9 ms·
Sex differences
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- klodolph 9y agoA major problem with this kind of armchair analysis is that in practice variables are only ever approximately normal, and the differences are most noticeable in the tail. Taleb's book The Black Swan talks about this phenomenon, but I can't recommend the book--it's basically one chapter's worth of material stretched over 400 pages.
- tptacek 9y agoDarren Dahly is a biostatistician and lecturer at University College Cork. I don't think you get to dismiss his analysis as "armchair".
- klodolph 9y ago"Armchair" in this case means "without looking at the data". We're making hypotheses about the tail of a distribution based on the assumption that the distribution is normal, rather than looking at the data. It's still a problem with the argument, no matter who makes it. It sounds like you're saying that it's more important to know the identity of the person making the argument than the content of the argument itself?
- tpeo 9y agoI don't think would be a problem of armchair analysis. Rather, it would be an issue of trying to fit the wrong distribution to the data. Granted, not having even a peek at the data would increase the likelihood that the distribution someone pulled out of their hat is wrong. But it doesn't prevent people from making that mistake. I don't think the tail of the techiness distribution would be an issue either, because this tail isn't that fat. Techiness is most likely constrained to a definite variance. I mean, Googlers are part of that tail, yet none of them are some sort of post-singularitarian cyborg, beyond the comprehension of their own colleagues. It might sound stupid, but this is the sort of thing we expect to see in the fat-tailed distributions.
- Mattasher 9y agoTo fill this out with an example, adult male heights are normal for most of the distribution, but we have a handful of people who've grown to 8 standard deviations beyond the mean, and a large cluster of people even farther below the mean.
- nemo1618 9y ago>Starting again from the standard normal, adding 0.10 SD to the male mean would lead to a 1.2 to 1 male to female ratio (at ≥1.5SD); but adding a full SD would give almost 5:1. Remember, a 1 SD shift is a pretty big one (e.g. a difference of 3 inches for height), so not suprisingly, the evidence seems to suggest that the 10% increase in the mean is the more realistic scenario for most variables where differences seem to exist. The average male is about 6 inches taller than the average female. If a >1SD difference is possible in height, why not other areas? Or am I missing something here?
- klodolph 9y ago[deleted]
- ikeboy 9y agoNo, the part they quoted is talking about mean.
- Smaug123 9y agoIs it? Have I just really badly misunderstood? > Starting again from the standard normal, adding 0.10 SD to the male mean would lead to a 1.2 to 1 male to female ratio (at ≥1.5SD); but adding a full SD would give almost 5:1 [emphasis mine]
- tptacek 9y agoIf you want to conjecture that there is an X factor for technology work that has a >1SD bias for men, you can do that (for a lot of reasons, I don't think you'll be able to do it persuasively), but you'll have unmoored your argument from the premise of the Google Memo, which is that these differences are well documented in the scientific literature and it's merely culture that prevents us from talking about them.
- JamesBarney 9y agoOne of the few >1SD ways that men and women differ is when you ask men and women what jobs they think they'd prefer. If you list jobs that have large social components like teacher, social work, etc... more women will say they sound pleasurable than men. When you list jobs with smaller social components like carpenter, electronics technician, forester, car mechanic more men will say they are pleasurable. Is this difference entirely cultural, women being told they should prefer people jobs, and men being told they should prefer thing jobs? No entirely. It looks like biology plays a significant role too. Women(XY) with congenital adrenal hyperplasia are raised as women, but tend to show occupational choices that are less people oriented. And the degree to which these women have been exposed to prenatal testosterone predicts how much they'll prefer thing oriented jobs. Just to reiterate though, I don't think this is a valid reason to give up on getting more women into tech. It just means it'll be an uphill battle, and maybe we should expand our toolset to include things we otherwise wouldn't have tired. When I think about how we get to a profession with much better gender parity, I imagine the world that has changed how it sees developers. Right now the world sees great developers as technical geniuses sitting in a dark basement staring at a command line solving garbage collection bugs and doing memory dumps. But instead we thought about a great developer as someone who used their eloquent communication skills, amazing empathy and a generous helping bad ass technical skills to delight their end-users with features they didn't even know they needed. I think that's a job more 16 year old girls could get excited about. P.S. this doesn't mean we shouldn't stamp out sexism where ever it rears its ugly head. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3166361/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3166361/
- njarboe 9y ago"This is because while Google might be selective in their hiring practices, they aren’t +4 SD selective. This is because, given a normal distribution, we only expect 0.000032% of observations to have a score ≥ 4 SDs above the mean." Maybe there is something I don't understand but 4 sigma is .006334% so > 4SD would be 0.003167%. "This percentage equates to just 273 New Yorkers, 30 people from San Francisco, or just 11 thousand people in the entire United States, the 3rd most populous country on earth." 0.000032% of 320 million would be 102 people.
- itsdrewmiller 9y agoDrop the "%" and it all makes sense.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Smaug123 9y agoYou may have got confused with both the percentage and with the fact that we require "greater than four sigma above the mean" rather than "greater than four sigma away from the mean".
- dnautics 9y ago> So what happens if we instead say that Google recruits from the mere mortals with Techiness scores ≥ 2SD, which is still the top 5% of all people? Does anyone have any idea of what the selectivity at google hiring is? How many people do they reject for each person they hire? Also using this number would have to roughly take into account that the distributions are supposed to be "over all people" whereas the hiring pool is self-selected. Simply by being able to get python to print "hello world" you're probably already in the top 15% of "all people". I am also curious about modeling this where the median of population A is LOWER than population B but variance differences and selectivity pushes selection for population A higher. (to wit: I think, and the scientific evidence supports me, that men are generally dumber than women)
- trhway 9y ago> I think, and the scientific evidence supports me, that men are generally dumber than women and given that the programming is a pretty dumb job, a blue-collar job of the 21st century ('S' in CS isn't a real science), i think we have the explanation.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> So what happens if we instead say that Google recruits from the mere mortals with Techiness scores ≥ 2SD, which is still the top 5% of all people? That ratio drops to 1.5 to 1. Despite my enjoyment of Google’s products, I have a hard time believing they are even this selective Being a software developer at all is ~2.5% of the US population (and even less internationally). Moreover, if the variability hypothesis is true then the entire point is that 1SD for men will be larger in absolute terms than 1SD for women.
- tptacek 9y agoFirst, the baseline isn't the total US population. We're not surprised that toddlers and retired World War 2 veterans aren't software developers. You're looking for the percentage of the labor market, which, of course, is higher. Second, what you're pointing out is orthogonal to the question. The premise of the question is that there aren't many women software developers; the dispute between the memo and Dahly is why that is. Third, if you bring international labor into this, you muddy the issue even more, because female participation in the software development market is sharply higher in some major overseas markets. I don't follow your second sentence.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> First, the baseline isn't the total US population. We're not surprised that toddlers and retired World War 2 veterans aren't software developers. You're looking for the percentage of the labor market, which, of course, is higher. ~2.5% is the percentage of the US employed workforce. > Second, what you're pointing out is orthogonal to the question. The premise of the question is that there aren't many women software developers; the dispute between the memo and Dahly is why that is. The argument is that Google would not be excluding >95% of people, but 97.5% aren't even software developers. > Third, if you bring international labor into this, you muddy the issue even more, because female participation in the software development market is sharply higher in some major overseas markets. But why would a US employer hire foreign employees from those markets and not the world market overall? > I don't follow your second sentence. The complaint is that four standard deviations is a lot, but it's not actually four because the size of a standard deviation is not the same.
- JamesBarney 9y ago17% of google devs are women 18% of cs majors are women. This isn't a google problem, no need to talk about variances. http://splinternews.com/survey-says-92-percent-of-software-developers-are-men-1793846921 http://splinternews.com/survey-says-92-percent-of-software-d... https://www.ncwit.org/infographic/3435 https://www.ncwit.org/infographic/3435
- stickfigure 9y agoFurthermore, 18% of high school AP Computer Science exam takers are women. http://www.exploringcs.org/resources/cs-statistics http://www.exploringcs.org/resources/cs-statistics (scroll down to 2013) Whatever the cause, it seems like we should look upstream and leave Google out of it.
- fulafel 9y agoAre both of those US-only figures? Google is a multinational company. If the "all cs majors" figure is US and the Google 17% is global, then they are not comparable. If you want a global conclusion you should include weighted CS grads % from Google campus countries, if you want a US-only conclusion you need some way to exclude devs from non-US Google campuses.
- JamesBarney 9y agohttps://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/05/28/google-releases-employee-diversity-figures/9697049/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/05/28/google-releas... This says it's an international number but it also puts the % of female CS grads in the U.S. at 12%. Other ways it might be off include that women who get CS degrees enter non-development positions at higher rates(Project managers, business analysts, etc) and drop out of the industry at higher rates(I've heard).
- JamesBarney 9y agoThese numbers from hackerrank say that 14% of American devs are women, but 23% of Indian devs. Which puts Google right in between those two numbers like we expect. https://blog.hackerrank.com/which-countries-have-the-most-skilled-female-developers/ https://blog.hackerrank.com/which-countries-have-the-most-sk...
- imtringued 9y agoThe article is too google centric. It's believable that google is hiring a significant chunk of the top 0.3% of the US population because they pay incredibly high salaries (300k+). It would make more sense to look at average companies that don't have the resources to hire from the right side of the normal distribution. If they have a 4 to 1 ratio where a 1.5 to 1 ratio was expected that means the differing distribution is one of the less significant possible factors out of many.
- singularity2001 9y agosorry for the lazy reading but why does he center both normal distributions at 0? is there no scientific proof for increased 'techiness' in males? and how does he come to the conclusion that "they don’t seem to be the dominant factor."?
- Smaug123 9y agoNear the end of the post, the author considers what happens when the means of the two distributions are different. "They don't seem to be the dominant factor" because in order to fully generate the observed ratio of male/female employment at Google using only the "general techiness factor", one needs to hypothesise implausibly large differences in the underlying distributions of techiness.
- naasking 9y ago> in order to fully generate the observed ratio of male/female employment at Google using only the "general techiness factor", one needs to hypothesise implausibly large differences in the underlying distributions of techiness. Except it's only implausible if you assume the conclusion. The implausibility is literally summoned from the aether, because it's certainly not based on any empirical facts.
- wmf 9y agoBecause that's what the Greater Male Variability Hypothesis is. There are other articles about other hypotheses.
- suneilp 9y ago> Science is a tool for explaining what we observe. There is almost always more than one plausible explantion for any observation, and so it’s the job of the scientist to pit these against each other and see which comes out on top. That is such a crude way to go about things. It's been suggested before that there are larger influences from society on how men and women should act and live their lives. I still believe that. I don't think we've made a lot of progress on gender issues. A lot of them still lurk under the surface and the PC culture shields them and prevents discovery and resolution.
- david38 9y agoA lot from when? In the 80s, a woman couldn't get a credit card w/o her husband co-signing. That's a pretty huge access to money they previously didn't have.
- stcredzero 9y agoThis article is effectively a straw man. It uses an argument which isn't directly applicable (not central to the points made by James Damore in the Google Memo) to give an appearance of being reasonable. If you want to be more familiar with the science James Damore was referencing, take a look at this video of a presentation by Steven Pinker and the sources referenced therein. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PaL5FW5src https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PaL5FW5src The key takeaway for the Google Memo, is that James Damore was fired for referencing mainstream science, then asking if that was relevant to Google's hiring practices. What's more, many of his coworkers and many of my fellow college classmates were more than willing to throw him under the bus and impute all sorts of unsavory thoughts and emotions to Mr. Damore with no evidence, while the Google management was willing to publicly do the same while re-disseminating his memo in the worst way possible to encourage misreadings of it. See also Christina Hoff Summers' video on the subject. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tu4tB9W3xFo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tu4tB9W3xFo Steven Pinker identifies as a feminist, as does Christina Hoff Summers. Diane Halpern certainly isn't a misogynist. The extreme left which ascribes to Postmodernist political theories is coming for the scientists, rationalist nerds, and Aspergers neuro-atypicals. They want to cow everyone into agreeing to their ideologically driven Lysenkoist-like censored science. They represent a new authoritarianism operating through a fear of social ostracism and economic disenfranchisement. (You don't have to take my word for it -- you can take theirs. Just pay attention to what campus activists have been saying since about 2014.) If you believe in rational discourse, free speech, and meritocracy, you need to courageously speak out against these authoritarians. (First they came for the social scientists and evolutionary biologists...)
- tptacek 9y agoCan you tell me more about what you believe that Pinker video establishes? I have generally high regard for your comments. But in this instance, I think your claim about what happened to Damore is facially flawed. Damore didn't simply "reference mainstream science". Whether you agree with him or not, I don't think it's possible to defend the claim that he was fired for citations. I'd also urge you to step back from the Damore framing of this post. I know why it's hard to escape. But I think the author is just using Damore as an opportunity to make a more general statistical point. Certainly, at no point in this post does the author even mention Damore by name, let alone advocate for his termination.
- haberman 9y ago> The apparent [appeal] of this message wasn’t limited to chauvinist TechBros. Many “moderate” commentators also seemed quite impressed. After all, the memo wasn’t arguing that all men, or even most of them, are better suited than women for tech jobs. That would be ridiculous! But since the existence of sex differences in some traits is scientifically uncontroversial, some supporters of the Google Memo claimed the scientific high-ground. “You see? We aren’t sexist or biased”, they proclaimed. “This is just science.” And you can’t hate on science. The tone of this introduction doesn't inspire confidence that the author is truth-seeking without agenda. > Remember, a 1 SD shift is a pretty big one (e.g. a difference of 3 inches for height), so not suprisingly, the evidence seems to suggest that the 10% increase in the mean is the more realistic scenario for most variables where differences seem to exist. Several times he references the Stevens/Haidt results, but doesn't seem to acknowledge this finding from Stevens/Haidt (https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/08/10/the-google-memo-what-does-the-research-say-about-gender-differences/ https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/08/10/the-google-memo-what...): > Gender differences in interest and enjoyment of math, coding, and highly “systemizing” activities are large. The difference on traits related to preferences for “people vs. things” is found consistently and is very large, with some effect sizes exceeding 1.0. (See especially the meta-analyses by Su and her colleagues, and also see this review paper by Ceci & Williams, 2015).
- MaysonL 9y agoAnd of course, preference for people over things would be a very useful (some might even say essential) trait to have among some members of a software engineering team.
- lucio 9y agoHaving "preference for people over things" will lead you to choose other more fulfilling careers than software engineering.
- naasking 9y ago> Several times he references the Stevens/Haidt results, but doesn't seem to acknowledge this finding from Stevens/Haidt (https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/08/10/the-google-memo-what... https://heterodoxacademy.org/2017/08/10/the-google-memo-what...): Excellent citation. I think it overreaches a little in attributing the position that women don't perform as well as men at software engineering, ie. they label many claims red which people have attributed to Damore, but he didn't make those claims; I believe Damore said the exact opposite actually, that women absolutely can perform at the same level, but that women simply aren't interested in CS careers. Your cite covers this in the conclusions, so it's pretty fair overall. As your citation explains, in societies with greater gender equality, women have so many other choice of careers that CS just isn't an attractive option. Perhaps it's not attractive for reasons that can be changed, but those reasons should be investigated, not simply assumed to be driven by sexism.
- xupybd 9y agoI think one thing the author needs to look at is the number of females trying to enter this field. When I was studying there was only one female in all of my computer science related papers. But loads and loads in the papers that overlapped with the chemical engineers. Many of the female chemical engineers did a lot better than the bulk of the CS students even when the assignments involved coding. But it seemed that most of the Engineers performed better than the CS students I don't think it's that females aren't good at or don't have natural abilities equal to men when it comes to programming but for what ever reason (that I don't care to speculate on) programming is not an attractive career option to many of them. So I think this point is a little off >>At this point, anyone already familiar with the normal distribution is probably having a sensible chuckle. This is because while Google might be selective in their hiring practices, they aren’t +4 SD selective. Because there is just a much smaller number (at least in my experience) of female developers. So if one company is 50-50 male to female they would have a disproportionate number of the total population of female developers.
- bArray 9y agoI've made the point more times than I care to mention, put simply there are two ways to think about the problem. The first is that men are dominating STEM fields. The second is that women are dominating non-STEM fields. IMO, the latter is mostly true. Less males are attending Western Universities than females, yet there is absolutely no push what-so-ever to fix this. Nobody cares about the lack of men in subjects such as Art or English Literature and certainly no initiative exists to even begin to correct this. Nobody is trying to push women into the lower 5% of jobs. Brick layers, plumbers, electricians - all well paying jobs - where is the push to get women into those? There are fundamental differences in the sexes which favour men for some jobs. For example, millions of years of evolution means that when you take a random pack of dogs, a group of apes or a gathering of humans and allow them to discover natural social order - almost always the leader will be male. Whether we want to accept it or not, we are still just highly functioning animals. Probably the most concerning, despicable, disgusting act of them all is a "recognition of women in... award" (rarely recognition of men of course), or the manipulation of wages to equal the "pay gap", or biasing employment, etc. To me, it says "we know women can't compete, therefore we're biasing the end result to make the outcome equal". It's like first-wave feminism meant nothing, what was the fight for equal opportunity even about if you only go on to bias towards equal outcome anyway? The point: Equal opportunity > Equal outcome
- naasking 9y ago> Nobody is trying to push women into the lower 5% of jobs. Brick layers, plumbers, electricians - all well paying jobs - where is the push to get women into those? Because these jobs don't address the power imbalance between men and women in our society. Lawyers and doctors are highly respected careers that influence the direction of society. Lots of women pushed into this field. Politics also needs more women, as should be obvious given how much states and Congress tries to control women's health care options. Computer science is increasingly pervading every facet of our existence, and so having gender parity ensures female concerns are equally represented as this field evolves.
- bArray 9y ago>Because these jobs don't address the power imbalance between men and women in our society. The "power imbalance" should be represented in all areas, surely? You can't just have the icing on the cake. And I think you've hit the nail on the head, this isn't about equality, this is about control, particularly money and power. >Lawyers and doctors are highly respected careers that influence the direction of society. And have begun to dominate these fields now (although I can't find a source of that I would be happy to quote). >Lots of women pushed into this field. I'm not sure there has been a significant struggle for a long time. >Politics also needs more women, as should be obvious given how much states and Congress tries to control women's health care options. I wouldn't say the main problem with Congress is that there is a lack of women, I think it's very existence is it's largest issue. >having gender parity ensures female concerns are equally represented as this field evolves "female concerns" sounds like a terribly generic term, you'll have to be more specific and explain how these concerns override the need for women representation (not necessarily women by the way, just a person who fairly represents them) in politics. My thinking is that tech for the most part is completely genderless, it's simply the application of Science. Most control is tech can be or has been completely overridden by law. But in general, I think (without being rude and wanting a genuine reply) that you've missed my point with regards to the lower 5% of jobs. My point is that instead of making STEM fields artificially more difficult to get into for men, another option is to make other fields more attractive. Social care for example is horrendously dominated by women, yet of massive importance to society - they are struggling to recruit due to social stigma, yet little is being done to address this.
- TheCoreh 9y ago> We will further assume that the distribution of Techiness is sex-specific; and that those sex-differences exist at birth and aren’t the result of later social or environmental factors. That's a really strong assumption, and one that even the author of the "Diversity memo" didn't make, IIRC. In fact it would make sense to assume the exact opposite: Whatever the differences of "initial state" may be, they will compound over time in a "feedback loop". Another issue: "techiness" isn't the only or even the main factor considered when hiring employees. If you consider this vaguely defined variable a function of several other variables, some not related to technology at all (e.g. cooperation, willingness to work at a major corporation, to work long hours, alma mater, other job opportunities, etc) you're left with basically no way of estimating if the standard deviation differences between males and females are, say, 1.5x or 4x. The author also didn't combine simultaneously changes in mean and standard deviation on his analysis, and didn't consider the possibility that the traits might fit a different curve (e.g. Tracy-Widom)
- naasking 9y ago> The differences in means is what the Google Memo seems to focus on No it doesn't. "Mean" isn't used in this way even once in the whole memo. The only indirect reference to means differences are two sample graphs that Damore only uses to explicitly label judgement based on means as fundamentally incorrect because it ignores significant overlap between groups. The greater male variability hypothesis is the only correct way to interpret the memo. Further, this article's conclusion doesn't follow from the facts as presented. It's literally asserting, "I can't fathom the existence a gender-specific difference of 4SD, therefore it doesn't exist and so such a difference can't explain our observations". Didn't you miss a step where you have to actually demonstrate that this difference actually doesn't exist before you can dismiss it? Certainly we can debate how reasonable such a distribution might be given what we know about gender-specific variability of other traits, but we absolutely can't dismiss it out of hand. Consider, for instance, that "hiring at Google" isn't the first time this variability comes into play, but instead the Nth time, where N is fairly large. If people tend to pursue things they're naturally good at, and such variability will obviously influence what genders will be naturally inclined to pursue, on average, then this acts as a compounding filter over a decade where students are first exposed to computer science. Consider the distribution characterizing "people's net worth". The variability in people's ability to make and save money isn't that broad, but including compounding effects of interest on debt and investments, even these small differences will yield huge variability in your net worth on your death bed.
- yellowapple 9y agoYet another article that misses Damore's point. Damore's hypothesis is not about ability or qualification. It's about interest. The paper claims that women are underrepresented in the tech sector simply because they're less interested in tech than men, not because they're less qualified or capable. I disagree with that hypothesis, sure (quite a bit of anecdotal evidence among coworkers and family/friends actually suggests the opposite, and I don't think Damore adequately isolated supposed biological factors from potential socioeconomic factors), but I at least bothered to read the paper before blabbing about it on the Internet.
- he0001 9y agoEven if I think the Author have a point, isn't the assumption of Googles hiring practices flawed since they are making an selection of an already biased selection, meaning hiring from the top tech institutions in the world?