debated topic in the photographic community, but banning ALL retouching would, I am convinced, be reviled by almost everybody.
- juancn 9y agoIn Argentina it has been the case that digital alterations of the human figure must be stated for several years, and people still use photoshop and just add a tiny disclaimer below. Pictures are roughly the same.