10 ms·
I read an interesting forum post about Sears a few years back [1] TLDR: In 1985 Sears had vast mail order experience, co-founded an ISP (Prodigy), and had thei
by michaelt 9y ago
I read an interesting forum post about Sears a few years back [1]
TLDR: In 1985 Sears had vast mail order experience, co-founded an ISP (Prodigy), and had their own credit cards (Discover). All the components they'd need to dominate online retail. In 1993 they closed their mail order division. In 1995, Amazon launched.
[1] http://www.metafilter.com/62394/The-Record-Industrys-Decline#1742245 http://www.metafilter.com/62394/The-Record-Industrys-Decline...
- xigency 9y agoI've read this point in a few places as well, but it doesn't really explain why they closed the catalog. Here I found an article from 1993 describing the move: http://www.nytimes.com/1993/01/26/business/sears-eliminating-its-catalogues-and-50000-jobs.html?mcubz=0 http://www.nytimes.com/1993/01/26/business/sears-eliminating... This was the same time the company was leaving the Sears Tower. I think Sears faced a number of bad decisions over the decades leading to its early and later decline. Edit: Here is another article of the decision to cut the catalog - http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1993-01-26/news/9303172240_1_catalog-sears-auto-centers-big-book http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1993-01-26/news/930317224... It ends with the extremely ironic, "Sears on Monday wasn't interested in the past. It was positioning itself for the future."
- CydeWeys 9y agoWhy was leaving the Sears Tower a bad decision? What ramifications did it have?
- xigency 9y agoBuilding the Sears Tower was a bad idea. It ended up being a waste of money. Reading those articles it's clear that they were hemorrhaging money in 1990, compared to being profitable 20 years earlier.
- adventured 9y agoThey weren't hemorrhaging money at the time. Sears was profitable from 1980 to 1990, including fiscal 1990. 1990 is approximately the year when their earnings started to plunge toward losses. Earnings nearly got cut in half from 1989 vs 1990. At the time Walmart was still the #2 retailer, having just passed Kmart (for the curious, Walmart went from $32b in sales for 1990 to $485b by 2015; now Walmart is in a position where their earnings are falling and sales growth has been flat for years as Amazon starts to eat into them). This NY Times article from January 1991, describes the atmosphere well: http://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/28/business/big-change-is-expected-for-sears.html http://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/28/business/big-change-is-exp...
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe Sears Tower was built in 1970-1973 though? I'm still not seeing what it had to do with the profitability of the company in 1990. And you originally said that leaving it was a bad idea, not constructing it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- justherefortart 9y agoJCPenney is why Sears closed the catalog. JCP did it better with better technology and faster.
- Johnny555 9y agoI wonder if the seemingly shortsighted decision was influenced by the desire to appease stock analysts (who are more interested in next quarter's results than next decade's) by shedding costs quickly. Analysts seemed to think the company was heading in the right direction... few companies (aside from Amazon) have the luxury of telling analysts "We're forgoing profits now so we can build up our business" A quote from that 1993 article: Still, most analysts hesitated to say that the revamping alone would put Sears back on its feet. "Put it this way: They're off their knees," said George A. Ashur, director of corporate bond research at Chase Securities Inc. "This is without a doubt good medicine for the company, but I have to see a few quarters of good returns before I'm ready to ditch the conservative show-me attitude."
- Animats 9y agoAt the time, mail order shopping was dying. Montgomery Ward and JC Penny were also bailing on mail order. The Sears model was for a pre-car America, where it was either Sears or some local overpriced retailers with no selection. By 1993, the US had malls everywhere there were people, Wal-Mart was taking on the job of servicing small towns, and the customer base of people reachable only by mail had shrunk. Sears had the first good fulfillment system, but it was geared to the postal system and rail transport. It took about two weeks to get delivery on something from Sears, and you never knew what was out of stock until the package showed up. That allowed malls to beat them on convenience.
- helper 9y agoReally interesting nytimes article. > The operation, which also published 50 small specialty catalogues, only recently began accepting Visa and Mastercard for purchases, and for many years, customers had to pick up their purchases at a Sears store even though other catalogues would mail items directly to homes. Its easy to be nostalgic but it really sounds like sears had already fallen significantly behind by the time they shutdown their catalog.
- knz 9y ago> Its easy to be nostalgic but it really sounds like sears had already fallen significantly behind by the time they shutdown their catalog. It's not unique to Sears either. I know a few people who work at the Target HQ in Minneapolis and have heard stories in the past of executives being astounded by online shopping, especially the idea that people would do comparison shopping while in the store. Target has significantly increased their digital offerings since then but it's still far from the experience of Amazon.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoBut they are very different experiences. Amazon is the grand prize winner in the contest of looking up something you already know you want to buy, bundling it up with some shampoo you forgot to pick up at the grocery store earlier, and having all of that on your doorstep in two days. Amazon's Achilles Heel is browsing. Their selection may feature 100,000 relevant items to my search but I seem to only find shitty versions of products, or at too high prices, regardless of how I mess with the search filter. Target is great when you have an idea of what you might like to buy: you can try on shoes, sit on furniture, feel the bedsheets - you get the idea. Sometimes the hassle of not getting the right size/feel of a product bought online, and having to repackage it and wait for another delivery simply isn't worth it compared to driving out to your local Suburban Mall Hell to just go and buy things like mom and dad used to do.
- gregmac 9y ago> Amazon's Achilles Heel is browsing. Their selection may feature 100,000 relevant items to my search but I seem to only find shitty versions of products I would say their major problem is the lack of curation. The Amazon Marketplace brought all the garbage of eBay sellers to Amazon, and mixed it in with everything else. As a result, you have to carefully watch out for things fulfilled by third parties (often subject to high shipping and strange return policies), and items with sketchy review histories. I can't find an article on it now, but I've come across items where it seems like the manufacturer pulled a bait-and-switch. The initial reviews are all very positive, and all the recent reviews are low and talk about poor product quality -- yet the item still has a reasonably high score. Did they seed reviews themselves? Did they actually change to a lower quality product? Who knows. There's certain categories of products that I find to be an an utterly frustrating shopping experience on Amazon -- cell phone accessories is the one that immediately comes to mind.
- hownottowrite 9y agoThey actually tried a diversification strategy by discontinuing the big-book and spinning up specialty books. The idea was that they could get a higher $/book by targeting specific interests. This helps in the world of prospecting (i.e. buying names from co-ops like Epsilon). It was also a strategy that would allow them to take advantage of bundling innovations at USPS like co-mailing. Obviously, none of it worked which was more of a function of merchandising than anything else.
- drzaiusapelord 9y agoBy the 80's, Service Merchandize had green screen "Silent Sam" terminals in all their stores you could walk up to, order what you wanted, pay right there, then walk to the back of the store and pick it up from a conveyer belt from the warehouse area, a bit like picking up your luggage. Imagine if this kind of system went through a dial-up and the items were simply shipped to you. We would have had mass e-commerce in 1985. The French did actually have something like this via their minitel system, fwiw. In the end, open-ish standards and SSL won the race, which is probably a good thing. I'd rather be stuck with a broken-ish web than locked into these various proprietary designs controlled by one corporation. Even if Sears/Prodigy would have delivered these services, they would have been crushed by the web.
- ams6110 9y agoIn the 1980s the number of people who had dial-up online services at home was tiny. It wasn't anything close to mainstream until the mid/late 1990s -- well after the start of Sears' financial difficulties.
- pwg 9y agoYes, in 1993, when Sears decided to close their catalog, much of the internet was still considered off-limits for commercial purposes [1]. We take today's use of the internet for shopping (and other commercial uses) for granted, but in 1993 it was not at all 100% clear that such a use would be allowed. [1] Business Use of the World-Wide Web, 1995, http://www.informationr.net/ir/1-2/paper6.html http://www.informationr.net/ir/1-2/paper6.html ("Commercial activity on the Internet has only recently been possible.")
- drzaiusapelord 9y agoBut home computer adoption was skyrocketing at the time. My argument here is that once people saw the utility of this then they'd buy modems, the same way they saw the utility of printing and bought printers for their computers. At the time, a modem was the same price, if not cheaper, than a printer or a floppy disk drive. It wasn't exactly a luxury expense.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSears is a textbook case of the evolution of a company. As the Atlantic points out they were really successful at capturing trends, but what Sear's secret was they were building infrastructure that let them respond to changes quickly. Then sometime between 1975 and 1985 they seem to have started thinking they were successful because they were 'the best' and took their eye off the core competencies that made them nimble (logistics, accountable management practices) That is according to people who worked there at that time. Suddenly people who should not have been promoted (they weren't 'Sears people') were being promoted, and things were focused less on operations and more on public image. The challenge is that you start managing to the effect rather than the cause. It is like companies that spend all of their time doing 'market research' and spend their time trying to be better than their perceived competitors at what their competitors are doing. They lose sight of why they were doing so well in the first place. "chasing your tail", "following the followers", lots of names for it, but they were being challenged by many up and coming brick and mortar competitors (K-Mart, Target, Walmart, Montgomery Wards, Etc.) By worrying about those threats they forgot to watch for the changes in the market, and that led to a lot of what would be difficult pain. And yes, it is "easy" to see that looking backwards in time at their choices, but even in the 70's and 80's there were voices telling them that they were not focused on the right problems.
- rhizome 9y agoThen sometime between 1975 and 1985 See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_history_of_private_equity#Regulatory_and_tax_changes_impact_the_boom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_history_of_private_equit...
- cat199 9y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers
- marcosdumay 9y agoYou mean that easy money was the problem?
- 9y ago
- jasode 9y ago>In 1993 they closed their mail order division. In 1995, Amazon launched. If one compresses the timeline, it does seem like Amazon killed off Sears when in reality, Sears was already getting killed off in the 10 years before 1995. In the 1980s... - Home Depot, Lowes, Builders Square, etc home improvement stores were taking away business from Sears power tools (Craftsman) - Best Buy and Circuit City were taking the consumer electronics business and appliances. Less customers buy Sears Kenmore. - Target, Walmart, Williams-Sonoma, etc were taking housewares (pots, pans, etc) business - consumers (especially kids) didn't want "department store brand" clothing from Sears/JCPenney because they were "uncool". They wanted the boutique brands (Guess jeans, Calvin Klein, etc) - peak mall traffic was 1986 and malls started dying off after that. An easy way for me to remember that point in time is the 1985 movie "Back to The Future". When you watch the DeLorean spinning around the parking lot of Twin Pines Mall, remind yourself that you're seeing "peak mall". - credit-cards criteria were loosened and easy credit was expanded. Sears no longer had a captive audience with the Sears credit-card that kept shoppers within Sears' "walled-garden". Before 1990s, if a young person had zero credit history, one of the first credit cards one attempted to get was the "Sears department store credit card". Once one built up credit history with it, he/she could then try to get Visa/Mastercard. In the meantime, they used the Sears card to spend money at Sears. To contrast the difference, today an 18-year-old college student can get a Visa/MC without a parent as a cosigner. That type of easy credit approval for a person with no job was unheard of in the 1960s/1970s. There were lots of competitive forces that Sears' management didn't respond to long before Jeff Bezos arrived on the scene.
- chipperyman573 9y ago>today an 18-year-old college student can get a Visa/MC without a parent as a cosigner. FWIW, when I was 18 I had to get a secured card[0] and I was barely able to get it (I had to go to my bank twice to appeal the decision). It's definitely different from 40 years ago but it's not super easy for most college students, and a lot of it came down to the fact that I had a few grand sitting in a checking account and a job that paid $12.50/hr. Some of my friends who didn't have that got flat out declined multiple times (I have one friend who has applied for three different cards and she's been denied all three times, with no credit history at all). [0]: Basically, the card had a $500 credit limit and you had to give the bank $500 for a year, after a year if you've made all your payments they give you your $500 back. It still sat in my savings account generating "interest", but I couldn't spend it
- sulam 9y agoThe failure of Sears is really the success of Chinese manufacturing and the rise of disposability and dramatically lower prices that followed. Craftsman used to be tools that would last you for decades, but you paid. Now it’s the same crap everyone else is selling with a different logo thrown on.
- jstarfish 9y ago> Craftsman used to be tools that would last you for decades, but you paid. Now it’s the same crap everyone else is selling with a different logo thrown on. Only certain items. They certainly have fallen victim to slapping the Craftsman label on cheap plastic "things" out of desperation which has definitely impacted their reputation as of late, but for those of us who can't pay Snap-on prices for everything what remains of Sears' actual tools are still light years better than the malleable/rusty junk Lowe's, Home Depot, Amazon and Walmart sell.
- dugditches 9y agoDewalt, Makita, Milwauke, etc are 'malleable/rusty junk'? The only Craftsmen tools I see on job sites now are wrenches and screwdrivers.
- Aloha 9y agoThose are the durable ones that craftsman makes.
- jstarfish 9y agoNo, I didn't have power tools in mind when I said that. Anything with a motor or more than a few moving parts is worth shopping around. The basic hand tools and precision instruments are the Craftsman products I find are still worth using. The wrenches, torque wrenches, calipers, hammers, screwdrivers and the like. Nothing electronic or mostly plastic.
- lotsofpulp 9y agohttp://pressurewashr.com/tool-industry-behemoths/ http://pressurewashr.com/tool-industry-behemoths/ Here's a list of which companies own which brands. A lot of them probably come out of the same assembly lines with different names slapped on.
- Alex3917 9y ago> co-founded an ISP (Prodigy) Famous for being one of the least competently-managed joint ventures of all time.
- ghaff 9y agoProdigy was truly awful. As I recall, it attempted to appeal to non-techies with a graphical interface at a time when computers really weren't fast enough and color graphics sucked (CGA). Just terrible in comparison to commercial services like CIS as well as BBSs (both paid and free).
- Endy 9y agoWeird, because I was on Prodigy and it worked beautifully for me; and it's the only reason I'll even give online gaming a marginal glance nowadays.
- erdle 9y agoSears was such a dominant player at EXACTLY what Amazon does that at one point... more Americans had Sears catalogs than indoor plumbing. It use to be normal to take the Sears catalog out to the outhouse and use it for toilet paper. Retail is flat circle, you just move the counter between the seller and the customer. Some generations like picking out the products, some generations like having someone pick it out for them. Some like it getting delivered, some like picking it up. Not much changes... people need goods... but no one makes all the goods they need.
- turk184 9y agoIn like 1910, yes what you said is true, not the 1980s.
- Waterluvian 9y agoSears had 120 years of experience selling stuff to people through the mail. It's unbelievable how they managed to not parlay that into what amazon is now.
- turk184 9y agoThe Swiss didn't make digital watches. The Germans didn't figure out reliable cars (and still haven't). It's how it is.