8 ms·
To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously bulk up savings
- hugh3 16y agoThis article needs to be printed everywhere, at all times. I have no idea how some of the people I see every day are going to save up the $1.5 million (in today's money) they'll need to retire. Half of 'em can't even pay off their credit card bills every month.
- jsz0 16y agoMy retirement strategy is to die young. If I start making a lot more money or my cost of living magically decreases over the next decade I might reconsider this but otherwise I don't think social security is going to provide any quality standard of living. If I can't continue to work (which I don't mind doing) I plan to check out. (sad but true)
- cageface 16y agoThinking the same thing here. If I'm not able to work I'm not sure how able I'll be to enjoy much else anyway. This whole model of slaving away your healthy years in the hope you'll still have the savings and the strength to enjoy life after 70 seems like a scam to me. My plan is to work less each year but keep on working. This isn't so bad if you do work you enjoy.
- superk 16y agoLearn Spanish and move to South America.
- jarek 16y ago... then watch the previously low cost of living skyrocket as everyone does this and brings their money with them.
- nostrademons 16y agoThis actually works wonderfully if he buys up a lot of property. When everybody moves in and brings their money with them, land values shoot through the roof, and the people who owned that land make out like bandits. Folks who owned small orchards in Silicon Valley in the 1950s made out like bandits (assuming they managed it well), as did people who bought humble ranch-houses in the Boston suburbs in 50s and 60s. He could be the Astor of Curaçao!
- hugh3 16y agoWow, that's actually a really tempting idea. (Starts making plans to buy up half of Buenos Aires.)
- forinti 16y agoBig cities in developing countries are expensive too. A better idea would be to find some beach property in South America; the continent is developing and getting older as well, so lots of people are retiring to the sea-side (as I said, big cities are expensive). In the south of Brazil you won't find many bargains left, but I've read that lots os europeans are buying houses in the northeast (the infrastructure is a lot worse there, but it's 3.000km closer to Europe).
- yardie 16y agoAsk the cubans that were forced to leave how much they got for their land. One of the things that people take for vantage and dont realize is the stability of the US government. I'm not saying that mexico is on course for collapse but the police have lost control of the north border
- forinti 16y agoI think the US needs to seriously start rethinking its system. What's the use of being so rich if you need to contemplate retiring to another country or dying early after you stop working? Please look at Europe and Canada. They have their problems, sure, but they take care of their old and sick. And they do it with less money!
- mrtron 16y agoIf you are poor and old in Canada, you will not get the quality of life you want from the public system alone. You will get the medical care you need, and won't go without food, shelter and basic care.
- piramida 16y agoYour understanding of life and things never changed before? Recall your beliefs 10 years ago. Now imagine 30 years passed - there is a very good chance that your desire to live will be strong. You will be miserably calling your current selfish self "an idiot" for not saving up while trying to meet ends on the government money. No offense really, but some people can't extrapolate their own personality even 5 years ahead. Trust me, you will change with age, everybody does. Hopefully it won't be too late to start saving then...
- jsz0 16y agoI'm open minded about the future. I think the problem for people my age (30-ish) is that the entire time we've been working real wages are flat or negative. We've never had a chance to get ahead of the game. I make more money than most of my friends, lots of them have student loans to deal with too, and it's hard to project a way to save even $200k-$300k over the next 30 years. Of course I could cut my expenses, move into a cheaper place, eat lots of ramen, but that's just choosing to live poor now instead of later. So for now I'm making the choice to be poor later.
- steveklabnik 16y agoYep, this is it. I have at least two friends from college that have spent over a year trying to find work. "Defeated" doesn't even begin to properly describe how they feel.
- heresy 16y agoSo true :) My present self is cursing my 20s self for having spent a load of time traveling and running up lifestyle inflation debts, basically boozing it up non-stop. On the other hand, I have some really good experiences and memories. But I've been incredibly focused on reducing debt and building equity for the past year or so, and I don't see that changing. I'm just glad I woke up while I still have 35 years to repair the damage, I have my health, live in a country with affordable healthcare, etc.
- mechanical_fish 16y agoOkay, it takes effort to make me suspend my rule against politics on HN, but I have my limits. If you are some kind of troll, I nominate you for an Academy Award. First: Social security is solvent, it will be solvent for years, and to fix it will require a minor tax increase decades from now. Quit believing propaganda. Second: Our future budgetary problems are nonetheless real. But they are all about health care. If you really want to worry about balancing budgets in 2040, worry about that. Social Security is fine and will continue to be fine unless somebody deliberately fucks it up. (By talking like a fatalist, as you do, you inadvertently help the cause of the people who are trying to fuck it up; that is why we are having this little chat.) Third: The major problem in the USA today is that we have a massive excess of productive capacity. Not only can the country afford to feed, clothe, house, and entertain you quite nicely, but our biggest problem is that after we did this we might still have too much capacity. The economy is not well designed for such a situation, and it needs fixing. (Aside: The fix is called "stimulus", literally known as "printing money". People won't spend money? Make them spend it now. Create new money and give it away; make the old money move by threatening to inflate it away in the future. That nobody in power understands this, or that they pretend not to, is an epic failure of education and/or governance; the consequence will be millions of impoverishments and, likely, early deaths, perhaps even your own. Tragedy sucks.) To the extent that the country does not choose to feed, clothe, house, and entertain you and everyone around you, it is a problem of government, economics, and politics. It is not that we are physically incapable. It is that we are not so organized. The solution is to organize. Where will "the money" come from? Money is not a physical thing, like platinum. It's some numbers in a spreadsheet by which we keep score: If your number is higher, you get to control more about what the economy does. If you wake up and discover that all the money belongs to a handful of people who have gamed the ruleset by which money is distributed, and that they are failing to use their giant pile of money to direct the economy to keep everyone else fed, clothed, housed, and entertained to the correct extent: You change the rules, or you stop playing the game. By many orders of magnitude, the best option is to change the rules. Or, rather, to change one rule, to turn one knob that was designed to be turned: Raise taxes on the people with the money. That anyone contemplates suicide rather than go down fighting for this simple rule change is a triumph of modern propaganda. Get up out of the fetal position and be an American, for the love of all that is holy.
- mdwrigh2 16y agoI think the basic answer is they won't, which is a sad sad answer.
- _delirium 16y agoI don't think it has to be all bad. The article is talking about people saving enough money to live purely off their savings for 30+ years without working, which seems like a kind of silly goal. Why would someone spend something like half of their adult lives not working? At that age, I expect I'll either have enough presence of mind that I'll be doing some sort of work (even if reduced), or else I'll be senile/decrepit, in which case I definitely hope I don't drag out my end for 30 years. The idea of planning for 30 years of complete idleness seems crazy. Rather than retiring at a specific fixed age, it makes more sense to me to retire at a specific time-til-death or health status: say, when you're down to 10 years of life expectancy, or too sick to work, whichever comes first. Actually I think 65 was probably chosen because it was once roughly the age where those things were true.
- mdwrigh2 16y agoWhile this is true, I think my answer still stands even if you plan on retirement for only 10 years. It doesn't really matter, they don't have enough income to live how they're living now, let alone having extra to support themselves once they are no longer working.
- axod 16y agodoes everyone want to retire...ever? I'd say that especially the types of people who hang out here would get completely bored stiff if they did ever retire. The work we do (programming etc) can be done into your 80s,90s,etc. Sure, people will probably want to slow down a bit, and when sight starts failing etc but it's not like we're sportsmen or builders or anything strenuous.
- sabat 16y agoI want to retire in only one sense: I don't want to worry about money, and I want to be free to go do stuff. Anything.
- icey 16y agoI want to "retire" so that I can work on things that i think are interesting without having to figure out how to monetize them.
- axod 16y agofiguring out how to monetize things is interesting ;) But I do see your point.
- mbrubeck 16y agoMy 80- to 90-year-old relatives are in nursing homes with failing minds and bodies. That will happen to almost all of us eventually, and your quality of life then depends on paying for quality care. No matter how much you love your work, there will probably come a time when you need to support yourself from savings, not salary.
- _delirium 16y agoI suppose it's not legal in most places, but I think if I reached an extent of failing mind where I was unable to do any sort of productive work, even part-time, I'd take the euthanasia option. What's the point of just sitting around senile in a nursing home for years on end? I do still agree some significant savings are needed, e.g. for the case where your mind is still reasonably good, but you need physical assistance. But this article is talking about thirty years of living off savings! I definitely do not want to live thirty years of my life in which I'm completely unable to do anything but sit in a nursing home living off my savings.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoBut that's sort of the point. I don't have a problem with this article which is largely good advice but I think it's useless. Everyone knows what he's saying is true yet people aren't saving. As someone whose friends are predominantly in their 20s I can tell you people generally give 2 excuses... 1. "One of these startups will eventually work and I know I'll cash out on at least 1 big IPO before I retire so it doesn't matter" 2. "I don't know anyone whose saved for retirement and the average american household owes 20% more than they make. So the Government will have to do something and even if I don't have enough money I'll be taken care of" So the bottom line is people are in denial and you can print this article up and tape it to their heads and it still isn't going to fix that problem
- gaius 16y ago3. If I do save, it will all be taxed off me to pay for those who didn't. Here in the UK, the last government started levying a tax on the pension funds, and the present government hasn't revoked it. So people who have guaranteed pensions paid for by the taxpayer, out of tax revenues, are doing so off the backs of those in the private sector who save for their retirement. It disgusts me.
- waqf 16y agoOne can make this "off the backs" argument about any tax. Why is the tax you describe worse than other taxes, or isn't it?
- gaius 16y agoYes, it is worse. Already private sector workers know, despite record levels of NI, we cannot expect the State to look after us in our retirement. To tax us further to secure the votes of the unionized public sector is the worst sort of political cynicism.
- _delirium 16y ago$1.5m is a bit high for the average case. The median household income in the United States today is about $50k, so if you estimate 80% of your income for retirement, that's $40k. The conditional life expectancy of a 65-year-old is ~17 yrs, and inching up very slowly, so maybe will be 20 years in a few decades. So that's $800k in today's money, modulo investments. And that's assuming zero contribution from social security. Even if social security gets chopped at some point, I don't expect it to go all the way to $0; people working today and paying in will probably get some payout. Even if it's only $10k/yr, that reduces the needed savings to $600k. Granted, most people don't have anywhere near $600k either, so it might be arguing between whether they need to save infinity or 2*infinity more than they currently are.
- JoachimSchipper 16y agoYes, but your math only works if you don't exceed the life expectancy... if you want to be reasonably sure to have money into your 90s, you'll need more.
- qw 16y agoYou also have to factor in the risk of deceases and injuries. You may have to be forced into early retirement.
- slantyyz 16y agoA good start is to not live beyond your means. Having consumer debt that you can't pay off every month is going to put you in a deep, deep hole.
- exit 16y agosuppose everyone did the exact opposite. they saved like crazy and only spent enough to survive. then the economy collapses for lack of consumption, no!? something seems deeply wrong here.
- nostrademons 16y agoYou've hit upon the most important and possibly most overlooked point in macroeconomics. At the level of the whole economy, modulo things like inventory, there's no way for aggregate savings to be anything other than aggregate consumption + investment. Every good or service is produced by someone and consumed by someone else. If you don't have both parties, there's no transaction. When you "save" money, it's essentially a claim check against someone else's income. It's a way of recording that you contributed more than your fair share to the economy this time, so at some time in the future, you have the right to consume more than your fair share. If everybody contributes more than their fair share, who's using up the excess? And then if they all go to cash in their claim checks at the same time - say, when the baby boomers retire - who'll produce the goods and services needed to satisfy those claim checks?
- ShardPhoenix 16y agoI haven't implemented this myself (yet), but perhaps the solution (for an individual) is to store value through scare resources (eg gold and other precious metals, maybe land) rather than through money (ie stored labour).
- nostrademons 16y agoIt still has the same problem: the price of gold goes up as everyone purchases claim checks denominated in it, and then crashes as everyone tries to cash out those claim checks for the goods and services they need to live. The real solution is to store value in resources that increase the productive capacity tomorrow, so that when everyone tries to cash out their claim checks tomorrow, there will still be enough goods to satisfy them all. In other words, investment. The problem is that an investment is only a good investment when it increases the productive capacity for something that people actually want tomorrow. It does no good for everyone to invest in houses when they really need health care upon cashing out those claim checks. And there are often technological barriers that prevent dollar investments from being productive. You can pump all the money into biotech research that you want, but you're still not going to get a cure for cancer until someone actually cures cancer. Innovation has a random element that isn't always amenable to throwing money at the problem. People often wonder why the U.S. economy did so well after WW2, compared to the Depression before and the 1970s malaise afterwards. IMHO, it was because the large amount of pure scientific research undertaken during the war created a large stockpile of fundamental scientific breakthroughs that were ready to be exploited. All the hard, risky parts of innovation were already done, funded by the War Department, and so companies could readily transform surplus cash into innovations that made people's lives better in the future.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- TomOfTTB 16y agoFirst some advice you should take: Check out Bob Brinker (http://www.bobbrinker.com/portfolio.asp http://www.bobbrinker.com/portfolio.asp) I don't worry about retirement because when I was 19 years old and working in the valley I happened to catch his radio show when he said to pull out of the market. It saved me $20,000 that's still working for me today. (The 10 year numbers might look low right now but keep in mind the Dow was DOWN 14% in that same time frame) Second some advice that's based on my semi-educated opinion: 401(k) is a scam for anyone under 50. Yes your employer might match it but even the risky portfolio of a 401(k) is usually very conservative and the guy running it usually isn't the firm's star (no one ever got rich managing a 401(k) accounts). If you're over 50 and can't afford to lose the money than go with that but if you have some time I personally think it's better to take a little risk and hopefully get a bigger reward.
- brown9-2 16y agoIt's great that you were able to save $20,000 and miss out on a market decline, but why does this mean you no longer need to worry? If anything, you should take this "win" and continue to build upon it. For most people, there is no point where you've saved "enough" - more is always a good idea. Second some advice that's based on my semi-educated opinion: 401(k) is a scam for anyone under 50. This is why conventional advice is to only contribute as much to your 401(k) as to receive the employer's matching contribution, which is essentially free money. The rest of your retirement savings which you want to invest should go into an IRA, which allows you to control what exactly it is invested in.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoI didn't say I stopped investing but I don't have to worry because even if I don't make any more than the return I'm making now (in the worst economy on record) I'll still be making more in interest than I should be taking out (if I use around the average amount that retired people need per year).
- gcheong 16y agoThe big advantage of 401k is that it is a tax deferred account which can be a good amount depending on your tax bracket. Also they don't have to be limited to just a small number of funds, some companies also provide the option to invest on your own( if this is not an option at you company, have a chat with the person running the benefit plan) and if you leave you can roll it over to a rollover IRA at any broker you want. Finally, if your company does provide a match, that is money you are essentially throwing away for what is usually a very small percentage of your salary.
- sachinag 16y agoMy startup is working on exactly this problem. Our customer development reinforces that people - of all ages - know intellectually that they're supposed to save. But they have no idea how to start, or if they've started, if they're actually on track to have a decent retirement. You can request an invite for our preview at http://www.blueleaf.com http://www.blueleaf.com and shoot me an e-mail to sachin@blueleaf.com with HN in the subject and I'll make sure you get in before we launch. If there are any pony requests - "someone should really do [x]" - I'd love those too, even if you're not interested in our preview.
- mattculbreth 16y agoSo this is cool, looks like a great app. Will it be as a service only, or will you offer customers the chance to buy the software and run it on their own hardware? I for one am leery of giving out all of my financial data.
- sachinag 16y agoWebapp only for the foreseeable future. The security/privacy is something we've spent a lot of time and effort on. (Our CTO is a crypto by trade with a focus on financial applications: http://www.eecs.harvard.edu/~cat/ http://www.eecs.harvard.edu/~cat/ ) Thanks!
- cat 16y agoMint.com has millions of users who have provided that information. That said, in the medium to long term we're working on a unique solution that will permit you to keep your usernames and passwords only on your local computer while keeping the less sensitive data (transaction history, balances, etc.) on our servers.
- theycallmemorty 16y agoDoes your service work with Non-American (Canadian in my case) financial institutions?
- marknutter 16y agoWhat if you don't plan to retire? If you're making money doing something you love (in my case, web development), why would you ever need to retire? To rest? To do all the things you've always meant to do but didn't make time for when you were younger? To see the world? I'd rather do that stuff while I'm young; learn a new language in my spare time now, start that band now, travel to foreign countries now - hell, I can do my work there if I need to. I think retiring makes sense for people slogging it out 40 hours a week at jobs they hate, but it doesn't make sense for those of us who actually find our work fulfilling.
- swilliams 16y agoThat's fine. This article is aimed at the vast majority of office workers that live paycheck to paycheck, and have no idea what they're in for.
- hop 16y agoWeb development may not be around in 20-40 years, certainly not in the way it's done today. That said, I'm sure that type of technical ability will be in demand, you may have to learn some new things.
- marknutter 16y agoWell, I think the internet will be around in 20-40 years, and if you're not constantly learning new skills then you're dead in the water anyways. I just don't see retirement as the goal.
- jbhelms 16y agoI'm with you on this except I want to own the company, not work for it.I see nothing wrong with working until you die, it's the working for someone else till you die that bothers me
- jarek 16y agoI don't really see that much of a difference. Working "for yourself" just means you deal with clients directly. You still have to work to make other people happy before you can be happy. They will only pay you as much as they need to, and collect the benefits your work brings them. True, working harder or better lets you have more enjoyable work or earn more. On the other hand, when working for others, working harder or better earns you promotions or allows you to change jobs or employers to more enjoyable or better paying. Where exactly is the difference?
- vaksel 16y agofrankly I think retiring in the U.S. just won't be a viable option for many people...the cost of living is just too high. I mean think about it....to retire properly, you need to pretty much put away all your spare money for decades. What I think will happen, is people will just start retiring to other countries where the cost of living is so small, that you can live comfortably on 10-15K a year.
- iron_ball 16y agoI've heard that Costa Rica has a thriving American retiree community for exactly that reason.
- telemachos 16y agoCosta Rica is safer and more stable than many other countries in the region, but even so, it's not just Costa Rica. Mexico, Panama, Nicaragua and many other Latin American countries are apparently seeing more and more US retirees. Top two hits from a pretty naive Google search: http://www.ehow.com/about_5488519_places-retire-latin-america.html http://www.ehow.com/about_5488519_places-retire-latin-americ... http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/RetirementandWills/RetireInStyle/TheWorldsBestKeptRetirementSecret.aspx http://articles.moneycentral.msn.com/RetirementandWills/Reti...
- jacquesm 16y agoWhich in the longer term will drive up the cost of living in Costa Rica.
- gcheong 16y agoPerhaps in 20 years the US will be that country.
- code_duck 16y agoNot without dramatic social upheaval. Imagine going through a deflationary period where it makes economic sense to walk away from every single mortgage in the US? I don't think I'll be interested in living here right then.
- watmough 16y agoBasically, if you're not either a Wall St trader, or in a government retirement plan, or a company owner, then you're screwed. Quote from the article: "In other words, if you have saved just $25,000 -- and remember, that describes about half of all workers -- you are less than 2 percent of the way toward your goal. Your future definitely doesn't include cable." My situation is that I have diligently saved 12-14% of everything I've ever earned, in the 12 years I've been in the US, into a 401K. Sadly in those twelve years, I've endured 2% mutual fund fees and two market crashes, all of which hit my savings pretty hard. In fact, I lost money after inflation is taken into account. So at 42, I basically need to build something I can sell and assure myself of some income over a reasonable time period. In my case as an engineer, I need to build a software company. I also need to stay healthy, live as cheaply as possible, and shed as many expenses as possible once I get nearer to retirement. Boat or RV living looks like a great way to do that. Certainly paying the fixed costs of a house or apartment is going to be a killer for those on a small income.
- brown9-2 16y agoI am not a financial advisor, but don't put everything into a 401k. Only put the minimum required to get your employer's matching contribution (if anything). But the rest of your intended retirement savings into an IRA, where you can completely control what your money is invested in. Hell you are probably better off putting a bunch of money into an index fund that tracks the S&P500 and paying less expenses than the 401k funds do, for the same or better performance. Make sure you are still saving a sizeable amount of money in a traditional, FDIC backed savings account, for emergencies.
- aspiringsensei 16y agoI am not a financial advisor, but I am a personal finance writer. This is well intentioned, but too reductive. All 401(K)/403(B) plans are not the same. Mine is managed by the vanguard and has microscopic fees. Similarly, all investors are not the same. I don't think it's necessarily sane to sock money into an S&P 500 index fund, especially one that's capitalization weighted. As much as it sucks to say this...the best way to deal with your finances is to get an advisor. A lot of them are leeches, but good ones exist. The emergency fund idea is a great one though. I'm partial to keeping 3 months of expenses in cash and another 9 months in highly liquid, low volatility securities.
- jarek 16y agoI realize this probably won't be the most popular of opinions around places like this one, but the more I think about it, the more I conclude that leaving everyone to individually save for their own retirement is not the best of ideas. There are far too many variables in the system for most people to navigate successfully for 40 years straight, even if they are earnestly trying. You could have an extemely well diversified portfolio and still lose money when The Market as a whole tanks as a result of bad decisions of other people. You could have money saved up in multiple savings accounts or bonds and be out of luck when a government you didn't vote for fucks up and causes a period of hyperinflation. I'm not even mentioning things utterly out of individual control like a war resulting from an invasion by an aggressive, more powerful neighbour. Implementation details such as retirement age are very important, of course, but a from mile-high view, providing a decent if not extraordinary living standard to millions of people seems exactly like the type of infrastructure and public good projects governments are normally the best option for. /jarek, who nevertheless has more private savings right now than "a quarter of those surveyed"
- mattmcknight 16y agoBut many of those same factors affect public pensions. The existence of defined benefit schemes, as opposed to defined contribution schemes, itself causes economic problems, including the bankruptcy of large firms. While there is risk in any investment, defined benefit simply imagines that it doesn't exist. Even traditional Ponzi scheme style public pensions are susceptible to drops in population growth.
- thrill 16y agoAny plan that is not fully funded, in cash, is not a pension - it's a bet - a bet that someone (else), somewhere, sometime, will assume the risk if it goes south. Those who offer "public" pensions are the worst offenders - everyone knows the taxpayer will be on the hook for it - it's easy to promise the world to a public employee when it's not coming out of a bottom line.
- jarek 16y ago
- bluedanieru 16y agoYes save that money and watch it disappear down the rat-hole the next time some Too-Big-To-Fail bank decides to raid whatever fund you've put it all in. He's right, of course, that younger people need to save more because institutions are failing all around us. Too bad he neglects that second part...
- motters 16y agoA lot of things are likely to change over the next few decades, so I wouldn't bank on retiring in the same way that people have done in recent history. The whole notion of retirement is actually quite a modern concept, which really only arose within the last century (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retirement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retirement). There's going to be more automation which will mean that people can work for longer, and I suspect that the whole notion of what it means to "work" will change.
- exit 16y ago> There's going to be more automation which will mean that people can work for longer, and I suspect that the whole notion of what it means to "work" will change. why doesn't automation eliminate the need for work?
- motters 16y agoAutomation has greatly reduced the amount of agricultural work, and jobs today which we regard as central to the economy are also likely to be eventually automated. Probably what constitutes "work" will change, and things we regard as recreational today may become "work".
- mrtron 16y agoMy grandmother is in her 90s and mentally she is at 100%. She gets around a little slower now. That is a scary thought for some. She retired in her 50s!
- mseebach 16y agoThe whole thing gets a bit less scary if you decide to retire at 75, rather than 65, which is not a problem if you take care of yourself, and don't have a physically demanding job (which most of us don't). You need 1/3 less money and have ten years longer to get it.
- MikeCapone 16y agoYou might not have a choice, though. Better be prepared for other scenarios (bad health, etc).
- diN0bot 16y agothe hardest part for me to truly believe, since i'm currently in my 20s and enjoy work, is that i'll have to retire. is it true that when i get old i won't be able to program/manage or find some kind of reasonably enjoyable and sustainable employment? will my flaws, such as physical and possibly memory constraints, out weigh my virtures, such as experience and knowledge? there's so much unknown to getting old and i am so confident and able right now. do i really need to be scared of old age?
- known 16y agoI think globalization and internet will saturate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_dream http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_dream
- exit 16y agoi don't understand what you're saying.
- code_duck 16y agoMaybe someone needs to start paying those under-40 workers what they're worth. Perhaps salary increases should be considered annually in context of ACTUAL cost of living increases, not fairy tale inflation figures? Well, executives are having no problem hanging onto their savings. Actually, oh - they're hanging on to our savings. Maybe it will start trickling down soon!
- Flemlord 16y ago$1.5M is a ridiculously high target. If you retire at age 60, you have a 20 year life expectancy (males) and 24 years for females. With $1.5M you can spend $50k a year for thirty years without even factoring in continued earnings on that money or $20k/year in social security payments. Once you do factor those in, you'll die with more than the $1.5M you started with in retirement funds.
- tjogin 16y agoRight, and you'd have to save over three thousand dollars, every single month, for forty years, to reach that goal.
- thomaspaine 16y agoThis math is grossly oversimplified...you're assuming zero interest. I'm on a train and can't do the math right now, but compounding interest + other variables like employer 401k contributions, tax shelters, etc make a huge difference when doing this calculation.
- heresy 16y agoInterest rates won't hover near 0% forever. Getting returns of 2% a year, drops that down to $1300/month. Still steep for most people, but much more achievable, and 2% return is pretty conservative. Of course you would not save for your retirement using a savings account.
- seltzered 16y agoMy plan is one mentioned on NPR several years ago: retire, but work part-time at a grocery store that has insurance benefits.
- gaius 16y agoAll these clever plans fall apart when everyone does them. What are the barriers to entry to working part time in a grocery store? What makes you think you can compete with a teenager who wants that job?
- seltzered 16y agofair enough. I'd still like to do some job that is more socially involved and keeps me standing up every day, and talking to people. We have a fairly wealthy guy in his sixties who decided to work as a manager just to have something to do every day. Along with that my similarly-aged pension-era parents are starting a business for the first time. My point is that retirement isn't a requirement for living your older years. If anything retirement is more of a nascent American concept.
- _delirium 16y agoI agree everyone can't do it, but it does seem to be pretty common already, so quite a few people are doing it. Go to a grocery store at, say, 10am on a weekday during the school year, and the cashiers are mostly old (at least around here).
- exit 16y agodoesn't this problem reduce to the availability of labour? i'd like to see a thorough accounting of how much labour is required to maintain: our food supply, our residential properties, basic services, etc. and i'd like to see that compared to current price of these things, to see if they make any sense. it makes no sense to me that as we've progressed technologically, it seems to have become increasingly difficult to survive.
- nostrademons 16y agoA lot of this has to do with marginal value. The cost of basic survival has gone way down - but in the process, it's freed up a lot of disposable income, so people build bigger, better, and yet less efficient ways of doing things to soak up that extra money. Health care's perhaps the biggest example. A hundred years ago, millions of children died in infancy from things like measles, whooping cough, polio, etc. Now this has been wiped out by vaccines that cost maybe a day's salary for a parent (and cost the manufacturer probably pennies to make). Same with antibiotics. The money all gets spent on the other end of life. We now have the technology to keep patients who would've died within the hour alive for months in an ICU. That costs millions, and doesn't work all the time. But when it does - how can you put a price on that? What price is there on a father being able to see his kids grow up, or a grandparent being able to meet their grandchildren? The same goes for many other areas. We can build 1200-square-feet houses pretty cheaply. But why bother, when there's some family that's willing to pay over $1M for that 5000-square-feet McMansion? I think a lot of the problem is that American culture is so damned competitive. It's not enough to have enough - you also have to have more than the neighbors. There's really no end to this game - it will always be possible to have something slightly better, it's just that it becomes increasingly expensive the more you try to squeeze out.
- terra_t 16y agoI told the financial adviser that administers my 401K at my current job that "it's clear that putting money in a 401K makes Wall Street rich, it's not clear that it's making me rich." There's a serious breakdown of trust between Main Street and Wall Street, and it's got (at least) three angles: (i) I'm not confident that money I invest in retirement plans is going to grow, or even keep it's value, (ii) I'm not sure that the "system" currently knows how to distribute capital to places where it will promote prosperous business (if it did, investment funds would be making money...) and (iii) I'm worried that giving money to Wall Street is like giving it to an enemy that's going to actively make my life worse: it's going to go into lobbying to keep Washington D.C. corrupt an ineffective and it's going to be used as a club to force businesses to eliminate jobs in the U.S. and ship them out elsewhere. Given that business, government and such doesn't have a vision that makes sense five years down the road, never mind 25 or so when I retire, it's hard to avoid a "carpe diem" attitude and to simply try to minimize your use of financial services: spend what you make, don't borrow or save. I've noticed some people here are enthusiastic about index funds; now, "seldom is heard a disparaging word" about index funds, but personally I think they're a lot more harmful than hedge funds could ever be. I mean, index funds just spray money indiscriminantly at companies that are lucky enough to be on some list. It gives the big shareholders a great opportunity to collect rents, but it means that investors aren't doing there job -- why does an investor deserve to get a return on capital? Because they do some thinking about where they can put their capital to get a good return. If you don't do that thinking, you don't deserve any return... Just as if if you've got some job and you don't do your job... You don't deserve a paycheck. "Bubblenomics" made index funds look brilliant from 1980-1999, but in the long term, I think mass investement in index funds is one of the major reasons why Wall Street doesn't work...
- nostrademons 16y agoThe interesting thing about index funds is that the better they work, the worse they work. If everybody put their money into an index fund, then nobody would be actively researching stocks, and the valuations reflected in the index would be wildly out of whack with respect to the true values of the stock. But if nobody puts money into an index fund, then we have a lot of people chasing high returns, a very efficient price-discovery system, and index funds that should return the exact mean of all your actively-managed funds. As a very broad heuristic, I take the size of the financial industry to be a pretty good indicator of the efficiency of index funds. When the financial industry is large, you have many eyes actively looking over stocks, an efficient market, and index funds that should track the performance of the underlying assets well. When the financial industry is small, you have fewer eyes keeping an active watch on stocks, and so you're often better off becoming one of them than sticking everything into a dumb index fund. Right now, the financial industry is still pretty large. As another interesting heuristic, I've found that oftentimes the best asset class to invest in is the one that everybody is certain is a bad investment. In the early 2000s, that was probably precious metals; in 2007, it was cash. Both asset classes have zoomed up since then. You don't want to invest in asset classes that people are actively looking at and decide are bad investments, though (eg. penny stocks). You want asset classes that people just take on faith to be bad investments.
- christkv 16y agoIts great to save up but imagine you get a chronic illness or cancer and you have a 20% deductible on your insurance. Suddenly your life savings are gone or seriously reduced.
- known 16y agoOr migrate to countries that offer free health care.
- gaius 16y agoThere's no such thing as "free" - you mean healthcare paid for by their taxpayers. Who might not be keen on non-contributors showing up and using it...