18 ms·
> Practically speaking, do I need to be able to play phone games from 2009 on my 2017 iPhone? Not really. The problem is not that you can't play phone games fr
by masklinn 9y ago
> Practically speaking, do I need to be able to play phone games from 2009 on my 2017 iPhone? Not really.
The problem is not that you can't play phone games from 2009 on your 2017 iPhone, tying 32b deprecation to a hardware revision would actually have been nice (regardless of the hardware still being able to run in 32b mode).
But that's not what's happening, the problem is that you can't play phone games from 2009 on your 2013~2016 iPhone which had been able to run them right until you updated iOS.
> users (who get some free space back in iOS 11)
"Free space" which they could already have gained back by removing the applications in the first place.
- mikeash 9y agoAnd not only does the upgrade semi-arbitrarily make old apps stop working, it's impossible to go back.
- RKearney 9y agoApple is still signing 10.3.3, so it's not impossible to go back (yet).
- mikeash 9y agoTrue, but that will only last some days or weeks.
- js2 9y agoThe iPhone 5C won't update past iOS 10 so Apple will keep the signed version of that around and you can find 5C's for cheap. I mean if you really want to keep using 2009 apps. (I am not claiming that this is at all a reasonable work-around, just that there is a work-around.)
- mikeash 9y agoThat's a good point. They can be stupid and inconvenient about it, but it's not making this stuff completely inaccessible.
- scarface74 9y agoYou can still download iOS 5 for the original iPad and restore it. The newest version of iTunes still supports the first generation iPod as far as I know. I know it still supports the first generation iPod Touch.
- ohfouroneone 9y agoIt's not that games from 2009 don't run, only games that haven't been updated since 2009 don't run. All a developer needs to do is recompile and push an update.
- _ph_ 9y agoI have a ton of apps no longer supported on iOS 11. They come in 2 main groups: - apps which were abandoned - apps which were replaced by a successor. In the absence of update fees, this is the easiest way to generate new revenue for continuous updates. I am happy to pay for app maintenance, but this scheme means, that there is no automatic data migration from the old to the new apps.
- misnome 9y ago> apps which were replaced by a successor Hello, Omnigraffle. I bought this on iPad, used this something like, three times before having a need to use it over a year later and "Sorry! There is a new version to buy and your version is no longer supported, or runs!". It wasn't cheap, as apps go. Never, ever buying anything from Omni, ever again. Edit: To add details, I bought this for £35 on iOS 7. When iOS 8 came around, it was discontinued, left to crash on open, and you had the "opportunity" to buy version 2 all over again.
- jasonmp85 9y agoThey rightly don't want your "business".
- EpicEng 9y agoWhat do you mean by that? Of course a developer doesn't have to support version X forever, but the damn thing no longer runs at all? This was paid software. I guess OP was renting it for some undisclosed period of time, and you think that's acceptable?
- kbenson 9y agoThat seems wrong. I wonder if you could petition apple for a refund in the case where developers purposefully sunset an app purposefully but for no technical reason (which I understand isn't really what this thread about, nor may not match your situation entirely).
- wlesieutre 9y ago>"Free space" which they could already have gained back by removing the applications in the first place. Were apps previously installed as fat binaries with 64 and 32-bit architectures included, and the 32-bit chunk has now been removed? Or was that already taken care of with the "app thinning" stuff a couple of years ago?
- kccqzy 9y agoThe free space here mostly refers to 32-bit system libraries.
- masklinn 9y ago> Or was that already taken care of with the "app thinning" stuff a couple of years ago? It should have been. And the update only removes 32b applications, not 32/64, if they were not doing so before I doubt they're going to thin fat binaries now.
- cm2187 9y agoIf I have to choose between my beloved Tetris app and iOS 11, I stick to my Tetris app.
- scarface74 9y agoThe problem is not that you can't play phone games from 2009 on your 2017 iPhone, tying 32b deprecation to a hardware revision would actually have been nice (regardless of the hardware still being able to run in 32b mode). The latest processor doesn't support 32 bit code. All 64 bit phones can support the latest OS. Why should Apple waste time, resources, and space on the device to support 32 bit code?
- alien1993 9y agoBackwards compatibility.
- PopsiclePete 9y agoThe bane of everyone's existence. No thanks. I'm glad one company at least isn't willing to do that. I've had it up to here with "Windows XP is good enough for me, make your software run on it" types.
- bartread 9y agoOn the one hand I agree with you: on the other I quite like the fact that relatively large bodies of code I wrote 12 years ago still run unmodified (albeit in Windows desktop apps that have received updates and enhancements since then). Due to these updates I don't know that they would still run on Windows XP but it's nice that the code hasn't needed to change.
- MBCook 9y agoMuch of the code needs nothing more than a recompile. It’s just no one is doing that. To run 32 bit stuff you need copies of all the system libraries. You lose a lot of RAM to that. You have to continue to ensure they don’t have bugs. All for apps that are abandoned. I totally understand what apple is doing. I bet you a ton of those apps were never updated for iPhone 6 screen shizes either.
- 9y ago
- 013a 9y agoI find it hilarious that every time Apple does anything like this, people complain and Apple still sets record sales. You're fundamentally wrong and Apple knows it. They can rip the headphone jack out. They can deprecate 32 bit apps. They can remove TouchID. They can block installing third party apps. Keep complaining; neither they nor their customers care.
- sgift 9y agoYour comment reminds me of a time when the same was said about Microsoft. It will be interesting to see when/if Apple falls the same way MS did.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoI think Apple has a far greater advantage than MS did (if not quite the marketshare, although the markets are different). MS was never seen as 'cool' or an aspirational status symbol like Apple products are.
- sgift 9y agoFair point. I always thought that was mainly due to Steve Jobs, but so far it looks like they're able to stay one without him.
- pjmlp 9y ago> MS was never seen as 'cool' or an aspirational status symbol like Apple products are. Sure it was. In Portugal during the 90's, there were lots of CS students applying to work there. Apple not so much, specially since they were about to close, and except for the Interlog shops in Lisbon, it was almost impossible to get an affordable device in a country where the average salary was about 400 euros on today's money.
- fasquoika 9y ago>if Apple falls the same way MS did Are we thinking of the same MS?
- marban 9y agoSpeaking of games, are there any archival initiatives for a future retro apps scene? Not that I can think of any games that would be worth it — but just for the sake of it.
- pjc50 9y agoOccasionally there are some apps which aren't games: https://www.f150forum.com/f118/ford-abandoning-remote-access-app-382732/ https://www.f150forum.com/f118/ford-abandoning-remote-access... "good luck unlocking your car with abandonware lol" https://twitter.com/SwiftOnSecurity/status/910130130571419648 https://twitter.com/SwiftOnSecurity/status/91013013057141964... Sure, this is Ford's fault in this case, but it means that anything which has a tie-in iOS app needs to either budget for or bill for ongoing updates to make sure it keeps working.
- huxley 9y agoIt's going to be more than an annoyance in some case, but IMO, anything that has processor and access to the internet already needs to budget for ongoing updates to make sure it is secure.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y ago> the problem is that you can't play phone games from 2009 on your 2013~2016 iPhone Devil's advocate: you don't have to install iOS 11 on your four-year-old iPhone.
- masklinn 9y ago> Devil's advocate: you don't have to install iOS 11 on your four-year-old iPhone. That is in fact my plan, but is nonetheless frustrating.
- amelius 9y agoIt only takes one "This app requires iOS11 to run" and there you go.
- scarface74 9y agoThere are very few apps that require the latest OS to run unless they are 64 bit only. Even then, if there is an older version on the app store that was supported by your OS, you will be given the option to download an older version most of the time. I can still download older versions of apps on my first gen iPad that hasn't been supported by iOS since 9/2012.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoThe typical lifetime of an iPhone is so short, I can imagine that Apple will one day save themselves a lot of pain and cost and just limit each iOS release to a single phone / ipad release.
- swift 9y agoThat's not accurate. I keep my iPhones for two years, and when I upgrade I give them to family members who have always gotten another 2-3 years of use out of them. (And Apple has continued to support them during that time with software updates.) It's actually one of the main things that keeps me in the iPhone ecosystem.
- smitherfield 9y agoThe arbitrary removal of 32-bit app support could be thought of as a heuristic to clear away abandonware. Which, for obvious reasons (security), Apple would like to have as little of in its App Store as possible. It also lets them aggressively deprecate and remove legacy APIs going forward.
- joshuas 9y agoYou know. It just occurred due to me, due to your post, how convenient it must be to have every app using your APIs in one place like the app store.
- softawre 9y agoYeah lockin has huge advantages for the company.
- greglindahl 9y agoIt's great for asking "who uses this function" and "how do they use it"? CPAN is used by the perl community to make lists of modules broken by new perl releases. They use this to find how intrusive proposed intentional changes are, as well as to find accidental breakage.
- madeofpalk 9y agoTake it further - they can look at all the apps in their App Store and make decisions like "Okay, lets improve this instruction set in the next ARM processor we make".
- ctdonath 9y agoSomeone was/is tracking "zombie apps"; the percentage of iOS apps that aren't/can't be found is huge, like well over 70%. It's a longstanding practice at Apple. At some point hardware & software are old enough that not only are they not supported, they're pointedly ignored when some appropriate new development "breaks" them. Other platforms garner some favor by supporting ancient software, but I've long seen the subtly crippling consequences of preserving such backwards compatibility.
- EpicEng 9y agoAgreed. On a sort-of-but-not-really-related note, I assume Android specifically because I can run an emulator (SNES, OSX, etc.) on it. If I could do that on iOS I'd jump back over.
- acqq 9y agoIt's not just the games. I've paid some 45 USD for a dictionary which won't work on iOS 11 on the same phone where it worked three years. The developer however wasn't able to renew the license, so he can't make a new version even if he would like to do it.
- MBCook 9y agoIs t only 32 bit? Three years ago we’d already had 64 bit phones for a year. Or is it some kind of API incompatibility?
- acqq 9y agoI've bought the dictionary in 2013 and used on my previous model of iPhone too. My point is that the same phone which run the program for 3 years will stop running it as soon I allow the "upgrade" of the same phone to iOS 11. So I'm motivated to keep running iOS 10 and sacrifice security. Which is bad.
- timbo1642 9y agoThere are TONS of apps that aren't game that haven't been updated or are never going to be updated, but are good or very useful.
- valuearb 9y agoAnd they have been replaced by better, compatible apps.
- scarface74 9y ago"Free space" which they could already have gained back by removing the applications in the first place. It's not the free storage space that is a big deal, it's the freed memory from not having to keep 32 bit and 64 bit dll's in memory. * iPhone which had been able to run them right until you updated iOS.* Every OS update whether they had deprecated 32bit apps or not breaks abandoned apps. Apple also removed support from the Mac years ago for PPC apps that could run on x86 apps up to 10.6.
- clarky07 9y agoConsidering the fix is simply re-compiling, I don't think this is the end of the world. There aren't THAT many apps that are both still very good, and haven't been updated in YEARS. Yes there are some, but not that many.