17 ms·
These keynotes were magical before leakers leaked everything. I'm wondering if Apple should scrap these and aim for smaller, unplanned releases instead. As far
by nunez 9y ago
These keynotes were magical before leakers leaked everything. I'm wondering if Apple should scrap these and aim for smaller, unplanned releases instead.
As far as this phone goes, I am really excited to see how it stacks up to the Galaxy S8. Face ID is incredibly enticing, but Samsung Pay is much more universal. The only thing that is making me want to retreat back to an iPhone is its inferior Bluetooth audio quality.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoYeah the leaks gave this entire presentation away. We are at peak Apple. If I may borrow a similar peak story I'd look at Microsoft and the release of Windows XP. Balmer banked on that cash cow for far too long. Tim Cook is doing the same thing here. They need to buy Tesla and put Musk in charge of Apple. Everything they do these days is just another way to milk the money machine for them. They need a world class micromanaging innovator at the helm.
- baby 9y agoThe problem is that a bad release of a novel product will make them uncool and will crash them on the market.
- bhnmmhmd 9y agoExactly! Tim talked about Steve's legacy, but really, was SJ's dream to build a stale stagnating company? Did he prefer money over putting a dent in the universe?
- coldtea 9y agoSteve's Apple was just like Tim's Apple: all about incremental improvement. Youngsters might not remember, but I've followed those keynotes and introductions since 2002 or so. It took 4 years for the iPod to get a color screen -- and 8 years to get a video camera. Several years to get Wifi. The original iPhone wasn't 3G -- that was the next model. Those years we waited year over year for Jobs to announce some extremely incremental updates. And people cheered for them -- they were actually exciting, all the press was speculating and gushing, and it was e.g. just a few additional features on the iPod, like the touch wheel as opposed to the old click wheel. New announcements like the iPhone and the iPad were rare under Jobs too. And those products were low hanging fruit for Apple themselves -- a mobile phone and a table. Quite basic stuff -- not some whole new product category like flying cars and whatever people expect to see. Apple is not in the business of creating experimental stuff to dazzle geeks. It's in the business in incrementally improving mass market products. Besides, what competitor exactly did introduce those mythical "Jobs-worthy" products that people ask from Apple to deliver? Google Glasses? Microsoft's laptop/tablet combo that failed to gain much traction and is returned like crazy? https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/14/16142490/microsoft-surface-consumer-reports-memo-return-rates https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/14/16142490/microsoft-surfac... What Apple did better, and affected the industry, was not innovation in the sense of some new BS product category that didn't exist ever, it was delivery. Better thought out, more polished, and with lots of innovation in the details. The kind of innovation that the iPhone models get incrementally but few can understand, but then you use a model from 2-3 years ago and it feels ancient after you've used the last one. For such introductions of new products, the Apple Watch has been one such under Tim's, err, watch, and it does great in the market (in fact it's almost the only smartwatch people can actually see in the wild -- it outsold Samsung Galaxy watches so much in units it's not even funny).
- madshiva 9y agoI'm not more young now, I have see the evolution and never see any Apple Keynote or Steve speech because they talk for nothing wasting time , but I remember a things that every company still can't do now, reducing overwaste, improve autonomy. A single AAA battery did the job for a full week in my Rio MP3 Player. I don't care about fancy color screen, video camera? come on, wifi? useless. If the mp3 player isn't working for a full week the product wasn't better. There was no improvement on the MP3 player, only the storage, but on crap Apple storage, you don't have choice to throw away a device that have slow memory 8GB? when you can buy a SD card? Too much innovation from Apple...
- coldtea 9y ago>A single AAA battery did the job for a full week in my Rio MP3 Player. I don't care about fancy color screen, video camera? come on, wifi? useless Well, you might find yourself in the extreme minority on this. It's not like non-color-screen, non wi-fi full-week-lasting mp3 players don't exist -- there are tons of such models. It's just that the market has spoken, and most prefer to be able to also stream, plays apps, etc on their multi-purpose device than get one such. >There was no improvement on the MP3 player, only the storage, but on crap Apple storage, you don't have choice to throw away a device that have slow memory 8GB? when you can buy a SD card? Well, obviously companies like Apple don't cater to some small niche of music aficionados. Most people don't care for juggling cards and having different parts of their record collection on different SD cards or whatever -- they did it with CDs and such on 1999 out of necessity. Heck, most people will just stream today and be done with it. Also not sure how "slow memory" means anything in the context of an mp3 player. Ever had problem reading mp3s from the memory quickly enough?
- archagon 9y agoUgh, no. Goodbye privacy and corporate ethics, hello creepy analytics.
- andrewjl 9y agoFacial data is stored on device, just like touch id fingerprints were. ML happening on device instead of on the cloud. By all means, if you see privacy leaks point it out but I don't see any here.
- biot 9y agoThe "creepy analytics" remark is obviously a response to "They need to buy Tesla and put Musk in charge of Apple". Apple has a very good privacy track record. Tesla is the one with creepy analytics, witnessed by how the company is seemingly eager to release every detail of what you and your Tesla vehicle did leading up to a collision.
- notheguyouthink 9y agoI mean, I like quality hardware and as far as I can tell, Apple is the only one even remotely trying to protect privacy. Compared to Google, Samsung, etc. at least. So which phone maker fits your level of privacy?
- artursapek 9y agoI don't think Musk would be enticed by the prospect of heading up a company that's focused on animating poop emojis. He's busy saving our species.
- briandear 9y agoReally? Armageddon has been coming for centuries. There is not evidence that humanity is about to be wiped out. Solar panels and electric cars are saving our species? From what? Musk is certainly an inportant innovator, but he’s not a Messiah.
- rootlocus 9y ago> Solar panels and electric cars are saving our species? From what? Global warming
- pvg 9y agoWe seem to be at peak Apple year after year, as it continues to inexplicably churn out new products and rake in money. Tim Cook somehow keeps popping up on stage with something new, devoid of vision and utterly oblivious he's standing on the precipice of catastrophic decline. Again.
- mcphage 9y agoJust gotta keep climbing this mountain, before we reach the cliff on the other side.
- conductr 9y agoIMO it's purely because Android as OS has not tapped into the UX that most iPhone users enjoy. So when replacement time comes around every couple years, users think why not get the new iPhone even though it didn't change much from my old one. My thought is most iPhone users would and maybe have considered switching but really enjoy the UX familiarity/simplicity of iPhone. This is actually a conversation I have over and over with friends, family and coworkers. The OS switching cost/risks are too high although most iPhone users know the top Android devices are typically better than the iPhone the risk of not liking the OS experience is too high compared to the reward of taking slightly better photos or bigger screen or whatever Android does now that iPhone won't until XI
- criddell 9y ago> the top Android devices are typically better than the iPhone In some ways (and on paper), you're right. Apple's stores are a huge advantage though. Any family member that asks me what they should buy is going to be told to get an iPhone. The Genius Bar might not be perfect, but it's better than calling Verizon or posting a message on the One Plus forums.
- twothamendment 9y agoFor many, the Genius Bar may be hours away. For me it is over 3 hours. A full day of driving to deal with a Genius? I'll take my chances with the forums - they have yet to let me down.
- coldtea 9y agoBecause random advice from internet armchair experts would have worked wonders for them in the past have they followed it. I mean they're only breaking record after record, poor them...
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoPeople don't care about Apple because of it's MarketCap.
- coldtea 9y agoNo, but its Market Cap is what it is because people care about Apple. Whereas if it was some geek factory making "wild bets" on not-ready-yet technologies, like the kind geeks ask to see, it would be liked by few, ignored by most (and for good reason). If someone wants that, they can buy all those wonderful innovative products MS, Samsung and Google regularly put out... Rocking their Google Glass look and pioneering VR with their Rift.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI think what makes (or made) Apple what it is, is that it did wild-bets correctly. So that's what people are complaining about - the fact that they can't, or won't make wild bets that win. Is that extremely hard? Yes of course, but doing that effectively is why Apple got the reputation it has.
- coldtea 9y agoWild bets on what? That people would buy a good smartphone? That's not exactly Tesla (the inventor, not the company) territory, bet-wise. Phones were one of the hottest markets already -- and they would have only gotten smarter, iPhone or not. The iPhone just brought lots of smartness and polish in concentrated form all at once -- it took around 3 years for competitors to catch up (Android wasn't released for another full year), and I guess it would have taken them like 5-6 years or so to put it all together (or course with less panache) if they iPhone had not existed at all. But still it was no wild bet (except in daring to deal with the telcos -- that was a big bet and took balls). So, in 2017, what exactly product would you think Apple should introduce as a bet?
- valuearb 9y agoYou guys have been saying it's peak Apple for almost a decade. I'm tired of waiting, when do we get to the other side?
- rmrfrmrf 9y agoI actually thought Tim Cook did a great job this time around. For the first time in a while, I got that "reality distortion field" feeling that I haven't had since Steve Jobs had been the presenter. I think these keynotes go a long way to sell the product. Admittedly, I haven't seen any of the leaks, so yeah I'm sure it's not as cool if you know what's coming, however I do remember from past leaks that they tend to leave out the narrative (just opting for raw features, photos, etc.) that don't really do justice to the product.
- TheRealDunkirk 9y agoWithin seconds, I really got the impression that he's been working on his presentation skills. I agree; much improved. The dramatic tension was noticeably better.
- nunez 9y agoWhile I think Tim was much more expressive this time around, I still think he sounds too stiff and rehearsed. The one thing that Steve did incredibly well was make his keynotes sound improvised, even though they weren't. I'm not sure if Tim will ever get there, as it's kind of a character trait. Phil and Cue are better at it, IMO.
- eight_ender 9y agoI think it's really hard for him to act that way. He's a proven logistical and managerial genius but those qualities don't directly map to stagecraft.
- Tsiklon 9y agoAnd frankly in terms of stagecraft Tim Cook has come on leaps and bounds from his first few conferences. As someone who's quite withdrawn and reserved at work, I'd imagine it's quite a challenge to have to develop those skills.
- gknight 9y agoOne way he's made these keynotes his own is by the humanity he's injecting into them. I've noticed that whenever there's a big keynote after some big crisis or tragedy, he'll acknowledge them in a very sincere way. I'm still moved by his brief remarks and moment of silence after the Pulse nightclub shooting in Orlando.
- make3 9y agoHaving worked at Apple, the company feels like complete stress apocalypse all around for the 2 months before the fall major releases. I'm pretty sure no one would fall for the unplanned release thing, and that leaks would still happen
- xtreme 9y agoIf some leaks can reduce the reaction to a product from magical to meh, perhaps the reaction was engineered by hype and not actual quality or features of said product. To be concise, if something is truly groundbreaking, leaks don't diminish their value.
- bdibs 9y agoIt doesn't diminish their value, but it takes away from the magic and showmanship behind the whole event.
- komali2 9y agoExactly, I think you're just describing marketing, which some would view as a form of dishonesty or at least smoke and mirrors.
- macintux 9y agoHonest marketing is explaining the value of a product. Marketing can be smoke and mirrors, but to deny its utility is shortsighted.
- conception 9y agoThis is a fantastic point. Marketing isn't evil - it's just a tool. It gets you connected with things you want faster. And like anything it can be misused.
- lostmsu 9y agoI think in most cases marketing deprives me of things I want faster being a resource hog.
- IowaBoyInMN 9y agoThat's advertising. Some consider it a subset of marketing. Some consider it an entirely separate area. I agree. Ads on web pages are resource hogs. ;) In its purest form, marketing is any communication from a company. Without marketing you would not know about any products from any company. So some forms of marketing are very valuable to everyone. As with any discipline there are bad points as well.
- westiseast 9y agoMeh. This and any of the last few keynotes would have been magical if they'd shown something that actually did something new. What they've shown is just fancy new technology to do the same old things - great, now I can lock my screen in a different way!
- 1_2__4 9y agoThey were also magical when they were announcing new, incredible features instead of small iterative improvements.
- seanp2k2 9y agoThe front-facing dot projector and dual cameras
- qq66 9y agoWhat were the new incredible features that are missing now? Seems like the iPhone has been a pretty steady march forward in terms of processor, memory, storage, screen, camera, hardware features, and the software enabled by the hardware capabilities. Why is this release underwhelming?
- geff82 9y agoHonestly, my wife and I had no previous exposure to leaks besides "there will be something expensive". And then it felt like the real Apple magic. We sat there and at every product presented we said "Wow, we want this. NOW!". While the iPhone 8 still felt quite normal, the iPhone X absolutely killed it for us. And let's not begin with the eSim-Watch... which is so SciFi that I wanted it back in 1990 when I was still 8 years old. We have to appreciate that there is more to life than revolution, Apple "simple" does evolution at a very high level and in the end, they lead the competitors. Today, we could see the stuff that Samsung and others will get right in a year or two. When Apple already presents their next evolution... It is not about having the right specs, but the right concept. I already know the friend who will come to me tomorrow that his HTC has and 8 core processor while Apple has only six. The point is: it is all useless without the whole package being perfect. And while Apple is freaking expensive upfront, the peace of mind is worth it.
- kingnothing 9y agoSimilar watches with LTE have been available from Samsung and others for years. Objectively speaking, Apple's latest watch isn't anything special.
- muninn_ 9y agoThat's like saying the Model T was built a long time ago, so a new Ferrari isn't anything special.
- mockindignant 9y agoIt's special in that it makes lots of money unlike really just about every other smartwatch.
- yodsanklai 9y agoand the $60 xiaomi 4K TV box has been around for a year...
- synicalx 9y ago
- ovao 9y agoThe leaks tend to be a consequence of their supply chain not being able to keep tight lips more than anything else. One approach to combat that would be to announce a product well in advance of production, but then you have announcements followed by six or more months of production ramp-up. Which is obviously awful. Until Apple is able to bring much more in-house, which they can't realistically do in most cases involving manufacturing, the leaks are inevitable. If you want to maintain the magic for yourself, though, that's simpler: don't look at Macrumors or what have you :)
- roflchoppa 9y agoI always thought that the leaks were deliberate to create media hype around the products.
- chipotle_coyote 9y agoApple's (presumed) controlled leaks tend to be about setting expectations rather than "building hype": they're not going to deliberately spoil the reveals of their own press shows, but they may deliberately shoot down rumors about things their upcoming products don't have. Also, they tend to talk to established venues that don't have a reputation for rumor-mongering. If a "leak" appears on the WSJ, it's often presumed to be a tip from Apple itself; if it appears on 9to5Mac or MacRumors, it almost certainly is not Apple's own doing.
- addicted 9y agoThey also try and reveal controversial stuff early so the public can digest it before the event. And I'm sure they have a bunch of people working the social media trying to explain why them taking a feature away isn't such a bad thing leading up to the reveal event (I bet the removal of the headphone jack was deliberately leaked .
- fiatpandas 9y agoThis latest keynote was pretty much completely spoiled due to a leak which came internally from Apple (URLs to golden master iphone firmware). I was really surprised that happened. I follow Macrumors pretty closely so I'm used to seeing a lot of hardware leaks over the years from manufacturing partners, but this fall's leaks were kind of insane.
- yodsanklai 9y ago> These keynotes were magical before leakers leaked everything Even without leaks, there's usually nothing really surprising in the keynotes. You get the usual hardware and software upgrade you would expect from a year to the next. Far from magical, I find these keynotes stereotypical. The fake enthusiasm, the marketing buzzwords and the endless flow of superlatives are sometimes painful to watch. I almost feel bad buying their products after seeing this (unfortunately they still make the best laptops!).
- 659087 9y ago> (unfortunately they still make the best laptops!) Are they still soldering hard drives and memory down? That pretty much permanently drove me away from their laptops.
- xraystyle 9y ago> The only thing that is making me want to retreat back to an iPhone is its inferior Bluetooth audio quality. The S8 has AptX, which in my experience is really quite good. Once Android O drops for that phone you'll have AptX HD and LDAC as well. I've got a pair of Sony headphones. Running LDAC from my Pixel XL on Android O to them, sounds CD quality to me.
- mrpippy 9y agoiOS has supported AAC over Bluetooth A2DP for years. For some reason, it's not as widely supported by headphone makers as aptX.
- rasz 9y agoWhy would you support anything but your proprietary codec in your bluetooth controller chips? CSR didnt know either, was rewarded with handsome ($2.4B) Qualcomm buyout.
- mrpippy 9y agoHaving done development with CSR chips, AAC (and also MP3) support is shipped with the SDKs just like aptX is. AAC patent licensing may be more complex though.
- nunez 9y agoNone of the headphones I use support AptX (Bragi Dash Pro, AirPods, Jaybird Freedoms); nor do any car audio receiver I know of.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoThe majority of these leaks came from Apple itself.
- bitmapbrother 9y agoIt would seem there are people ignorant on the subject. The majority of the leaks came from firmware prematurely release from Apple. A second leak was from iOS 11 GA download links.
- toephu2 9y agoOnly apple fanboys checked out leaks. The average consumer did not look up leaks before the event.
- eblanshey 9y agoFYI android oreo is getting high quality Bluetooth support.
- yoz-y 9y agoDoes Samsung Pay work with more banks where you live? In France there is no support for it (due to come this month but still no dice). I suppose that both can be used anywhere you could use a contactless credit card. (Aside: in France you can use Apple Pay anywhere a bank card would work up to 20€ but in shops with explicit support there is no limit, few have it though)
- madshiva 9y agoYou've been fooled. There was never magical, only a hype train. Apple sell expansive product without argumentation about the technology. People who fall in this scheme are too easy tricked. I buy because of the technology, support not because I see a keynote. What a waste of time to see Apple Keynote and how they never had real innovation that increase the price by 2. It's 2017, almost 2018 and Apple continue to over price the storage and you all support them? It's just a phone, what do you want magic behind a phone?