7 ms·
Global shockwaves from electric cars will be here sooner rather than later
- Freestyler_3 9y agoWhen it reaches 100 million electric cars, Peaks are going to be really big on the power grids. The electrical grid needs improvement, a few battery hubs won't do. The energy to move 1 billion cars around needs to come from somewhere and it needs transportation for that energy from source to user. This requires big changes in power infrastructure. Wonder what the future holds.
- neon_electro 9y agoWhat are your thoughts on home batteries? Assuming the decline of battery prices is a major influence in the uptake of electric vehicles, I'm wondering if a similar uptake in home batteries (alongside residential solar) would mitigate stress on the grid.
- Freestyler_3 9y agoHome batteries would have to hold more than the car. This will still put the baseline of the grid higher, just averages it out possibly taking more when its a good time. I think batteries should be hosted/hooked up by the power company, so they can attach them to a power management system. (I think that already exists) I left out the "where will we get all this power" part, because that is already discussed a lot. I just wonder if the power grid will be able to handle this immense increase in usage, even if spread out. You still need to transport it. edit: I think the powering down of offices and business makes enough room for the evening to use more.
- epistasis 9y agoWhat reason is there for a home battery to hold more than a car?
- Freestyler_3 9y agoYou can drive your car empty faster than your home battery might charge (due to supply/demand), and it is possible to give back to grid if there is a peak in your area.
- pmuk 9y agoWith smarter grids that support dynamic realtime pricing of electricy to end users, I think electric cars, home batteries and even appliances like fridges, refrigerators and washing machines can help balance supply and demand in the grids, using electricity, pausing consumption or pumping it back into the grid as needed. The UK government recently performed an industry consultation on this subject and has released a plan to: * remove barriers to smart technologies (such as storage and demand-side response) * enable smart homes and businesses * improve access to energy markets for new technologies and business models https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/upgrading-our-energy-system-smart-systems-and-flexibility-plan https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/upgrading-our-ene...
- philipkglass 9y agoIt's not necessarily going to lead to much higher peaks. Most EVs do not need to charge continuously from the moment the owner gets home until the owner leaves home the next morning. Simply time-shifting the bulk of charging to, say, between 9 pm and 6 AM would enable vehicle charging without boosting peaks on the California grid: http://www.caiso.com/Pages/TodaysOutlook.aspx#SupplyandDemand http://www.caiso.com/Pages/TodaysOutlook.aspx#SupplyandDeman... It's even better for places where renewable generation is more weighted toward wind than solar, like Texas, because wind output tends to peak while people are sleeping and demand is otherwise low: http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/CURRENT_DAYCOP_HSL.html http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/CURRENT_DAYCOP_HSL.htm...
- jasonmaydie 9y agopeaks will happen if enough people do it at the same time. Almost every summer (maybe except this one), there's always that heat wave that taxes the grid. A solvable problem for sure (just like how we can now handle cell phone overload during emergencies) but lets not pretend the problem doesn't exist.
- epistasis 9y agophilipkglass showed how the problem is solved, he did not ignore the problem.
- kronosEnvy 9y agophilipkglass showed how the problem is solved jasonmaydie showed that even if a problem is solved it can still be a "problem"
- Shivetya 9y agoIt may require that electric providers require deferred charging, even to the point they set when you can. While you could defer your charging don't expect that everyone will. As we see with charging stations in areas with more EVs there are those who just don't care. We need to instruct future owners the expected etiquette
- jhayward 9y ago> Peaks are going to be really big on the power grids Can you supply some supporting documentation for this? All the studies I've seen have shown that the charge cycle is very flat, can be centrally demand controlled, and essentially "fills in" the night-time slump that saps much of the generating profit from major types (e.g., thermal) of generator plants.
- Freestyler_3 9y agoIf every household hooks up, and all the trucks? Currently there is more investment in solar/wind, one is always unreliable and the other is certainly off at night. Now a grid of batteries might be enough to fill up the gaps today, but once that night slum is no longer a slum, who knows how big batteries you'll need.
- epistasis 9y agoWe're still at low levels of renewable penetration on our grid; once over 50%, all these vehicles become a fantastic source of "negative" demand response. Current demand response asks customers to decrease consumption when there's peak usage and the grid is strained. Negative demand response is a signal to consume electricity when a free-on-the-margin source like solar would otherwise be curtailed. The massive array of car batteries becomes an absolutely wonderful source of both positive and negative demand response. Currently, almost no one insists on driving around with a 100% full fuel tank. Those with electric cars commonly keep them around 80%. And daily usage of the battery is nearly always far less than 50%. And a decent sized EV battery is 1-2 days of household electricity usage. If a significant chunk (20%-30%?) of our electrical demand is for battery-powered transport, we've solved a huge problem that comes with high wind and solar penetrance on the grid, without having stationary batteries. As car batteries age and have reduced capacity, they will potentially have a second life as stationary storage, where power density doesn't matter as much. This means, that if we are able to install chargers at a percentage of workplaces, that car batteries will be able massively smooth out not only the daily duck curve of demand, but also deal with fluctuations where some days have more production and others less.
- solaris_7 9y agoI think the expectation is that as the grid slowly gets "smart" this will reduce the peaky-ness of demand generated by electric car charging. If the price of a kWh is dynamic based on current use then the combination of smart charging stations & locally installed batteries should even things out a lot. Obviously the total consumption will increase dramatically. If this shift takes place the society-wide energy mix will include a lot less petrol/gasoline/diesel and lot more electricity. Hopefully the prices of solar & wind will continue to fall and the shift in this mix will be massively to the advantage of the environment - and to the quality of life in our cities.
- condiment 9y ago> Peaks are going to be really big This got me thinking, what does the power draw look like? A Model S has two battery options - 60kWh / 335km @ 5.85km/kWh - 85kWh / 426km @ 5.01km/kWh So a battery will need to recharge 1kWh for each 5km traveled. The typical US commuter travels 48km per day. 50km per day / 5km/kWh is 10kWh per day of required draw. Say 10 hours of charging per day smooths this out to an additional draw of 1kW per driver (a big assumption). With 100M additional electric cars (there are only 165M daily commuters) in the US, the additional draw on the power grid would require 1,000GW of additional capacity. That's a 25% increase over 2016 power generation. Compared to the 1999-2016 growth rate of 9.5%, it is significant, but seems manageable. Especially considering it'll take 10+ years for electric cars to be widely used by a significant fraction of the US workforce.
- epistasis 9y agoThis type of demand is far different from that 9.5% growth rate, and far more manageable, precisely because it happens during off-peak hours. At night, transmission lines are uncongested, and the wind (typically) blows more.
- Freestyler_3 9y agoThanks, that's some good info. 10kWh × 165M on the night grid, that's big impact. I went and got the miles travelled per year and the total nr of vehicles, you are not far off. although we are forgetting that most traffic is during weekdays, and the size of the cars varies (and with it the usage) For convenience I don't do anything with the size of the cars. "According to the Bureau of Transportation Statistics for 2012, there were 254,639,386 registered vehicles. Of these, 183,171,882 were classified as "Light duty vehicle, short wheel base", while another 50,588,676 were listed as "Light duty vehicle, long wheel base". Another 8,190,286 were classified as vehicles with two axles and six or more tires and 2,469,094 were classified as "Truck, combination". There were 8,454,939 motorcycles also listed along with 764,509 buses." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_vehicles_in_the_United_States#Total_number_of_vehicles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passenger_vehicles_in_the_Unit... 250m vehicles in us, if 150m of those are electrical at some point, and the number of miles driven total might be 3.5T miles by then (3.5×0.6=2.1T) 2.1/150m/313×1.6 (6 days of driving a week, and miles to km) comes to 71 km per day, which is 14 kWh (6/7 days) of required draw. I think it is manageable like you said, considering that it will take a while.
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> Wonder what the future holds. I hope it holds a great shift towards decentralization of energy production. Not complete decentralization, but a blend of massive power plants like today, and lots and lots of homes with solar panels on roof tops and the like. I also hope fusion research is accelerated. Fusion in the sky, plus fusion down on Earth, that would cover a lot of bases. Portable fusion reactors would also truly open up the solar system - ride the fusion torch to your destination, power your habitat with fusion reactors.
- vl 9y agoEVs at home charge at night, solar panels produce energy during the day.
- schiffern 9y agoCounterpoint: EVs plugged in at work charge during the day. Scaling up charging infrastructure at work probably pays for its own deployment in reduced energy storage costs. If the underlying economics are there, it's "just" about getting the incentives right. An always-connected EV fleet can dispatch charging from a central load-leveling server, passing a percentage of the utility revenue along to incentivize the EV owner. Such a car would always Do The Right Thing(TM) with respect to TOU/tiered metering, real-time (or forecast) renewable generation, local distribution grid loading, and the availability of any extra baseload generation at night. Personally I would want the option to always immediately charge the car to X miles of range (to drive to the local hospital), and to always charge to Y miles by Z:00 every day (for commuting). Subject to those constraints, the service provider is free to shift around the charging schedule to suit conditions on the local electric grid. The more leeway the service provider has to shift charging around, the more the EV owner earns. Obviously Tesla is pursuing this, but I hope they have competition.
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> EVs plugged in at work charge during the day. Good idea, but the infrastructure would have to be tied to the building, not to the companies operating in it. A lot of companies change offices all the time, and then there are all those small companies that can't afford to build this sort of thing. So it would have to be part of regular infrastructure just like running water or comm/data lines.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoIt will be interesting to see the impact on oil producing nations, if the price of oil plummets most of them are going to be in real trouble as few of them have diverse economies.
- QAPereo 9y agoGiven how much they depend on that wealth, and how unstable that part of the world is...
- xPhobophobia 9y agoWe already are seeing what happens to the likes of surprised countries like Columbia and Zimbabwe and worried countries like the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. It's a big deal and diversification is not an option, it's the way they need to go.
- jbattle 9y agoIt has already been happening to Russia the last few decades - as the price of oil rose then fell it played havoc with their economy and government budgets
- drdrey 9y agoLook no further than Venezuela
- solaris_7 9y agoIf this shift takes place - what would be the best 10 year investment strategy be? Long electric utilities, renewable generation, charging networks, smart grid companies & lithium miners. Short oil companies, petrodollar denominated govt. bonds & gas station networks. Is there a "massive shift to electric cars within 10 years" ETF I can buy?
- lettergram 9y agoStill buy gas, it's not like we're going to suddenly produce clean energy. All that's going to happen is we are going to build more power plants to support charging cars... With the push for less nuclear, and less coal, all that's left is oil and natural gas. Renewable energy is no where near where it's necessary. So invest in companies that build windmills, solar, etc. But also natural gaz power plants. Really the best investments are construction companies, and companies that manage and build the power grid infrastructure.
- olivermarks 9y agoGood paywalled piece on FT about the hedge/shift to LNG by the big petroleum players 'Big Oil bets on a dash for gas' https://www.ft.com/content/f23e35e0-92b5-11e7-bdfa-eda243196c2c https://www.ft.com/content/f23e35e0-92b5-11e7-bdfa-eda243196... LNG is a big electricity creation fuel, escaping methane is the big pollution challenge.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoPush for less nuclear? Where? Germany, Japan? Anyways, electric cars are made for renewables (sans hydro) and nuclear that provide energy when it might not be needed but can be used for charging batteries instead. Gas will fill in the gaps, but it's on demand nature means it doesn't really become more useful like the other sources do with car electrification.
- drdrey 9y agoFrance too. Public perception is against it, but so are the economics (nuclear is expensive to produce and decommission)
- graycat 9y agoI'm still concerned about the time needed for recharging, especially if that recharging is to be a home with the now common 100 A and 230 V connection to the grid. Even with charging stations, there is the question about how fast can recharge a battery without overheating it.
- cynix 9y ago> I'm still concerned about the time needed for recharging, especially if that recharging is to be a home Charging at home is the least worrisome of all charging situations, because you can charge while you sleep and not care about how long it takes. Same with charging at shopping centres, restaurants, parks, hotels, etc., because you're going to spend the time doing the thing you went there to do anyway, regardless of whether you're charging or not. The only time charging speed actually matters is when you're on a long road trip and need to keep moving. That's when you need a fast charging solution, like CHAdeMO or Tesla's Superchargers.
- graycat 9y agoCharging time: In the US, houses commonly have from the grid 100 A at 230 V. So, that is 100 x 230 = 23,000 W (Watts) or 23 KW (kilowatts). For an electric car with a 75 KWh battery, the charging time using all the house power would be 75 / 23 = 3.26 hours. Maybe the house needs also to use an electric stove, electric clothes dryer, air conditioning, a water pump, a microwave oven, some lights, etc. so wants to use only half the house power for the car charging in which case the charging time would be 75 / (23 / 2) = 6.52 hours. From a Google search, supposedly at https://www.tesla.com/models https://www.tesla.com/models is "With unparalleled performance delivered through Tesla's unique, all-electric .... will achieve the maximum charge rate of 11.5 kW for 75 kWh configured vehicles." Then the minimum charging time would be 75 / 11.5 = 6.52 hours. So, net, for an electric car, I'd be concerned about charging time. With a gasoline powered car, can fill up in a few minutes.
- throw2016 9y agoA lot of countries are getting pretty aggressive about electric vehicles. The grids will probably scale but the geopolitical ramifications are more unpredictable. The demand for the US dollar worldwide is linked to oil and the 70s deal with the Saudis. This is a core component of US foreign policy that people like Gaddafi and Saddam found the hard way. US foreign policy is deeply linked to oil. The middle east itself is a hotbed of political intrigue and geopolitical action since oil, and will lose this central role in the global sphere. Both of these will have far reaching consequences for global politics.
- cr0sh 9y agoI don't see an extremely widespread adoption of electric vehicles until the battery issue is fixed. Half of the issue is almost solved: Range. But it has a couple of problems. First, while the range of miles being able to be driven on a battery is now fairly large - upwards of 200+ miles - that still isn't quite comparable to the range an internal combustion engine can get. That value needs to double, if the car is to be used for more than general commuting (at least here in the United States, where the only way to go between cities cheaply and without hassle is to drive). Some of this issue may be mitigated in the future - and other advances could help it with current technology for batteries; for instance, more power efficient motors would greatly assist in extending the range of current battery technology capabilities. The second issue is Charging. For general commuting, this likely isn't an issue at all, even today. Just find a place to charge it, plug in, go into the office (or wherever). At home, plug it in, and it will be ready to leave again in the morning. But for long distance driving, assuming you have a place to recharge (let's suppose this is common in the future), you still have to wait a while to get a decent charge on the battery. With an ICE, you can simply pull up, put some fuel in, and be gone in less than 5 minutes, depending on what you need. You can't do that currently with an electric vehicle. Instead, you need to wait around until it is recharged; if you have no reason to wait (like stopping for food or something), you are basically forced. For long distance driving, this has good and bad points, but sometimes you just want to fill the car up, get some snacks, and go. Maybe the segment of the market that does longer drives is shrinking, or is already small enough not to matter? Maybe advances will help out here? Maybe car owners can add a "hybrid module" for long distance drives that incorporate an ICE/generator combo to keep the battery topped up as it is driven? Right now, the answers are unclear. For those who are only going to and from work, maybe doing a bit of shopping, electric cars can make sense. For others, at best they'll be a secondary vehicle, or only used for going to work and back, with something else in the driveway for longer distances. Lastly - there's the issue with the supply of lithium on the planet. I have read (I don't know the truth of this) that there isn't enough lithium available to support a large population all using electric vehicles. Perhaps we'll find other sources, or perhaps my information is out of date. Recycling will help too, most likely. Future battery technology may do away with the need for lithium. Lots of "ifs" here, but we may have an issue if we are sticking to lithium chemistry for power (given the reactivity of lithium vs other elements, this may not be possible - IIRC, elements that are more reactive than lithium have problems to them for the use of them in batteries).
- harwoodleon 9y agoAs batteries get better and cars charge less frequently, solar improves (and improved solar is added to the car's energy collection) and wind too - the demand will even out, in fact the demand per car may well decrease by a large margin - as market forces come into play (think the MPG figure for marketers). Local generation can take up the slack too, with fewer volts being sent over wasteful energy grids - that can waste 6-7% of energy in transit, up to 30% in undeveloped countries. I was concerned before I got my first electric car that the electricity bills would be massive. But I use the car every day, charge it at home 70% of the time and I have hardly noticed an increase in my bills. I think the fear that the grid won't be able to cope is overblown. Especially in hotter countries where solar will have such a massive impact on transport. In fact reducing oil consumption will only have benefits in remote locations where oil is very difficult to come by. Think about places where oil is a reason for war. No one will fight over the sunshine.
- mikestew 9y agoI was concerned before I got my first electric car that the electricity bills would be massive. That should have been an easy calculation to at least get a ballpark figure of what to expect. But I use the car every day, charge it at home 70% of the time and I have hardly noticed an increase in my bills. Any decent charger should be able to tell you, once you tell it how much you pay for electricity, how much you spend each month to charge. For us, it's about $20/month compared to $60 or $70 for ICE. And that car never needs to spend time at a gas station, which once we owned an electric, is more of a hassle than I thought.
- schraitle 9y agoI used to drive a Volt to work, where I had access to charging and Booster for the rarely needed gas fill-up. On days when my wife's Prius was low on gas, we'd switch cars and I'd fill it up while at work. We didn't visit a gas station for months with either car. Unfortunately, we got rid of the Volt and I now ride my bike, so no charging and no Booster. The Prius tank now has to get below 0 on the gauge before either of us will find the time to go out of our way to a gas station.
- 9y ago
- jimjimjim 9y agojust a thought, when thinking about the pros and cons of this, try not to just think about it from a US lifestyle point of view. a lot of countries are more densely packed or have governments that can just arbitrarily enact new laws.
- all_usernames 9y agoA good read on the topic of electricity production and distribution in the age of renewable, distributed sources: https://www.amazon.com/Grid-Fraying-Between-Americans-Energy/dp/1608196100 https://www.amazon.com/Grid-Fraying-Between-Americans-Energy...