14 ms·
As Amazon Pushes Forward with Robots, Workers Find New Roles
- wongarsu 9y agoSo in short, robots do the boring and physically demanding tasks, making the humans more efficient. No workers were laid off. I see the benefits of "relieving" humans of boring jobs, but most of the article seems like a weird PR spin. Nobody got fired because Amazon is expanding its warehouses rapidly enough that those people have work to do despite the robots. Without this modernization Amazon would have needed to hire more workers, meaning this is still a net job loss.
- riku_iki 9y agoAnd workers were likely laid off from other companies who lost competition.
- adventured 9y agoThat assumes a zero sum game, which is not how the world actually works. Which is why China could go from $1.x trillion to $11.x trillion in GDP in just ~17 years, while the US - the world's largest economy - simultaneously still managed to add $8+ trillion to its GDP. Global and local economic growth makes it possible to absorb slack labor. Which is why we have 7+ billion people on earth, while simultaneously the global median income has been rising for decades nearly non-stop, the global median living standard is at an all-time high, and famines are at an all-time low. If it worked in any regard as a zero sum game, most of those people would be dead or never would have existed in the first place.
- krapp 9y agoThey do some of the boring and physically demanding tasks. Robots bring the bins, but humans still stand there putting things into them or taking things out of them, and that is still incredibly boring, albeit necessary because those taks require visual acuity and fine motor skills, which are currently kind of hard problems in robotics and AI. And even though those human jobs are standardized as much as possible, there are still inefficiencies in the system, many of which are (in my inexpert opinion) caused by the design of the bins and UI deficiencies in the stowing app. If Amazon really wants to improve employee efficiency, I think they could do well to invest more in their internal tools.
- GCA10 9y agoVery few parents say: "I hope my child can get a shipping center job stacking bins, day after day, and hold that job for 40 years." Shipping-center automation is going to move people out of rote jobs in the same way that farm automation sent a lot of workers off the land. From this story, it sounds as if the people working at Amazon shipping centers have found mildly more palatable jobs that could lead (with more training) to better paying careers in industrial operations, design, etc. We can (and should!) argue about how fast "better" jobs are taking shape. We can explore ways of making that happen more systematically so that children of pallet stackers have a brighter future. But it's a dim world if we think rote labor like pallet stacking ought to be preserved as long as possible.
- notatoad 9y agonobody says they want their kid to have a job stacking bins, but there is a need for low-skill, low-training jobs. "Industrial operations, design, etc" are jobs for skilled employees who want a career. Not everybody wants a career, or wants to go to school. Some people are just looking to stack bins for a few months to fund their travel or surfing or whatever.
- jdietrich 9y ago>Very few parents say: "I hope my child can get a shipping center job stacking bins, day after day, and hold that job for 40 years." For a lot of parents, the possibility of their children having a secure full-time job is a lofty aspiration. Millions of Americans are trapped in cycles of unemployment or in low-wage jobs with no security and no benefits. Vast swathes of the US are blighted by long-term unemployment, crumbling infrastructure and a lack of inward investment. Amazon aren't buying these robots out of some altruistic desire to lighten the burden of their workers. Their treatment of warehouse staff is notoriously dreadful. If Bezos could fire every single worker in his warehouses, I have absolutely no doubt that he would. Better jobs would be great, but at the moment we just need jobs. http://articles.mcall.com/2011-09-18/news/mc-allentown-amazon-complaints-20110917_1_warehouse-workers-heat-stress-brutal-heat http://articles.mcall.com/2011-09-18/news/mc-allentown-amazo... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/amazon-devastating-expose-accuses-internet-retailer-of-oppressive-and-callous-attitude-to-staff-10458159.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/amazon-devas...
- franciscop 9y agoThis feels quite political. I agree that robots are the future, but I think that some structural changes will be needed. Trying to sell it like no jobs are lost is quite naive at best, and purposefully misleading at worst. If I remember correctly (don't quote me on that) Amazon used to employ quite a lot of temporary workers and had a high turnover (hire/quit) rate. Then they would no need to purposefully fire anyone to reduce their headcount. Just not temp hiring those people would be enough. Or not hiring as many people as befoe as they grow. Or ... My point: there are many ways of making it look good on paper; but when a robot does a human job, that job is not needed anymore. What IMO we need to do is to keep on discussing structural unemployment from all points of view.
- krapp 9y agoThey need the temp workers during peak seasons - they can't really afford to not hire them, nor can they afford to keep on that many longer-term employees.
- mikeyouse 9y ago"Afford" is a very relative term. They don't want to be responsible for that many FTEs but with $48 billion in gross margin and $2.5 billion in net income, they can certainly afford to employ a few thousand seasonal workers year round.
- krapp 9y agoThat's true. Amazon has "frugality" as a core cultural value - a valid definition of "can't afford it" for them is "just don't want to pay for it."
- FussyZeus 9y agoIn my experience, this doesn't make them that different from virtually any corporation. I don't think I've ever worked for one where getting money for literally anything wasn't a constant uphill battle (which incidentally is why so many consumer electronics feel cheap as shit; they are).
- darawk 9y agoThe fact that nobody was laid off does not mean that no jobs were lost. If efficiency increased, and nobody was laid off, what does that mean? More product/service was produced. That marginal additional product/service would have required more workers, had they not had this efficiency gain from automation, and I think it's only fair to consider those jobs to be 'lost'. That being said, I think this is all wonderful, in spite of the misleading framing.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> I think it's only fair to consider those jobs to be 'lost'. Is that like someone losing a child because they decided never to have any?
- stephengillie 9y agoIt's like a recording studio claiming they lost sales because people downloaded the album they produced.
- NegativeK 9y agoOr like complaining that physical media is crashing and burning while paid digital media is exploding.
- darawk 9y agoI'd say it's more like declining birth rates in wealthy countries due to the collective decision to have fewer children. From the perspective of social accounting and governance, it doesn't matter why we aren't having fewer children, simply that we are. The same with jobs. Losing jobs due to lack of job growth concomitant with GDP growth (as is the case here - i.e. more efficiency, same job count) creates more inequality - a larger share of the value produced flows to capital. Depending on your politics, this is either a bad thing, or just a benign fact. But it is definitely a thing.
- pamqzl 9y agoI lost a five thousand dollar watch today, by never buying it.
- annon23 9y agoUntil they further automate... this ride is just getting started ... lol
- c3534l 9y agoDoes anyone know why Amazon has such visually striking facilities? I'm not used to seeing a warehouse like that. I imagine there is some sort of reason for it (reduces workplace accidents by making certain things stand out), but I suppose it's also possible that Jeff Bezos just thought it looked pretty.
- RQJSOKJVVRPM 9y agoWhat makes them striking to you? I work at Amazon in operations, so I'm a little more able to answer than most, but to me it's just a warehouse. The buildings are built as huge boxes. The only thing I can think of is that they're brightly lit. There is an eye toward safety.
- c3534l 9y agoEverything is the exact same shade of yellow with a splash of red for danger and occasionally blue. However, after seeing the video (I read this on mobile initially), there is more photoshop going on than I gave it credit for. However, there is still a high degree of color-coordination, even when you're not looking at shots emphasizing the orderliness of the place with the colors brightened. There are lots of very clear, systematic horizontal lines. Part of that is how all the equipment is the same, and those self-moving crates are all the exact same height, but they went to the trouble of painting the bottom of poles yellow and the rest white. When you do see red, it's all on the same horizontal line, too. The bottom of the self-moving crates are red, then nothing until you get the tops of the poles, which are all at the exact same height. If I didn't know anything about the company, say it was Walmart's warehouse, I'd expect it to look more like this: https://imgur.com/a/A8ALC https://imgur.com/a/A8ALC
- RQJSOKJVVRPM 9y agoThe photos are definitely unusually bright. That said, the 360 video in there seems strangely "dusty" as well. From my recollection, reality is somewhere in between. The photo composition is also having an effect on things- they are crafted to show, as you say, order. It's also worth considering that there may well be an intentional effort towards aesthetics. These are frequently hard and unglamorous jobs. If white poles and good lighting help make the place feel less oppressive, then I think we'd consider those merits. Side note: I liked "self-moving crates". Those are Kiva robots carrying pods around. They're fascinating and oddly adorable.
- petra 9y agoThis is the historical wage share of gdp of workers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_share https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_share And i'm sure the story for the bottom 50% of employees is even worse. The trend is downwards, and the internet accelerated it. Does anyone think that robots and a massive technology boom that may soon happen won't accelerate it ? Why ? And from that trend, given minimum wage, it seems that at some point in time, we'll have large unemployment.
- jieiieifnfj88 9y agoPlenty of important work to be done: https://aeon.co/essays/the-key-to-jobs-in-the-future-is-not-college-but-compassion https://aeon.co/essays/the-key-to-jobs-in-the-future-is-not-...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- WoodenChair 9y agoWhy concentrate on share of GDP? Isn't it more relevant how many people are starving? How many people are literate? How long people are living and what the quality of their life is? I don't think share of GDP is a proxy for any of those. Perhaps median wage is though at PPP. The trends there are not great, but not as dire as this (IMHO false) picture implies.
- dangerlibrary 9y agoBecause money isn't just for sustenance and shelter - it's also a way to buy power, freedom, and autonomy. As the shares become more uneven, people's ability to act to better their own circumstances without a handout from the ultra-rich (or without the permission of the ultra rich) is curtailed. Look at businesses being dominated by companies that can afford high fixed costs in order to gain huge economies of scale. Good luck opening a mom-and-pop grocery next to a Wal-Mart, or even an independent gas station within two miles of a Sheetz.
- jupiter90000 9y agoDoes that mean that the info in [1] is no longer true? I don't think so... [1] http://www.limitstogrowth.org/articles/2016/10/13/tech-sector-booms-but-job-creation-is-falling/ http://www.limitstogrowth.org/articles/2016/10/13/tech-secto...
- magerleagues 9y agoI really love the 360 video here. Makes the content much more interesting when you can see all around.
- SapphireSun 9y agoRobots are cool. Even though amazon is hiring, they employ robots for a reason, it means that fewer employees are needed per a unit of work. In the absence of robots, more employees would be hired. I like efficiency. I think abundance is great. Our economic system ensures that those things will not help the great mass of people in our society.
- jackcosgrove 9y agoWhoever said it, the quote about digging with spoons instead of shovels and backhoes comes to mind. Productivity is the root of economic surplus. It's the lodestone of the economy. If we stop increasing productivity, the pie stops growing. Productivity is the reason the poor today live better than a king or emperor of old.
- darpa_escapee 9y agoThe problem isn't increased productivity, it's how the revenue generated from increased productivity is distributed in society.
- sokoloff 9y ago> Whoever said it, the quote about digging with spoons instead of shovels and backhoes comes to mind. Often ascribed to Milton Friedman, but it seems more likely to be William Aberhart originally. https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/10/spoons-shovels/ https://quoteinvestigator.com/2011/10/10/spoons-shovels/
- whytaka 9y agoYes but perhaps we don't need a bigger pie, we just need it shared more widely.
- jdietrich 9y agoIt's patently obvious that the freshly baked pie is being hoarded by an elite. Average wages and compensation have been almost entirely stagnant since the 1970s. At best, this unequal growth is irrelevant to most people; in all likelihood, it's driving rampant inflation of house prices, rents and an array of essentials like healthcare and education. If trickle-down economics ever worked, it certainly doesn't work now. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/05/08/researchers-have-answered-a-big-question-about-the-decline-of-the-middle-class/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/05/08/resea...
- ravirajx7 9y agoWhether you read article or not it is quite clear the Robots will eradicate a lot of working force though not very soon for delivering products but even that after some time considering the development of drones.
- vlunkr 9y agoAt a quicker rate than they already have been for decades now? New tech has always displaced workers but we've survived it before. Unless you foresee major unprecedented advancements in AI, I don't think it's going to be catastrophic.
- forapurpose 9y agoThe article prints Amazon's claims and vision - even their animated VR presentation about future robots - but doesn't tell us the warehouse workers' reality or their point of view. I think it has one short quote from one worker. So we know the former, which is interesting, but we have no idea how it really works out for the employees. If someone asked your boss about your experience of your job, or someone a couple of levels above your boss (much of the article quoted "Dave Clark, the top executive in charge of operations at Amazon") and didn't ask you, how accurate a picture would they get? Can Amazon's (effective) COO really tell us what it's like to be a factory worker there? In my experience of being in the position of the interviewer, as a consultant, the boss and even the immediate supervisor usually have little idea about their subordinates' actual work, challenges, frustrations, etc. Unless you ask the person doing the work, you really have no idea what's going on. A common experience: The boss says, 'the new system works great!'; the subordinate says, 'it's awful and I just have to work around it'. But I shouldn't have to talk about consulting fundamentals here; I thought that was a journalism fundamental too.
- RQJSOKJVVRPM 9y agoI don't really have an answer, but you may be interested to know that the retail half of Amazon has a program in place whereby all employees (up to a certain level) are required to visit a one of the warehouses. This is a 3 day affair with a mix of "classroom" time and floor time. While this is obviously far from the unfiltered reality of associates, we (corporate) are at least not totally oblivious. I don't know about Clark, but I'd imagine he has a rough idea, at least of the general state of affairs. The quote about wanting associates to have less monotonous jobs rings true- I've heard that notion before, and it's good to know that it comes from that high.
- forapurpose 9y agoThanks for responding. IME, the types of things you discuss are things "corporate" and executives talk about and sometimes believe, but often are not reality on the ground. Without evidence, why do you believe it? If you were given that sales pitch about something core to your job, would you buy it at face value? If corporate actually cares, why isn't this issue taken as seriously as other Amazon projects? Wouldn't they be collecting data to evaluate the results? Why is there no regular, quality, anonymous objective survey of the warehouse employees? For all I know, there is, but there's no evidence of it in the article (the NY Times dropped the ball on it too - and they are supposed to be the skeptical journalists). If not, how do I, the NYT reader and Amazon customer, know if it's not just feel-good stuff that eases hearts and minds not on the factory floor, but in the corporate offices and in the customers' homes.
- comencan 9y agoWe tried to create this system in Turkey with AltaTech technology and we can't find a solution about virtual routing.Workers can't find a job in the future because even the backward countries try this system.
- empath75 9y ago> “For me, it’s the most mentally challenging thing we have here,” Ms. Scott said of her new job. “It’s not repetitive.” This is a really important statement. If you ever feel like your job is boring, unchallenging and repetitive, that is a sign that it could be done by a robot. Either you need to figure out how to automate it and get a promotion, or you're eventually going to be replaced and let go.
- ThomPete 9y agoThe truth is that Amazon will most likely be adding job, but the industry as a whole wont. At some point Amazon will start dropping jobs too.
- throwme211345 9y agoHS dropout. I used to build windows and doors when i was nineteen at an industrial park for wage. I wrote poetry and prose, d&d adventures and designed games + drew maps. Later I fixed cars on the side but wasn't very good at it. Studied philosophy in comm college and on my own. Eventually I started coding and building/modding PCs and became a TKD instructor and international FC fighter. I've since become an experienced SA and systems programmer. Where is the alike progression to be found now?
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoThe captions "Human pickers followed instructions on computer screens" and "A robotic arm in Florence" are swapped, depicting a robot and a human respectively. Oh the sad irony.
- Robotbeat 9y agoAutomation is good. It enables greater productivity. The kind of automation here doesn't seem actually much different from the 19th century when hand weavers were replaced by power looms. Except we're talking about warehousing and fulfillment instead of weaving thread. But same case of workers now moving from doing something themselves (weaving or stacking) to overseeing (multiple) machines doing the previous task faster. But this doesn't mean the old jobs required less skill; oftentimes automation actually REDUCES the required skill level. ...and so overall, more stuff is made. And this can reduce worker leverage (especially if combined with devaluing of skill... such as skilled spray booth technicians replaced with people tending automated spraying machines). And THIS is where the negative part comes from. So we need some way to give leverage back to workers. Whether minimum wage, labor unions, tech cooperatives, etc. Automation pays for the $15 or $20/hour minimum wage. $20 minimum wage also drives automation. If employment is maintained and innovation in automation continues, this is a virtuous cycle that COULD benefit everyone. But there's also this: http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm