6 ms·
Tesla is working with AMD to develop its own A.I. chip for self-driving cars
- faragon 9y agoSo after Tesla hiring Jim Keller -brilliant engineer- from Apple (DEC Alpha 2116421264, AMD K7/x86-64/HypertransportK8/K12/Zen, Apple A4/A5), the cards are on the table: they will play hard for winning the AI race on cars.
- EddieRingle 9y agoActually, Keller went back to AMD after Apple to design Zen. After that is when Tesla hired him.
- senatorobama 9y agoHow much can a great CPU designer help a fundamentally (non-deterministic) AI process?
- zamalek 9y agoAssuming that they want to print TPUs: Optimistically, Tesla could run more elaborate networks. AI being AI means that rarely equates to better decision-making - still, it's an option for the rare cases. Pragmatically, there may be no benefit to the quality of the decisions that the AI makes. It will simply drain less energy and make those decisions faster. Tesla could use the chip themselves to save time and energy on training the AI. Both scenarios depend quite strongly on the quality of the CPU/TPU and don't strongly depend on determinism.
- dragontamer 9y agoEhhh? Computer vision algorithms are hardly non-deterministic. And hell, Neural Networks (which are the best simulation of the "human brain" we've got) are fully deterministic.
- microcolonel 9y agoProbably a whole lot, this guy is probably somewhere near the top of the pareto distribution in a given team. I doubt his abilities are limited to GP CPUs.
- wrinkl3 9y agoThey also had Chris Lattner on board for a while, the guy responsible for llvm and Swift. He quit/got fired after about half-a-year though, citing irreconcilable differences with Musk as the main reason.
- amaks 9y agoInteresting parallel with Intel working with Waymo.
- slg 9y agoIt is interesting that Tesla still maintains that cars sold today will eventually be self driving. That implies the remaining problems are mostly software related. Meanwhile there are still heavily investing in developing new replacement hardware. That continued investment is obviously the right move from a long term business perspective. However if I was a customer it would have me questioning the capability of and their commitment to the current hardware.
- felippee 9y agoThey will deliver some sort of slightly enhanced autopilot that will be able to drive autonomously in few areas and require constant attention in all others, and announce a major victory. If you think level 4 driving AI is just a software problem (particularly with stripped sensor suite lacking a lidar), and that all it will need to run is some year old nvidia drive PX (or equivalent, whatever Tesla is putting into their cars), then you are very naive.
- rdlecler1 9y agoThis could just be a strategic play by Tesla. I’ve heard NVIDIA’s hardware is extremely expensive. If Tesla can commoditize it by helping AMD, then it’ll help their bottom line. Interesting that this announcement stripped $5B off NVIDIA’s market cap, and added about $1B to AMD.
- nullnilvoid 9y agoThis makes little financial sense to me. At Tesla's scale, the cost to commoditize AI chips out-weighs the gains from commodity AI chips as they will not be dirt cheap. Tesla sells less than 100K cars every year. A decent datacenter with AI chips hosts tens of thousands boxes.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoBy your own estimates, Tesla is effectively shipping 2-10 data centers worth of AI hardware a year, with a budget of something like $500M ($5k electronics in 100k cars). Granted, AI is probably more of a $10-50M budget, but... Does it really not make sense to talk to chip houses if you're moving 100k units of special hardware at $50M/year for the foreseeable future, and looking to scale up?
- synaesthesisx 9y agoInteresting considering all Teslas currently come with Nvidia cards (AFAIK)
- mikel205 9y agoAudi and Mercedes have been in partnership with NVIDIA for a year or so now, interesting to see Tesla join up with AMD at this point.
- phkahler 9y agoLisa Lisa Lisa....
- firefoxd 9y agoThere was a correction: > Correction: GlobalFoundries CEO Sanjay Jha mentioned Tesla as an example of a company working with chip fabricators, but did not specifically say that it was a GlobalFoundries customer.
- brentis 9y agoThink this bodes well for AMD’s datacenter aspirations with next gen cloud being heavily AI focused (and GPU)? Also what about Musk’s Neuralink? Https://www.theverge.com/2017/3/27/15077864/elon-musk-neuralink-brain-computer-interface-ai-cyborgs
- deepGem 9y agoI'm surprised that they went with AMD and not an ARM vendor. ARM is pushing into the ML space big time with ARM GPU with even a Caffe fork CaffeALC on the ARM GPU. These GPUs are built with mobility and energy conservation, so these processors are somewhat of a natural fit for TSLA. https://github.com/OAID/caffeOnACL https://github.com/OAID/caffeOnACL