21 ms·
Dear Amazon, We Picked Your New Headquarters for You
- rmason 9y agoThis really burns me. The Times compared the metro population of Grand Rapids (1 million) to Detroit's population (670,000) in order to disqualify the city in their first round. But metro Detroit has a population of 4.5 million so the Times either was sloppy with their criteria or they deliberately snubbed Detroit. Detroit may be a dark horse in this competition but with Dan Gilbert going all out to win I don't think you can count them out just yet even if the New York Times hastily does.
- curiouscat321 9y agoI think this is an excellent point. While Detroit has a relatively small population, it's metropolitan area does not. It's large metropolitan area has a large STEM talent pool thanks to the automotive sector, the second largest Delta hub (behind Atlanta and just a giant airport anyways), and has a very willing government plus Dan Gilbert. It'll be a uphill battle, but I think Detroit is a serious dark horse.
- flamedoge 9y agobut big question is, will Amazon go into automotive sector? otherwise, I don't see Detroit being their pick.
- nkozyra 9y agoPerhaps the point was that there may be some transferable technical talent already in place. Plenty of programmers, statisticians, UX experts, data scientists and IT folks needed for modern auto companies.
- hpcjoe 9y agoDan Gilbert has created RocketFiber. 1Gb for $79/month residential and business in Detroit. 10Gb available for reasonable amounts. When I was running my own company, I came quite close to looking at spots there. I was in Plymouth (30 miles west), but needed lots of bandwidth at the time, and DC hosting wasnt an option. FWIW: you could do air cooled DCs up and down the Michigan west coast. Wonderfully cool air coming off a natural chiller, Lake Michigan, cheap power, excellent transportation infrastructure, very business friendly state government ... though sometimes they lurch the other way, most of the time they don't do stupid things. I tried gauging investor interest in this model of DCs a few years ago ... few thought DCs were a growth industry, and clouds/hosting was a fad. Go figure.
- hbosch 9y agoStill, despite the size of metro Detroit, I think it's 100% off the table for Amazon's HQ2. The positive side of it is, sure, Amazon could own Detroit like vintage Ford – that's neat but I don't think Amazon wants that. The winters are still some of the most frigid and intimidating of any major American city, Michigan is still seen as the turncoat swing state (or one of them) that lead to Trump's election, and even though it's regarded as ripe for an artistic revolution (cheap permits, cheap housing) it's still not a "cool" place to be. It's a huge gamble on a city that is pulling itself out of bankruptcy.
- thesagan 9y agoI think it'd be an amazing PR move, to be honest, and one Amazon would profit much from and suffer minimal risk. Amazon has been criticized lately for eating retail and causing economic upheaval. Going into Detroit turns all that around. Shinola has been capitalizing on Detroitness. So has Chrysler, successfully. Things are moving back from burbs into the city and gaining visibility. These are the successful test cases. "Imported from Detroit" (The bankruptcy itself hasn't prevented much from improving in Detroit. The bankruptcy turned out to be the launchpad.)
- danjayh 9y agoAll depends on your perspective. Unlike many on ycombinator, I voted for Trump. I suppose it is more accurate to say that I actually voted for his Supreme Court justice list -- I viewed that issue as far more important than the president for the next four years. I lean libertarian, and while Trump had several justices that I'm OK with on his list, Hillary had no list and probably wouldn't have nominated anybody that I like. I live in Michigan, and I'm proud of our role in getting him elected (and getting a justice with a strict interpretation of the constitution nominated). Also, please don't crucify me for admitting that I voted for Trump. I usually don't tell people IRL, because most left-leaning folks are extremely intolerant about it, many to the point of anger/hatred and possibly violence. If you want to know why you can't find the trump voters out in the real world, I think that's one of the big reasons.
- rurounijones 9y ago
- pj_mukh 9y agoDetroit seems like a fantastic choice. Both Toronto and Chicago are fairly close. All the great Michigan and Ontario schools can be tapped and the city has tremendous potential to grow. Hopefully, they'd be nicer to their local population ala Facebook/East Palo Alto.
- amorphid 9y agoSpeaking only for myself, "fairly close" is basically as far away as really far away. If I have to move, there's not much of a difference between moving 100 miles and 3,000 miles. If I were planning to operate in one city because it was fairly close to another city, I'd probably just go to the fairly close city instead (or somewhere else altogether).
- davidcbc 9y agoI agree that this is sloppy reporting. Amazon said they want metropolitan areas that have a million people, not necessarily cities with a million.
- tonglil 9y ago> ...keeping those metropolitan areas that have had the best job growth over the last decade, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data. Metro areas that have actually lost jobs (Tucson; Birmingham, Ala.) and those that have grown more sluggishly are out of the running.
- jsnell 9y agoDetroit was not eliminated due to population, everything on the first map qualified for the population criteria. It failed the job growth test. (There's an argument about whether “stable business climate for growth" really can be boiled down to just "job growth". But is Detroit really going to do well on any kind of proxy for stable growth?)
- drawkbox 9y agoSame with Phoenix as Phoenix metro is 4.5 mil. and lots of room to grow, great cities in Tempe/Scottsdale/Chandler and more with an Amazon presence already here. But ultimately they are probably right, Denver deserves it. Great quality of life, smart governance, good markets, healthy living and room to grow. Lots of people moving to Denver just like Seattle so it is very close to the same style of city. It is very, very easy to attract people to Denver.
- danjayh 9y agoAs others have stated, Detroit was eliminated for sluggish growth, not low population. Having said that, I'm definitely in their target demographic (35 yrs old, BSCE and MSEE, 10 years software development experience and team leadership experience), and I think that their 'has the right labor pool' filter is a bit off. I'd guess that Amazon is looking to rein in their labor costs a bit, and often a large city with some tech (but not a ton) can provide a very good labor pool at a reasonable cost. They got rid of a lot of places I'd be willing to re-locate to in that round (I can't stand huge cities), but perhaps I'm alone in my desire to live in a place that has low cost of living, reasonable traffic, and abundant housing+land. PS - I actually currently live and work near Grand Rapids. I have 11 acres that didn't cost me a fortune, and I love it. GR would probably have also failed their 'amenities' filter, which I think is also wrong - any place with broadway, concerts, sports teams, good restaurants/breweries/bars etc. is probably good enough for most young people.
- Johnny555 9y agoI don't think you're in their target demographic if you want to live on 11 acres but don't want to deal with the traffic to work at a corporate campus of 50,000 workers in a city of 1M+ I think there are a lot of workers who would like to live on that much land, but it's just not sustainable. If 50,000 people each lived on 10 acre plots, the amount of land they'd need to live would exceed that of a large city. That's 780 square miles, larger than the 600 mi^2 of of Houston which has a population of 2M people.
- dionidium 9y agoThis is a good time to remind folks that arbitrary political borders are, well, arbitrary and that all serious city-to-city comparisons should be done using MSA numbers. A failure to understand this leads to all kinds of ridiculous impressions and conclusions.
- acranox 9y agoWell, Boston also has a population of only 600K, so they must have used some other criteria to include the metro areas of the cities.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hpcjoe 9y agoI'd say snubbed. The Detroit-Ann Arbor corridor and metro area is 5-ish million, with a strong tech scene, quite a bit of airport capacity (DTW, and if they wanted to use it, Willow Run). Cheap (and I mean cheap) housing, active and growing downtown, etc. This is not the Detroit I went to grad school in, (mumble) 20+ years ago. Very different place, lots of investment. Ann Arbor is a dense tech mecca. East Lansing (90 miles away) less so, but between Wayne State, UofM's, MSU, Central Mich, MTU, and some of the smaller schools, there is a very strong engineering and computing culture. One that is frequently overlooked. One thing I will note is a paucity of investment capital in the region, and a strong reluctance on the part of costal VCs to invest in fly over country. However ... cost to hire/retain people here is very low compared to the coasts. Given how much the percentage of cost is in people, this should be a factor in any companies calculation on where to move. Land/facilities are cheap. Transportation is ok ... we still have to work on local transit, as decades of mismanagement if not worse, have left the public transportation options in terrible shape. However, there are strong pushes from Dan Gilbert, the Illich family, and many others for modern regional transport. There are light and heavy rail all over here. And, not for nothing ... we have 4 real seasons. Though, in my first few weeks out here (mumble) 30 something years ago, I surprised how they could all be on the same day ... Detroit should be in the mix. As a leading contender. All of the rust belt should be.
- JPKab 9y agoI work at a software company between Boulder and Denver. It's easy to recruit people here. You fly them out (at any time of year, even winter) and the weather is typically sunny and pleasant. (yes, in the winter, it's usually sunny, dry, and mild temps) Good luck doing that in Detroit.
- jackmodern 9y agoBut why would you want Amazon in Colorado? Rent there is already increasing, Amazon there would make everything unaffordable.
- simmons 9y agoI can't speak for the grandparent poster, but it seems he was making a case for Denver being great for Amazon, not necessarily discussing if Amazon would be great for Denver. That said, I wouldn't mind seeing Amazon HQ2 locate here. While I doubt I would personally want to work for Amazon due to its reputation as being a lousy place to work, it would probably boost the tech scene and salaries. I think Denver's cost of living is going to continue its steep trajectory with or without Amazon.
- JPKab 9y agoCorrect. I think Amazon would be ok for Denver. It would probably boost tech salaries across the board here.
- JPKab 9y agoThe housing prices in Colorado are high because of a specific reason that is soon going to end: 1) Land is available, but labor and building companies are still not fully recovered from the 2008 bust, and this has created a sharp supply issue with new housing to accommodate the hordes of newcomers. 2) This issue is quickly on the way to being remedied, because the housing prices are high enough to produce huge profits for builders, and the national companies are quickly getting their infrastructure in place. 3) If anything, housing prices are going to retreat downward, (probably not a crash due to demand) and Amazon would help cement the decision for big building companies to devote more assets to correcting the supply issue.
- nether 9y agoBut nobody wants to move there. I loved my four years in Ann Arbor, but any other metro area just blows it out of the water.
- codingdave 9y agoAnd those of us in Utah say... "Wait, no, we have Universities here, and could totally support Amazon." Then we think about the urban sprawl of SLC, and look at the outdoors and think about how crowded it has gotten already at Arches and Zion and say... "Yes, OK. Denver sounds good."
- batbomb 9y agoIt wouldn't work in SLC for a variety of reasons. Utah really needs some sort of excellence (lab/institute/etc...) in engineering/science/high tech research that's not just biotech, in addition to a more diverse workforce, to really be a next-level tech environment.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI wouldn't be surprised if more than few executives at Amazon were LDS and pushing for it (same is true at most Seattle tech companies).
- maxharris 9y agoThis violates the same principle as: "Dear NYT, We Decided the Stories You'll Be Reporting on for You" "Dear John Smith, We Picked Your Next Girlfriend for You"
- mtmail 9y agoJohn Smith put out a document outlining his preferences and released a document 'submit your proposal" (https://www.amazon.com/amazonhq2 https://www.amazon.com/amazonhq2).
- maxharris 9y agoThe New York Times is a newspaper, not a city. And ultimately the decision rests with Amazon, not anyone else. The wording of their headline should reflect that, because the way it is written currently is quite disrespectful.
- artursapek 9y agoAll of Denver collectively tells NYT to shut the hell up
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 9y agoNot sure if Washington, DC includes Northern Virginia (Ashburn, Herndon, Reston). AWS is already here. And a ridiculous amount of fiber seems to out through this area. I see new data centers popping up quite often. And prices are crazy expensive but probably still cheaper than the city itself. So I would pick this area if I was them. Though not sure how I'd personally feel about prices and traffic going up even higher with Amazon's second HQ moving in.
- rayiner 9y agoAs someone who lives on the opposite side of D.C. from Reston, I'd be so smug if Amazon inflicted its HQ on NOVA.
- hiram112 9y agoI think the area around Reston / Dulles would make a great pick. The Silver Line will be finished soon, and there is plenty of room to build it up in the style of Arlington's Orange Line or Old Town's Blue. Dulles being 10 minutes away would be a huge advantage, especially compared to Denver where the airport is a long ways from both the tech corridor and the Boulder area. Traffic is still a nightmare and housing costs are pretty bad compared to most cities, but there is a lot of tech talent here and wages seem lower than NY, Seattle, and the Bay Area. NOVA is liberal, but Virginia is business friendly, unlike DC and MD. There is already the big NE Virginia AWS here, and I'm pretty sure most of the governments and intel communities AWS infrastructure is also housed close by.
- JPKab 9y agoBad place for an HQ. The tech talent is a mix of actual tech talent vs. "I have all of the Microsoft and Cisco certs that XY Agency requires".
- JPKab 9y agoI currently live between Denver and Boulder. Lived in the DC area for 8 years. It's an AWFUL place to build an HQ, but Amazon might do it anyway. 1) Salaries are artificially inflated by competition from the Govt and Govt contractors. 2) Traffic is nightmarishly bad. 3) Housing is incredibly expensive 4) Tech skills aren't as high as the stats indicate. The gov't and contractors have an amazing way of creating people whose titles indicate they know what they're doing, but they don't. See healthcare.gov fiasco for an illustration. A senior data engineer in DC is someone who knows SQL and Informatica, as opposed to someone that can actually do real tech. The intelligence agencies have awesome talent, but they have enormous salaries inflated by their security clearances and you're not going to get them. 5) Weather fucking sucks. I lived there 8 years, it sucks. 6) Quality of life just isn't good. Average commute times and cultural amenities are bad.
- acconrad 9y agoOh cool Boston is making it pretty far (I live and grew up here) > … and workers can easily get around — and out of town … Haha yup and that's when it drops off- WAIT WHAT??
- hbk1966 9y agoI'm surprised DFW was knocked out at that stage too. From what I hear traffic is horrible in Denver.
- sparrish 9y agoI can witness to that fact. It's getting worse each year.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoIt is, but it's even worse in Dallas.
- nether 9y agoPeople say traffic is bad in LA, but Seattle is next level congestion.
- bagacrap 9y agoLA #1 woohoo http://www.businessinsider.com/us-cities-ranked-worst-traffic-2017-8/#15-austin-received-a-score-of-25-meaning-it-took-commuters-25-more-time-to-travel-anywhere-in-the-city-thats-a-3-increase-from-2016-showing-traffic-conditions-have-worsened-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/us-cities-ranked-worst-traffi...
- umanwizard 9y agoReally? Having lived in Seattle and visited LA, my impression was that traffic and public transit in the latter were both WAY worse.
- bagacrap 9y agoI moved to Denver from LA and I can tell you they're having a laugh to even use the word traffic here.
- blinkingled 9y ago> We asked the economist David Albouy to rank these metro areas for us with an index he uses to measure how much people would be willing to sacrifice, in terms of housing costs and commutes, to live in desirable places. On that basis, we cut Charlotte, N.C. My experience being that neither housing costs nor commute times being horribly bad around CLT - this bums me out. It's actually a great city with lots of nature around it, ATL is 4hr drive, housing costs in nearby areas (Fort Mill, SC e.g.) aren't anywhere near as bad as say Atlanta suburbs. It's not NYC to be sure - culture wise not very hip but I did not think the mid-career experienced people Amazon would be hiring would mind that at all. Maybe the NYT was too literal when they considered CLT or maybe I don't understand what exactly the sacrifice would be in terms of housing costs and commutes.
- cjslep 9y agoI spent the first 18 years of my life growing up in Charlotte during the 90s and 00 housing and bank boom, and have revisited friends there fairly often since. Can't say I am rooting for Amazon to locate a HQ there. Downtown has never really had any appeal for an under-21 besides Discovery Place (is that even still around?) which is more geared for the pre-13 age group. Post-21 more recently it seems to have been revitalized but having been spoiled by Raleigh, still feels sterile and kind of bland. Even in NoDa, where all those creative people have already been priced out of that community. I'm definitely still colored by my hatred of bland suburbia of that city, which afforded teenagers absolutely nothing to do except shop or watch movies in the theatre. It really is geared for the traditional suburban parent types through and through. Compared to other parts of NC with a diverse cultural scene (Asheville and Raleigh) Charlotte drops the diversity for an increased price. It also has the unfortunate location of being inside NC, whose state politics have been anything but sane the past half decade, and the local college is also overshadowed heavily by Chapel Hill, Duke, and State in the Triangle area. That's the metro area I would expect Amazon to pick over Charlotte, as there's a lot of non-hip tech companies already established there. And even a few hip ones like Epic Games.
- santaclaus 9y agoMore importantly, the BBQ in the Triangle is superior to that of Charlotte.
- Fricken 9y agoWhen the hq2 news first broke, Denver was the first city to pop into my mind, without really thinking about it. And I've never even been to Denver, just the airport.
- dogruck 9y agoI've visited Denver many times -- but I had the same immediate thought. Or Kansas City.
- virtuallynathan 9y agoI'm surprised to see Philadelphia eliminated so quickly, it ticks almost all of the boxes, and has a very large number of engineering schools (UPenn, Penn State, Drexel, Temple, Princeton, Rutgers, etc). It's transit is better than many of the other cities, and it has 2 major development plots in the city with existing full tax abatements. Not to mention its proximity to NYC and Washington, DC via Amtrak (~1h20m to NYC, ~1h50m to DC) Transit: http://www.septa.org/site/images/system-map-1400-lrg-03.30.17.jpg http://www.septa.org/site/images/system-map-1400-lrg-03.30.1... Locations w/ Tax Abatements: http://navyyard.org http://navyyard.org http://www.schuylkillyards.com http://www.schuylkillyards.com
- tehlike 9y agoLets hope not, for the sake of people living there. Obviously half joking, but phily is one of the places im considering to move eventually, most likely for retirement.
- jawns 9y agoIt's also smack dab in the middle of the East Coast megalopolis, but I get the impression that supply-chain logistics are being handled at a different level. Regarding the talent pool, as someone who works in the Philly area, I agree it has a lot of well regarded engineering schools nearby, but tech talent doesn't necessarily stay here in the quantities Amazon might find compelling. Granted, it's a chicken-and-egg issue. The top talent tends to go where the top jobs are, and if the top jobs are in Philly, the top talent might be more inclined to stay.
- imissphilly 9y agoI would move to Philly in a heartbeat, ad a reduced wage. There just isn't the demand there anywhere near the level of other comparable metro areas.
- tw1010 9y agoIt wouldn't be a good article with a dramatic ending if there turned out to be two cities that matched the criteria.
- brownbat 9y ago> The company has asked for very specific information on all the state, regional and local incentives communities are willing to offer, and the timelines for how long it would take to approve them. Amazon concludes its proposal by stressing that this a “competitive project.” So let the competition among cities begin! Sigh. I know these could be good in some situations, but sometimes I wish cities had a most favored company law: every business that employs people gets the same tax benefits as the company that got the best deal. Cities could only agree to things that were good for businesses generally, rather than letting one or two ignore the rules for five years before they suddenly relocate to shop for a better deal. Relevant Planet Money: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/05/04/476799218/episode-699-why-did-the-job-cross-the-road http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/05/04/476799218/episo...
- ISL 9y agoThat works as long as there are no other cities playing the game.
- PorgSmorg 9y agoAbsolutely love, despite the fact that it's mentioned numerous times that Amazon is searching all of NA for its second hq, that both Canada, and Mexico are completely ignored. This is despite the fact that Toronto is currently the continents fastest growing tech market due to a lot of factors that would be of incredible interest to a behemoth like Amazon. Feels a like a bit of a snub of the thumb by NYT on that one...
- jacques_chester 9y agoAs they explained in the article: > (With apologies to Canada, we’ve set aside Toronto and several other large cities because they’re not included in most of the data sets we’ve used to determine which places meet Amazon’s needs.)
- umanwizard 9y agoIf the NYT were intellectually honest, that would have been the point at which the editor said "okay, this is pointless, let's not do the article". Reporting results you know are flawed is not the correct response to discovering that it's impossible to get non-flawed results.
- PorgSmorg 9y agoExactly! As I mentioned in my reply to this comment, if they actually used the platitudes of data available on the subject - instead of clearly cherry - Toronto would easily be in the top 3, at the very least. The fact that they admit that the data they chose didn't mention Toronto doesn't help their case any.
- PorgSmorg 9y ago>we’ve set aside Toronto and several other large cities because they’re not included in most of the data sets we’ve used Not because the data isn't available, which it is (in abundance), but because it's not available in the data sets the chose to use. Not to put on a tinfoil hat or anything, but I have a very strong suspicion that they chose the data they did, and specifically mention leaving Toronto out, because they know that if they did otherwise, the data would show that Toronto is probably, if not the best, one of the top 3 options, and that likely wouldn't go over well with their core readership...
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoWhy doesn't Amazon choose a city that almost meets their criteria and invest the wealth they generate there back into the city? Then we get more good cities instead of overinvesting into any single city.
- intopieces 9y agoBecause they want the most bang for their buck. This is not a goodwill gesture by Amazon, this is them looking to squeeze as much as they can out of their next location.
- umanwizard 9y agoWell Amazon isn't a charity; why would you expect them to care about anything other than their own criteria?
- KGIII 9y agoFor the same reason my company used to, I'm retired, sponsor the local little league sports teams - even though the audiences were absolutely never going to be clients? Sometimes, you do the right thing, just because it's the right thing to do. It wasn't an investment. It was just giving back to the community that housed us. I guess you could argue that it improved employee morale? I don't think any of our employees even had kids on the team.
- umanwizard 9y agoI'm not denying that companies do charitable things, but I think where to build your headquarters is much more fundamental than whether to give money to a kids' sports team. Would your former company have made decisions about the parameters of their core business based on the interests of Little League?
- KGIII 9y agoI'm not convinced that their office location is a core business decision. Wherever they go, people will also go. They could HQ in Mozambique and still attract top talent.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoIt will probably land in Reno. Just my prediction.
- eelkefolmer 9y agoI agree, Nevada is able to provide the largest tax abatements which is probably going to be the deciding factor (helped recruit GigaFactory, Las Vegas Raiders etc). 300 days of sunshine, cheap real state, low cost of living and close proximity to 15 ski resorts, plus 45 minute flights to Seattle/Silicon Valley.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jaggederest 9y agoI think a lot of cities would be well advised to steer clear, Amazon would have a pretty crazy distortion effect. It might make sense in Denver, but I can't imagine them fitting into any smaller city (~3m). I expect it to end up in a former rustbelt or midwestern city explicitly eliminated in this article in the 'strong job growth' phase. Dallas, Chicago, Minneapolis, Detroit, Philadelphia.
- oh_sigh 9y agoDenver only has 700k in the city itself, and ~2.7M in the metro area.
- jaggederest 9y agoYeah I'm saying that, for example, the effects on Raleigh would be pretty overwhelmed at 2m, if Denver could even handle it at 3.3m. Contrast with Minneapolis at 3.8m, Dallas at 7.3m, and Chicago at close to 10m on the money. I'm using the CSA definitions because I think that's a better way of comparing wildly different cities.
- beart 9y agoGrand Rapids, MI is just WAITING for something like this to turn it into a major city. It has an awesome culture and a ton of interesting things happening. However, the available tech job pool is still low and what jobs do exist are typically at non-tech companies who happen to employ tech workers.
- thelambentonion 9y agoI'd really like to see something happen in Grand Rapids to help put it on the tech job map. My brief time working there was a _ton_ of fun, and I really hope that I'll be able to return at some point, either as a remote worker or (hopefully) for someone local.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's not easy to get in and out of GR. Airline connectivity was one of Amazon's criteria.
- nether 9y agoPlease no. Leave Denver alone.
- avenoir 9y agoI have a strong suspicion that Denver will become the next San Francisco in the next 5-10 years.
- sumedh 9y agoWhy, can you be more specific
- megadopechos 9y agoBecause the amenities and attractions and character of the city are being ruined by the flood of people moving here.
- sumedh 9y agoFair enough
- Chloro 9y agoPortland would win if it wasnt so close to Seattle
- ruffrey 9y agoPoorly researched. They kicked Sacramento off the first round "1 million or more" yet there are 2 million in the greater Sacramento area, strong job growth and local economy, affordable housing, and decent tech chops (ok not the Bay Area by a long shot). The SMA has no detectable boundaries between cities; they just blend together. I wonder how many other cities were eliminated due to poor research.
- Spooky23 9y agoTheir view of metro area is pretty limited. The Albany-Schenectady-Troy MSA is about million people, and it's barely a top 50 market. There are definately a lot of other markets in a bunch of different places that can compete for this.
- in_cahoots 9y agoSacramento was kicked off for poor job growth, not population. Every city on the list met the population criteria.
- mrep 9y agoI was thinking about this today and realized something about tech/finance/entertainment... hubs. The best way to get one is by having major players in the industry set up shop there. Cities hope the next big tech company will be in their city, but lots of the employees that switch companies to help startups grow come from top companies and it is way easier to get people to switch companies if they don't have to move. Seattle has become a good tech hub due to amazon and microsoft. I think whatever city wins this will have a massive long term tech hub boost because of it. This will probably be many times better for a cities economy than some factory.
- Spooky23 9y agoIs Amazon looking for a tech hub or a place for administrative functions. Recall Microsoft moving all of their admin stuff to the Midwest somewhere.
- mrep 9y ago> Is Amazon looking for a tech hub or a place for administrative functions. "The jobs will likely be broken down into the following categories: executive/management, engineering with a preference for software development engineers (SDE), legal, accounting, and administrative." [1] SDE is clearly mentioned but who know the actual distribution. [1]: https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/G/01/Anything/test/images/usa/RFP_3._V516043504_.pdf https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/G/01/Anything...
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoI know they eliminated Pittsburgh right out of the gate, but I think it has a bunch of things going for it. It's one of the few places where housing is cheap (but a pretty beautiful downtown) but young tech workers would love to live: tons of stuff to do but lots of knowledge workers with CMU. Biggest obvious issue is no direct flights to Seattle, but if Amazon built a headquarters there it seems like it would be easy to reach critical mass to add more flights
- tomschlick 9y agoAlso, they eliminated PGH based on the 1 million population without accounting for the city borders being much smaller than normal cities due to how Allegheny county is structured. The metro area is ~2.5 million and is about the same size as most city borders.
- _n_b_ 9y agoIt was actually eliminated on "job growth is strong" not on metro area size. The first map is all >1M metro areas, which lists Pgh.
- hirsin 9y agoNot to mention a starving international airport that would be desperate to help make flights to Seattle happen. I know I'd be on the first one. And really, Pittsburgh is fantastic. Good schools, good commute even if you live in a suburb, great food and alcohol scene, with an arts scene and history to rival any major city (Carnegie and Warhol for starters).
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoI visited Pittsburgh recently, and I kind of fell in love with it: 1. Beautiful, unique geography, with a ton of outdoor stuff to do (granted, at least in summer). 2. Gorgeous architecture all around. 3. Great public transportation. 4. Lively nightlife, lots of options. 5. Relatively cheap Pittsburgh basically has infrastructure for a city twice as big, but has managed to transition from its industrial past better than most rust belt cities.
- spectrum1234 9y agoCharlotte doesn't have a good cost of living (or whatever the metric was)? Last I saw it was one of the best for wages/job ratio.
- jszymborski 9y agoAmazon made it clear that it was looking for "someplace in North America"... there are 2 other countries you've left out with metro areas that fit at least some of the criteria.
- umanwizard 9y agoI would be shocked if Amazon put its headquarters anywhere where English is not the primary language. That leaves Toronto and Vancouver, unless I'm forgetting somewhere.
- tzs 9y agoParts of Mexico could end up satisfying that if Congress does not act on DACA. It would be interesting if a company opened facilities in Mexico with the specific purpose of recruiting from deported DACA beneficiaries.
- walterkobayashi 9y agoBoston has crumbling infrastructure. A Big NO
- drewcon 9y agoIt really doesn't. Big dig and associated/dependent projects have taken care of a lot that. Also "Boston"!= Boston...which is basically a euphemism for Eastern Massachusetts, Northern RI, and Souther NH. You could do this project in Nashua, Worcester, Providence, Waltham, outside 128, and it would make double or triple the cost sense of downtown Boston/Cambridge/Somerville.
- senatorobama 9y agoWhy not Australia? XD
- skookumchuck 9y agoOr, Amazon's announcement could just be a move to get Seattle to stop their attacks on local businesses. The Seattle Times has routinely run pretty negative articles on Amazon, and suddenly today they ran a positive one. I think the Times has gotten the message. http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/editorials/end-of-amazons-seattle-monogamy-should-be-lesson-to-civic-leaders/ http://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/editorials/end-of-amazon...
- kitten_mittens_ 9y agoIt's pretty hard to argue that Amazon's relationship with the city is not toxic.
- skookumchuck 9y agoSeattle elected and re-elected Kshama Sawant to the city council. She is an avowed socialist, and is openly hostile to Boeing and Amazon. At one point she wanted to nationalize Boeing. I'd think twice about investing in anything under her sway.
- JBlue42 9y agoShe's an elected official, which means some Seattle people seem to think her ideas are worthwhile.
- skookumchuck 9y agoThat's right, she's reflective of the community. And if that community is hostile to Amazon/Boeing, why should they continue to invest in that community? The Seattle mayoral election candidates are all well over on the left. There isn't even anyone to vote for if you aren't on the left.
- JBlue42 9y agoOut of curiosity, what has Amazon actually "invested" in the community?
- X86BSD 9y agoI am voting for KC.
- throwaway2016a 9y agoThis is going to sound crazy and I have no idea of the "Willingness to pay to play" aspect but... Nashua New Hampshire. - Easy reverse commute from Boston - Easy access to Boston schools - New Hampshire is a business friendly state - Plenty of cheap office space - No income or sales tax And, if a larger[1] company moves into the area it will make the commuter rail to Boston project the city has been trying to push a no brainer. It is even already in one of the highlighted areas of the article (the Boston highlighted region covers Nashua). [1] It is already home to the headquarters an entire large subdivision of BAE Systems, as well an Oracle office, EMC, Fidelity, and an Amazon distribution center.
- fma 9y agoI live in Atlanta. I was hopefully it would be the final pick...but when I got down to the section about being able to move around the city easily, I knew we'd be cut. Not going to complain about traffic/mass-transit here...but it's a known issue and we supposedly lost another bid (can't think of the company here) because of traffic. We did get a few others...Mercedes-Benz for one.
- technofiend 9y agoActually I would challenge the idea Houston doesn't have enough of the professionals required. Houston was eliminated as not having enough white collar workers. Yet they left in Austin which is far smaller because at least 12.5 % base of their base has the right skills. It makes sense to compare desired jobs versus the general population but not without context. Seriously with six million+ people here, do you really need 12.5% or 750,000 of them to be what Amazon would consider hiring when they only need 50,000 people? I find the idea absurd: Amazon could fill their entire job quota out of the current worker pool.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI haven't lived in Houston in 30 years but wouldn't it have been eliminated on the mass transit/transportation/traffic congestion round or possibly the amenities via outdoor recreation round and definitely the culture of inclusion due to the GOP state priorities on bathroom bills? I loved Memorial Park when I lived inside the 610 Loop but the options after that at that point in time required a significant amount of time in the car. The other amenities of restaurants/arts/music were pretty good, though.
- technofiend 9y agoDepends on where Amazon ends up. We definitely are weak on public transportation but have a couple of international airports. With 600 square miles of area, it's tough to have a single metro system serve that entire area and frankly with our weather few people choose to stay outside and wait on transportation unless they just have to. Which is why you see things like Exxon's move to the Woodlands. There's enough local infrastructure and housing to support their corporate HQ. Unless Amazon decides to buy an inner-city coporate park here they may end doing the same by going to Clear Lake, Sugarland, etc. Houston is sort of like Austin in that it's an oasis of less conservative politics but the even so the bathroom bill didn't pass. There's plenty to do outdoors here: I regularly play disc golf, cycle and kayak in the summer. But you do need lots of sun screen, water and to acclimate to the heat. Otherwise you will suffer. I don't think it's any different that living in the South West. You need to know how to deal with the heat.
- vturner 9y agoGlad to see Columbus off the list and hope it stays that way, if we must give tax breaks, I'd rather it be to small businesses, not monopolies.
- all_blue_chucks 9y agoThe major factor that isn't mentioned: state income tax. Washington has no income tax. It's no small coincidence that it has so many billionaires living there. But Seattle is trying to impose a 2.5% income tax on high earners. This might be Jeff's way of reminding them they have to compete to keep his business around. Also, a 0% income tax rate makes a HUGE difference in attracting tech workers who earn $200k+...
- JBlue42 9y agoBoo hoo for rich people?
- all_blue_chucks 9y agoAre you lost? This is a site full of software industry types. Everyone here is either "rich" already or trying to be...
- JBlue42 9y agoVery true. I'm just here to spy on what the well-to-do and techno-utopianists are up to and want to inflict on the rest of us in the future. ;-)
- cozzyd 9y agoI think Rahm might be able to pull it off for Chicago. I could see Amazon moving into the Old Post Office, partially for the symbolism, partially for the convenience.
- vforgione 9y agoThis could actually be a cool idea. It seems like the Fulton Market boom flopped and all the real estate went to condos and luxury apartments. Moving a major tech hub into the loop could have some interesting outcomes like balancing the opportunities for people who don't have easy access to the near north and west sides.
- shawn-butler 9y agoI wonder if there is a study of these "sweetheart" municipal discretionary tax incentives deals? I have to imagine very few, if any, ever achieve the ROI the politicians claim and usually on top of non-tax incentives. Would be interesting to see some actual data. These people in power make these deals with little public oversight, usually negotiated in secret, knowing full well they won't have to deal with the long term impacts.
- tanilama 9y agoCan't the residents vote the deal down if they are not happy with it? Just curious.
- joveian 9y agoSince Bezos has a house and newspaper in D.C. but D.C. itself isn't suitable, I'm thinking "distance from D.C." is a major unmentioned criteria and the main point is to get suburbs and nearby cities to compete. I'll guess Baltimore. Unfortunately, I suspect a lot of places will offer plenty of bribes ("tax benfits") that should be illegal.
- meow_mix 9y agoHappy to see Columbus on the list, shame our tech growth isn't quite at the other state's levels right now (although I think it will be in the future!)
- Osiris 9y agoI live in the Denver metro area and I think this assessment is pretty spot-on. The only downside is rush hour traffic around downtown can add 15-20 minutes to the commute. However, these is a significant light rail presence. I would say quality of life is great for anyone that likes to do anything outdoors: fishing, skiing, mountain bikes, dirt bikes, etc. And there's a pretty strong community of software engineers here.
- conorgil145 9y agoI lived in Denver for the past 2 years and agree with this assessment as well. The light rail has expanded lines in recent years to the airport and I have read that the plan is for that expansion to continue to eventually link Denver and Boulder. Amazon could build their huge complex anywhere in that area and workers could take public transportation to the office.
- heimdall 9y agoI graduated from CU-Boulder in 2009 and have lived in the Denver-metro area ever since. I could very easily see Amazon drawn to the Boulder-Longmont-Lafayette triangle if not in Denver proper. Lots of growth here in the last 5 years especially. Many long-time locals are complaining about the cost-of-living going up, though.
- peatmoss 9y agoHaving been in Seattle for nearly a decade now, Denver is one place that I'd absolutely consider at some point. I love mountains and sunshine, which Denver gets in spades. Having grown up in MT, the mountains around Seattle are beautiful, but never feel quite right to me—mountains should be dry!
- saryant 9y agoThe Denver-Boulder train isn't going to happen for a very long time. IIRC the current target date is 2044.
- uptownfunk 9y agoSan Diego would be an awesome choice. Great weather. Burbs are good for families. Beach is not far.
- c3534l 9y agoI don't think Amazon is actually "looking" for a new headquarters so much as asking for a sweetheart deal to do business there, sort of like how cities will spend absurd amounts of money to woo sports teams.
- boulos 9y agoI'm surprised none of the comments here highlight the time zone benefit that one of the east coast options would give them. Having a large group of employees still based in the US, yet able to sensibly overlap with Europe is a huge deal. In the same way that Portland is too close physically, Denver doesn't gain you "anything" for timezone diversity. They might offer the sweetest financial package, but it still seems like a wasted opportunity.
- querulous 9y agoI think Amazon has already selected Toronto (or possibly somewhere else in Ontario like Kitchener-Waterloo or Windsor) and is just running this 'contest' to extract the best deal they can get. I don't see any reason for dual HQs unless they are hedging against the risk they may have to abandon their current HQ and the biggest threat they face is anti-monopoly actions by a hostile government. Any secondary HQ is going to be outside of the USA and they've already eliminated Europe and Asia. No city in the USA can compete with Toronto on the basis of legal risk, cheap labour (senior software devs top out around $90k usd in Toronto) and population/infrastructure
- troydavis 9y ago> I don't see any reason for dual HQs unless A huge one: Seattle is starting to feel a bit like a company town. This has all sorts of practical considerations, like labor cost and real estate availability. For example, from https://www.geekwire.com/2017/how-seattles-office-market-became-a-modern-day-gold-rush-thanks-to-amazon-and-a-deep-roster-of-out-of-town-tech-companies/ https://www.geekwire.com/2017/how-seattles-office-market-bec...: Amazon "takes up approximately 20 percent of Seattle’s office inventory, one of the highest concentrations in the country by a single corporate entity," and Amazon anticipates 50% growth in square footage between 2016 and 2020. tl;dr: the strongest reasons for 2 HQs aren't political.
- muninn_ 9y agoNot sure why people are down voting this? Wtf. Toronto is definitely a top choice and it makes sense. You added some other considerations I hadn't immediately thought of as well.
- kyledrake 9y agoThe Twin Cities (AKA Minneapolis) perhaps doesn't scale well on the "raw growth" charts, but the region has a strong track record for being a very good place for corporate headquarters. By metropolitan area, it ranks first among the 30 largest metropolitan areas in the number of Fortune 500 companies per capita. It's also a major knowledge hub for shipping logistics, which is why Amazon opened an office there related to that work. I'm not really jazzed about the idea of Amazon moving in, but don't discount the Twin Cities here, it's a very strong contender.
- mcbits 9y agoInstead of two headquarters, why not 50 headquarters? They have one of the largest and most reliable networks in the world - use it! With offices spread across the country (continent, even), they could hire from a talent pool that dwarfs Seattle and Denver. They wouldn't have to find 100+ contiguous acres for sale in one metropolis. City Council elections wouldn't have to be of strategic importance. Likewise for disaster preparedness. They already have distribution centers all over the place.
- Johnny555 9y agoThe same reason Google, Facebook, Apple, et all still bus employees 40 miles south from SF to their offices -- having people together in one office (or campus) makes them more productive, no matter how much technology you throw at it.
- mcbits 9y agoIs that really true? How many people in a 50,000-person campus ever even make eye contact, much less work together in a way that requires physical proximity?
- drawkbox 9y agoMost communication in an office still takes place virtually just as you do remotely. Within a company located in the same physical area you might communicate across floors, across buildings, across campuses. Yes it is nice to have small groups together on regular basis in meetings, integration sessions, brainstorming but for the most part jobs are virtual even in an office today with chat, email, text, phones, video chat, etc. Everyone in one location is both a single point of failure and doesn't scale well to employees changes, i.e. people move frequently, skill is available in different technologies not always in one location, etc. Better virtual communication in companies even on-site is needed, being in one place without that can actually put a damper on performance and ability to ship.
- Johnny555 9y agoYet the evidence from major tech companies suggests that physical presence is worth the time and expense to bus most employees to a central campus. Apple is spending $5B on their new building to house 13,000 employees together. Amazon is committing $5B to their new campus to house 50,000 employees.
- muninn_ 9y agoI know it won't happen because of the "amenities" clause but it would be so great to see a HQ dropped in a state like Ohio or Michigan. There are tech workers in those areas and it would draw in even more, while providing a boost to the economies that have been getting screwed up. But Denver makes sense, as does Austin, Chicago, or Toronto. Places like Houston or Atlanta have no chance. Nobody wants to live in car land. NYC and the like are too expensive. Denver university system is weak compared to a Columbus, Austin, Pittsburgh, Chicago, Detroit, type area. For Denver I'm also a little concerned because it is kind of far away from everything.
- musikele 9y agoFor Europeans to come and work in USA, a West Coast city would be better - Washington, New York, Miami, boston ...
- jpatokal 9y agoI think you meant East Coast? But as far as immigration is a factor, it would make more sense to optimize for access to Asia.
- SQL2219 9y agoDenver is not going to make the cut. Housing prices are already growing at 10% yoy. Add an Amazon to that and you're going to be Seattle in about 18 months. https://www.forbes.com/sites/troymcmullen/2017/05/03/denver-home-prices-continue-to-rise/#bbc81d923039 https://www.forbes.com/sites/troymcmullen/2017/05/03/denver-...
- throwaway1493 9y agoI am quite surprised that they are focussing on the US only. After all, the search is going on in North America, not just the USA - would have preferred to see this covering at least Mexico and Canada as well..
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tzs 9y ago> At this point, though, we’re going to eliminate Portland, because it makes little sense for the company to put a second headquarters so close to Seattle. Nonsense. Most or all of the reasons people have speculated on for why they want a second headquarters work as long as it is not in the same state as Seattle. Portland is only three hours from Seattle by car. That's close enough that it is not unreasonable for someone at one office to make an occasional day trip to the other. That could give some flexibility they would not get if the offices were farther apart.
- JPKab 9y agoI live between Denver and Boulder. My brother lives in Portland. I think Portland is great, but I think it would be a mistake. 1) The lack of sunlight in Portland is the same as Seattle. There are a ton of people who just won't live in places like this. It's actually allowed my company to easily recruit people from places like LA who won't consider cloudy, rainy places due to Seasonal Affective Disorder. 2) Portland has bad traffic. Shockingly bad for it's size. 3) The airport is nice, but small. Flights aren't often direct.
- jagger27 9y agoI think Ottawa, Canada would fit the bill too.
- adverbly 9y agoThis is such a terrible way to make a decision like this. The types of filters they used were completely arbitrary,the filtering level for each type of filter was arbitrary, and the number of filters they used was arbitrary. Plus, they didn't even include Toronto, who is probably a very strong contender.
- snarf21 9y agoI agree, there is strong factors to consider a location outside of the US. Despite the NYT analysis, I think this is going to end up in Boston. I don't buy the "there is no room for the location" argument. It is like they've never been to Boston. Sure you can't drop it in the downtown but there are lots of areas in need of redevelopment very near by. I also think that Boston has a huge advantage in terms of talent pool. Look at all the top schools in Boston, Amazon needs the talent more than the money. Additionally, I think this is a game. They've already decided where, they just want leverage to get a better deal there. This isn't like the Giga factory where they just need manual labor so anywhere would work. I'll be interested to see where it ends up though.
- JPKab 9y agoBoston has colleges and universities, and yes, they are amazing. But guess what? Recent college graduates are happy to move to places with better weather and lower costs of living, and they do. We interview top tier people looking to relocate from Boston all the time. I say that as someone who loves Boston, and especially like the culture and people.
- snarf21 9y agoI meant it largely in the local ability for intern programs, partnerships with the various internal school "labs", etc. You also have a better chance at attracting institutional talent as they can switch without moving or upsetting their life. Look at the huge exodus of staff from CMU to Uber, etc.
- tootie 9y agoThey've already spent a ton and bought probably 1M square feet in New York. I know it's expensive as hell, but I don't how that slows them down at all. It's the default first choice for any big business on the east coast.
- hourislate 9y agoThe article fails to take weather as part of the equation. Did not address green energy. My thoughts are DFW will be one of the top contenders.
- natch 9y agoNotwithstanding the NYT process, it would be interesting to see if Amazon can find a spot that does not fit all the criteria itself, but is situated such that people can be pulled (by lower cost of living) to the place from nearby areas with talent. An example of this would be the Sacramento / Davis area. The Mexico possibility is also very intriguing, though it seems difficult to make it work with the safety and language issues.
- dokument 9y agoDidn't Amazon say North America, not United States?
- lazyant 9y ago"workers can easily get around — and out of town" - Washington DC makes the cut, that's a joke, 470 and beltway is one of the most congested roads in the US.
- Corrado 9y agoI'm a native of Louisville, KY and while I was excited to see them on the original list of cities, I can understand why it might not make it. To me, Louisville is a great place to live; we are average in almost every way possible. So, we get snow but not blizzards, rain but not hurricanes, heat but not heat waves, etc... We also have a lot of growth potential and plenty of room to expand. The place we falter, IMHO, is the social aspect; it's just not cool to live/work here. Sure we have Churchill Downs (The Kentucky Derby) and quite a lot of bourbon but I'm not sure that makes up for the lack of cool places to live and out downtown shuts down after 5PM. Still, if Amazon HQ showed up I'm sure those things would change pretty quickly. $50MM and 50,000 extra people have that effect. :)
- obeone 9y agoI've lived between Denver and Boulder for a couple of decades now, and my gut reaction is that Denver/Boulder is probably the type of area that Amazon is looking for to attract talent. Louisville, CO (outside Boulder) is often ranked #1 or #2 for great places to live, and Louisville has the abandoned Storagetek campus (~432 acres) and immediate access to HWY36 and the 470 Tollway. Whether or not adding a mega-campus of 50,000 to the 80027 zip code (or frankly, even one 20 minutes south to Denver proper) is good for the Corridor is another conversation entirely.