8 ms·
Automotive Grade Linux Platform Debuts on the 2018 Toyota Camry
- mrpippy 9y agoToyota's previous generation of head units (all Entune-branded, started rolling out in 2013/2014) used different hardware platforms and OSes, depending on the supplier. But they all ran a UI that was virtually identical, although there were some very minor differences. The Panasonic-made units ran QNX, Pioneer and Fujitsu Ten units ran Linux. Presumably this means no more QNX.
- subway 9y agoBased on everything I've read about automotive software development, I'm impressed they've managed to degrade the Linux kernel enough to call it Automotive Grade.
- microcolonel 9y agoThey've been making a serious attempt for the last decade or so, Toyota has been doing especially well. The UI is one thing, and it may be a bit gaudy, but the systems have been getting much better.
- BoorishBears 9y agoI found out my car's infotainment system can run HTML/Js/CSS apps. The performance guidelines give you a great hint about the hardware (or lack thereof), they discourage using percentages for example. And have strict versions of Angular 1 and jQuery you're allowed to use
- sircastor 9y agoMazda by chance(?) - I've worked in this space, they're interesting systems. A number of OEMs have explored web stacks as an option for applications. It's very accessible for vendors to work with. Dealing with the system resource limitations is a huge deal.
- BoorishBears 9y agoGM/OnStar's "Next Generation Infotainment" headunits
- phkahler 9y ago>> Based on everything I've read about automotive software development, I'm impressed they've managed to degrade the Linux kernel enough to call it Automotive Grade. It's a different set of people with different constraints.
- Xcelerate 9y agoWell this is interesting. I purchased a 2018 Toyota Camry in August (first ever car purchase), and I absolutely love everything about it except the Toyota Entune 3.0 system. Lack of apps, useless Scout GPS navigation gimmick, and it doesn't even show album cover art while you're driving. When I was comparing cars, the lack of CarPlay was the only (massive) downside with the Camry, but the other features of the car were so good that I went with it in spite of it. I wonder what AGL means for the driver. I would love to tweak the OS myself, but I doubt Toyota would let a customer flash their own version of the code (at least not without violating the warranty). I suppose it could mean more frequent updates with better features. Curious to see how this plays out.
- 0xfeba 9y agoDoes it support Android Auto/CarPlay? I use AA all the time now.
- twblalock 9y agoI'm a happy Prius owner, but I bought mine before CarPlay existed. I'm not sure I would buy another Prius to replace my current one, primarily because of the lack of CarPlay and Android Auto. The Entune interface just isn't very good, and it's not going to get better. This isn't unique to Toyota -- no matter how good the system in your car is, it will seem very outdated after 5 years. In contrast, CarPlay and Android auto are great now and will improve with software updates over time.
- BoorishBears 9y agoThe lack of CarPlay made the Volt vs Prius Prime a pretty easy choice. That... and the design of the Prime, but I digress.
- rothbardrand 9y agoI've been a loyal toyota buyer for over 30 years. But I will not buy another car, unless it has first class CarPlay support. (and it should support the android equivalent as well) Having to interact with the phone while driving is a safety problem and Apple (and presumably android too) delivered a great solution several years ago-- no excuse for not implementing it. Especially given that auto makers really suck at this kind of software. My car has navigation and all the bells and whistles (was not a choice when buying) and I ONLY use it as a bluetooth audio receiver, effectively. IT's just terrible for everything else. I'm drawing a line in the sand here. I will buy a 10 year old used something if I have to and put in an aftermarket CarPlay system. (They're also making it harder to put in aftermarket systems..... ok you going to do that, then you better make yours first class.) I love that with my current toyota when I get in my phone hooks back up and starts playing music, but I hate having to use the phone screen for navigation and the like, since there are no good auto mounts I can find. [1] [1] I have a vent based magnetic one. The magnetic attachment is great, but the vent vanes swing back and forth and its never been quite satisfying... right now if I turn at the right speed the phone swings over and turns off the radio by hitting its button. annoying.
- yial 9y agoAlmost flippant based on the issue with the car mount, I have a 2013 Infiniti g37x, and where the gps/ touch screen is they have a circular dial. If I put my phone over the built in screen, the dial holds it in place perfectly. Better then any mount I’ve owned. Funny how that works out. (I’m agreeing that car mounts suck, and car play is amazing in the cars I’ve been in that have it )
- kalleboo 9y agoOur in-laws car has a screen that flips down to let you put a minidisc(!) in or replace the navigation DVD. That flip-down tray makes for a perfect phone stand.
- rexf 9y agoI agree, my family has a long history of buying Toyotas. I really, really dislike their usage of entune at the expense of just integrating CarPlay + Android Auto. This is an issue that also will cause me to shop non-Toyota.
- interfixus 9y agoCan someone explain to me, honestly, why I would want an 'entertainmaint' system built into my car? I do long commutes, I drive a lot, I am an occasional truck driver, I have crossed Australia east to west more than once - and I still don't get it. My car is the one place in the world where I stand a decent chance of escaping the all-pervading goddamn film and music industry.
- a3n 9y agoAnd for me, my car is almost the only place I listen to music. However, I have never crossed Australia, in either direction.
- rossy 9y ago> My car is the one place in the world where I stand a decent chance of escaping the all-pervading goddamn film and music industry. That's a very odd way of putting it. You do realise that music is not just a marketing platform, but also a very common form of entertainment and medium for artistic expression, right? I'm not sure if you're saying that you don't listen to music at all while you're driving, but if you are, I think you have a very uncommon experience. When I ride in other people's cars, there is almost always music playing, either from a phone connected over bluetooth, a stack of CDs in a CD changer, or just a music radio station. Driving in silence is so uncommon that I'd consider it strange. When I am driving my own car, I often use my long Australian commute as an opportunity to listen to a full album. Given that people do listen to music in cars, and that against better advice, they often fiddle with their non-built-in music playback devices while the car is in motion, an in-car entertainment system with a proper interface goes a long way to prevent distracted driving.
- ams6110 9y agoFor me, I want a good sound system and that's it. No screens, no touch controls, no bluetooth, no internet. Knobs, switches, and analog gauges please. Sadly pretty much no longer available in a new car. So I'll probably never buy another one.
- planteen 9y agoI get it. I drive silent often myself when I am alone.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoThere's an increasing amount of people that won't buy a new car unless it has Android Auto/CarPlay compatibility. To ignore these consumers and think that you have a better solution is ignorant to what's happening around you.
- mrpippy 9y agoExactly. I think this will be Toyota’s last generation of head units without CarPlay/Android Auto, simply because all the competitors now have it, and the complaints will only get louder from here. In particular, when every Toyota reviewed by Consumer Reports lists “no CarPlay” as a negative, and every competitor uses it against them, their current position will become untenable
- martin1975 9y agoHope Entune dies a horrible death real soon now.
- ausjke 9y agoChecked the software stack, it's basically: Yocto(OS framework) + Tizen(application framework) + Genivi(infotainment). Yocto is totally over-engineered and only RTOS vendors really enjoy it as they can sell services on top of that, it's a nightmare for small players, they should just use Buildroot the alternative to save money and time. Tizen has never reached what it wanted to be, partially because of Android. Genivi has been around for a few years but I have yet to see it took any market share on the infotainment side, many infotainment systems are just using Android instead as well. Actually because Camry is using this stack, my next car will certainly not be it. How am I going to upgrade the kernel with patches every few weeks?
- TickleSteve 9y agoAbsolutely... Yocto is definitely massively complex compared to BuildRoot. Yocto is difficult to maintain and inflexible despite attempting to be exactly those things. A prime example of over-engineering. In comparison, BuildRoot uses well-known mechanisms and is much simpler to use as a result.
- sircastor 9y agoGENIVI is an industry consortium to generate software standards. As a group, it does produce the GDP (GENIVI Development Platform, née GENIVI Demo Platform) but it doesn't produce software that actually gets deployed to production vehicles. Software produced by OEMs and vendors may be GENIVI compliant, but it's not a product that would have market share.
- jcelerier 9y agoI don't think that Tizen is used as an application framework. In the HMI architecture document, they mention Qt, HTML5 and JavaFX for apps: https://wiki.automotivelinux.org/_media/eg-ui-graphics/170802_agl_hmi-fw_arch_0_2_4.pdf https://wiki.automotivelinux.org/_media/eg-ui-graphics/17080... the WindowManager spec seems to assume Qt as default: https://wiki.automotivelinux.org/_media/agl-hmi-fw_windowmanager_spec_v0.1.0.pdf https://wiki.automotivelinux.org/_media/agl-hmi-fw_windowman... and most of the UI demos seems to use it too : https://gerrit.automotivelinux.org/gerrit/#/admin/projects/AGL/meta-agl-demo https://gerrit.automotivelinux.org/gerrit/#/admin/projects/A... I could not find apps built with Tizen's native toolkit (EFL).
- t1o5 9y agoAutomotive makers like FCA is still sticking with QNX and Harman made headunits hardware for many years. Having programmed on them, it was a pain with so many constraints while we have watches 100x more powerful than them. While the UI/UX and performance of headunit telematics apps are not the forte of automotive manufacturers, they need to change with times. Headunits are still marketed as an add-on with which the manufacturers can up the price by several thousands. While too much of an entertainment system on a car is a distraction even though they have speed lockouts, a little bit of improvement will be a welcome change. Its not that they should have APIs for CAN Bus access, but can piggy back on CarPlay for a good music & nav system.
- twiddo 9y agoThe thing I hated most about my automotive purchase was the nav. I'm not sure any built-in, eventual bit-rotten nav would be any better though. On the one hand, we can't even get manufacturers of our phones to keep the software on their devices up to date past a couple years and somehow they're our last hope for your in-dash media player? I guess some people jump to a new lease every couple years, but I don't see the mobile model being the future of car ownership. On the other hand, cars have mostly avoided the security disasters of other embedded devices so it might be fine. Unless of course, we make them into the eventual IoT device everyone wants them to be. I mean these software-controlled navs now need to both downloads updated maps and show you engine diagnostics. Doesn't this seem like a bad idea waiting to happen? It sucks that only the low-quality models can escape these devices. Soon it'll be like Smart TVs where your choices are 480x600 or 4K Samsung SpywarePro.patchfix-m2015.
- mark212 9y agoThey all suck. BMW, Ford, Honda, Infiniti are all ones I've had ample experience with over the past year and they're all horrible. I've gone back to headphones and it's glorious (I use maps very rarely, just audio content)
- tw04 9y agoFord supports both Android auto and apple carplay with the latest generation of sync. The interface is extremely responsive to boot. I'm not sure I'd call that horrible.
- post_break 9y agoYeah we've got two fords with Sync 3 and it's fantastic. The fact that I can use my android and gf can use iPhone is amazing. Ford did it right by saying, you want Nav? We've got it but you can also use your phone if you want.
- sircastor 9y agoI absolutely love our 2017 Mini Infotainment system. It's not perfect by any means (It's BMWs), but I find that it meets all my needs, is very fast and responsive. Not sure where you are, but here it's illegal to drive with headphones.
- DKnoll 9y agoEven if it's legal it's a terrible idea.
- InitialLastName 9y agoAs a non-car road user, I'm with you. mark212, please don't do this. You're making the world a more dangerous place for everyone, with (extremely limited) benefits only to yourself.
- sircastor 9y agoInfotainment system developer here, A number of people have mentioned preferring/wanting Android Auto/CarPlay in their infotainment systems, and that it would be preferable to many of the systems that exist in current vehicles. I have a couple of thoughts. The Infotainment system is one of the most user-facing components of the vehicle. It's something that can reflect the brand identity of the vehicle, and most OEMs are not eager to cede that space to Apple or Google. Google and (especially) Apple certainly aren't interested in mixing their branding with a manufacturers. The utilization of AGL doesn't necessarily mean CarPlay or Android Auto are out. AGL is a system, and CP/AA are applications. While I certainly believe there are a lot of terrible systems out there, I also think there are a lot of systems that people don't like because they never took the time to figure out how to use them. Cars aren't like phones. When you're in them, you're most likely driving and you don't have the bandwidth to figure out how to do something as well as drive. A while back I saw a study that concluded if you didn't learn something about your infotainment system in the first 3 days, you never do. I encourage you to actually identify the things you find confusing/frustrating/difficult about your vehicle and write a letter to the manufacturer. Customer input makes a big difference. And no, "It's not CarPlay" doesn't help. That's kind of like sitting down to Windows and complaining to Microsoft that they didn't give you macOS. (Thoughts are my own, of course)
- shmerl 9y agoWe need more Wayland based systems. There is already enough Android around.
- pokstad 9y ago“It’s not CarPlay” absolutely helps. I don’t care if Toyota makes a decent infotainment system. I will not buy a Toyota or Lexus until they come with a CarPlay option. Period. It’s a waste of time to elaborate on that (for free). I would rather save my breath and vote with my money by supporting a car company that does understand my needs (e.g. Honda/Acura).
- mbaha 9y agoSpot on remark. Consumers should be voting with their buying decisions. Markets will eventually correct themselves.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoPersonally, the last thing I want is Silicon Valley engineering at work on my car: I'm happy with the built-in console of my RAV4. It's the most reliable piece of software I've ever ran.
- yitchelle 9y agoHow are these infortainment systems rated for Functional System? Last time I looked (about 7 years ago), Linux was only suitable for QM rated systems, and that was questionable already.
- ianhowson 9y agoThey're not. That side of the car systems is firewalled off because of the tyre fire that is Linux/Android/Internet connectivity.
- b1daly 9y agoThis just reminded me of my personal pet "first world problem." The move from hardware based interfaces to touch screen interfaces is an astonishing regression in usability. Older car "audio" systems could be controlled with simple knob and button interfaces. This would allow the user to fine tune the audio playback, as well as find radio stations, without having to look at the device. Asside from picking the music, and adjusting the volume, my most desired adjustments are to: bass, treble, L/R balance, front/back balance. In my current run of the mill, screen based, "infotainment" system, doing this without endanger myself and others, requires stopping the vehicle, and undertaking a series of awkward and unresponsive controls, none of which are accessed on the same screen! The whole concept of a "touch screen" interface in a car is dubious. Ironically, touch screens require visual attention, due to lack of haptic feedback, and inconsistent UI patterns. If I ever"upgrade" my car audio, I'm going back to an old-school style unit, with an aux plugin.
- phkahler 9y agoTotally agree. My car radio still has 10 station preset buttons that are very easy to access along with next/prev buttons on the steering wheel. My wife care has a touch screen where only 4 stations are shown at a time and you need to push/touch extra to scroll through the list. None of it has dedicated buttons, so it's a lot of looking and poking around. Not appropriate at all for a driver. Exceedingly poor UI design.
- neogodless 9y agoThe worst I've seen for presets is in GM's implementation. You first have to touch a tiny "up" arrow in the bottom right of the screen, and then you have five touch presets along the bottom. Madness!
- virtualized 9y agoFor some reason most people like bad user interfaces by default. They randomly decide on a layout and are immediately too proud to consider anything else.
- 9y ago
- Ice_cream_suit 9y agoI have a Prius C with Toyota's infotainment system. It works fairly well.
- stonewhite 9y agoI think why Toyota is spearheading this AGL is related to its prior software failure related deaths[1], considering broad the scope of AGl: "..advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) and autonomous driving.." [1]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/toyota-unintended-acceleration-has-killed-89/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/toyota-unintended-acceleration-...
- amelius 9y agoReminds me of this joke: [1], which may now become a reality. [1] http://mistupid.com/jokes/msvgm.htm http://mistupid.com/jokes/msvgm.htm
- crb002 9y agoHow is this different than Windriver Linux?
- zguig52 9y agoGot a prius with touch and go, I connect my phone with bluetooth and I can control all my music and phone calls from the steering wheel without having to look to anything. Good job Toyota for supporting open innovation and sharing code with other car manufacturers! I enjoy the way you design car for ecology. Supporting linux is top. I hope they will support userspace apps so end user can also be part of the car innovation!