8 ms·
Privacy implications of email tracking [pdf]
- omnifischer 9y agoFor those reading https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15354114 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15354114 OSX mail client does not help.
- akerro 9y agoThunderbird blocks remote content in emails.
- mosselman 9y agoWhat do you mean? I have blocked external content, is that not enough?
- f055 9y agoOS X mail has an explicit option in the "Viewing" section of its preferences saying "Load remote content in messages. Email messages may contain images or content stored on remote servers." I think this option was there since Lion or even earlier.
- omnifischer 9y agoThe average user enables them otherwise, newsletters or other mails are unreadable. Smarter would be if Apple can IMAP store certain content.
- mpweiher 9y agoActually, the paper says it does. It doesn't display inline content, I think by default. The paper goes on to say that then you don't get to look at those e-mails. Yes. That's OK.
- englehardt 9y agoWe found that Apple Mail clients typically load remote resources by default, unless the message is spam. That content can't set or retrieve cookies, which is an improvement over other standalone clients. I'd still recommend disabling remote content by default since the tracking identifiers (the hash of your email address, etc) are present in the image URL. That's enough to continue to track the read and serve targeted content. See: https://web.archive.org/web/20170922213846/https://support.liveintent.com/hc/en-us/articles/208828206-Solving-for-Google-Proxy https://web.archive.org/web/20170922213846/https://support.l...
- cimm 9y agoI simply stopped reading HTML emails and read everything in plain text. Works fine for most of the emails I receive, the ones that don't are almost always marketing emails anyway. I do realise clicking tracking links still works but they are way more visible in plain text mode and it's not that hard to copy & paste the relevant part of the link. Too bad most email clients have removed plain text rendering these days. I also haven't found a good mobile plain text email client yet. MailMate has a really nice feature when you can read your mails in plain text by default and toggle the HTML version on a per mail basis with a shortcut.
- pjmlp 9y agoI use Thunderbird with automatically downloads disabled. Same on GMail app.
- discreditable 9y agoThunderbird with Simple HTML view is my favorite. It strips the remote content and fluff, while allowing simple things like bold and tables.
- alex-e 9y ago> Too bad most email clients have removed plain text rendering these days. I also haven't found a good mobile plain text email client yet. eul [1] only has plain text rendering. It only supports Gmail right now, but a full-fledged email client is coming soon. A mobile app will be released in early 2018. [1] https://eul.im https://eul.im
- kwhitefoot 9y agoSounds interesting. It looks like a one man show though. Is it open source/free software?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- j_s 9y ago
- Crontab 9y agoYes you did - we all did. By not paying attention, by not speaking up, and by deferring to those who don’t give a shit.
- j_s 9y agohttps://www.emailprivacytester.com/ https://www.emailprivacytester.com/ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9237550 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9237550 > mike-cardwell: a web app I wrote [...] Sends an email to you which checks to see how much stuff your email client is leaking
- rypskar 9y agoIt is a bit fun how some think they can track if I open emails from them or not. I have several times got email with something like "we see you are not reading the emails you get from us, so we will remove you from our list". I did read the emails using Thunderbird, so was only their tracking that didn't work. But this is maybe what we get when most read emails in web apps from companies that want to track everything everyone do and think so they can show the adds that are least relevant
- avh02 9y agooh god I wish spammers did this. Imagine: "we notice you don't care about our spam advertising, we'll remove you from our list" heaven.
- eli 9y agoGmail actually takes steps to protect privacy when loading images. Apple's mail apps are the ones that load images indiscriminately. Pretty sure that's for UX reasons not ads.
- oaeuntsh32nts 9y agoNot sure what you mean by, "Apple's mail apps are the ones that load images indiscriminately"? I've been using Apple's Mail.app for years on many different machines with many different accounts from different providers, and I have image loading turned off. I've never seen it load an image when I didn't ask it to. Furthermore, it sounds like Gmail will download all images from a mail and store them on Google's servers, which means they're triggering the tracking from those email providers!
- Sephr 9y agoDoesn't Google immediately download any external images/assets in an email and cache them to prevent exactly this?
- pjmlp 9y agoYou can in any way disable automatic downloads and only see what you actually wish.
- gaius 9y agoIt's not for your benefit - you are Google's product, and only they get to milk their own cows.
- mike-cardwell 9y agoIt's my understanding that they only download the assets when you first read the message. So it protects your IP address, but it doesn't protect the fact that you read the message. [edit] Yes, I have just confirmed this by using emailprivacytester.com
- englehardt 9y agoGmail's image proxying actually won't help much with this style of tracking. In the paper we found email addresses (or hashes of them) leaking to third parties via a query string parameter in the request URL. So the proxied URL still contains your email address and the third parties can still learn you opened and read the email. As another commenter mentions, we found these requests to occur the moment you first open the email in the Gmail web interface. Since the request URL is unique to you, it can still be used to serve you targeted content. See: https://web.archive.org/web/20170922213846/https://support.liveintent.com/hc/en-us/articles/208828206-Solving-for-Google-Proxy https://web.archive.org/web/20170922213846/https://support.l... Actually I suspect image proxying will also interfere with request blockers like ABP or uBlock Origin, which may have otherwise blocked all requests to that third-party domain.
- matthewcford 9y agohttps://gmelius.com https://gmelius.com seems to block email trackers in Gmail.
- J_Sherz 9y agoSimilarly, I've used the PixelBlock Chrome Extension and it works well. Very much a "set it and forget it" kind of tool.
- vanderZwan 9y agoI'm surprised there isn't an equivalent for Firefox. At least no obvious one I can find so quickly.
- jlgaddis 9y agoThis is why I still love and use mutt (NeoMutt, technically) even after all these years. I occasionally do fire up Thunderbird but only for those extremely rare cases where I actually do need to be able to read an HTML e-mail.
- nsomaru 9y agoSurely there's a way to pipe an html email to $BROWSER from [neo]mutt?
- jasonjayr 9y agoPut this in your ~/.mailcap (all on one line) text/html; elinks -no-connect -dump -dump-charset UTF-8 -dump-width 140 -default-mime-type text/html %s; needsterminal; copiousoutput;
- jlgaddis 9y agoYeah, as jasonjayr pointed out, and it's done automatically for pretty much every HTML e-mail I receive. Occasionally, however, due to formatting or whatever, I need to be able to view the actual HTML e-mail "as it was intended" (so I fire up Thunderbird).
- marak830 9y agoInteresting (to me and hopefully to others!) Side note, this is why eve-online added the option to bot autoload images in the forum. As eve-online has a shit ton of spies(and some people take this game very seriously) a large alliance was using self hosted images and logging ips that we're viewing those images. Through matching posts they were able to scout out alternate accounts and catch spies. That's how we all heard about it at the time anyway, while technically fesable, I don't have first hand knowledge either way. Although it did make me start to think about those emails with images and convinced me to turn them off by default ;-)
- wlkr 9y agoAs others have pointed out, the best solution is to configure your email client(s) to your security preference but it's worth noting that some companies will give you the choice of plain text emails over HTML. I was pleasantly surprised to find Amazon (at least in the UK) offer this.
- skrebbel 9y agoFolks, every email client and service has an option to not auto-download images. Plenty have it on by default (MS Outlook, notably). All of them ought to (IMO), but it's better than nothing. I warmly recommend you turn it on. There is no need to switch to text-only email clients just because of tracking.
- vim_wannabe 9y agoDoes that help though? I've used Airmail for a long time with "Autoload Remote Images" off and thought it worked. Then couple months ago I installed Little Snitch and saw the client contacting all kinds of places. I had to explicitly deny connections to all other domains except my email provider's.
- Dotnaught 9y agoLast time I checked, Google's Inbox by Gmail did not include a way to disable image loading, which is why I won't use it.
- xpressyoo 9y agoGmelius (https://gmelius.com https://gmelius.com) detects and blocks pixel trackers in Inbox.
- neuronexmachina 9y agoAll Gmail (and presumably Inbox) images are transcoded/downloaded via Google's image proxies. https://support.google.com/mail/answer/145919?co=GENIE.Platform%3DDesktop&hl=en https://support.google.com/mail/answer/145919?co=GENIE.Platf...
- oaeuntsh32nts 9y agoDoes that mean that if you even receive an email from a list, they get notified that you opened and read it, even if you didn't? If so, that seems bad to me.
- 9y ago
- PrivWeeble 9y agoAt least we have some control over the exposures discussed in the paper. Very many companies are exposing (sensitive) information to third-party email delivery services, customer feedback and polling services, etc. Thus creating a privacy issue (and in some cases, a serious one) even before the email arrives at the recipients' server.
- makecheck 9y agoWe still have a serious problem with mail client behavior. There is so much that clients could still do to add basic security, even though E-mail protocols are terrible. For instance, why do we not see in every client a big warning at the top saying something like: “NOTE: YOU HAVE NEVER RECEIVED E-MAIL FROM THIS INTERNET LOCATION BEFORE.”? Heck, such messages should even be auto-quarantined to specific folders. It would go a long way to protect people from constantly opening spam. And, why by default do they insist on making everything look “simple” and “clean” at the expense of helping users to do even the most basic validation? They show senders as short names like “Facebook” when CLEARLY the message is coming from facebook.spammer.com or whatever when you do even the slightest digging into the original message. Why are “rules” so complex, since damn near everybody needs them for basic sanity? There ought to be a button in every message saying something like “Mark Every Future Message From This Sender as Junk”, and similar short-cuts.
- code_duck 9y agoThe 'simplicity' is the same as Microsoft hiding things like file extensions, ostensibly to help less experienced users. It ended up making users have even less of an concept of file types, and made it easier for evildoers to disguise executables as photos and such.
- bradleyankrom 9y agoHave never really thought about this, but it's a great point. At the very least, mail clients should have options to enable this kind of behavior.
- jcranmer 9y ago> For instance, why do we not see in every client a big warning at the top saying something like: “NOTE: YOU HAVE NEVER RECEIVED E-MAIL FROM THIS INTERNET LOCATION BEFORE.”? Because that is way too dangerous a policy. Recently, I moved, and in creating online accounts for online bill pay, I got confirmation emails from each of my utilities. Saying that they're spam just because you've never received email from them would cause most people to be unable to find these confirmation messages. > And, why by default do they insist on making everything look “simple” and “clean” at the expense of helping users to do even the most basic validation? They show senders as short names like “Facebook” when CLEARLY the message is coming from facebook.spammer.com or whatever when you do even the slightest digging into the original message. Uh, my email client doesn't do that. If the email address isn't priorly known, it shows the email address instead of the display name. > Why are “rules” so complex, since damn near everybody needs them for basic sanity? There ought to be a button in every message saying something like “Mark Every Future Message From This Sender as Junk”, and similar short-cuts. Most spammers don't reuse the same email addresses. You end up with a lot of useless rules. Bayesian spam filtering is much more effective, for example, and requires very little user action.
- englehardt 9y agoHello, I'm one of the authors of this work. The code and data for the study is available here: https://github.com/citp/email_tracking https://github.com/citp/email_tracking (measurement platform here: https://github.com/citp/OpenWPM https://github.com/citp/OpenWPM). We also just released a blog post that highlights the main results (and is a quicker read): https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2017/09/28/i-never-signed-up-for-this-privacy-implications-of-email-tracking/ https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2017/09/28/i-never-signed-up-f...
- oaeuntsh32nts 9y agoThank you very much for doing this work! I have recommended that my employer, who makes a popular email client, read this and consider adding these sorts of features.
- xpressyoo 9y agoGmelius (https://gmelius.com https://gmelius.com) detects and blocks pixel trackers within Gmail and Inbox. We'll soon release a way to prevent link tracking. You can learn more about this privacy feature at https://gmelius.com/gmail-block-trackers/ https://gmelius.com/gmail-block-trackers/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]