12 ms·
Florida Power and Light: Regulations for home solar installations
- crististm 9y agoThis seems to be straight from a dystopian movie or book I'm not sure it isn't a joke. Is the "get off my lawn" a thing of the past in US? What business have US gov, or anybody else for that matter, to do with what I do on my property?
- wallace_f 9y agoMost states wont even allow you to collect your own rain water to drink it.
- 24gttghh 9y agoThere only appears to be a single state (Colorado) where collecting rainwater is strictly regulated,[0] and in most states (31) it is not illegal/no regulation/even encouraged. A further 9 states regulate and encourage rainwater collection, and then Texas provides incentives to do so. The remaining 5 states simply have regulations around rainwater collection. [0]https://energy.gov/eere/femp/rainwater-harvesting-regulations-map https://energy.gov/eere/femp/rainwater-harvesting-regulation...
- maxerickson 9y agoThat page even links technical documents about collecting rainwater for household use: https://extension.psu.edu/rainwater-cisterns-design-construction-and-treatment https://extension.psu.edu/rainwater-cisterns-design-construc...
- wallace_f 9y agoThanks for the link. I had come across this link [0], where: >Both Texas and Ohio allow the practice for potable purposes, which is frequently excluded from other states’ laws and regulations Also there it notes most Western states disallow or regulate it. From your link any state that says water rights are regulated, as far as I can tell means water rights exist seperately from property rights, and typically belong to the state. Anyways it is not as bas as I had believed. 0-www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resources/rainwater-harvesting.aspx
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoBecause it screws with the surrounding environment if you do it incorrectly? Sometimes people forget externalities are a thing!
- emodendroket 9y agoWell a lot I'd say, given that your home has to conform to tons of local building codes.
- wallace_f 9y agoI think his point was that it's not a legitimate role of government to interfere in the details of your private life inside your own home, especially when they affect no one else.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, I mean, let's say, for the sake of argument, solar panels had a tendency to burst into flames and cause not only the house they were installed in but also neighboring houses to go up in flames. Would it still be unreasonable to ban them? If not then you've conceded the principle and we're back to arguing about the specifics of each case.
- wallace_f 9y agoAs far as I know the historical justification for legitimate government rule is social contract theory -- hand over some of your rights to protect the remainder of them. There is some debate about how this should play out in the real world. Technically, solar panels, batteries, ovens, etc all can catch on fire and cause my neighbors to as well. Should we ban all of them? Sometimes what we do is to try to protect rights through a heavy handed authority (outlaw something), and sometimes through the court system (sue for damages). Anyways, what seems to be clear is that if there is no potential in one harming another's rights, there's no legitimate reason for government to get involved.
- emodendroket 9y ago> Technically, solar panels, batteries, ovens, etc all can catch on fire and cause my neighbors to as well. Should we ban all of them? Maybe not, but there are lots of regulations on how they have to be made and installed and I think that's quite reasonable. > But I think what we can see here is that if there is no potential in one harming another's rights, there's no legitimate reason for government to get involved. I don't think it's that simple. A lot of things you can do would just be unsafe for the occupants of the home, but since it is likely you are not the only person who will ever live in the home it is harmful to an unwitting next resident if you are doing a bunch of work that is not up to code. And that's before we consider that a lot of work will be done by contractors for people who, let's face it, don't have any idea how to judge whether work is safe. Whether or not this particular regulation is reasonable, I think the government does have a compelling interest in regulating what you do with your home in this way.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe main reference is a page giving guidelines for what sort of equipment is required for connecting a solar system to the grid for net metering. Of course there will be some requirements for that, and most systems that use the grid for "storage" aren't setup to power the house when the grid is down. Thus the system that isn't capable of powering the house without the grid is off when the grid is off. The question of whether one can operate a house with solar+battery when the grid is down is not really answered by the article.
- chris_wot 9y agoHope power prices don't spike too much, or else this law will backfire pretty quickly.
- zeep 9y agoThe hikes already started, apparently: https://flaglerlive.com/102278/fpl-rate-increase-settlement/ https://flaglerlive.com/102278/fpl-rate-increase-settlement/
- binocarlos 9y agoIf this is a joke then it belongs on Reddit /r/jokes - if it's not a joke it belongs on /r/LateStageCapitalism
- sumang 9y agoThis is what happened in Spain too.
- jvannistelrooy 9y agoWhy is it forbidden in Spain?
- emodendroket 9y agoKnowing nothing about the situation in Spain I'm going to guess because power plants see it as a threat to their business.
- loopbit 9y agoIt's not forbidden, but you have to pay extra taxes and there's way more limitations. This gives a bit more background: http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2015/10/spain-approves-sun-tax-discriminates-against-solar-pv.html http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/articles/2015/10/spain-a...
- ndespres 9y agoI'm looking over my balcony in Spain and can see quite a few solar panels! Maybe they are for hot water heaters or something then.
- DiThi 9y agoOnly for installations that are connected to the grid, which pays taxes (the so called "sun tax"). AFAIK installations not connected to the grid are legal and don't have to pay taxes. The difference seems to be that in Florida you can't live in a house that is not connected to the grid.
- denzil_correa 9y agoI'm waiting for someone to justify this with a warped sense of "economics".
- stephen_g 9y agoSo far it's just been technical reasons that would be a problem if pretty much all standards-compliant inverters didn't already have safety features to mitigate them...
- oconnore 9y agoThe article is trying so hard it's hard to tell what the actual issue is. It is dangerous to backfeed the grid -- you may kill the line worker coming to fix a blown transformer or downed line. In some places a grid connection is considered necessary by the building code. If so, you must use proper equipment.
- jackemupguy2 9y agoExactly, my point too. If you back feed, you usually get like 3.5c for each kwh you produce. The only problem is you generally pay 3x that to purchase when you are required to use electricity (et al. cloudy day). The shut-off thing is just common sense "don't kill they neighbor" doctrine.
- mcv 9y agoIt'd still be nice if you could temporarily disconnect in order to power your own home, though.
- Clubber 9y agoYes, it's required for generators too. You have to install some sort of switch (I forgot what it's called) so the house power doesn't feed back into the grid and kill a lineman. The title is very misleading as well. Just goes to show that Fox News and their ilk aren't the only ones who do fake news, it's journalism in general. Also, the title is an outright lie: "Thanks to Lobbying, It's Illegal to Power Your Home with Solar Panels in Florida"
- jsymolon 9y ago> ... have to install some sort of switch ... A qualified electrician installs a "transfer" switch. It's two breakers tied mechanically so that one position feeds the house with line power, flipping it, the other is the generator. I have one to keep my refrigerator, well and furnace running.
- viridian 9y agoDoes anyone actually still believe this? The idea that [journalism I agree with] is fair and [journalism I disagree with] is fake news was dead by last year. I can't think of a single general audience publication that hasn't transitioned to clickbaity, half truth nonsense. I have largely stopped reading the NYT and the WSJ for this reason. I still like the economist, but even they feel like they are slipping at times.
- josteink 9y agoWhen generating emergency power is outlawed, only outlaws will have emergency power. I can't see how anyone would think this was a good idea. I expect respect for the law to plummet faster than you can say "Dad. Can you please give us non-rotten food?"
- spodek 9y agoYou can point fingers and say it was them lobbying, but everyone who didn't do something to act in the opposite direction could have influenced but didn't. I say this not to blame more but to motivate people to take responsibility and to act, to stop people from thinking they're powerless (no pun intended).
- skrebbel 9y agoIn other words, lobbying is great and there should be more of it! I think people here are disappointed not so much in this particular outcome, but the harmful effects of a political system that is nearly entirely fueled by lobby money. I mean, in other countries they call that "corruption".
- addHocker 9y agoOne particular outrageous mob-lob in germany is the driving instructor caste. Basically, the old generations, are allowed to drive everything with there old driving allowances. Now for every generation coming after that, new driving allowances are needed, per various class of vehicle, wether you have a trailer attached and so and and so forth. Its the new kind of mob activity, that uses the law to pressure people into paying for unneeded services and obstruct buisness for new buisnesses.
- spodek 9y ago> In other words, lobbying is great and there should be more of it! I said nothing of the sort. Lobbying is not the only way to influence. How about voting and educating the population for starters?
- jaimex2 9y agook, so its illegal to power your home with solar... but is it illegal to charge a battery with solar in Florida? Powerwalls would still be viable and legal right?
- yardie 9y agoIt's illegal to occupy a house that is not connected to the local power grid. The power wall would effectively be redundant and mostly useless. You have to get your power from the power company.
- gnode 9y agoThe title of this article is quite misleading. It's not saying that it's illegal to have solar panels powering your home, only to have a solar system that does not tie into the grid. Then making it seem that requiring anti-islanding protection is some act of malice.
- sddfd 9y agoI think the title is right in spirit. The law forbids you to use power from your own solar panels if the grid is offline. This is a nonsense requirement. Also the law requires you to use the same inhouse wiring as the grid for power from the solar panels. Why should anyone care about how you wire your own home, as long as your interface with the outside world is according to spec?
- jimktrains2 9y agoThe future buyer of your home would like to ensure the safety and correctness of the wiring. The future buyer also needs to know what the limits of the system are, so that they don't accidentally overload it, and if it is overloaded that it performs appropriately (i.e. stop instead of catching fire). A future buyer may, thinking the house is to code, attempt to connect the house to the grid. If it is not wired appropriately that can also cause risks to the occupants. Future contractors also need to know the set up of the system. Being done differently could possibly very real safety risks. Neighbors would like to ensure that your house does not catch fire, risking their houses.
- JshWright 9y agoFirefighters would like to ensure that your house does not catch fire, risking their lives.
- sddfd 9y agoThe requirement to use the same wiring precludes the home owner from having an additional low-volate wiring in the house. Most modern devices use low voltage nowadays, check what any of the power supply units for your laptop, phone, etc output to the device. Low-volate is less dangerous, and international regulations (IEC 60449) reflect that. I'm not an expert, but it is likely that besides the law discussed here, such wiring would be legal even without approval. It definitely is in Germany, and to say the least, we like regulations.
- d--b 9y agoIsn't it necessary to have the grid as a backup consumer? What happens if you over produce solar energy, but don't have the necessary means to dissipate it?
- nickthemagicman 9y agoI assume there's battery systems in place.
- rahible 9y agoIt looks like FPL has a Net Metering program, which a lot of power companies offer. In short, you get credits on your bill for the power that goes back into the grid. It used to be that some power companies actually write you a check. https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering.html https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering.html
- yardie 9y agoIt's not necessary. If you produce more than you use consistently then a good sized battery bank may be all that you need. A lot of new home appliances are so energy efficient they are starting to see use on sailboats. Solar cells can produce at load. It's not like panels that aren't connected are melting down, like nuclear.
- Filligree 9y agoSolar panels get less efficient as voltage increases, hitting zero at a reasonable point. This is very convenient, since all you need is a buck converter in the battery charger and any unused power can be ignored. The power still exists, of course. It just ends up heating the panels, which are fine with that.
- dom0 9y agoPV panels are not damaged by no-load conditions.
- AtomicOrbital 9y agoI can see an opportunity here for the grid to become owned/operated by the people, not massive corporate greed machines. A house who has excess sells it to neighbors who do not have the solar capacity where neither are connected to the normal grid. Throw some technology into automatically shutting down the generator side every X hours unless its given authorization wirelessly. This foolproofs the root cause of uncontrollable distributed hot lines.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoYou still have the back feed issue. Sooner or later, someone is going to have to do maintenance on that new grid you just created.
- tpxl 9y agoDisconnect the grid on both ends of the issue, fix it, then reconnect?
- Caveman_Coder 9y agoThe problem is that utility company distribution system operators can issue clearances (ensuring a de-energized state) on their systems disconnects, but not on individual home system disconnects. Its not a tough problem to work around though, all the troublemen would have to do is to ensure the line is dead before installing their shorts and grounds, if the line wasn't dead, they'd stop work and figure out which network was backfeeding the line they were trying to work on.
- tpxl 9y agoSorry for the late reply. Since it is completely distributed, you would need to have an ability to disconnect it pretty much everywhere, and as such could disconnect it locally. Eg. if a new house is being connected, disconnect the adjacent houses, install it, then reconnect (assuming a linear grid between the three houses).
- thriftwy 9y agoDo they have the authority to enter your home and check what kind of power you are using? What does it stem from? Can you shoot them for trespass? The same thing WRT rain water which is mentioned in comments. To me it seems like an unreasonable invasion of household borders: trying to regulate something confined in a household.
- criddell 9y agoNo you can't shoot them for trespass.
- JshWright 9y agoFlorida has strong "castle doctrine" and "stand your ground" laws. If you can convince a jury you were afraid, you can do pretty much anything you want on your own property.
- criddell 9y agoI understand that. But if you're so fearful that you think a code inspector is there to harm you, you probably shouldn't be allowed to own a gun. Instead you should seek medical care.
- thriftwy 9y agoWhat if code inspector isn't there to harm you, but you see no reason to allow them on premises? I don't see why one would have to deal with spurious/frivolous visits from officials without their own request.
- criddell 9y agoOh sure, I see what you are saying now. If it's inconvenient the most reasonable course of action is to shoot the inspector.
- 9y ago
- yanivleven 9y agoLobbying should be made illegal
- qazqwert 9y agounbelivable..... fuck them all....
- rb1 9y agoRelated to the website, not specifically the story: http://explosm.net/comics/3557/ http://explosm.net/comics/3557/
- maxerickson 9y agoThe stuff about the bi-directional meter is warblegarble. What the requirement is talking about is operating a grid tie system before FPL upgrades the meter to one that measures in both directions in a way that meets their requirements. This is a sensible requirement, not a ginned up excuse. (all the quotes are coming from a linked grid interconnection guideline https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering/guidelines.html https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering/guidelines.htm... ) I wonder if there is actually any legal requirement to have a grid interconnection. The article isn't real convincing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- todd8 9y agoIn 2015 about 10% of Hawaii's residential customers had solar installations (0.5% is the national average). Such a large intermittent source of electricity caused problems for the utility companies and led to limitation on buying back electricity from these solar installations. Naturally, this has slowed installation of additional residential solar in Hawaii. See [1] and [2]. Hawaii has a goal of 40% renewable by 2030 but they have a number of technical hurdles to get over. [1] http://e360.yale.edu/features/will_new_obstacles_dim_hawaiis_solar_power_surge http://e360.yale.edu/features/will_new_obstacles_dim_hawaiis... [2] http://www.utilitydive.com/news/hawaiian-electric-opens-20-mw-more-grid-supply-rooftop-solar-capacity/440523/ http://www.utilitydive.com/news/hawaiian-electric-opens-20-m...
- martinald 9y agoTBH I think it makes sense that all houses should be connected to the electrical grid. Just like all houses should have proper sanitation facilities. This is a small edge case for people who want to be self sufficient even though it makes no economic sense, as FPL does have net metering in place. If they didn't have net metering in place I'd understand this, but considering they do and at first glance looks like a very reasonable program, is it really worth altering city and state building codes to allow it? The city/state would have to pay for very expensive specialists in off grid solar/battery/inverter setups to ensure they were at parity as a simple grid connection.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- radisb 9y agoIn FL, would it be illegal if I installed solar panels and just charged a large battery, never connecting it to the grid? Is it illegal to even just own a solar panel that is not connected to the grid?
- doitLP 9y agoMore subpar click bait from this website. No references or citations, poorly written and possessing that indignant IFLS attitude.
- doitLP 9y agoMore subpar click bait from this website. No references or citations, poorly written and displaying the standard IFLS indignance.
- microcolonel 9y agoRather, thanks to regulation it is illegal to power your home with solar panels in Florida. Lobbyists are not legislators. That said, power grids are incredibly difficult to coordinate, there is almost no describing it. You need extra installed capacity if some endpoints are also generating stations. Personally I would not really want to backfeed to the grid anyway, so if this regulation applies even when you don't hook up to the grid, that seems pretty ridiculous. Either way it doesn't seem like you'd need laws to keep people from hooking up their panels to the grid, unless they need to cancel out a law that says they must be able to hook up their solar arrays to a grid.
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoIn today's news: USA being USA
- kbutler 9y agoHysterical article is hysterical? The actual laws are more reasonable: "Renewable generator systems connected to the grid without batteries are not a standby power source during an FPL outage. The system must shut down when FPL's grid shuts down in order to prevent dangerous back feed on FPL's grid. This is required to protect FPL employees who may be working on the grid." Note the "without batteries" exclusion a similar exclusion applies to the cutoff switch when the grid is down, to protect line workers. https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering/guidelines.html https://www.fpl.com/clean-energy/net-metering/guidelines.htm...
- ams6110 9y agoIt sounds reasonable but the way to do this is with a device called a transfer switch. It's used on any proper installation of local power such as a home generator. When the utility power is out, the transfer switch cuts over to local power. There is no feedback to the outside power lines; the transfer switch disconnects them. Are home generators illegal also?
- phasetransition 9y agoNote 7 on the same page linked above would seem to set up the guidelines for grid tie switches. The language here appears similar to the way the NEC is written, which can seem confusing unless you use it all the time (as I do). If one had a transfer switch, the renewable generator would no longer be grid tied. The NEC is full of statements of this style, and often without specific references to the underlying section that defines, e.g. the times where a transfer switch is legal. The code expects you to view it as a whole, and be familiar with the interlocking sections.
- philplckthun 9y agoSeems like requiring such a switch would have been a more reasonable regulation in this case. Isn't this already legally required in other countries, when feeding power back into the grid? > Are home generators illegal also? If the quote is accurate then they are not: "Renewable generator systems". So why does it make a difference to law makers? This sounds utterly bonkers
- xenophonf 9y agoIn Africa we've built small home/lab/datacenter power systems that charge a battery bank off utility mains plus on-site generation. It's basically a gigantic UPS that can automatically switch among a variety of power inputs. What's stopping someone from building something like that here in the U.S.? Charge batteries from solar, supplement with mains power, maybe even add a diesel generator for extreme emergencies, and use an automatic transfer switch to prevent backfeeding the utility mains (which is super dangerous to line workers and probably the reason for Florida's regulation). Not being a power systems guy myself, I don't see where the flaws in such a design are. Any EEs out there who care to comment?
- chiph 9y agoIf the system is technically correct (won't back-feed power into the network because it has a transfer switch) it's a licensing and regulatory issue. In this case, Florida Power & Light objects to systems like this and won't certify them.
- turbohedgehog 9y agoThis reddit comment thread [1] explains the issue well. In short: most households get grid-tied solar power setups with no batteries. If the main grid is off, it creates islands of power where the units can't safely backfeed to the grid. However, you can legally get a battery setup which costs more money and use that when the grid is down. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/70oz3k/due_to_excessive_lobbying_from_fpl_florida/dn55emr/?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/70oz3k/due_to_e...
- jackemupguy2 9y agoWait ... all that is says is that if you back feed into the grid, that you have to have a system shut-off. That's common in all southern states as far as I know? It's basically to protect utility workers that are working on electricity in the area so they don't kill themselves. It makes perfect sense and they have the ability to come in and turn your power off, naturally when doing so. Am I missing something?
- veryrad 9y agoI work in the solar industry and can confirm that this is standard safety practice in my state as well. When grid power goes down the inverter is required to shutdown and remain off until a few minutes after normal grid conditions are restored. This is to ensure that the grid equipment is actually de-energized so it can be worked on safely. It's such a ubiquitous policy that all inverters need to be UL Certified to prove that they do this. Utility companies pull a lot of bullshit, but this policy is actually pretty sound. If you want to use your PV as backup power, you need to treat is as you would a conventional backup generator and install a manual transfer switch that that isolates disconnects the electrical service as the backup power is engaged. This can nearly double the cost of the solar project, so most people don't do it.
- addHocker 9y agoNot conspirancid related - but a real problem. If there is a fire, solar panels produce power while preventing water from reaching the roof - and electrocute fireman. How to solve?
- mapmap 9y agoAs part of install there is typically a diagram added to the fuse box or inverter showing how to switch generation off.
- addHocker 9y agoThe generation is not switched off - in fact the generation is not off-switchable- that is the problem. You can break the circuit, but on any connection of source and ground - it still shortens- so if the solar plates shater due to heat stress and connect with dirty water ...
- phasetransition 9y agoSince the original, hyperbolic article is no longer linked, This post is to give some technical background on home electrical systems in the US for understanding of the underlying considerations of how secondary home power sources should operate. First two points of context: 1. The United States does not have a uniform electrical code, but instead has a document called the National Electrical Code (NEC) published regularly by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) as NFPA 70. The most current version of the code is from 2017. Looking inside out, the NEC stops at the main electrical service input to e.g. a house, and from that point a different code, called the NESC, takes over. 2. There are a wide range of variants of the NEC that are codified to force of law throughout the United States. And states/cities/municipalities can exempt and/or add to their preferred version. Here inside City of Atlanta boundary, for instance, we are on the 2014 version of the code. But even then there are different versions of the code in force at different locations in the multiplex. --- With the caveats that not everything below is 100% uniform everywhere in the US, here is how wiring in US homes generally works. There's a few steps here, but it should all make sense: A. There is a stepdown transformer with a "center tapped" secondary configuration. The end result of this is that homes are fed with two energized conductors ("hots") and a "grounded" conductor colloquially referred to as the "neutral." The two energized conductors are 240 Vrms apart, and each energized connector is 120 Vrms to the neutral (i.e. grounded conductor). Hold the idea that these three wires terminate on the incoming side of the main panel for items B, C, and D. B. The wall outlet in a typical US house, colloquially called an "Edison" receptacle has three conductors. Those are an energized conductor (hot) the grounded conductor (neutral), and the "Equipment Grounding Conductor" (EGC). The latter is a green wire commonly referred to as "ground." Under normal conditions the EGC (ground) carries no current, because it is not a part of the electrical circuit between hot (energized) and neutral (grounded) connectors. C. Now imagine that you have a wiring problem inside your table saw, and as a result the outer surface of that saw becomes energized. That surface is "bonded," i.e. conductively connected, to the EGC (ground). So if the surface has suddenly has a voltage on it, a large current then flows back through the EGC to the main panel. This is because the EGC is a low resistance path. This sudden surge in current causes the OCPD (i.e. "circuit breaker") to open. This disconnects the energized conductor (hot) feeding the table saw. D. At the main panel, and only at the main panel, the EGC (ground) is connected (bonded) to the neutral (grounded conductor). This is so that the current from the EGC has a return path. In this case it goes equipment fault -> EGC -> EGC to neutral bond in main panel -> neutral coming into main panel from street -> center tap of secondary on the outside pole transformer. The winding of the utility pole secondary then completes the circuit with low resistance, insuring the OCPD (breaker) opens. E. Note that neither the main panel "grounding/earthing," technically called the "grounding electrode conductor (GEC), nor any similar grounding/earthing (i.e. connection to physical earth) of the center tapped neutral at the utility pole play a role in the low impedance path for current that opens the circuit breaker. In fact, the earth is specifically excluded as a "ground fault current return" path by NEC 250.4(A)(5). F. Any utility is concerned with essentially two things when it comes to secondary power at the house: 1)Feeding electricity back to the grid while their workers are making repairs/upgrades. 2)maintaining a singular low impedance "ground fault current return" path in the home at the main panel electrical service entrance. G. Point F is why there are subtleties about what can be tied to the grid, and how the secondary "renewable generator" must behave in the event that it is exclusively providing power while the utilities' transformer is physically disconnected from the residence at the service entrance. --- Beyond points F and G are lots of subtleties around sub panels, secondary current return paths, GFCIs, "floating neutral" generators, transfer switches, ground field impedances, etc. It is a surprisingly big topic, but I'm happy to try to answer specific questions.
- smndelphi 9y agoYou have to design the system correctly so it does not backfeed grid. https://goo.gl/iw8f8w https://goo.gl/iw8f8w Look at the marketecture from solar edge. You can add in a generator with a automatic transfer switch. They also highlight a scenario with existing PV and a separate grid tie inverter.
- smndelphi 9y agoYou need to design system correctly. Look at literature from solar edge. You could also add generator with automatic transfer switch. Also, you can modify existing system. https://goo.gl/iw8f8w https://goo.gl/iw8f8w