9 ms·
Tulipmania: More Boring Than You Thought
- ruytlm 9y agoSo, the damage wasn't as widespread, as the whole economy wasn't tied to tulips. In other news, BTC/ETH should replace currency, and every transaction should be on a blockchain! Don't worry, no bubble. Did I mention my upcoming ICO? [edit: the second half is sarcasm. If the lesson to be learned is that an isolated bubble does isolated damage, it seems to make sense to be cautious before integrating something as speculative as crypto into the rest of the economy.]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lojack 9y agoPeople say this every time the price has a sharp increase, but after seeing this happen repeatedly, I'm convinced its simply a price correction that swings too far into an overcorrection and eventually comes back to the intrinsic value. But, perhaps I'll be wrong and the price will one day come crashing down to zero, I've just seen literally zero evidence of this happening. Edit: s/actual/intrinstic/
- lawpoop 9y agoWhat is the "actual" price? Can you point to a day in the past when bitcoin was at its actual price, instead of in a swing? How about today's price? Is it in the swing, or is it actual?
- tdb7893 9y agoEven discounting the possibility of a catastrophic crash bitcoin is a pretty risky investment because it's relatively new and unknown compared to most ways that normal people invest. Nothing wrong with some bitcoin as long as it's only a part of a larger investment portfolio, though.
- lojack 9y agoVery much agreed.
- dogruck 9y agoI understand your argument as "bitcoin hasn't crashed yet, therefore I see no evidence that it will ever crash."
- lojack 9y agoYou're cherry picking my argument. My point was that we've seen this happen numerous times in the past to the point where its a trend. Every other time we saw this pattern, the price ended up higher than where it started. So, its more "bitcoin hasn't crashed yet, and has exhibited this trend before and didn't crash then, therefore if I'm not wrong and its still following this trend then it will not crash"
- dogruck 9y agoOk fair point. I agree that any particular downswing in bitcoin's price is not predictive of a total crash.
- wslh 9y ago> Did I mention my upcoming ICO? Until one or more ICOs bring successful and innovative products. At the fundamental level ICOs are a frictionless way to fund your project. There will be a lot of scams and unproductive projects until the community makes an error correction looking for more due diligence and stronger evidence. There is a huge gap between ICOs and IPOs that make it difficult to fund new companies globally.
- fyrerise 9y agoThe title is a little misleading. The article itself acknowledges that there was a tulip fever: > That’s not to say that everything about the story is wrong; merchants really did engage in a frantic tulip trade, and they paid incredibly high prices for some bulbs. And when a number of buyers announced they couldn’t pay the high price previously agreed upon, the market did fall apart and cause a small crisis—but only because it undermined social expectations. But it implies that it's not all that notable because it didn't collapse the entire economy: > But the trade didn’t affect all levels of society, and it didn’t cause the collapse of industry in Amsterdam and elsewhere. Personally, I don't think I'd ever made the assumption that it had. Likewise, if Bitcoin were to implode, it would be similar — some people would suffer, but it wouldn't be all that widespread of an effect. Tulipmania still makes a great historical anecdote on speculation, and I for one, will keep using it as one.
- pfarnsworth 9y agoI was going to make the same comment. I never heard that the Dutch economy collapsed from the tulip trade. But everything else was confirmed. And just like when the bitcoin bubble bursts, I don't think there will be a collapse in the economy either, but it will definitely be a phenomenon that will be talked about decades later.
- dogruck 9y agoI'd say the title is absolutely misleading.
- abstrct 9y agoSounds like a case of... titlemania... Edit: Sorry, you're all right. There wasn't any titlemania after all.
- conistonwater 9y agoIt's very modern of them to assume that a speculative bubble would cause collapse of industry and that it's remarkable that it didn't. The whole relationship between "some people default on loans" and "some other people lose jobs" is a relatively modern type of financial crisis, starting in late 19th century. In a way, it's a curious introduction to macroeconomics, the apparent puzzle that when one person is unable to repay a debt, why does another person somewhere else lose their job? I think they missed an opportunity there to write a little bit more about it, it would explain why people should still care about bubbles.
- mmonihan 9y agoHere's a perspective from the Austrian school: https://mises.org/library/truth-about-tulipmania https://mises.org/library/truth-about-tulipmania
- mdpopescu 9y agoYou learn quickly not to mention favorably certain taboo subjects here on HN, like Austrian economics or free markets being better than regulated one. (I'll refrain from pointing out others, I want to limit the number of downvotes I get. Self-censorship or, in other words, learned helplessness.)
- stephen_g 9y agoLook, as much as I dislike the Austrian school (it all hangs on certain premises that I don't believe are necessarily true, so I don't think it contributes much to being able to understand the economy), the main problem with the comment above was that it wasn't very useful in just dropping a link with little context... With a bit of commentary or a brief summary of the article, people would have engaged with it instead of just downvoting.
- neilwilson 9y agoSo does mainstream economics. They are both wrong. At least the Austrian school admits they made the whole thing up in a religious fashion and never submit their ideas to actual science. Mainstream economics just pretends it's scientific when really the whole belief structure is a house of cards in the same way
- stephen_g 9y agoI don't disagree, I think that certain ideas from the post-Keynesian and modern monetary theory are probably the closest to actual evidence based Economics at the moment.
- djsumdog 9y agoThere no real free market. I highly encourage the book Debt: The First 5,000 Years. The author makes the argument that markets do not exist independently of states, or at least when they do, they exist in the vacuum of a previous state post-collapse. It's an incredibly eye opening book that talks about debt, money, war and slavery. They are all deeply connected.
- aqsheehy 9y agoThis is good for bitcoin
- ionwake 9y agoNo one gets it
- aaron695 9y agoAt some stage it'd be interesting to collate 'dumb things HN believes' TulipMania would join Split Sleep, Drones hitting/near misses planes, X just discovered Y happened Z years previous to what was thought. This Voynich manuscript article adds to the discussion. The Valley has a unique problem with Y.
- seibelj 9y agoSelf driving cars will be here "in just 5 more years" (I have been hearing that since 2007)...
- dang 9y ago'HN' is a statistical distribution; it doesn't believe anything. Some people here might believe some of those things but I doubt they're the same people, or close to a majority. It's popular to diss one's fellow community members, but kind of in bad taste. If you're commenting here, you're as much 'HN' as the next person.
- aaron695 9y agoHN has emergent behaviour. Like an ants nest or a physical human community or a corporation the behaviour doesn't reflex individuals or even necessarily the majority of individuals. Shrug, I wasn't even saying the dumb things were common. But I do think these emergent memes bleed across to real world issues. While people think it's ok to think hundreds of years ago people were stupid and paid 'really' ridiculous amounts of money for tulips, they will also be susceptible to allow war propaganda like what's coming out of North Korea or Iraq. People are people, do we really think the North Korean's are that dumb they think their leader doesn't poop or see the whole Iraq 'Latif Yahia' saga.
- justin66 9y agoThe real bubble comes when you watch Smithsonian's webpage use close to two gigabytes of RAM in a very short time.
- eadmund 9y agoHey, didn't you know? It's 2017, and we can't display pictures and text without a sandboxed virtual machine running thousands of dynamics queries.
- tpeo 9y agoI feel so glad that we finally live in the future. Such a shame how terrible it is, though.
- djsumdog 9y agoDo you remember the Palm Treo? I remember the Palm Treo. I had the SDK. Every app had direct memory access, no threads and it was easy to crash the phone. I mean, they didn't serve us tons of ads either but...things aren't that bad...
- bhaak 9y agoYou make it sound as if it were bad back then? Was it on the Treo? Because I had the previous non smartphone Palms and there that was not an issue. It was even an advantage IMHO. Apps were fast and good easily exchange data or even better you good use a better app than the standard app for a given data collection. You didn't have the walled data containers we have today. Granted, with an internet capable device this opens up lots of security problems but I also feel that I was more productive with my handheld back then than I am now with my iPhone.
- justin66 9y agoIf you value performance over stability, things were infinitely better. Of course I actually don't value performance over stability, but I am still capable of being shocked by things like the Smithsonian website. I noticed this a week or two ago when the Chick Parsons article popped up. I made the mistake of... leaving that web page open in the background. It's a world gone mad.
- TwoNineFive 9y agoThis is an advertisement for the movie Tulip Fever that just came out. I noticed a lot of similar posts on other social media sites in the last six months.
- mirimir 9y agoArguably it's more criticism than advertising.
- forkLding 9y agoI guess the paper is trying to help with the misconception that a lot of what occurred in Tulipmania is relatable to modern-day financial bubble crashes where a lot of the general public suddenly lose jobs and money or how a lot of perception was influenced by Calvinists condemning materialistic pursuits, whereas in the actual event of the Tulip fever, it likely only affected the rich and not your ordinary 1600s general public.
- djsumdog 9y agoSo if anything, what we faced in the 2008 crisis and what many are experience now is on orders of magnitude worse than Tulipmania...
- wallace_f 9y agoAbsolutely. Also an example of how the financial system has evolved to tie the fates of some of the large, institutional (too big to fail) speculative investors to that of the common working man in the most unjust way possible. It is impressive how remarkarble they've evolved the finacial sector (for themselves).
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoClick bait pattern 101: Claim something is completely different than everybody thought then write that it mainly was as everyone thought with some minor variations.
- coldtea 9y ago>For decades, economists have pointed to 17th-century tulipmania as a warning about the perils of the free market. Writers and historians have reveled in the absurdity of the event. The incident even provides the backdrop for the new film Tulip Fever, based on a novel of the same name by Deborah Moggach. The only problem: none of these stories are true. Well, speaking of economists' historical-based arguments that weren't, there never was much truth about the keyboard wars either: https://www.utdallas.edu/~liebowit/keys1.html https://www.utdallas.edu/~liebowit/keys1.html
- runeks 9y agoAs someone on HN pointed out recently, there’s a much better explanation for the tulip bubble than “speculators went crazy all of the sudden”. In a 2007 paper, Earl Thompson argues that the extreme tulip bubble was formed because the Dutch government, in coalition with insolvent tulip speculators, allowed speculators to nullify tulip futures contracts, thus inadvertently enabling close-to-risk-free speculation in tulip futures (which, after the regulation, resembled options contracts to a much higher degree). Here’s an Economist article on the subject: https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2013/10/economic-history https://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2013/10/economi... And Wikipedia has a summary here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania#Legal_changes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania#Legal_changes
- jmh530 9y agoI just posted about this without checking to see if anyone else had said anything...
- jondubois 9y agoIf the environment is stable enough, a bubble doesn't necessarily have to pop. I think that chronic sustained wealth inequality can create lasting economic bubbles that never pop. If we lived in a world where everyone had near infinite resources, everything would be a bubble because markets would be driven entirely by status value. If you think about it, the rich today have practically unlimited wealth thanks to dividends, rent payments and/or interest; they can afford to lose large portions of their income and still become richer. Now thanks in part to social media, the rich live in a separate world from others; one which has near unlimited resources. So long as money flows into their world faster than it leaks out, bubbles are completely sustainable.
- danmaz74 9y agoIsn't a bubble defined as a price increase that at some point pops?
- jmh530 9y agoThis is a frustrating article, but perhaps the book is better. The key work here is really Earl Thompson's "The tulipmania: Fact or artifact?" in Public Choice. The article at least does not make any mention of Thompson or his argument. In particular, his argument is that there was a legal change in how the tulip contracts worked and so it didn't make sense to compare the previous price history with the history after that change.
- gmiller123456 9y agoMy first thought was "It couldn't possibly be more boring than I think", then in the article I see it's the more accurate title for the book I read that convinced me of that. tl;dr. Even though Tulipmania might have been an exciting and fascinating event, the actual details of what/why it happened have been lost to history. There are ledgers and letters mentioning tulip prices and do definitely show a bubble. But there's not really any information on why people thought tulips were worth the price they were promising. As with investors today, they generally don't make their motives public, and when they do, you can't necessarily trust them to be honest.