12 ms·
“There Is No Reason for Any Individual to Have a Computer in Their Home”
- yial 9y agoI guess some of the ideas were “half” right of the future to come, considering how many of our devices now make use of “cloud” computing.
- gnicholas 9y agoFunny how we're now at a time where we're moving past computers. I thought this was going to be about how you don't need a computer at home anymore because you can do so much on tablets, phones, watches, and TVs. When the Apple Watch with LTE was announced, I wondered when people will start to have a watch but no phone. When the iPad got LET, senior execs shifted to them and raved about the experience. It worked for them because they mostly just did email and a few other things, unlike worker bees who need a traditional computer OS. I wonder if a similar thing will happen with higher-ups foregoing phones for watches. My guess is that in the next 3-4 years, we'll start seeing people talking about how amazing it is to go around without a phone. Perhaps a tablet for doing "real work" and a watch for everything else.
- CrystalGamma 9y ago… but modern phones, watches and TVs are computers …
- Retric 9y agoTerminals are also 'computers' in that they have RAM and a CPU etc, but they where not independently useful. A tablet without google, Netflix, Facebook, Pandora, etc is just far less useful to people.
- CrystalGamma 9y agoTeletypes, which might have been what people where thinking of in the 60s and early 70s, didn't have a CPU AFAIK.
- Retric 9y agoIBM 2260 video display terminal dates back to 1964 and is rather different from a Teletype though it also does not really have a CPU. The IBM 3270 on the other hand does significantly more processing on the device and dates to 1972 which would have made it well known in the late 70's computing world.
- camus2 9y ago> A tablet without google, Netflix, Facebook, Pandora, etc is just far less useful to people. What you say makes no sense. Tablets are independent computers. You don't have to be connected to the internet to make the most of it. You rely on these internet services only if you choose to. I can read a book, listen to music or watch a video without Pandora, Netflix and Co. A tablet is not a dumb terminal.
- Retric 9y agoStarting from scratch you load a book, music, or video onto an iPad by connecting them to another computer. In that context your just cashing information from another system. Unless your talking about taking photos / video from it, but that's another story as a cassette deck can also record and play back audio without being a computer. Granted, you can play games with one or write notes etc, but I just mean they are mostly used as connected devices.
- camus2 9y ago> Starting from scratch you load a book, music, or video onto an iPad by connecting them to another computer. In that context your just cashing information from another system. And that's true for any desktop or laptop as well. It doesn't make them dumb terminals either.
- Retric 9y agoYou can still buy CDs / DVDs and load them on a PC. It's possible you could jury-rig something up for a tablet, but it's also clear the intended use is as a networked device.
- camus2 9y ago> You can still buy CDs / DVDs and load them on a PC. Because phones and tablets don't have SD slots? or data transfer from blue tooth or NAS drives isn't a thing?
- simonh 9y agoFor some tasks they are less useful, but there are still a ton of things our smartphones and tablets do that rely on local computing power. Biometric authentication such as face and fingerprint recognition is a heavily compute intensive application. It needs to be done locally in order to be secure. Face ID is just nuts. Modern smartphone photography is heavily compute-intensive, from HDR to optical zoom to image editing and markup. Just look at what Apple is doing with portrait mode and lighting effects. I love using time-lapse and slow-motion video modes. What would instagram and snapchat be without locally applied filters? Note taking, address book and time management. The notes apps on modern mobile devices are multi-media wonders with integrated text, image and handwriting recognition built-in. Calendar management, alarms and notifications all rely on local processing even if they do make use of cloud services. Without local smarts those services would lose a huge chunk of their utility. Document and media management. I read eBooks and listen to podcasts. My ebook reader has dynamic font selection, text size adjustment and will even read my books to me. Managing media on the device is essential as contemporary networks are still nowhere near good enough to stream everything all the time. My podcast app has sound modulation and processing options built in to tailor the sound to my tastes and needs, including speed up, voice level adjustment and dead-air 'vocal pause' elimination in real-time, all on-device and adjustable at my fingertips. That's serious sound studio level stuff in my pocket. Playing digital video files. Even ones downloaded or streamed. So what if we've had it since the 90s. It's still proper computation, especially with advanced modern codecs. VOIP and video calling even between continents have also become everyday and absolutely rely on powerful local number crunching. These things have become so everyday that we hardly notice most of them, but without serious on-device processing power, some of which would have been beyond $10k workstations just 15 years ago, none of this would be possible.
- Retric 9y ago10's of Gigaflops is now cheap and in your pocket. But, unlocking your phone is not a use case that's just a hoop you jump through before making a phone call etc. The phone might happen to have an on board address book and calendar, but this was not a statement about access to computation. It's a statement about cost/benefit and use cases.
- wongarsu 9y agoTell that to the people who sit in public transport playing games on their smartphone. A lot of the tasks usually done are impossible without internet connection, but that can be said about almost any computer. That doesn't make them useless, it just restricts them to a (still very useful and big) subset of functionality.
- Retric 9y agoStarting with a new iPad, load a game without connecting to another computer. Yes, they do processing without connection to an external system. But, unlike say a play station you can't just go to a store and buy a game without connecting your device to another system.
- cesarb 9y agoThat might be possible on an Android tablet, though I haven't tested. Skip initial Google account setup, enable sideloading in the settings, plug a SD card (or an USB drive, if that's supported), use the built-in file manager to open the APK.
- wongarsu 9y agoThe disk with your playstation game is pressed as a copy of a master disk that was created by a computer. In contrast, an iPad is connected via radio waves to a transmitter that is connected via cables to computers. The only difference is the transport medium used for the computer-computer connection. At least on Android Tablets there's also nothing really stopping me from buying a USB-stick with games and installing them, without any computers involved after the stick's creation (I would have to get a friend to create it and sell it to me, but the lack of market demand, and thus supply, is besides the point).
- Retric 9y agoIf every other computer in the world was off you could still load and play a game on a PlayStation. That's a difference in kind. The reality is there are tablets are a third option between a standalone computer which could be programmed by hand and an dumb terminal.
- gasbag 9y agoLess useful to most people, sure, but most people also use their desktop computers for only those same things. I make music, and for the past several years, I've been pretty much exclusively using my phone and iPad to do it. The touchscreen works very well for my use case, and the audio pipeline is quite flexible with the right apps--in many cases outshining the workflow available on a full PC. I'm working exclusively on the device and using no external services after downloading the apps themselves. That takes far more computing power than a dumb terminal.
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoPeople have been saying tablet for "real work" for years now. Real work isn't one size fits all. Computers (laptops, PCs, ...) will be around for quite some time.
- 6ak74rfy 9y agoI immediately got excited about the idea of replacing my phone with a watch, until I learned about the constraint of needing a phone to setup the watch. That shows that the phone isn't completely replaceable right now, but I guess Apple will fix that in a year or two. I'll definitely get rid of my phone then.
- gnicholas 9y agoYeah, even though I don't currently have an Apple Watch (go Pebble!), I wondered whether this would be feasible now. You could just choose to leave your phone at home all the time, but you'd still have to pay for the wireless plan. Currently, carriers charge $10 extra for the Watch, but you can't yank coverage for the phone. They use the same phone number, so you still have to have both.
- valuearb 9y agoMy iPhone is a three year old 6 Plus. I have no problems leaving that giant at home to rely on a watch. I'd hope it would bring more attention back to my day, and help break me of the habit of going to my phone when bored. The watch would do everything I need, texts, phone calls, email alerts, and I can even use it for navigation. While it would be better not to pay the $10 a month surcharge, that's a fairly small price to pay if it's an improvement in my daily experience.
- gnicholas 9y agoYep! And one issue Apple will have to deal with is: if people routinely leave their phones at home, will they pay $600+ for new phones every 2 years? My guess is that Apple will not be too eager for that scenario...
- valuearb 9y agoApple isn't dumb enough to think they have a choice. When Android finally figures out watches as well as Apple, a hundred watch makers will start chipping away at the phone market. Apple has always been smart enough to try to cannabilize its own products if cannibalization was inevitable.
- j3097736 9y agoAnd 10 years later everyone will be using glasses to correct the "looking at an 8K postage-stamp sized display" syndrome. Not possible without some magic holographic technology.
- gregmac 9y ago> To understand the mindset of this period it is important to recognize the distinction between a computer terminal and a free-standing computer. Some experts believed that individuals would have terminals at home that communicated with powerful remote computers providing utility-like services for information and interaction. These experts believed that an isolated computer at home would be too under-powered to be worthwhile. Considering how the majority of the general population's use of "computers" is really interacting with remote and cloud services (Facebook, Netflix, etc) this is a valid argument today. While today's equivalent of terminals (phones, tablets, and even PCs) have a significant amount of local computing ability, for the most part they really are just used as fancy terminals. Gaming is maybe the one mainstream application where local compute is important. The other quote that stuck out to me was this: > “The personal computer will fall flat on its face in business because users want to share files and want more than one user on the system,”
- baddox 9y agoI don't know about this analogy. With websites, you're running the software locally. You just happened to download the software right before running it. Your phone's web browser is hardly "just a terminal," and in fact for most websites it probably requires significantly more processing power per user on the front end to render the site than it does on the backend to serve the data. Netflix might be a slightly better analogy, since it can naively be thought of as a dumb encoder just outputting a stream of data as it receives it.
- throwanem 9y agoIn the 99%+ case for web apps, you're running only part of the software locally, and without the remote component the local part is useless. The distinction matters, especially when it comes to tasks like home automation - Nest alone is sufficient to exemplify the intractable problems that result from failing to design systems which perform purely local tasks in such a way that they require only local resources to do so. But Nest is far from alone in having so failed.
- 9y ago
- ender89 9y agoGeorge W. Mitchell's quote was pretty much spot on considering the context of the time, he was basically describing an internet connected pc which was communicating with servers somewhere that do the real computing. Now obviously even the cheapest netbook has more computing power than anything he was thinking of at the time, and your average gaming computer is vastly more capable of computing than what the home terminal he was envisioning was, the fact of the matter is that we're moving more and more towards the thin client model where the majority of your computing is done in the cloud. Hell, I'm sitting in front of a macbook pro that could tear your face off but I rely on the web and a remote server to run my word processing software.
- digi_owl 9y agoIt hits me as i dig though the comment pile that what has changed is that while compute power has grown, storage has downright exploded. The power of Google et al is not the compute, it is the storage. The amount of data that Google have on tap and sifts through is downright staggering, and clearly not something that is possible to store locally for home users.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoEspecially considering the petabytes of tape they use.
- jandrese 9y agoThe computers there were talking about would be analogous to the big iron supercomputers of today. The quote "There is no reason for any individual to have a supercomputer in their home." is much closer to reasonable. It does show a lack of foresight on their part, but it's not as completely wrong as it looks on the surface.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoTrue, but... for that era, a "supercomputer" was a Cray 1. How many Cray 1's do you have in your home? That is, how many devices do you have that can do 160 MFLOPS? For many HN readers, it may be in double digits.
- digi_owl 9y agoThen again said Cray1 was a liquid cooled beast that acted as much as a piece of furniture as it did a computer. What blew everything up was how fast Intel and "friends" could get ICs to shrink. But even then we now have vast warehouses that we access remotely that is mostly there to store metadata that is sifted and sorted on command.
- michrassena 9y agoEvery time this quote about computers in the home is brought up, it seems like people miss the point. It wasn't that the people saying no one needs a computer at home were entirely wrong, it's just that the meaning of "computer" changed. What computers did, what they looked like, their power and space requirements were reduced to fit into the home. The big iron of the era were the equivalent of trains, and it's true no one needs a train parked in front of their house. But powered transport was miniaturized too. So I agree, it boils down to a lack of vision on their part.
- drtse4 9y agoFrom the same period, a radio interview where Ted Nelson tries to convince, unsuccessfully, a skeptical radio host that home computing has a future: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI
- paulgerhardt 9y agoWe laugh at these quotes and yet we keep making them. "640K... nobody would ever need that much memory" "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame." "Well this is an exceptionally cute idea, but there is absolutely no way that anyone is going to have any faith in this currency." It seems inevitable that despite knowing better we will keep putting our collective foot in our mouth. I'm ok with that. The takeaway is that limiting predictions aren't useful.
- B1FF_PSUVM 9y ago> The takeaway is that limiting predictions aren't useful. Er ... isn't that rather limiting?
- throwaway135634 9y agoOr maybe the takeaway is that most things fail and cherrypicking the times they didn't isn't a real argument
- ajross 9y ago> "640K... nobody would ever need that much memory" The Gates quote was "640k ought to be enough for anybody", and it's been wildly misinterpreted by basically everyone. The IBM PC had already picked the 8088, which had a 20 bit addressing architecture regardless of whether or not 1MB was "enough" or not. The issue Gates was addressing was whether or not DOS's choice of 640 as the barrier for loadable program memory management was enough given that it was only about half the space in the machine. And he wasn't really wrong. The time frame between DOS programs bumping up against 640k and "DOS" programs wanting to use the multiple-megabyte flat spaces available on the 80386 (which couldn't possibly have been architected for in software in 1981) was like three years. If you want to ding DOS, complain not about the 640k limit but about the complete lack of architecture and discipline in the high 384k. Really no one ever got this space under control, and it was a bucketful of undetectable device I/O hazards and too-clever-by-half hackery well into the 90's.
- paulgerhardt 9y agothe quote was "When we set the upper limit of PC-DOS at 640K, we thought nobody would ever need that much memory." "640K... nobody would ever need that much memory" was just a contraction https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/09/08/640k-enough/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/09/08/640k-enough/
- rektide 9y agoBut less and less do we have personal computers in the home- the PC is being converted into a dumb terminal, a screen and keyboard, with all the real brains on the other end of the wire.
- Koshkin 9y agoThis would have been true today if people no longer felt the need to buy desktop computers. (They still do it to play games.)
- amelius 9y agoAnd 640kb ought to be enough for anyone :)
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Unless you are very rich and very eccentric, you will not enjoy the luxury of having a computer in your own home." - Ed Yourdon, Techniques of Program Structure and Design, 1975 Yourdon had been at DEC, but left the company prior to 1970.
- contingencies 9y agoAwesome quote. Added to http://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup http://github.com/globalcitizen/taoup
- wglb 9y agoFailures in imagination can be deadly for businesses.
- zzzeek 9y agoThere is no reason for any individual to have a high energy particle accelerator in their home. 35 years later...
- ctdonath 9y agoThose not around (or aware enough) back then don't grasp how staggeringly little computing power there was, and how enormous the effort to do that paltry processing. Sure there were "desktop computers", but they barely did anything; a computer sophisticated enough to do anything meaningful in one's home would have required an entire room devoted to it - and still wouldn't do much. Today's Lightning cable literally contains more processing power than a "home computer" from the early 1980s. "Document processing", today a simple matter of scanning a paper at >300dpi and running OCR, was a huge undertaking just to identify & fragment documents (varying extreme compression of components based on differing legal importance of preprinted content vs handwritten content vs legally-binding signatures) precisely because there was so very little space to store anything in. One common image today could easily overwhelm an entire storage unit back then. (Tangent: I believe this is a major & widely-disbelieved source of much of the consternation surrounding Obama's birth certificate). The notion of utility-level remote computing was necessitated by computing problems of real practicality requiring such scale, not just of straight capacity but of complexity to squeeze maximum usability out of such under-powered hardware, that doing it at home was unthinkable. Nobody expected computing power would increase, per volume & dollar, so incredibly much. Some 40 years later, processors are about 10,000x faster, displays 10,000x more detailed, and memory & storage & networking 10,000,000x greater. I remember my brother taking all day to download a large book; today we use as much data for 1 web page. "These experts believed that an isolated computer at home would be too under-powered to be worthwhile." It was. Think: modern insulated automated-HVAC 2000 sq ft home, vs mud hut. They couldn't comprehend what was to come; most today can't comprehend where we came from.
- compiler-guy 9y agoOne of my favorite examples: The parent comment above would have been too big to store in main memory for one of these computers. The comments on this thread wouldn't fit into secondary storage. It's also useful to remember that was talking about his then present, not forever and ever. He didn't say, "and there never will be."
- ctdonath 9y agoNicely put. It's hard to get the orders of magnitude across; that's a good example. One could argue that the "didn't say 'never'" was implicitly understood. What I don't think most grok is then-incomprehensible scale change; those loading multi-ton 5MB storage units on airplanes couldn't imagine a half-terabyte on your fingernail. https://imgur.com/uqKOX https://imgur.com/uqKOX https://ae01.alicdn.com/kf/HTB1nA6XRpXXXXX1XXXXq6xXFXXXy/200PCS-LOT-MICRO-SD-Card-32GB-64GB-128GB-256GB-512GB-1024GB-CLASS-10-Memory-Card-TF.jpg https://ae01.alicdn.com/kf/HTB1nA6XRpXXXXX1XXXXq6xXFXXXy/200...
- tudorw 9y agoAs an adjunct, here's a journalist in 1979 struggling to comprehend Ted Nelson's vision that the computer would become a creative tool for the masses, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVU62CQTXFI
- microcolonel 9y agoThis is, in large part, still a popular sentiment in Japan.
- milansuk 9y agoThere is one big reason and that's privacy!
- alphapowered 9y agoAn interesting talk by Ken Olsen on his history with DEC: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNBS0I1h42k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNBS0I1h42k Sadly, the names DEC and Digital barely resonate with the average under-30 developer. In fact, I'd guess that DEC/Digital on a resume not only counts for much less than AirBnB or some other trendy, frivolous startup, but probably even hurts, given how prevalent ageism is in our industry.
- gumby 9y agoWhy didn't the investigator contact Dave or Gordon both of whom are alive and well?
- known 9y ago"There is no such thing as an underestimate of average intelligence" --Henry Adams
- mongol 9y agoFor these quotes I always wonder if we put them in the right time context. Is it fair to assume that the quote was meant to mean "never", or was it implied a time frame such as "during this decade" etc.
- caf 9y agoTo me the amazing thing isn't that DEC pooh-poohed the idea of the PC, but rather that IBM was agile enough not to!
- digi_owl 9y agoThe PC was really an outlier. Not only was it an IBM product, but beyond the BIOS everything was off the shelf (even the OS). So once the BIOS was cloned, and the clone defended as clean in court, they promptly tried to reassert control with the PS/2 and spiraled into irrelevance.