30 ms·
GNU Taler
- jabot 9y agoI was at the presentation at SHA 2017. The demo was nice, even though i did not understand any of the crypto. Although, to be fair, i didn't even try :-) One important take away for me was that this project aims to replace paypal, not bitcoin. Its target is to establish an open source payment infrastructure that is better than paying with credit cards, paypal, etc...
- anentropic 9y agoThis sounds awesome if it works and takes off
- jabot 9y agoYes, I would like to have some working open source micropayment system. However, as far as i can see there is no bank offering a backend yet. Hopefully that will change soon. It would have been great if the taler system had been usable at SHA 2017. We had to use weird, cheap and easily falsifiable plastic coins at the food court. Using taler instead would have been a really great tech demo...
- StudentStuff 9y agoI keep hearing about Taler from a friend of mine, but there hasn't been much adoption among banks or credit unions, limiting its usefulness. The banking sector in the US is a mosaic of banks and credit unions running a wide variety of debit networks, with ACH vaguely tying them all together. I wish it was easier to move money between banks here, seems like the quickest way is to write a check!
- throwanem 9y agoACH is quicker but much less secure, because the initiator has to have the recipient's account number and bank routing number, which also suffice to initiate wire withdrawals that do not require confirmation to complete and can't easily (if at all) be clawed back.
- StudentStuff 9y agoThe average person doesn't have access to an ACH console though, and most banks & credit unions offer local transfers only, with "Bill Pay" that is just them mailing checks out for you. ACH is essentially for businesses only currently.
- colanderman 9y agoA few years back I was able to configure payments for my Citizens' Bank credit card from a non-Citizens' checking account without any verification. Needless to say I was livid and contacted their customer service, who were basically like "yup that's how it works". (I closed my account with them soon thereafter. Citizens' is awful for other reasons.)
- snuxoll 9y agoMost (if not all) of the major banks and some credit unions have joined Zele (formerly clearXchange) [1] to handle person-to-person transfers. Only since the rebrand has it been obvious that each banks person-to-person service is part of a multi-bank network, but I've been using it to pay my landlady since I moved into my house last May (money is transferred instantly, so there's no worry about timing a check with bill pay's slowness - and she never gets a piece of paper with my account information on it either). It's taken forever, but I'm hopeful with the big banks getting onboard Zele for person-to-person payments we may see something similar to the push-based systems other countries have for making everyday transactions online someday. [1] https://www.zellepay.com/ https://www.zellepay.com/
- StudentStuff 9y agoThere is also Popmoney, which seems to have a few dozen more Credit Unions (though no BECU :c), they also have the big banks.
- diggernet 9y agoHow does Zelle compare to Venmo on things like fraud protection and customer service? (I imagine simply not being owned by PayPal is a real good start.)
- pjmlp 9y agoUau, checks are still in use?!
- StudentStuff 9y agoYep, checks are very common, its how most people pay rent, larger bills, etc in the USA. Credit Unions and Banks here offer "Bill Pay", which is just them mailing out a check on your behalf. Cash is popular here too, many of the grocers I work with see 40% to 60% of their revenue in cash, though that market segment has discouraged check use (with the exception of Costco).
- pjmlp 9y agoIn most European countries checks are not trusted anymore by common business, given the usual fraud schemes, and in some banks you need to jump through a few hoops to get them (only crossed or pre-validated). Digital payments have replaced the majority of checks.
- elliottcarlson 9y agoIt depends on the trust relationship -- stores will not accept checks from customers most of the time anymore, however as the parent said, rent and utilities are still often paid via check as there is an established relationship between the payer and payee.
- maxerickson 9y agoNational retailers mostly accept checks; they just treat them as debit card transactions though, scanning the numbers and printing the check for the customer, even handing it back to the customer after it is accepted. I guess it isn't even limited to national retailers, the independent grocer here does it too, I guess because it is worthwhile for them to pay for it.
- snuxoll 9y ago
- TomK32 9y agoSEPA, guaranteed wire transfers over night and in November this year a payment under 15000€ will happen in 10s (ten seconds!). Not even Bitcoin can do that anymore with transactions taking more and more time (or fees). If the US gov would put some weight behind it, the US could easily catch up.
- nannal 9y ago>transactions taking more and more time Bitcoin blocks will always be ~10 minutes, if you pay the fee to get into the next block, it'll be 10 minutes until your payment is confirmed, before that, all the nodes will announce it anyway so 0 conf is much faster.
- shpx 9y agoAlthough bitcoin aims to generate a block every 10 minutes, in practice it usually takes longer than that. As I'm writing this, the last block[0] took 30 minutes to mine (sometimes it spikes to hours though[1]). Most importantly, a transaction needs[2] to be confirmed 4-6 times[3] meaning it should be 4-6 blocks in the past, so you're looking at a 1-2 hour transaction time. On top of that, if you want to pay less than a certain transaction fee[4] (right now it's $1.62[5]) you probably won't get into the next block, see https://bitcoinfees.github.io https://bitcoinfees.github.io. Recall that 1 block = 20 minutes and add that on top of the confirmation time. [0] https://blockchain.info/block/0000000000000000005f0e639f66af0e85c767bfd5cb75cf3fd1ebe8557c68f6 https://blockchain.info/block/0000000000000000005f0e639f66af... look at the Timestamps of this block and the Previous Block [1] https://blockchain.info/charts/avg-confirmation-time?timespan=1year https://blockchain.info/charts/avg-confirmation-time?timespa... [2] https://youtu.be/bBC-nXj3Ng4?t=18m41s https://youtu.be/bBC-nXj3Ng4?t=18m41s [3] https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf page 8 [4] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Transaction_fees https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Transaction_fees [5] https://bitcoinfees.21.co/ https://bitcoinfees.21.co/ (a satoshi is 0.00000001 BTC, 10,000 satoshi is 40 cents right now) https://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin-is-Worse-is-Better https://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin-is-Worse-is-Better
- joosters 9y agoIt's impossible to know how much to pay to get into the next block. If there's 10 payments waiting to get into the next block and there's only space for 9, there's no way they are all going into the block, regardless of their fees. Users don't want to play a complicated expensive, impossible to win game in order to get their payments processed in a known timeframe.
- fcbrooklyn 9y agoOnce upon a time, a friend of mine needed to repay me for a loan of about $1000. Since we both banked at HSBC, we figured walking into the bank together might be a simple way to do that. Nope. I had opened my hsbc account online, he had opened his account in person. Therefore we may as well have been two separate banks, apparently. After debating the sanity of this system with a bank manager (whose fault it clearly was not), I noticed a big sign on their ATM. It said "Now accepting cash deposits!". I asked the guy if there was a limit on the size of those deposits. There was. I can't remember how much, but it was in the neighborhood of five grand I think. My friend took a withdrawal in cash. He handed me the money. I walked over to the machine and deposited it. Makes sense if you look at it sideways.
- loeg 9y agoThere are also checks for that kind of thing.
- scott_karana 9y agoCheques don't typically clear immediately (to crudely attempt to prevent overdraft/double spending attempts) and can have a cost associated with their purchase.
- rmc 9y agoCheques are uncommon in Europe now-a-days.
- fcbrooklyn 9y agoThey take five days to clear, however.
- asveikau 9y agoAbout ten years ago I moved from New York State to Washington State. I wanted a bank account that would follow me and Chase had not yet bought WaMu so I went to BoA in NY, opened an account, moved my money into it. I arrived in Seattle and at the BoA branch there they said they didn't recognize BoA of New York. I couldn't deposit into the WA branch. I could write myself a check and it would be processed with the reduced speed of a check from an out of state bank.
- raggi 9y agoBringing agpl into a banks systems would cause lots of fears. Adoption there is unlikely.
- peterbotond 9y agoI read "vaguely tying them together" as "usually it works, sometimes not". This latter is my experience. Electronic transfers enjoy a certain priority also, direct deposit, wire transfer, cash or check deposit at atm or branch are all different for different banks. In other words, it is a vague description when things clear. Some banks are better to their customers some are not so much. I live in the US. An improvement is most certainly welcome and appreciated.
- littlestymaar 9y ago> One important take away for me was that this project aims to replace paypal, not bitcoin. Its target is to establish an open source payment infrastructure that is better than paying with credit cards, paypal, etc... Well actually if you read the initial paper from Satoshi Nakamoto, bitcoin was invented as a replacement for paypal, not money : > Commerce on the Internet has come to rely almost exclusively on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties to process electronic payment [1] But bitcoin became really popular among the libertarian movement which hated the Fed and other central banks because they saw them as threats to freedom, and now people mostly think about bitcoin as a replacement for money. [1] : https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
- kome 9y agoThat's would be an awesome alternative to PayPal. I wish them luck. Edit: btw, we really need a public and free payment system, why are we giving to paypal and credit cards this incredible privilege? Paying with digital cash should be as inexpensive as paying with real cash.
- mavhc 9y agoBecause the credit/debit card systems are horribly insecure and we need to pay them so they can pay people who were scammed
- fiatjaf 9y agoAre you serious? Do you think "we should", really? Have you ever considered the problems and probably impossibility in achieving what you want?
- cyphar 9y agoTFA sort of proves that it is theoretically possible. But I believe that mints in the Taler model can take a flat fee to pay for server costs and so on.
- jabot 9y agoOn the other hand, it's not like handling physical cash is free, really. Think about time spent counting, ensuring that there are no falsified notes, bringing excess notes to the bank and making sure there is change, etc. I think it is quite feasible to create an electronic payment system that has comparable overhead. Consider that there are existing electronic payment systems, e.g. electronic cash in europe, that already work and are quite secure (being smartcard-based)
- fiatjaf 9y agoI didn't say that. I've just said that it is not possible to have an "open" web payments standard. Someone has to maintain it and link it to the real world money. The only way besides having centralized for-profit organizations maintaining the payments infrastructure is to use cryptocurrencies.
- jerguismi 9y ago"Once the wallet is charged, payments on websites take only one click, are never falsely rejected by fraud detection and do not pose any risk of phishing or identity theft." Pretty bold claims. Anyone can give ELI5 how it works? Merchant needs a bank account, customer needs to load funds to the wallet... Sounds quite traditional to me. Either these people are geniuses or they don't know what they are doing.
- Geee 9y agoHow does this compare to the upcoming Payment Request API?
- FloDo 9y agoOnce the Payment Handler API [1] is completed and implemented in browsers and browser extensions can register themselves as payment handlers, GNU Taler could be used through the Payment Request API. [1] https://www.w3.org/TR/payment-handler/ https://www.w3.org/TR/payment-handler/
- secstate 9y agoAs I understand it, PR-API is a glue for current payment methods. So your browser would simply contain a hash that is connected to a payment method (i.e. a credit card). It's effectively like Stripe built in to your browser. Before you use it you need to put in a payment method. GNU Taler, however, is a payment method. It federates with other financial institutions to allow you to make online purchases without using credit cards. In the SHA2017 demo, they keep saying "it's like cash" and that's very close to accurate. The one difference is that payment recipients are forced to keep a paper trail of what money they've received (not from whom, but just that it was received). So in that sense it's almost better than cash in that it's more transparent for tax purposes, but maintains the anonymity of cash for the buyer.
- zdkl 9y agoI seem to remember that the Cannabis industry in the US was having difficulty establishing banking relations with reputable firms. They could be a good start for this project to see usage given the open source philosophy that might resonate with some dispensaries and the friction with traditional payment processors. Users of those commerces wouldn't be too hostile to the alternative payment option I'd imagine, and maybe with the combination of INRIA & GNU pedigree, backend relations would be less risky for the "real finance" interface.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anoother 9y agoIs this an official GNU project?
- mikegerwitz 9y agoYes. https://www.gnu.org/software/ https://www.gnu.org/software/
- jordigh 9y agoI think the official terminology is that there is only one GNU project with many GNU packages, of which Taler, gcc, and Gnome are: just a package.
- schoen 9y agoThat terminology doesn't seem to be used very consistently, even by project maintainers: https://duckduckgo.com/?q="is+an+official+gnu+project" https://duckduckgo.com/?q="is+an+official+gnu+project"
- mattl 9y agoYeah, typically "part of the GNU project"
- mikegerwitz 9y agoIt varies, even internally. Officially, yes, it's "package". "GNU Project" (capital "P") refers to GNU itself. "Project foo is part of GNU" is also common. "A GNU project" isn't uncommon informally. On Savannah, they're "projects". The maintainers guide uses both---you can tell what was written early on, possibly by rms, vs. changes that happened later on.
- misil 9y agoThis sounds a lot like the Ripple network. Or is there a substantial technological difference?
- ireflect 9y agoAgreed. The architecture diagram [1] describes a flow that is identical to how a user on Ripple buys IOUs from a gateway, trades or spends them with other users, and how a receiver redeems them with the gateway for the original currency. Ripple captured my attention for years, but its backing company has taken it in a direction of commercial adoption which is good for them, but antithetical to the applications I was excited about. If GNU Taler is going to revive that vision, then that's really exciting! [1] https://taler.net/en/architecture.html https://taler.net/en/architecture.html
- oniony 9y agoGNU are quite famous for their graphic design skills.
- kelvin0 9y agoI hate to admit it, but I do think their ideas and projects would gain wider adoption if they packaged them in a more visually appealing way. I do like the minimalist style, however the logo could use some work. PS: I am a programmer, not a designer.
- mikegerwitz 9y agoMany GNU hackers simply don't have those skills. I don't. Someone should offer their time/skills.
- flashdance 9y agoSome FOSS projects put a lot of work into UX, which is really great! Compare two implementations of OStatus-compatible social networks: GNU-Social and Mastodon. GNU-social: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/8a/GNU_social_web_frontend_with_Swedish_localization.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/8a/GNU_soci... Mastodon: http://wikigeek.co/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/mastodon.png http://wikigeek.co/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/mastodon.png Mastodon is a lot better for the average joe, but the important piece from this is that its predecessors, GNU-social and StatusNet, helped show that this sort of application can work--and I'm sure the development of Mastodon was easier because many of its challenges were solved already by other free software projects. The neat thing about all these social networks is that they're federated, which means a user on mastodon can send a message to someone using gnu-social or pump.io and vice versa. That's the magic of free software!
- mattl 9y agoThe https://github.com/hannesmannerheim/neo-quitter https://github.com/hannesmannerheim/neo-quitter theme is quite popular for GNU social, on sites like https://quitter.se https://quitter.se
- kbutler 9y ago> Private When you pay with Taler, your identity does not have to be revealed. Just like payments in cash, nobody else can track how you spent your electronic money. However, you obtain a legally valid proof of payment. > The exact details of the underlying contract that was signed between customer and merchant. However, this information would typically not include the identity of the customer. IRS: The term “money laundering” refers to the activities and financial transactions that are undertaken specifically to hide the true source of the money. https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/overview-money-laundering https://www.irs.gov/compliance/criminal-investigation/overvi... Am I missing something? [I see by the downvotes this is an unpopular perspective, but I can't see how Taler's claims "Taler is not suitable for illegal activities" and "Taler prevents tax evasion and money laundering" are justifiable. It seems ideally designed for money laundering as defined by the IRS - "hiding the source of the money". Please explain it to me (ELI5)]
- TeMPOraL 9y agoMy guess? Tax evasion is a different problem from money laundering, and Taler seems to care about the former, not the latter. Whether this turns into a legal obstacle for adoption remains to be seen.
- kbutler 9y ago"Taler prevents tax evasion and money laundering." https://taler.net/en/merchants.html https://taler.net/en/merchants.html I just don't see how they can claim that and claim to hide the payer identity.
- jimktrains2 9y agoHow is this different from cash? Money laundering is about intent, not means of payment.
- kbutler 9y agoIt is very similar to cash in that it is an anonymous means of payment. However, Taler tries to legitimize the transfer and explicitly claims "Taler is not suitable for illegal activities." https://taler.net/en/index.html https://taler.net/en/index.html But by hiding the source of funds, it seems eminently suitable for illegal activities. Putting a (partially) legitimate business as front to process illegal profits is a textbook money laundering structure.
- Y_Y 9y ago"the wallet's balance must be charged in the desired currency" I wonder if this was written by someone from Central Europe. This use of the word charge is no good in English because it's a heteronym - it can mean to add money or take it!
- fermuch 9y agoWhat would be the correct word for only adding?
- madez 9y agoEnglish has many heteronyms. I think that property is horrible and should be avoided whenever possible. Why is it accepted by english-speaking people?
- CNJ765 9y ago'I think that property is horrible' Spotted the commie! Also nice lowkey proof of your point :D
- jasonkostempski 9y agoI think it's common to use "(re)charge" when adding credits to something like a Steam wallet. This feels like that type of transaction.
- jiri 9y agoIn EU it is really trivial and very cheap, fast and safe to transfer payments between individual bank accounts and business bank accounts. It would be really hard to further simplify it.
- jordigh 9y agoFor me, the allure of bitcoin and any other newer payment transfers systems is to be able to get rid of the "In $somelocation" clause. I want internet money to be as universal as email.
- jabot 9y agoPlease take a look at the demo they have set up. They show an example micro payment system as browser plugin, where you pay for reading articles. I am excited at the prospect of paying for articles without spying adware and coin-mining javascript. Back to your point: Even in the EU paypal has still users, because it is still easier to use than SEPA - transactions.
- Kliment 9y agoI like that prospect too, but many media companies have proven to be scummy enough with their malvertising and tracking that they're likely to add micropayments and keep their spy/adware. A recent example is German television switching to a new digital terrestrial transmission format, whereupon the commercial (ad-ridden) channels now require a yearly subscription to watch, but have kept the ads. The enabling technology was the possibility to encrypt said channels in the new format, and they, of course, jumped on it, pocketing the extra money but keeping all their ads.
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago10x times better than the US? Maybe yes - but not cheap and fast enough for micropayments.
- criddell 9y agoWhy do micropayments need to be fast? Seems like exactly the kind of thing that could be held on to and batch processed.
- perpetualcrayon 9y agowith extremely low transaction costs Does anyone here happen to know what the pricing structure is?
- runeks 9y agoThe system is open, thus payment processors are in competition to provide the lowest fees possible. This is, in my opinion, one of the important reasons why a payment system needs to be open: competition forces fees to be as low as realistically possible.
- archagon 9y agoNeat! I'm of the opinion that journalism, open source development, etc. would be much closer to self-sustaining if only users had the option of dropping a quarter in the hat — performing a one-click micropayment — when visiting a webpage. I'm not likely to subscribe to the NYT, but I'd gladly pay 25 cents after reading a great article if it didn't require entering CC info and bouncing between three different webpages. Unfortunately, this would require immense coordination between web standards, browsers, OS vendors, and banks to implement. Taler sounds like it's targeting a similar use case; I hope it sees wide adoption so that at least the idea could be tested at scale! (Sadly, with most traffic coming from mobile these days, I'm not sure how well the wallet concept would play with iOS's closed ecosystem. Is it against the App Store guidelines to release a wallet-type extension? Sigh, I miss the days when hacky tech like Napster and BitTorrent would set the world on fire without anyone having to gatekeep...)
- throwawayjava 9y ago> but I'd gladly pay 25 cents after reading a great article if it didn't require entering CC info and bouncing between three different webpages... Unfortunately, this would require immense coordination between web standards, browsers, OS vendors, and banks to implement If you're okay with customers choosing to make piece-work payments after consuming the material, the problem becomes much easier because micro-payments don't have to be instantaneous or binding. All you need is a not-terribly-insecure ledger that the consumer has full read/write access to, and approves of every month (perhaps implicitly for bills under $X). This removes a lot of the security/trust/coordination issues -- an 90% solution is good enough if you just double-check with the consumer before doing anything actually important. Similar to the proposal here: https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/17/the-learned-helplessness-of-equifax/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/09/17/the-learned-helplessness-o... Micro-payments made by browser software (sim. SSNs) become spam-reducing mechanisms rather than trusted tokens. Of course, this doesn't work if you want true micro-payments; i.e., where the consumer pays for access to the material, instead of making a piece-work contribution after having already consumed the material.
- mst 9y agoAnd american signature-less swipe transactions and now the contactless sub-30-quid payment thing in .uk seem to make it pretty clear that below a certain amount, consumers really don't give a shit about explicitly approving things.
- nabla9 9y agoSuccess of payment system is extremely dependent on the network effect. The value for users comes from the ubiquity of the payment system. Nobody wants to transfer money into the wallet for infrequent or one time buys. They seem to have the right idea and might get the implementation just right, but if they can't get the momentum, it's all for nothing. I really hope this takes off.
- fsavard 9y agoThat's what I don't get. Publishers have all the incentive to get behind a solution like this, but somehow I never see a "send a tip" or Flattr button anywhere (maybe I'm not looking?). I just wish a bunch of well-known publishers would get together and agree on _one_ solution that they'd all add to their site. It's just a matter of adding a widget on their article pages. They already have large readership. It could kick things off and maybe get over that network effect cold-start issue. They could add a nice bounty like "make a first payment and don't see ads on our site for a month". Or similar. A solution like this could be a good candidate because it's neutral. With Flattr or similar you're encouraging that particular middleman. However I think to inspire confidence in publishers they'd need to prove that this solution will have strong support for years to come (which is always unsure with open source projects). EDIT: To be clear I'm mostly thinking of micropayments to news sites. The strategy is less clear when talking about electronic commerce in general.
- s73ver_ 9y agoIn the future, perhaps it would be useful to put what the thing actually is in the title. Just "GNU Taler" doesn't tell me anything about what something is, other than it's a GNU project.
- fusiongyro 9y agoUsually if you editorialize the title of the link submission the mods will reset it to the title of the page.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI can understand why, but would saying "GNU Taler is blah blah" really editorializing? As long as you aren't embellishing?
- teddyh 9y agoYes, the mods have been known to reset it anyway. It’s too bad, really.
- mst 9y agoI would hope "GNU Taler (one-click cash payments)" would've survived because it took a subtitle from the page rather than editorialising. I sincerely doubt you can draw an accurate line for what's editorialising and what isn't though and I think I'd prefer the mods to continue to err on the side of "nope" simply because I think the failure modes are less annoying overall. But it's always going to be a trade-off.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI think a blanket "nope" stance is too harsh, and leaves no room for nuance. It also assumes that the mods are not intelligent people.
- 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yarrel 9y agoNext: GNU Privacy Guard implements the Clipper Chip algorithm. Why did GNU accept this state surveillance system as a project?
- Aeolun 9y agoI think this suffers from the same issue that I have with a lot of crypto/magic currencies. It isn't immediately clear to me why I'd want to use it. They could advertise it as: 'Pay online, without Paypal!' and a big 'Sign Up' button, and it would do more for me than anything their current page does. Having GNU in the name doesn't really help either, as I associate it with nobody adopting the thing whatsoever.
- rekado 9y ago> They could advertise it as: 'Pay online, without Paypal!' and a big 'Sign Up' button, and it would do more for me than anything their current page does. Taler requires banks to cooperate, so "signing up" doesn't make any sense in this context. Taler support would have to be offered by the bank; a user doesn't sign up for Taler --- they just need to use the Taler wallet extension. > Having GNU in the name doesn't really help either, as I associate it with nobody adopting the thing whatsoever. Now you're just insulting. (I'm also a GNU hacker.)
- Aeolun 9y ago>> Having GNU in the name doesn't really help either, as I associate it with nobody adopting the thing whatsoever. >Now you're just insulting. (I'm also a GNU hacker.) I see how it can be taken that way. But I can't really help my impression of the name.