23 ms·
“The moon blew up without warning and for no apparent reason”
- m1el 9y agoWhile the simulation is really cool, I doubt it represents the reality (assuming the Moon blew up). Why I think so: the planets have formed out of space debris, they didn't all fall into the star. > Pairwise collisions between bodies – most of the collisions are approximated as elastic. Yeah, that's one reason why. > A static mass at the origin of a 2D co-ordinate system – this is Earth Why not simulate the Earth too?
- ginko 9y agoI would also guess a full 3D simulation would give slightly different results.
- marcosdumay 9y ago> Why I think so: the planets have formed out of space debris, they didn't all fall into the star. Nearly all of them did, there is way more mass on the Sun than orbiting it.
- mikeash 9y agoJust to put a number on "way more": the Sun contains 99.86% of all known mass in the solar system. Of the 0.14% of the solar system that isn't the Sun, Jupiter accounts for roughly two thirds of it.
- empath75 9y agoOnly 25% of the mass ends up on earth. And a point mass at the center of a sphere produces the same gravitational pull.
- kbutler 9y agoBut a different collision probability.
- Dylan16807 9y agoThe earth is being given a size for collision purposes. But possibly much too large of one? With that and it being 2d it's nearly useless for figuring out the actual collision rates, or how long it takes things to settle. But it is useful in some respects.
- robotcookies 9y agoDoes this account for the size of the pieces? Every time they fragment, the pieces would get smaller making it less likely to hit another.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThat was pretty damn cool
- cschmidt 9y agoThe first 11 words are cool. But my favorite was the chapter heading that said "Five Thousand Years Later".
- no_protocol 9y agoI think that is a spoiler, can you remove it?
- zbentley 9y agoIt might be a spoiler, but it's also a fascinating thing about this book. If it were broken in half, into two books, at the point GP refers to, they would barely even be in the same Dewey Decimal section. The two parts of this novel are incredibly different--moreso than almost any other fiction books I've read. A lot of people are unhappy about that; they get into the ambience/groove of one part and have to deal with a massive stylistic/thematic/character shift. Personally, I love it.
- treerock 9y agoI'd recommend Cloud Atlas. It's like 6 very different books in one. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_Atlas_(novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_Atlas_(novel)
- delecti 9y agoIt's also a rare example of a book whose movie adaptation is really worth watching. I watched the movie first, and I think both the book and movie are better thanks to the other. The book makes it clear how each story exists in the next, and the movie gives a better sense of how the themes of the books tie together, despite their differences. To anyone who reads Cloud Atlas, I strongly recommend you also watch the movie, and vice versa.
- ghaff 9y agoI was OK with it. At first my reaction was that Part 2 would have been better as an epilogue but I did get into it. A few things bothered me about how aspects of part 1 resolved to create the environment of part 2--probably all I can say without spoilers. But I wasn't really bothered that some of the details hinted at in part 2 were hand-waved away as "other stories." I'm really not a fan of sequel-itis and I appreciate Stephenson doesn't go in for it. I'm fine with not every backstory or thread being fleshed out in detail.
- lloeki 9y agoIs the second paragraph of TFA spoiling the whole book, or is that just part of the premise that is set up during the first chapter or so? Because it just sounds like a massive spoiler.
- Derbasti 9y agoThat's just the premise.
- klank 9y agoThe latter. I don't even know if I'd consider it a spoiler at all. Kind of like saying Harry Potter is a wizard.
- ghaff 9y agoNot only is it just the premise but it's basically treated as this event that just happened for an unknowable reason. The rest of the article discusses events that take a few more pages to get to but still aren't really spoilers. A few pages in a Stephenson book don't amount to much :-)
- benzofuran 9y agoNope, just part of the premise - you're good to go!
- unoti 9y agoThe moon breaks up in the opening sentences of the book. But the realization that it'll destroy the planet doesn't come for some time later. That part is a bit of a spoiler. But the moon blowing up just can't be good for the planet long term, so maybe it's not too big of a spoiler. Earth is the Ned Stark of Seveneves.
- mikeash 9y agoI checked it out on Amazon, and the threat to the Earth is out in the open by the 27th page of the story in the hardcover edition. It's also literally the first sentence in the blurb on the back cover.
- 9y ago
- unwaryquerier 9y agoCheck out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome Similar but with low earth orbit
- ajr0 9y agoThis book [0] was quite enjoyable to read. I realize the article is about far beyond the book, but in case anyone has not read it yet, I highly recommend it as some good grade Sci-Fi. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Seveneves-Neal-Stephenson/dp/0062334514/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1506006374&sr=8-1&keywords=seveneves+Neal+Stephenson https://www.amazon.com/Seveneves-Neal-Stephenson/dp/00623345...
- spapas82 9y agoI really liked the book, probably my favourite from Neal Stephenson. Great hard scifi, fantastic solutions to problems without any deus ex machina (of course the agent that splits the moon can be thought as one) - will definitely make you think and satisfy your hunger for this kind of thing. The book can be thought of two big parts (the first is about 3/4 of the book), I don't really want to spoil, but the second part is much inferior to the first one and you won't miss much if you skip it. I know you won't but in any case...
- barkingcat 9y agoThe 2nd part is terrible. Should have been cut by an editor. Or the editor should have made him rewrite that whole 2nd part, perhaps make it into Book 2.
- davidw 9y agoI thought the first 2/3's of it were too depressing, and thought the last bit was decent sci-fi, which is what I actually like to read.
- barkingcat 9y agoThere is a good story in the last bit, but it's horribly written and deserves to be better. Despite there being some interesting elements, it is still pretty much unpublishable (in terms of coherence in characterization and setting, plot, etc - basic elements of good writing). I think a fanfic writer can come up with something better given the same material. I think Stephenson could also do that material justice, IF he rewrote it.
- CodeCube 9y agoI love this post so much ... as a fan of Kerbal Space Program, the sentence, "as long as you can deal with hundreds of pages of orbital mechanics" is super interesting :P
- jasmcole 9y agoI'm not even exaggerating. If you're into KSP, I think you'll like the book!
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoElon Musk and Neil deGrasse Tyson also appear in the book as pretty important characters, just under different names. ;)
- VectorLock 9y agoI'd love to see the source code for this.
- leni536 9y agoI wonder how it would go in 3D. In 3D the relatively tiny Moon pieces have much smaller rate of hitting each other and fragment into smaller pieces.
- yoodenvranx 9y agoIsn't the whole process pseudo-2D even in a 3D simulation? The moon initially moves on a plane around the and I guess most of it's broken pieces would stay in that plane?
- stefs 9y agothis might be true, but i don't see why it should be. if two pieces collide at a high speed and shatter explosively, why would they stay confined to a single plane?
- mikeash 9y agoI think the plane change would be small, since the velocity change experienced by the fragments would be small compared to the orbital speed. For empirical support of this idea, consider Saturn.
- Retric 9y agoRing formation has an intermediate dust phase. http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/66-our-solar-system/planets-and-dwarf-planets/saturn/276-why-are-saturn-s-rings-flat-intermediate http://curious.astro.cornell.edu/about-us/66-our-solar-syste... Another consideration the moon does not orbit the earths equator but Uranus, Saturn, and Jupiter's rings do. This suggest tidal forces play a major role and you would not end up with a ring in the same inclination as the Moon's orbit.
- PeterisP 9y agoThe plane change would be just as small or large as the change in orbit, the directions are the same. If a collision is not likely to produce significant plane change, it's also not likely to produce fragments that go to significantly lower orbit to hit Earth; and if a collision is sending some fragments towards earth, then it's sending as many fragments significantly sideways to a different orbit inclination.
- rightisleft 9y agoIf you liked this, you should read the Broken Earth series: https://www.goodreads.com/series/112296-the-broken-earth https://www.goodreads.com/series/112296-the-broken-earth
- Symmetry 9y agoVery nifty, but the fragmentation of bodies wouldn't look anything like in Seveneves or this sim in real life. http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2015/06/seveneves-and-roche-limit.html http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2015/06/seveneves-an...
- mnw21cam 9y agoAgreed. In all likelihood, the seven parts would collide a bit, heat up a lot, and generally lump back together into a new moon. On that scale, the moon is really soft. So much so that each of the seven individual lumps would probably flow into a roughly spherical shape before colliding with anything.
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoRight. What most people don't realize is that at planetary scale (or even at Moon scale) things are fluid. There are no solids at that scale. Gravity dominates all other interactions except gas pressure - and that only for things made mostly of gas. That being said, I would love to see an accurate, 3D, high resolution simulation of the scenario described in Seveneves.
- Symmetry 9y agoIt's not exactly what you wanted but this is pretty close. If I'd run into it earlier I'd have put it in the blog post. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XDZR_gENo8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XDZR_gENo8
- raattgift 9y agoIndeed, and it would be interesting to take a fuller numerical simulation that takes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrostatic_equilibrium https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrostatic_equilibrium into account. Absent enough input energy to push one or more of the fragments onto a new geodesic, to zeroth-order the moon would very quickly recollapse into a hot spherical droplet (likely by way of seven increasingly droplet-like components), and it would take an enormous amount of time for surface features -- like seas and so forth -- and lunar mascons[1] to appear. There's some brief discussion of this sort of thing at https://gizmodo.com/what-if-the-earth-suddenly-turned-flat-1795819464 https://gizmodo.com/what-if-the-earth-suddenly-turned-flat-1... which while it's Gizmodo, is one of the better "What If?"s. Dave Stevenson (Caltech)'s answer is short and sweet. The undistorted body in the Earth-moon pair under either scenario is distant enough that the squashed Earth or the fragmented moon would still source a close approximation of the Schwarzschild metric[2], with an interface between the two as part of the boundary condition of each. Usually for simplicity we'd just describe the motion of the lighter body in the geodesics of the Schwarzschild solution of the heavier body, and the whole moon, its seven fragments, and the fragments' successor arrangements are very likely amenable to that. One could always kick part of the mass of the moon such that it escapes "to infinity" from the Earth-moon system. Unfortunately one would have to recalculate the stress-energy tensor around the residual moon (and around the Earth, and around the sun) and then work out the geodesics. This would make for an entertaining project in numerical relativity. - -- [1] https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/grail/news/grail20121205.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/grail/news/grail20121205.... from https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/grail/main/index.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/grail/main/index.html [2] The Schwarzschild solution is after all an exterior solution, and is fine for approximately spherically symmetric bodies with approximately zero angular momentum. Moreover, if we don't care about ~ microsecond accuracies (and we almost certainly don't, because the conditions at lunar fragmentation are not that finely specified), we can do everything with small corrections to Newtonian gravity (cf. sec 6.4 of http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9783527634569.ch6/summary http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9783527634569.ch6... for the post-Newtonian Kepler solution and ch 8 on relativistic geodesy).
- robterrell 9y agoWow, this is perfectly timed for me. I just read Seveneves last week. Interesting that this simulation results in a "white sky" event half a year after the moon explodes -- in the book this takes a few years.
- delecti 9y agoThe article mentions that he chose to use a larger than accurate size for the simulated earth to speed up the simulation. That suggests that "in real life" it would in fact take longer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seansoutpost 9y agoYou should have used Parambulator to create a more precise model :) Awesome job.
- jjallen 9y agoThis article should come with more of a SPOILER ALERT for a book I would like to read at some point.
- ghaff 9y agoIt's not a spoiler by any meaningful definition of the word.
- jjallen 9y agoIsn't just the title of this Hacker News entry and the connection with the book a massive spoiler? Could argue it got me intrigued, but wondering what Stephenson intended. (I always wonder about not putting spoilers in movie trailers for instance)
- jjallen 9y agoThe linked post literally talks about what happens in the book and says that it's half about orbital-mechanics so not sure how that's not a spoiler
- loeg 9y agoWhere do you think the book is going to go from "the moon blew up?" Orbital mechanics follows logically from the premise. Again, people who have read the book, myself included, are telling you: this is not a spoiler.
- mikestew 9y agoAs one who has not read the book, but very well might, it’s not a spoiler at all. The blurb (and first sentence of the book) says the moon blows up. Well, by golly if there isn’t some discussion of pieces of moon and orbital mechanics, and if those pieces just sit up there and inertly do nothing, that is going to be one hell of a boring book.
- fatbird 9y ago
- jasmcole 9y agoHey, author here. As several of you have noted, there are a lot of tweaks to speed this simulation up - making it 2D increases (unphysically) the collision rate, the particles have overly large collision radii, and the fragmentation threshold is quite soft initially but then quite high for small masses. Regardless, I hope the video is fun - the sudden burst of fragmentation makes for quite the sight.
- sorenjan 9y agoThank you for this and previous articles, your blog is my favorite technical blog online. It's a great mix of technical detail and entertainment, and it's always impressive.
- jasmcole 9y agoThank you, that's very kind. I'd like to post more often, but real life does tend to throw a spanner in the works!
- skizm 9y agoThought you meant you were Neal Stephenson for a second! Quick question: If I haven't read the book, but want to, are there any spoilers in the article?
- aetherson 9y agoThere are spoilers for like the first few chapters, that's it.
- rtkwe 9y agoThere's one bit that could be a pretty big spoiler for the last book too.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- madaxe_again 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- odammit 9y agoIf you don’t get the reference and you like scifi Seveneves is awesome. It’s not hard scifi. I managed to finish it in two days. Super entertaining. Anywho, this visualization is cool to see after reading the book.
- aeorgnoieang 9y ago> It’s not hard scifi. I'd say it's pretty hard sci-fi. What's harder?
- odammit 9y agoThere are fish people. So...?
- aeorgnoieang 9y agoThere are currently mammals living in the water, some people already have webbed feet, the "fish people" had evolved over 5,000 years, and their ancestors may have had access to advanced genetic tech. The book also references epigenetics pretty heavily in that part of the book; presumably that's involved in the evolution of all of the different surviving human groups. It certainly wasn't the hardest science element of the book, but it seems pretty well supported for scifi. That was also one pretty minor element of the book as a whole. I still can't think of another book that's 'harder' scifi (and not also like really-close-near-future).
- ryan606 9y agoLast I read, Ron Howard was involved in producing the movie adaptation. Anyone seen any update on this project recently?
- gasbag 9y agoI haven't heard anything since the announcement. IMDB's last update was in January. It's not just Ron Howard though--it's also a bunch of the people who worked on the Apollo 13 film, which seems like a very good fit. Unlike a lot of folks, I liked the second part of Seveneves, but I won't miss it if they cut it from the film. I don't even know how they'll fit the whole first part in without a 3.5 hour running time.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gus_massa 9y agoNice simulation. But I think that the assumption that all the collisions are elastic is too unrealistic. I expect that adding the inelastic collisions, where two fragments can merge in a bigger fragment, would produce a very different result, where a big chunk (50%?) of the moon is reconstructed and get to a stable almost circular orbit. For comparison: "What Made the Moon? New Ideas Try to Rescue a Troubled Theory" https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-made-the-moon-new-ideas-try-to-rescue-a-troubled-theory-20170802/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-made-the-moon-new-ideas-... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15094302 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15094302 (59 points, 27 days ago, 18 comments)
- CWuestefeld 9y agoThis was my first beef with the book. It seems to me that 1) the forces involved in smashing the big chunks into smaller pieces make the inelastic-ness of this significant, and because of this 2) there would not be the accelerating self-destruction that eventually turns into the white rain. Physics aside, the idea that multiple non-communicating groups, separated for 5000 years, would be able to communicate, is unrealistic. Two friends who are linguistic professors tell me that the idea is preposterous.
- blocked_again 9y agoAm I the only one who gave up reading Seveneves because of pages and pages of complicated orbital mechanics?
- vkou 9y agoNo, I know of other people who did. I was personally bored by those sections, since I already have a good understanding of them - so I skimmed through parts.
- tw1010 9y agoI absolutely loved this blog post. This, incidentally, is the perfect thing to blog about if you're looking for ideas. Just read books and things outside what is normally part of the engineering culture, in the meanwhile keeping all the things you're good at (e.g. mathematical modelling) or interested in in the back of your mind. When you stumble upon the intersection of things you're technically good at and things you read about, do some cool research or write some code and then post it on HN and there you go.
- pault 9y agoI agree, but I don't think Neal Stephenson is outside of engineering culture. :)
- SOLAR_FIELDS 9y agoI was frankly surprised seeing this thread just how popular Stephenson is here. It makes sense though.
- logreybaby 9y agoHas anyone considered that the witches from "The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O." are responsible for the moon's destruction?
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoThat's a hell of an ODEC.
- aeorgnoieang 9y ago> ODEC ?
- Florin_Andrei 9y agoA fictional device in the DODO book. Describing it would be a spoiler.
- aeorgnoieang 9y agoThanks
- seansoutpost 9y agoThey could be on a strand where they figured out how to stop the need for ODECs :)
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> I thoroughly recommend it, as long as you can deal with hundreds of pages of orbital mechanics. You say that as if it's a bad thing.
- cjsuk 9y agoThis is the warning I got when I borrowed someone’s three volumes of Feynman’s lectures in physics except with pages of calculus. It was a wise warning.
- scosman 9y agoBill Gates loves this book: https://www.gatesnotes.com/Books/Seveneves https://www.gatesnotes.com/Books/Seveneves
- tehsauce 9y agoFor anyone interesting in toying with a Barnes-Hut gravity simulator that can handle lots of particles and produce pretty pictures, here's one I made last year for fun. https://github.com/PWhiddy/Nbody-Gravity https://github.com/PWhiddy/Nbody-Gravity Takes about a minute to set up and start generating images and video (mac/linux only, sorry)
- inetsee 9y ago"(mac/linux only, sorry)" Don't be sorry. There's lots of software out there that I am interested in from a quick read of its description, but I have to pass on it because it's either Mac-only, or Windows-only. (And, yes, I am aware of Wine and the existence of some emulators for older versions of the Mac OS.)
- JorgeGT 9y ago> mac/linux only, sorry Don't be. Perfect use case for the Windows Linux Subsystem: https://i.imgur.com/v0b9Nmh.png https://i.imgur.com/v0b9Nmh.png
- Adamantcheese 9y agoNeat! But wouldn't Earth's gravity be affected by all the additional mass from moon-meteorites hitting it? It probably wouldn't be by much, but possibly enough to have an effect on how long it would take before the number of collisions leveled off.
- hodder 9y agoPretty cool work. Thanks for sharing. Articles like this are what makes HN great.
- gasbag 9y agoThis is tangential to the article, but one of the more interesting and less-discussed aspects of Seveneves is the ubiquitous surveillance that everyone is living under. Most characters hardly give it a thought most of the time. The way that this later becomes essentially an epic myth composed of original footage, and how it has tangible effects on subsequent cultures, is kind of fascinating.
- User23 9y agoMore support for the exploding planets hypothesis! https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sumer_anunnaki/esp_sumer_annunaki23.htm https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sumer_anunnaki/esp_sumer_...
- SunTzu9087 9y agoSo... one big thing I recall from the book is the collective collisions turn the world into an enormous ball of fire for decades. If (according to the simulation) the number of collisions tapers off after a couple years, does that mean the world would be habitable again in short order? I understand that, for the purposes of the book's arc, the planet needed to be rendered a literal hell for as long a time as possible... but perpetual burning seemed a bit far-fetched.
- Negative1 9y agoAs a huge fan of Neal Stephenson I found Seveneves to be one of his worst books. Cryptonomicon, Diamond Age, Snow Crash; some of my favorite books so the length of the book has nothing to do with it. The characters were flat, unbelievable and unlikable. The dialogue was weak and awkward. The scenario felt contrived and uninspired (the moon blew up, earth had to evacuate; yep, Cowboy Bebop already set a high bar for this story). I listened to this one in the car (10+ hours for books a week thanks to my drive). Maybe it was a rough week but I had to stop halfway through because it completely lost me. Maybe it gets better but having read the spoilers I really can't imagine how. But hey, your mileage may vary.
- Sophistifunk 9y agoAgreed. To me, it felt like three good books squashed awkwardly into one with jarring leaps forward in time, and entire viewpoints cut out. I also found the third act entirely unsatisfying.
- lttlrck 9y agoI really struggled with it. Over a year I’ve been stalled at the start of the third act. Hearing that others had similar experiences motivates me to give his other novels a chance.
- jsolson 9y agoWith you on this one -- I've got all of his major works in first editions -- Seveneves is the only one I actively disliked. It's probably the only one I'll never read again. Beyond being intensely depressing (near future enough that everyone you know and love dies on the page... horribly), the plot felt about as strongly held together as an average episode of network television, and the characters managed to be both boring and unlikable.
- ergothus 9y agoFirst, spoilers for the first few chapters below, if you care about such things. This (neat!) article and the comments here (so far) miss/skip a few details (or my mind is making fake memories again). 1. Regarding the destruction of Earth - IIRC, while the pounding (and subsequent geological and atmospheric responses) the Earth was to receive was an ELE, the real kick in the teeth was the cumulative heat generated as much of a moon's worth of mass burned up in the atmosphere. 2. Regarding whether the moon would just sit there fragmented or mirror the descriptions of the book - IIRC, the moon didn't just break, it was _broken_ (by what is never known). So whatever thing wielding a massive physics bat did that, it can also impart all sorts of momentum. Pretty easy to say that if you can get the end result from SOME starting conditions, that those starting conditions could have been created by the Deus Ex Machina. I know no orbital physics, but isn't the solar system is a great example of showing how big rocks in orbit become fewer, smaller rocks given enough iterations? So far as I know, asteroids occasionally manage to strike one another (defying the vastness of space by their numbers and persistence) and asteroids can capture smaller bits, but on the whole asteroids are getting smaller, not larger (albeit at a cosmically slow pace). 'Course, I could be wrong. Had an hour long argument with a friend who said that there was no angle that would allow one mass to capture another approaching mass approaching into orbit, while I was relying on my experience of reading of various suspected "captures". After much googling, we decided he was right from a two-body position, but that the Sun ( or other mass) can provide the necessary nudge to turn a swingby into a lasting orbit, so I could be right too.
- ytjohn 9y agoOn barely related note, I immediately thought about Three Moons Over Milford, in which the moon breaks into three chunks and rains meteorites down on the surface. As it turns out the tile comes from Seveneves, which has a similar concept. The TV show focuses on the life of the townspeople, while Seveneves focuses on the science and drama of the exploded moon. Stephenson started working on his book in 2004, completing it in 2013. TMOM came out in 2006. Again, these are two completely different stories with only a common catalyst, but I wonder if the idea for TMOM may have come from someone that knows Stephenson (ie, he mentioned the idea in 2004/5 to someone that ran with it), or if the creators are even aware of the other. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Moons_Over_Milford https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Moons_Over_Milford https://www.nealstephenson.com/seveneves.html https://www.nealstephenson.com/seveneves.html
- bawana 9y agoso how much does this contribute to global warming? no, seriously, how much does temp actually rise and can an equilibrium temp be predicted? Roughly how much of the energy can be accommodated by phase change of the oceans into gas? Once the increased vapor content in the air is calculated, then a predicted greenhouse event can be calculated.
- Anatidae 9y agoWell, shucks. There goes my idea for blowing up the moon next 4th of July. Now, how am I going to out-do the neighbor now?
- mmaunder 9y agoAw! I thought Seveneves was amazing and the orbital mechs made it even better. (Author sounded like it was tedious in the opener) I absolutely LOVE it when a scifi author gets that stuff right and it's great working it through in your head as you absorb the story they're weaving. Really added something to the book. Very much like Arthur C. Clarke's work - stuff that would work that way in real life.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]