12 ms·
Musk revises Mars ambitions
- ravirajx7 9y agoMusk is truly an inspiration for each one of us. He is the one who dreams big and works even harder. Musk's idea of connecting different parts of Earth using rockets is truly astounding and it would be great if all the government and private agencies come together and try to remove border barriers. It is inevitable that the days of flying cars and jetpack will come very soon and there may be drastic effects if border tension arises. https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/26/16362868/boeing-go-fly-prize-jetpack-competition https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/26/16362868/boeing-go-fly-pr...
- rothbardrand 9y agoThe funny thing is, there's nothing really new with the idea of suborbital planetary transport-- this was widely expected in the 60s and 70s. The problem was NASA was given a monopoly on space access, and many companies would never get permission to fly, or do any projects, without NASA approval, and NASA would never approve anything competitive with its own ambitions. (Always using "safety" as an excuse, but if you can't fly you can't prove safety.) It was the X Prize and Scaled Composits that broke the logjam with their "we can launch from anywhere with a runway" system, which combined with the failure of the shuttle system and lack of funding for NASA has forced them out of a stranglehold position to the point where they basically funded much of SpaceX's early work. But don't under estimate the effect of the X Prize-- because Virgin Galactic can launch from anywhere, NASA and the politicians had to decide if they were going to lose access to the space tourism business. They still were kinda silly-- at one point Richard Branson who funded Virgin Galactic was blocked from seeing the designs for the Virgin Galactic ship due to the fact that he is a "foreign national" and the work was considered a "national security" issue.
- electriclove 9y agoThe article does not do his talk justice. It is definitely worth watching the whole thing: https://youtu.be/S5V7R_se1Xc https://youtu.be/S5V7R_se1Xc
- jwilliams 9y agoAgree. I don't entirely agree that he's "revised" so much as got more specific.
- apendleton 9y agoI think "revised" is fair. This vehicle differs significantly in technical specifics than the one proposed last year. Different size, engine configuration, stage/payload configuration, engine count, max thrust, even to some extent purpose. It's not just that there are more details; the details have changed.
- georgeecollins 9y agoWho cares if Musk's predictions are realistic? He is doing us all a tremendous service by keeping Mars in the public conversation.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoRealism is a difficult thing to predict. If you're conservative in your estimate of what is probable, then you probably will choose to do nothing. If you are too liberal, you may say I'm a dreamer (But I'm not the only one). If you manage to peg it to the true probability, then you will probably fail to inspire the imagination, and thus fail to motivate the ones that will help you achieve. Knowing this, you let your dream be a bit inflated, and by doing so you achieve more than you would have if you had said outright what was truly probable.
- GoToRO 9y agoFor sure it's not a "tremendous service" for us all. It's just free marketing for his very real products.
- jasonmaydie 9y agoI still don't see why we should spend $$$ on mars when we have a perfectly good one here millions of light years in any direction. Maybe we should stop treating the only planet that supports life like shit and cherish it.
- baq 9y agoWe should but some people don't care. A wise man hedges his bets.
- jasonmaydie 9y agoa nuked earth will probably still be better than Mars after the dust has settled.
- tosstossy 9y agoThey're not mutually exclusive, and it's not getting any less crowded on earth. It can seem like a tremendous diversion with the potential to abdicate any urgent need to address our problems at home, operating under the assumption that we'll replace it. But that's obviously flawed thinking, since anything we find nearly habitable will always be a poor substitute for where we evolved to live.
- curtis 9y agoI think the new, smaller BFR is still too big. It seems to me like a rocket about the size of the New Glenn [1] would more sense. But then I'm not a rocket scientist. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Glenn
- castis 9y agoIn defense of the idea, it's not called the Moderately Sized Rocket.
- curtis 9y agoHa! But in that vein, I suggest we start referring to New Glenn as the "Moderately Sized Rocket", or "MSR" for short.
- neuromancer2701 9y agoBut there are rumors of the New Armstrong that will rival the BFG so Bezos is not stopping at the New Glenn.
- kbenson 9y agoLast year, it was the Interplanetary Transport System, but now Musk has regressed to using the original, cheeky "code name" BFR, in which the B stands for big, the R stands for rocket, and the F stands for fun. (Not really). I'm always astounded that apparently we still can't say fuck lest some bogeyman (real or imaginary) jump out and make you regret it. It's a fucking word. For fuck's sake. I mean, at the point where it's used more often as garnish in it's various adverb and noun forms than it's original verb form, you know, to fuck, how bad can it really be and why do we need to penalize the usage so? Now watch this get auto-depressed by HN's incendiary comment detection filters. Edit: If you see this reach the top, please downvote or unvote. I'm interested in this topic, but it doesn't deserve to overshadow real discussion about the submission.
- stcredzero 9y agoF stands for fun. (Not really). F does stand for fun. A lot of it. It's really down to attitude.
- ericjang 9y agoIs this an American cultural thing, or are other cultures just as averse to public swearing?
- saalweachter 9y agoIt's not particularly more professional to cheekily use an obvious substitute in place of 'fucking', either. If you are saying "big ... fun ... rocket" or "big freakin' rocket" anyone over the age of 6 will know what you are doing and, if they are inclined to feel uncomfortable or offended, will still be so. So for the most part I would say "either swear or don't", but if you are going to play that game, you need to be better at it, and call it something like "a big functional rocket" or "a big futuristic rocket", which is plausible, and then remain completely straight-faced, forever, never admitting in public or private there could be any other meaning for the acronym, ever. Leave historians a hundred years from now guessing. "Wink wink, I'm not cussing!!!" is just another version of "I'm not touching you!!!".
- danblick 9y agoSending humans to Mars seems less attractive to me than sending robots to Ceres. Is there an argument for Mars that doesn't include the phrase "multi-planet species"?
- twinkletwinkle 9y agoI don't think so. In terms of room and resources we could just as well colonize Antarctica.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoThere's a lot of undersea real estate, too. Both environments are less hostile than Mars, practically speaking. But of course neither cover the 'backup planet' scenario - and they don't put you out of reach of regional political struggles.
- mkempe 9y agoI will applaud (and support) both of you when you colonize Antarctica and the sea floor. What's your plan, timeline, and source of financing?
- dbingham 9y agoDo we really need more of an argument than "multi-planet species"? And in the case that "multi-planet species" is the goal, is there a better target? I'm not aware of one.
- roywiggins 9y agoI'm partial to the Venus airships idea, but that's probably mostly sci-fantasy.
- gkya 9y ago> Do we really need more of an argument than "multi-planet species"? Yes. I don't see what concrete benefits we gain becoming such a species, and I doubt it's possible to send live humans to Mars, or suspend life there. This is the new alchemy.
- benjaminl 9y agoI don't understand why people are so quick to dismiss SpaceX's ambitions as unrealistic. They were the first to achieve re-usability of the first stage of an orbital class rocket, the first to prove out supersonic retro-propulsion and the first private company to re-fly a spacecraft (the Dragon Capsule). Given that, it seems like they should be given the benefit of the doubt when they say they are going to do something.
- agumonkey 9y agoMe too. Especially after the beginning of the talk, when he mentioned 1) he became spaceX lead because no serious engineer would join beside the team he assembled 2) falcon1 failed 3 times, 4th attempt was their last one before folding I'm not fond of everything Musk, but he achieved something deep and qualitative. Also, even if the end smelled like fund-me marketing, the first half was genuinely simple and factual (of course considering it's hindsight).
- mikeash 9y agoHe didn't mention this in the talk, but the story of how SpaceX came to be in the first place is pretty amazing too. He wanted to land a greenhouse on Mars basically as a stunt, to get people interested in Mars again. He wanted to buy surplus Russian ICBMs as a cheap way to launch the thing. After tough negotiations, the Russians basically gave him the middle finger. He basically said, "Fine, I'll build my own rocket, with blackjack, and hookers!" And thus SpaceX was born.
- agumonkey 9y agoOh yeah I read that elsewhere too. Think about how SpaceX would be different if the Russian deal went through..
- mikeash 9y agoThis Esquire article gets into a lot of detail if anyone is interested in reading more: http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a16681/elon-musk-interview-1212/ http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a16681/elon-musk-interv...
- zaroth 9y agoConsolidating all their effort behind a single vehicle makes sense, but is there a large risk of the same thing that happened to the A380? Could the BFR end up being too big for servicing the existing market? Or does the existing market end up as 1/1000 the new market opened up by having the BFR?
- Robotbeat 9y ago"Too big" isn't a thing. "Too expensive per flight" is. In aircraft, cost per flight is roughly proportional to aircraft size, so "too big" can be indirectly a problem. With rockets, the difference between fully/rapidly reusable and expendable (or even partially reusable) is so vast that "too big" is basically irrelevant. In his presentation, Musk showed the expected per-flight costs. BFR would be cheaper /per flight/ than Falcon1. ...and if you dig into last year's presentation, the projected per-flight costs are lower even than Rocketlab's Electron. PER FLIGHT.
- erikb 9y agoWell, as the presentation shows he's also increasing the market, attacking traditional public air transportation, as well as increasing the amount of space missions by a margin. And in the end if the repeated flight is cheaper than a traditional rocket it will still pay off, as long as it flies enough missions to refinance its initial investment.
- Perfect_Pitch 9y agoIt still seems rather ambitious to me. 2022 is coming up pretty quick. If I were a betting man I'd bet they will push back to 2025-2027.
- mikeash 9y agoHe outright said that the 2022 timeline was "aspirational." That's basically an "if everything goes perfectly" date. We know everything won't go perfectly, and so does he, but he still likes to start with that.
- r00fus 9y agoI'm absolutely ecstatic that Musk is talking about the Moon. Mars is great, but Luna is near & here, and honestly, it's a strategic location (not just militarily) as the it's at the top of Earth's gravity well with a minimal well of it's own - great basecamp for interplanetary missions. If we can't occupy the Moon, why should we shoot for colonizing Mars?
- mkempe 9y agoAnother interesting aspect of a moon base -- would it be easier and/or cheaper to produce propellants there instead of sending four rockets up to fuel each Mars-bound ship?
- duskwuff 9y agoUnlikely. The Moon lacks the feedstocks required to produce hydrocarbon fuels like RP-1, and is likely to lack the power to perform energy-intensive operations like cracking water to liquid hydrogen/oxygen.
- pacificmint 9y agoOn Mars you can use the Sabatier reaction to make Methane, and you can make Oxygen from Water or from CO2. What would you use on the Moon to make the Methane?
- mkempe 9y agoHeat up regolith?
- Nomentatus 9y agoYes. Oxygen is plentiful in the soil. You might have to bring your own hydrogen, but it's nothing if not light.
- pacificmint 9y agoThere is a school of thought that building a sustainable base on the moon is actually harder than Mars. Some of the reasons: * No atmosphere, no source for Oxygen and Carbon * 28 day night/day cycle, hard to keep your base power over the 14 day night * Unclear if water can be found * Lower gravity Potentially this means that way more resources would have to be brought in from the outside than on Mars. (If this is really the case remains to be seen. But the idea that the Moon is closer, therefor it's easier has to be at least challenged)
- godelski 9y ago> ...then why not go to other places on Earth as well? I'm addressing this because I know someone will ask. Honestly my first reaction was to laugh, then I made sense of it. Economically this does not make sense. Price points do not make sense for this, even from the most ambitious startups. You'd want to use a space plane. BUT I still think it is a good idea. The reason being is that this is a quick way to get his technology to TRL 8/9 [1]. TRL 7-9 is the hardest progression in this scale. So I'm going to guess that Musk is going to make a loss on these flights because SpaceX needs to prove that the vehicle and related technology is flight ready. What better way then doing a bunch of flights close to home, where you can easily repair and monitor the vehicle? NASA is going to be extremely strict on them sending people to Mars. Earth and Moon are the way to go to show proof (even NASA is planning Moon mission before Mars). Or I could be off base and this isn't what Musk is planning. But it is my hunch. [1] https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/trl.png https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/trl.png
- iamcreasy 9y agoHere is what Elon said on instrgram, "Fly to most places on Earth in under 30 mins and anywhere in under 60. Cost per seat should be about the same as full fare economy in an aircraft. Forgot to mention that." Source : https://www.instagram.com/p/BZnVfWxgdLe/?hl=en&taken-by=elonmusk https://www.instagram.com/p/BZnVfWxgdLe/?hl=en&taken-by=elon...
- godelski 9y agoWhich gives evidence to my guess. Because there is no way you can do a rocket for anywhere near that price. I mean, let's do some quick math. We'll even give him buffer room. Let's say you can get 50 passengers at $5k per ticket. That's $250k/flight. I just can't see how that would cover the flight (fuel), let alone things like: maintenance, licensing, insurance, and the staff to operate the facilities. Let alone doing it on $50k ($1k/ticket). I'm EXTREMELY skeptical. Elon's a pretty smart guy, and may see things that I'm not, but my best guess is that this isn't for the money. The money is just to lessen the losses.
- 9y ago
- ChrisBland 9y agoAs a little kid at Space Camp in the late 80s/90s we would 'dream' about what a moon base or a mars base would look like. I grew up thinking that it would be something my grandchildren would see. To even have this as a possibility now is something I think few fathom how important it is. Amazon & Google may not matter in 100 years, (go back 100 years and look up who the biggest companies were and how long they lasted) but getting to another planet and colonizing is a step that will forever be in the books as one of the crowning achievements of humanity. I applaud Musk and all he is doing, if my skill set ever fit what SpaceX needed, I would join in a heartbeat.
- gervase 9y agoIf SpaceX is able to realize its ambitions, I think it could certainly be a modern-day East India Company [0,1], if not more influential. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_India_Company [1]: Some sources have estimated that, adjusted for inflation, the East India Company would have had an equivalent market cap of $7.6 trillion.
- louithethrid 9y agoI honestly do not get the whole concept of a solar storm shelter room on a space object that is shaped like a tower. Just turn the tower with gyroscopes into the solar wind... last room is perfectly sheltered (from solar radiation)- not from space radiation. Also.. wouldnt a sun-shade providing drone with a water-ice container as ray shield always be superior?
- avar 9y agoBecause if you were to magically turn off the sun and were placed somewhere in the solar system wearing a space suit you'd still be in a dangerous radiation environment from interstellar radiation. The Sun is not the only source of dangerous radiation when making interplanetary trips. This NASA page has more info on that subject: https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/real-martians-how-to-protect-astronauts-from-space-radiation-on-mars https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/real-martians-how-to-pr...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- walrus1066 9y agoAny idea how they will deal with radiation exposure? Outside the earth's magnetic field the astronauts would be exposed to lethal cosmic rays & solar flares for many months.
- Someone 9y agoI don’t see them building their launch ports closer to cities than airports now are, nor do I see them (certainly initially) build launch ports next to each major city. So, for most civilian flights, those earth-to-earth trips would not be that much faster, if at all. Also, those flights would have to be extremely safe to get in the same ballpark as current commercial flights. I think that is needed to make this a ‘normal’ thing. I would guess those earth-to-earth trips could make more sense for the military than for civilians. Yes, there is the problem of refueling your rocket near a war zone, and a risk of your rocket getting shot down, but the ability to very rapidly deploy specialized troops and/or materials may eventually be worth that, and the military might fund it even if they aren’t convinced the advantages will pan out.