8 ms·
Tesla flips a switch to increase the range of some cars in Florida
- aftbit 9y agoI understand the value to managing the hardware and software of your deployed devices centrally and with protection from users breaking things or becoming a road hazard, and the significant difficulties in developing for an automotive environment. I still wish we could buy Tesla's hardware and run something open source on it like we can with Apple.
- brianwawok 9y agoYou can run something open source on an iPhone? So I assume you are talking about mac? Why would you buy hardware for double the going rate for a given set of specs and remove the OS that you paid so much for? Macbooks are OK, nothing against them, but I never understood who would buy one to run linux on. (I bought a Dell, and it actually included support out of the box)
- newman8r 9y agolol I own 2 macbook pros and a mac pro - wiped apple software off an installed linux on all of them. never looked back. They all work great (a little bit of extra work setting up) - but you are right, I wouldn't have bought them if I knew I was going to ditch apple software ahead of time.
- redial 9y agoYou can run open source software on an iPhone. You can even compile your own code to run on it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jsjohnst 9y ago> You can run something open source on an iPhone? Of course you can... first of all, the OS itself is (at least partially) open-source. Second, there's tons of apps in the App Store that are open-source. And third, you can obviously also compile open-source software yourself and install it too.
- elliottcarlson 9y agoThis is like on-disc DLC in the gaming world - http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Why-Disc-DLC-Bad-Crime-Gamers-Make-It-Out-48109.html http://www.cinemablend.com/games/Why-Disc-DLC-Bad-Crime-Game...
- newman8r 9y agoIMO locking down the battery capacity via software is pretty lame. Does anyone know exactly how this is done? does the battery just never charge up all the way? does it claim it's empty when there's actually more charge left? Are some of the cells locked down and just don't charge? How does it impact the health of the battery (since not being able to charge or discharge completely would presumably affect the health of the cells)
- toomuchtodo 9y agoFor the same reason that CPUs and solar panels (just two examples off the cuff) that are not up to spec are sold at cheaper prices: price discrimination. Tesla gets to sell a car it otherwise wouldn't get to sell, and a consumer gets a vehicle they otherwise couldn't afford. Why is that lame? That's capitalism.
- serf 9y ago>Tesla gets to sell a car it otherwise wouldn't get to sell, and a consumer gets a vehicle they otherwise couldn't afford. Why is that lame? That's capitalism. It's lame because the value change is one-sided. The value is being adjusted by taking away options from a good which has the same intrinsic material value as another to change the market value of the good. It's capitalism, sure, but it's not one of the better parts.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoSo you're suggesting only selling the 75kwh version, which means some folks who want it would otherwise not be able to afford it. How is that good for anyone? And if you buy a 60kwh version, would you be happier if it actually had fewer cells? Comments above indicate that means it would charge more slowly and charging would wear it out faster, but that appears to be the solution you prefer.
- bussierem 9y agoSo I'm REALLY curious to know now - in all those road tests where people testing the car gave the 60kWh cars such glowing reviews, was Tesla flipping the switch for more range, the way ISPs flip the switch when you run speed tests?? This has some pretty serious implications...
- chuckdries 9y agoProbably not... The 60 watt model s has the same battery as the 75 watt model s. It's well known that you can pay tesla $200 to upgrade your 60 to a 75. If the road testers were testing the 60 watt model, they'd be testing it with the software lock on.
- Cyph0n 9y ago> It's well known that you can pay tesla $200 to upgrade your 60 to a 75. The article says that it costs $5000...
- rgbrenner 9y agoconsidering that the ONLY thing it changes is the range.. and the ranges are public info... wouldn't that be pretty obvious to the person reviewing it?
- bussierem 9y agoI would normally hope so, but Tesla cars have definitely had a bit of "fanboy blindness" happening where they don't really think too closely about things. This also could apply to the battery's overall lifespan - by releasing more capacity with software as the battery degrades, they can make their "60kWh" battery seem to last far longer than any other competing battery. While this is nice for the consumer, it is very disingenuous if they do it and claim "we have better batteries" Edit: To clarify I'm not claiming they do this, but just bringing up another possible use of this "software switch" that they could use maliciously. We just can't possibly know because there's zero way TO know...
- 9y ago
- timgebrally 9y agoPerhaps it's like what Sony did with the PS3 a long time ago: they manufactured it with an eight-core processor but only allowed access to seven of them. The manufacturing yields were really low at launch so they manufactured an eight-core and played the odds that they'd be able to fix the yields later.
- chadcatlett 9y agoThe PS3 had one PPE core, and eight SPE cores. One SPE was disabled for yield purposes and of the remaining seven only six were available for usage by end developers.
- post_break 9y agoTesla had preorders for lower capacities and chose to honor the deal and charge for the extra capacity instead of build another smaller battery pack. They could have told people who preordered the smaller one to pucker up. They also probably have over provisioning so they could in theory enable more capacity in an emergency.
- advisedwang 9y agoOr they could have given those people a free upgrade. It would have cost them nothing except the opportunity to try and wring more money out of customers.
- post_break 9y agoBusinesses don't really survive when they give things for free.
- nopzor 9y agoleaving money on the table aside, wouldn't that have annoyed the people that paid more for the higher range? ie. their best customers?
- solracanobra 9y agoLove that I saw this online somewhere and I thought "This must be at the top of HN" and boom there it is.
- Abishek_Muthian 9y agoTalk about life saving update.
- nandhp 9y agoSee also, from four years ago: http://insideevs.com/entry-level-40kwh-tesla-model-s-cancelled-60-kwh-cars-all-get-supercharging-hardware/ http://insideevs.com/entry-level-40kwh-tesla-model-s-cancell...
- ccorda 9y agoIs there another car company that even does OTA updates yet? Let alone unlocking car features with geotargeting. For all the talk of Tesla's lead in electric vehicles being short term, their software DNA feels like an even greater competitive advantage.
- Negative1 9y agoA find it humorous that this is a real world equivalent to mobile game speed boosts, where you pay to save time. It's interesting to ponder the monetization model this could open up. Imagine paying extra to unlock another 10 MPH on the highway (or unlock the speed limit governor). Before going on a long trip you pay for extra distance. Level 3, 4 and 5 Autonomous AI can be toggled via in-app purchase on your mega-screen. One step further; the car is free and self driving, but you're bathed in a 360 degree never ending stream of advertisements, targeted to you based on where you've been, and where you're going (not just your digital/google footprint but real world).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- elihu 9y agoThis was a good move on Tesla's part, but the dark side of this is that they could also "flip a switch" to reduce the range of cars. Presumably they could also disable the car entirely, disable the brakes or rev the motor at an unsafe time, or cause the battery to catch fire. All of this seems very implausible for a company like Tesla, but cars can last a very long time and companies and society change over those time scales. It's not hard to imagine an authoritarian government forcing an auto manufacturer to mess with the cars of protesters, journalists, or anyone else they don't like and to use the implicit threat to encourage compliance from everyone else. I'm not saying this is a likely outcome for anyone who buys an electric car, but it is new failure mode that didn't exist in older, non-internet-connected cars. It's kind of frustrating that there doesn't seem to be a middle ground between giving an enormous amount of power to supposedly-benevolent-for-now product manufactures or finding and disabling the car's antenna and not getting any updates again ever. (Hopefully the car doesn't just refuse to function if it's not able to phone home?)
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoWhat they giveth, they can also taketh away.
- jccooper 9y agoYou can remove the SIM card from a Tesla if you don't want it to phone home, and only connectivity functions are broken (obviously). This isn't a particularly satisfying solution, of course, but it's more recourse than I have against, say, Google shutting me down. You probably actually have implied (or express) warranty protection against the manufacturer screwing with your car. Certainly for the first four years, possibly even after that. I feel like software updates ought to come with their own implied warranty, though that's far from standard understanding right now. Beyond that, it's likely that anyone deliberately degrading your car, even the manufacturer, is a tort.
- steventhedev 9y agoSomeone breaking into your house and stealing all your possessions will be prosecuted. So you have an implied warranty from the government for the security of your possessions. I bet you don't leave home without locking the door though.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoI've heard CPU companies do this sometimes for things like cache capacity (maybe even number of cores).
- pcurve 9y agointel did this back in the days when they sold 80486 CPU with DX and SX designation, the latter lacking math coprocessor a.k.a FPU. In assembly line, all chips would start off as DX with math FPU. In order to make SX variant, they would use just disable FPU function, though they eventually made different chip to cut out FPU altogether.
- Bromskloss 9y agoHow weird to have someone remote control your car.