12 ms·
An American City Where the Government Barely Exists
- rmason 9y agoI really like how they're routing around a dysfunctional government that is barely functioning. Compared to Detroit that surrounds it Highland Park is the wild, wild west.
- empath75 9y agoThere are a bunch of cities in the US that would be best ‘fixed’ by paying everyone to leave and letting it return back to forest. It seems like they’d have to invest hundreds of millions of dollars into this city just to make it minimally functional, and they still won’t have a viable economy afterwards.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoTotally agree, that's a huge part of city planning /permissions to build etc. You can't decide to build on top a mountain and then ask for city water, power, police cruiser patrols etc . In Detroit the city bought a lot of lots, demolished the homes and closed that neighborhood. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/7778335/Detroit-to-bulldoze-thousands-of-homes-in-fight-for-survival.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/7...
- rmason 9y agoThat plan by a former mayor (former NBA great Dave Bing) was hugely unpopular and never launched. Police and fire in Detroit is hugely difficult because they have a large area to protect that includes numerous ghost neighborhoods. Often a fire is set in an abandoned house and if it's windy spreads to occupied residences. Despite the difficulty Detroit's current mayor is committed to all the cities neighborhoods. However if you follow the money resources are concentrated in a handful of neighborhoods.
- zipwitch 9y agoExcept abandoned cities won't magically go back to some idyllic paradise. They're full of value (shelter, metals, art, etc) that someone is going to want to extract. And they're also full of lots of potentially dangerous stuff too. Dealing with broken cities will not be cheap, swift or easy. I have no ready solutions. But thinking that we can just walk away from them is only setting ourselves up for different problems down the timeline.
- Spooky23 9y agoIn 30 years when capital is harder to come by and suburban infrastructure starts to crumble, cities will come back.
- summer_steven 9y agoCities compromise 3.5% of the United States land area. They are not taking land away from trees or wildlife..
- sliverstorm 9y agoI don't think he's concerned so much about wildlife, I think the point is just that some cities don't really have anything in particular going for them, aren't worth rebuilding, and should be abandoned like a Western ghost town.
- vacri 9y agoWhen you take out the great plains, the desert scrublands, and the alaskan wilderness, that 3.5% grows.
- mikeyouse 9y agoThe Detroit/Warren/Dearborn MSA has a higher GDP than San Jose/Sunnyvale/Santa Clara MSA and is home to ~4 million people. Don't be confused by articles highlighting specific neighborhoods or old factories, there is a ton of economic activity. There are obviously some huge problems trying to provide government services for the same land area with a shrinking population, especially following a large recession, but "Won't have a viable economy" is silly given the number of companies in the area.
- skadamou 9y agoI think you make a good point. You shouldn't write off the whole Detroit area because of a few articles about specific neighborhoods. But Detroit/Warren/Dearborn essentially have the same GDP as San Jose/Sunnyvale/Santa Clara yet twice as many people live in the Detroit area https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NGMP19820 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NGMP19820 https://www.bea.gov/regional/bearfacts/pdf.cfm?fips=19820&areatype=MSA&geotype=4 https://www.bea.gov/regional/bearfacts/pdf.cfm?fips=19820&ar... https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NGMP41940 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/NGMP41940 http://www.bestplaces.net/metro/california/san_jose-sunnyvale-santa_clara http://www.bestplaces.net/metro/california/san_jose-sunnyval...
- mikeyouse 9y agoThat only strengthens my point though -- The original commenter said we should just pay everyone to leave since there's no hope of sustaining an economy there. If you can pay 4 million people to leave, you can pay to fix whatever services they are lacking -- and then you'd have 4 million people in a area with hundreds of large companies and good government services!
- dionidium 9y agoThis is why I constantly hammer the point about comparing cities using MSA figures. Focusing on “Detroit” or “St. Louis” or “Cleveland” or whatever without understanding their place in their respective regions and how much activity surrounds them only misleads. A failure to understand this leads to all kinds of confused and nonsensical beliefs about rust belt cities and ultimately to casual, confident assertions that can only be described as absurd (like the one you’re responding to).
- yairhaimo 9y agoIs there any scenario like this in any other developed country? (Im honestly looking for an answer)
- sleavey 9y agoGiven that the wealth gap in the US seems so much bigger than any other country, I'd wager not.
- contingencies 9y agoParts of China have some cool stuff. The arts community in Yunnan is a good example. Many sculpture parks, weird spaces, reinvigorated industrial, etc. But gentrifying quickly now, so creativity is waning.
- NeonVice 9y agosource?
- microcolonel 9y agoThe United States is not a particularly wealth-unequal country by world measures.
- greglindahl 9y agoThe US is very wealth-unequal, especially if you compare it to developed countries: https://data.oecd.org/inequality/income-inequality.htm https://data.oecd.org/inequality/income-inequality.htm
- specialist 9y agoCompared to itself, 30 years ago.
- IncRnd 9y agoThat page doesn't compare wealth but disposable income.
- 24gttghh 9y agoHonestly it’s good to hear about the things ‘Mama’ is doing on Avalon ST. That’s some perseverance right there.
- free_everybody 9y agoAs someone who has lived in and around Detroit for their whole life, I found this article to be very insightful. By far, the best part of Detroit is a trend of extremely creative people being able to do whatever they want with their respective spaces. It goes far beyond painting a mural or erecting a sculpture. There are huge gardens[1], performance art spaces[2], puppet theaters[3], concert venues in industrial buildings[4], and much more. And these spaces are very cheap to maintain, relatively speaking. [1]http://www.miufi.org/ http://www.miufi.org/ [2]http://thehinterlandsensemble.org/ http://thehinterlandsensemble.org/ [3]http://www.puppetart.org/ http://www.puppetart.org/ [4]http://tangentgallery.com/Tangent_Gallery/Home.html http://tangentgallery.com/Tangent_Gallery/Home.html
- greglindahl 9y agoConcert venues in industrial buildings sound great until you have a fire and people die, thanks to a lack of attention to fire safety.
- darkmuch 9y agoThat's a grim thing to say for no reason.
- greglindahl 9y agoYou're right that it's grim -- I said it because of the title of this discussion, "people being able to do whatever they want", and remembering the Ghost Ship fire in Oakland, CA.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- L_Rahman 9y agoUnfortunately, it's also something that actually happened: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Oakland_warehouse_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Oakland_warehouse_fire 36 people died.
- wavefunction 9y agoWith a population of 11,776 it's only a town.
- IncRnd 9y agoIt is incorporated, not only working from a charter, which in this case means city not town.
- thomas_howland 9y agoIt's far from "government barely existing". They exist in minimal form solely to extract resources from any remaining piece of value in the city. Eg: "Then earlier this year, he got a letter saying 333 Midland wasn’t up to code and it would have to cease operations immediately. He took care of the minor matters the fire marshall requested, like installing exit signs and extra fire extinguishers. But he still can’t get a clear answer from the building inspector about what else needs to be taken care of"
- missingcolours 9y agoI did some research a few years ago and HP had one of the higher revenue streams per capita in the entire state. There's lots of money in the city government, but not a lot of results, which points you toward the underlying problems.
- arbuge 9y agoIndeed, those were my thoughts on reading this also. That building inspector sounds like he's expecting a bribe of some kind to go away.
- icelancer 9y ago"But he still can’t get a clear answer from the building inspector about what else needs to be taken care of." This is local government at its finest. I deal with this on a regular basis. There are regulations with no clear code; when I ask for a specific contract and list of things to do, I get the runaround - but that doesn't stop them from telling me what I am doing with my building structures is not up to code.
- jokoon 9y agoI wonder why there would not be some kind of alternative economic opportunities in that city. I sense it would be the ideal place to "start over" and build something new in terms of politics and economics. But when you think about it, a city is such a complex thing, so unless there is money and investment, a poor american city will just stay poor, that seems to fit the law of gravity. Unless you redefine some new way to live in detroit that shortcuts the problems of money, this city will linger. It's surprising because I really think all the large pool of cash from the silicon valley and its thousands of new alternative ideas could revive detroit. But instead San Francisco is just the antithesis of detroit. That says lengths about the polarized world of today's capitalism. To be totally honest, I wonder why somebody like Bernie Sanders is not campaigning for mayor or governor other there. It's the ideal place for the left to accomplish things.
- mcherm 9y agoIs this libertarian paradise?
- IncRnd 9y agoIt's not even close to a comparison with "Galt's Gulch." It could be, but the prime movers aren't there. Historically, it actually shows the opposite of such a place.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoDearborn and Detroit both either barely have a government or the government has ceded power to private groups. Corruption and constitutional protections have largely gone out the window.
- intrasight 9y agoI, for one, am in favor of this experiment in less government.
- nether 9y agoYou should move there.
- quasse 9y agoLibertarianism for thee, not for me.
- intrasight 9y agoI have less government where I live now and like it just fine
- ionised 9y agoWhere would that be?
- intrasight 9y agoI wouldn't want it spoiled so I'd rather not say
- MilnerRoute 9y agoEast Palo Alto experienced something similar. They voted to incorporate as their own city, then discovered they didn't have a large enough tax base to adequately fund their police department. At one point in the 1980s they actually achieved the distinction of having the highest murder rate of any city in America.
- justinjlynn 9y agoIt's different now?
- costcopizza 9y agoSurprised a libertarian billionaire hasn't assumed Highland Park's debts and run their utopia here.
- jdale27 9y agoI was thinking something similar. Though rather than a billionaire, some enterprising libertarian / anarcho-capitalist folks could move there and push the city further in that direction by simply using legitimate democratic processes. Sort of like a smaller-scale version of the Free State Project in New Hampshire. Though maybe a billionaire could provide some seed funding to induce the initial migration.
- stevenwoo 9y agoYou would need a billionaire because actually running things like a libertarian doesn't pay the municipal bills - it's been tried without the billionaire. https://www.texasobserver.org/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-freest-little-city-in-texas/ https://www.texasobserver.org/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-frees...
- gilbetron 9y agoLive near Detroit, and this article candy-coats it, even given it's bleak picture. The city should, in no way, be held up as a positive example of anything. All it illustrates is that life can exist in the carcass of an immense, dead beast for many years. Detroit is an example of what must be avoided at all costs. Let the downvotes happen from those that romanticize urban blight!
- et-al 9y ago(Curious, are you still living there because of your social network?)